Pith. sign in

REVIEW 2 major objections 5 minor 65 references

Time- and momentum-resolved phonon population dynamics with ultrafast electron diffuse scattering

T0 review · 2 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-14 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read Diffuse electron scattering yields mode-resolved phonon populations

desk verdict Solid new method for branch-resolved phonon populations; the headline e-ph coupling value rests on a sloppy energy argument in Appendix B that could flip the number by ~2. read the letter →

arxiv 1908.02795 v3 pith:S2XCJOVF submitted 2019-08-07 cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Laurent P. René de Cotret , Jan-Hendrik Pöhls , Mark J. Stern , Martin R. Otto , Mark Sutton , Bradley J. Siwick This is my paper · ORCID
classification cond-mat.mtrl-sci
keywords ultrafastelectrondiffusescatteringphononpopulationselectron-phononcouplingBrillouinzonegraphitedensityfunctionalperturbationtheorynonequilibriumlatticedynamicsone-phononstructurefactor
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This paper establishes a quantitative, parameter-free data-reduction method that converts ultrafast electron diffuse scattering (UEDS) patterns into transient phonon populations resolved by phonon branch and wavevector across the entire Brillouin zone. The central claim is that, given intensity data from enough Brillouin zones and density-functional-perturbation-theory (DFPT) phonon polarization vectors, a linear inversion at each reduced wavevector recovers the eight in-plane mode populations; no additional free parameters enter. Demonstrated on photodoped graphite, the method tracks energy flow out of the strongly coupled $A'_1$ optical phonon at K, into mid-zone acoustic modes, and yields a mode-projected electron-phonon coupling strength $\langle g_{e,A'_1}^2\rangle = 0.035 \pm 0.001$ eV$^2$ consistent with other measurements and simulations. If the method holds generally, it puts full-Brillouin-zone, mode-resolved lattice dynamics within reach of a laboratory-scale electron-scattering setup.

What carries the argument

The load-bearing object is the one-phonon structure factor $|F_{1j}(\mathbf{q}, t_0)|^2$, computed from DFPT phonon polarization vectors $e_{j,s,\mathbf{k}}$ and Debye-Waller factors. It maps each phonon mode's contribution to diffuse intensity at every scattering vector, and it varies strongly with mode and wavevector: near $\Gamma$, longitudinal modes scatter radially and transverse modes azimuthally, and only 37% of the measured wavevectors have a single mode contributing more than half of the one-phonon signal. The paper's procedure uses this mode-dependent contrast to turn the measured diffuse intensity into a solvable linear system per reduced wavevector, then converts the fitted heating rate for the $A'_1$ mode into a mode-projected electron-phonon coupling through the relation $\hbar/\tau_{e,j}=2\pi\langle g_{ep,j}^2\rangle D_e(\hbar\omega_\nu-\hbar\omega_{j,\mathbf{k}})$ with a graphene-like linear electronic density of states.

What would settle it

Compute the mode-projected coupling using the full three-dimensional graphite band structure rather than the graphene linear density of states, and compare the resulting $\langle g_{e,A'_1}^2\rangle$ with $0.035$ eV$^2$; a substantial difference would show the DOS approximation dominates the error. Separately, apply the same linear inversion to static thermal diffuse scattering at a known temperature: the recovered populations should match Bose-Einstein occupations for every branch and wavevector. Any systematic branch-dependent mismatch would falsify the polarization-vector-based structure factors.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The paper's central discovery is that the time-dependent diffuse scattering intensity change $\Delta I(\mathbf{q},t)$ can be decomposed into branch-resolved population changes $\Delta n_{j,\mathbf{k}}(t)$ by solving the linear system $\mathbf{I}_\mathbf{k}(t)=\mathbf{F}_\mathbf{k}\,\mathbf{n}_\mathbf{k}(t)$ at each reduced wavevector $\mathbf{k}$, where the design matrix is built from one-phonon structure factors computed with DFPT polarization vectors. In graphite, intensity data from 44 Brillouin zones are used to solve for the eight in-plane phonon modes, with non-negative solutions stable for $|\mathbf{k}|>0.45$ Å$^{-1}$. The recovered populations show the expected fast population of the $A'_1$ phonon at K and the subsequent transfer of energy into transverse acoustic modes along $\Gamma$–M. Fitting a non-thermal-lattice model to the $A'_1$ population transients gives coupling constants $G_{e,A'_1}=(6.8\pm0.3)\times10^{17}$ W m$^{-3}$ K$^{-1}$, $G_{A'_1,l}=(8.0\pm0.5)\times10^{17}$ W m$^{-3}$ K$^{-1}$, and $G_{e,l}=(0.0\pm6.0)\times10^{15}$ W m$^{-3}$ K$^{-1}$, from which the mode-projected coupling $\langle g_{e,A'_1}^2\rangle=0.035\pm0.001$ eV$^2$ follows through a standard heating-rate conversion.

Load-bearing premise

The conversion from the fitted heating rate to the headline coupling value assumes that graphite's electronic density of states has the same two-dimensional, linear Dirac form as graphene's, with graphene's Fermi velocity; the quoted $\pm0.001$ eV$^2$ uncertainty covers only the fit covariance, not this electronic-structure approximation.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • The measured $A'_1$ and acoustic-mode populations provide a quantitative, wavevector-resolved view of the energy flow from strongly coupled optical phonons to mid-zone acoustic modes, including the predicted buildup of TA population at $M$ and $\frac{1}{3}M$.
  • Extraction of momentum- and mode-dependent electron-phonon and phonon-phonon coupling constants from a single UEDS experiment is possible, moving beyond the two-temperature model's assumption of internally thermalized phonons.
  • The same formalism carries over to ultrafast X-ray diffuse scattering with minimal changes, extending full-Brillouin-zone phonon population measurements to X-ray free-electron-laser sources.
  • Pre-photoexcitation thermal diffuse data can be used within the same framework to infer phonon frequencies, then the time-resolved data give population changes, so the method remains applicable when phonon frequencies are not known a priori.
  • With improved time resolution the approach could detect early-time populations of the $E_{2g}$ phonon in graphite and test the applicability of Kramers-Heisenberg-Dirac theory to Raman scattering in graphene/graphite.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • The quoted $\pm0.001$ eV$^2$ is likely an underestimate of the total uncertainty: the graphene-DOS conversion and the borrowed heating-rate relation introduce systematic errors not reflected in the fit covariance, so a fair comparison with other methods should quote a wider error bar.
  • The method's accuracy depends on the strength of the polarization-based selection rules; in materials or geometries where multiple scattering redistributes diffuse intensity between Brillouin zones, the linear inversion will be less reliable unless a correction for secondary Bragg scattering is included.
  • A natural test of the method's internal consistency would be to compare population dynamics extracted at two different pump fluences: the extracted coupling constants should be fluence-independent, while the transient populations should scale with absorbed energy density.
  • If generalized to three-dimensional polarization information, the same data-reduction route could in principle supply momentum-resolved phonon populations in anisotropic materials relevant to charge-density-wave and superconducting phases, where mode-resolved coupling is the key unknown.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

2 major / 5 minor

Summary. The paper presents a generally-applicable data reduction method for ultrafast electron diffuse scattering (UEDS) that recovers time- and momentum-resolved phonon populations from measured diffuse intensities and DFPT-computed phonon polarization vectors, without free parameters in the linear inversion (Eq. 7). The method is demonstrated on graphite, where the authors extract transient populations of the in-plane phonon branches and, using a non-thermal lattice model fit, report a mode-projected electron-phonon coupling of <g^2_{e,A'_1}> = 0.035 ± 0.001 eV^2 for the A'_1 phonon at K, obtained from the fitted heating rate via the conversion in Appendix B. The paper claims agreement with trARPES measurements and simulations.

Significance. If the central results hold, the paper establishes UEDS as a tabletop probe of full-Brillouin-zone, mode-resolved phonon dynamics, directly analogous to trARPES for the lattice system. The population-decomposition framework is internally consistent and carefully validated: the linear inversion uses M=44 reflections with no fitted parameters, and the authors explicitly check that time-dependent Debye-Waller changes are negligible. The paper also ships open-source tooling (scikit-ued) and detailed DFPT inputs, which aids reproducibility. The headline coupling value, however, is only as solid as the conversion in Appendix B, and the concerns raised below affect that absolute value and the claimed agreement with other measurements.

major comments (2)
  1. [Appendix B, Eq. (B10)] The conversion from the fitted heating rate to <g^2_{e,A'_1}> evaluates the electronic DOS D_e at ℏων − ℏω_{j,k}, with ℏων stated to be the 1.55 eV pump photon energy. For an 800 nm excitation in a Dirac-cone material, the photoinjected electron sits approximately 0.775 eV above the Dirac point, not 1.55 eV. After emitting an A'_1 phonon (ℏω ≈ 0.17 eV), the relevant final electron energy is ≈ 0.605 eV. Since D_e(ε) ∝ |ε| (Eq. B9), evaluating at 1.38 eV instead of 0.605 eV overestimates the DOS by ≈ 2.3×, which—because <g^2> is inversely proportional to D_e in Eq. (B10)—underestimates the coupling by the same factor. The corrected value would be ≈ 0.08 eV^2, well outside the quoted ±0.001 eV^2. This error directly challenges the claimed agreement with other techniques. The authors must either correct the energy argument or explicitly justify why D_e should be evaluated at the full photon energy in this two-band picture.
  2. [Appendix B, Eqs. (B8)–(B10)] The conversion chain rests on two unquantified approximations: (i) the graphene 2D linear DOS, Eq. (B9), is taken to represent graphite near the K point, and (ii) Eq. (B10) is adopted from a preprint (Ref. [62]) without derivation or a stated range of validity. The reported uncertainty ±0.001 eV^2 is only the NLM fit covariance; it does not include the systematic error in the DOS approximation (including the choice of v_F) or the uncertainty in the borrowed conversion relation. Since these choices can shift the headline value substantially, the authors should derive Eq. (B10), or cite a peer-reviewed derivation, and provide a sensitivity analysis of <g^2> with respect to the DOS parameters.
minor comments (5)
  1. [§IV C] The phrase "anndmode-dependent" should read "and mode-dependent".
  2. [§IV D] "Similarily" should be "Similarly".
  3. [Appendix B, Eq. (B10)] The symbol ℏων denotes the optical excitation energy, but ων could be confused with a phonon frequency; use a distinct symbol such as E_pump to avoid ambiguity.
  4. [§IV E, Fig. 7] The caption of Fig. 6 states an uncertainty of ≈4×10^-5 on the population values, while Fig. 7 shows the A'_1 population change in arbitrary units; the relationship between these two error statements should be clarified.
  5. [§II B] The term "kinematical scattering" should be "kinematic scattering" for consistency with standard usage.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity: the population decomposition is data-plus-DFPT with no free parameters, and the A'_1 coupling conversion is an external calibration rather than a self-referential fit.

full rationale

The central data-reduction chain is self-contained. Equations (1)-(10) invert the measured transient diffuse intensities against DFPT-computed one-phonon structure factors to recover mode-resolved population changes {Delta n_{j,k}(t)} with no fitted parameters, and the paper explicitly checks that Debye-Waller time-dependence is negligible. The subsequent extraction of G_{e,A'_1} is a standard fit of the non-thermal lattice model, Eqs. (17)-(19), to the measured A'_1 population transient. The headline <g^2_{e,A'_1}> value is then obtained from that fitted heating rate through Eq. (B10), which is cited to Ref. [62] (Na et al.) rather than derived inside the paper. That step is an external, model-dependent conversion: the graphene density-of-states approximation and the energy argument entering D_e(hbar omega_nu - hbar omega_{j,k}) are potential sources of systematic error, but they do not make the result equal to its inputs by construction. The same-group citations in the paper (Refs. [22], [27], [41]) are used for prior qualitative discussion, instrument descriptions, or software, and are not load-bearing for the central claim. The acknowledgment of M. X. Na for insights on the heating-rate-to-coupling relation does not constitute self-citation, and no equation in the paper reduces the measured population dynamics to the claimed coupling value by definition. Therefore no circular step is exhibited.

Assumptions & free parameters 4 free parameters · 7 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The population decomposition itself is parameter-free, but the extraction of the headline coupling value introduces three fitted coupling constants plus a hand-chosen integration radius, and relies on several material-modeling assumptions (DFPT phonons, NLM, graphene DOS, borrowed conversion formula). These are the costs the reader pays after the central measurement.

free parameters (4)
  • Ge,A'1 (electron-A'1 coupling) = (6.8±0.3)×10^17 W m^-3 K^-1
    Fitted to the measured A'1 population dynamics with the non-thermal lattice model equations (17)-(19); the headline g^2 value is derived from this fitted constant.
  • GA'1,l (A'1-lattice coupling) = (8.0±0.5)×10^17 W m^-3 K^-1
    Fitted simultaneously in the same three-equation model.
  • Ge,l (electron-lattice coupling) = (0.0±6.0)×10^15 W m^-3 K^-1
    Fitted; the large uncertainty shows the data do not constrain this coupling well.
  • A'1 integration radius = 0.3 Å^-1
    Hand-chosen radius for integrating the TO2 population near K to define the A'1 population (Section IV E); no sensitivity analysis provided.
assumptions (7)
  • domain assumption Kinematical single-scattering approximation for the diffuse intensity.
    Section III states the intensity expressions apply rigorously under single scattering; the paper argues multiple scattering is weak based on thickness variation tests.
  • domain assumption One-phonon approximation; higher-order inelastic terms are negligible.
    Section III ignores I2 and higher terms because their cross-sections are much smaller.
  • domain assumption Phonon frequencies and one-phonon structure factors are time-independent over the measured delays.
    Sections IV B and IV D argue anharmonic frequency shifts are negligible and Debye-Waller changes are at most 1.5-5%, hence |F1j(q,t)|^2 = |F1j(q,t0)|^2.
  • domain assumption DFPT-computed phonon polarization vectors and frequencies are accurate enough for the inversion.
    The structure factors in Eq. (3) depend on these computed quantities; errors in phonon eigenvectors would propagate into the population maps.
  • domain assumption The non-thermal lattice model with three coupled reservoirs describes the A'1 energy flow.
    Equations (17)-(19) reduce the phonon system to electrons, A'1, and an effective lattice bath; the effective heat capacity Cl is built from Bonini et al.'s decay probabilities.
  • ad hoc to paper A 2D graphene density of states is adequate for graphite in the conversion of heating rate to g^2.
    Appendix B uses D_e(epsilon) = 2A|epsilon|/(pi (hbar v_F)^2) with graphene v_F; this is an approximation chosen for the in-plane analysis, and no sensitivity test is provided.
  • domain assumption The relation between heating rate and mode-projected coupling, Eq. (B10), is valid as taken from ref [62].
    The paper imports this relation from a preprint by overlapping authors without derivation.

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Time- and momentum-resolved phonon population dynamics with ultrafast electron diffuse scattering." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/S2XCJOVF

@misc{pith2026190802795,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Time- and momentum-resolved phonon population dynamics with ultrafast electron diffuse scattering},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/S2XCJOVF}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:1908.02795}
}
abstract

Interactions between the lattice and charge carriers can drive the formation of phases and ordering phenomena that give rise to conventional superconductivity, insulator-to-metal transitions, and charge-density waves. These couplings also play a determining role in properties that include electric and thermal conductivity. Ultrafast electron diffuse scattering (UEDS) has recently become a viable laboratory-scale tool to track energy flow into and within the lattice system across the entire Brillouin zone, and deconvolves interactions in the time domain. Here, we present a detailed quantitative framework for the interpretation of UEDS signals, ultimately extracting the phonon mode occupancies across the entire Brillouin zone. These transient populations are then used to extract momentum- and mode-dependent electron-phonon and phonon-phonon coupling constants. Results of this analysis are presented for graphite, which provides complete information on the phonon-branch occupations and a determination of the $A_1'$ phonon mode-projected electron-phonon coupling strength $\langle g_{e,A_1'}^2 \rangle = 0.035 \pm 0.001$ eV$^2$ that is in agreement with other measurement techniques and simulations.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 1908.02795 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. FIG. 1. Schematic diagram of ultrafast electron diffuse scat [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p002_1.png] view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. FIG. 2. Experimental change in transient electron scattering intensity ∆ [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p004_2.png] view at source ↗
Figure 3
Figure 3. FIG. 3. Calculated one-phonon structure factors [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_3.png] view at source ↗
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Figure 4
Figure 4. Figure 4: FIG. 4. Calculated one-phonon structure factors [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p006_4.png]
Figure 5
Figure 5. Figure 5: FIG. 5. Reciprocal space locations where [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p006_5.png]
Figure 6
Figure 6. Figure 6: FIG. 6. Experimental change in transient population, across the Brillouin zone, of relevant in-plane modes of graphite following [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p009_6.png]
Figure 7
Figure 7. Figure 7: FIG. 7. Evolution of the [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p010_7.png]

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

65 extracted references · 63 canonical work pages

  1. [62]

    Direct determination of mode-projected electron-phonon coupling in the time-domain

    author author M. Na , author A. K. \ Mills , author F. Boschini , author M. Michiardi , author B. Nosarzewski , author R. P. \ Day , author E. Razzoli , author A. Sheyerman , author M. Schneider ,\ and\ author G. Levy ,\ title title Direct determination of mode-projected electron-phonon coupling in the time-domain ,\ @noop journal journal arXiv e-prints \...

    work page Pith review arXiv 1902

  2. [1]

    Eliashberg ,\ title title Interactions between electrons and lattice vibrations in a superconductor ,\ @noop journal journal Sov

    author author G. Eliashberg ,\ title title Interactions between electrons and lattice vibrations in a superconductor ,\ @noop journal journal Sov. Phys. JETP \ volume 11 ,\ pages 696 ( year 1960 ) NoStop

    work page 1960

  3. [2]

    Hur , author S

    author author N. Hur , author S. Park , author P. Sharma , author J. Ahn , author S. Guha ,\ and\ author S.-W. \ Cheong ,\ title title Electric polarization reversal and memory in a multiferroic material induced by magnetic fields ,\ @noop journal journal Nature \ volume 429 ,\ pages 392 ( year 2004 ) NoStop

    work page 2004

  4. [3]

    \ Zhao , author G

    author author L.-D. \ Zhao , author G. Tan , author S. Hao , author J. He , author Y. Pei , author H. Chi , author H. Wang , author S. Gong , author H. Xu , author V. P. \ Dravid , author C. Uher , author G. J. \ Snyder , author C. Wolverton ,\ and\ author M. G. \ Kanatzidis ,\ title title Ultrahigh power factor and thermoelectric performance in hole-dope...

    doi:10.1126/science.aad3749

  5. [4]

    Miyata , author D

    author author K. Miyata , author D. Meggiolaro , author M. T. \ Trinh , author P. P. \ Joshi , author E. Mosconi , author S. C. \ Jones , author F. De Angelis ,\ and\ author X.-Y. \ Zhu ,\ title title Large polarons in lead halide perovskites ,\ journal journal Science Advances \ volume 3 ,\ https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.1701217 10.1126/sciadv.1701217 ( ...

    work page doi:10.1126/sciadv.1701217

  6. [5]

    author author K. W. \ Kim , author A. Pashkin , author H. Sch \"a fer , author M. Beyer , author M. Porer , author T. Wolf , author C. Bernhard , author J. Demsar , author R. Huber ,\ and\ author A. Leitenstorfer ,\ title title Ultrafast transient generation of spin-density-wave order in the normal state of bafe 2 as 2 driven by coherent lattice vibration...

    work page 2012

  7. [6]

    Lanzara , author P

    author author A. Lanzara , author P. Bogdanov , author X. Zhou , author S. Kellar , author D. Feng , author E. Lu , author T. Yoshida , author H. Eisaki , author A. Fujimori , author K. Kishio , et al. ,\ title title Evidence for ubiquitous strong electron--phonon coupling in high-temperature superconductors ,\ @noop journal journal Nature \ volume 412 ,\...

    work page 2001

  8. [7]

    Lan , author B

    author author Y. Lan , author B. J. \ Dringoli , author D. A. \ Valverde-Ch \'a vez , author C. S. \ Ponseca , author M. Sutton , author Y. He , author M. G. \ Kanatzidis ,\ and\ author D. G. \ Cooke ,\ title title Ultrafast correlated charge and lattice motion in a hybrid metal halide perovskite ,\ @noop journal journal Science Advances \ volume 5 ( year...

    work page 2019

Show all 65 references
  1. [8]

    Porer , author U

    author author M. Porer , author U. Leierseder , author J.-M. \ M \' e nard , author H. Dachraoui , author L. Mouchliadis , author I. E. \ Perakis , author U. Heinzmann , author J. Demsar , author K. Rossnagel ,\ and\ author R. Huber ,\ title title Non-thermal separation of ele...

    2014

  2. [9]

    author author K. T. \ Tsen \ and\ author D. K. \ Ferry ,\ title title Studies of electron–phonon and phonon–phonon interactions in InN using ultrafast Raman spectroscopy ,\ @noop journal journal Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter \ volume 21 ,\ pages 174202 ( year 2009 ) NoStop

    2009

  3. [10]

    Yan , author D

    author author H. Yan , author D. Song , author K. F. \ Mak , author I. Chatzakis , author J. Maultzsch ,\ and\ author T. F. \ Heinz ,\ title title Time-resolved Raman spectroscopy of optical phonons in graphite: Phonon anharmonic coupling and anomalous stiffening ,\ @noop jour...

    2009

  4. [11]

    \ Yang , author S

    author author J.-A. \ Yang , author S. Parham , author D. Dessau ,\ and\ author D. Reznik ,\ title title Novel Electron-Phonon Relaxation Pathway in Graphite Revealed by Time-Resolved Raman Scattering and Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy ,\ @noop journal journal Scien...

    2017

  5. [12]

    author author J. C. \ Johannsen , author S. Ulstrup , author F. Cilento , author A. Crepaldi , author M. Zacchigna , author C. Cacho , author I. C. E. \ Turcu , author E. Springate , author F. Fromm , author C. Raidel , author T. Seyller , author F. Parmigiani , author M. Grio...

    2013

  6. [13]

    Gierz , author F

    author author I. Gierz , author F. Calegari , author S. Aeschlimann , author M. C. \ Cervantes , author C. Cacho , author R. T. \ Chapman , author E. Springate , author S. Link , author U. Starke , author C. R. \ Ast ,\ and\ author A. Cavalleri ,\ title title Tracking Primary ...

    2015

  7. [14]

    Stange , author C

    author author A. Stange , author C. Sohrt , author L. X. \ Yang , author G. Rohde , author K. Janssen , author P. Hein , author L.-P. \ Oloff , author K. Hanff , author K. Rossnagel ,\ and\ author M. Bauer ,\ title title Hot electron cooling in graphite: Supercollision versus ...

    2015

  8. [15]

    Rohde , author A

    author author G. Rohde , author A. Stange , author A. M\"uller , author M. Behrendt , author L.-P. \ Oloff , author K. Hanff , author T. J. \ Albert , author P. Hein , author K. Rossnagel ,\ and\ author M. Bauer ,\ title title Ultrafast formation of a fermi-dirac distributed e...

    2018

  9. [16]

    Trigo , author J

    author author M. Trigo , author J. Chen , author V. H. \ Vishwanath , author Y. M. \ Sheu , author T. Graber , author R. Henning ,\ and\ author D. A. \ Reis ,\ title title Imaging nonequilibrium atomic vibrations with x-ray diffuse scattering ,\ @noop journal journal Physical ...

    2010

  10. [17]

    Zhu , author Y

    author author X. Zhu , author Y. Cao , author J. Zhang , author E. W. \ Plummer ,\ and\ author J. Guo ,\ title title Classification of charge density waves based on their nature. ,\ @noop journal journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of A...

    2015

  11. [18]

    Wall , author S

    author author S. Wall , author S. Yang , author L. Vidas , author M. Chollet , author J. Glownia , author M. Kozina , author T. Katayama , author T. Henighan , author M. Jiang , author T. Miller , author D. Reis , author L. Boatner , author O. Delaire ,\ and\ author M. Trigo ,...

    2018

  12. [19]

    Harb , author H

    author author M. Harb , author H. Enquist , author A. Jurgilaitis , author F. T. \ Tuyakova , author A. N. \ Obraztsov ,\ and\ author J. Larsson ,\ title title Phonon-phonon interactions in photoexcited graphite studied by ultrafast electron diffraction ,\ @noop journal journa...

    2016

  13. [20]

    Chase , author M

    author author T. Chase , author M. Trigo , author A. H. \ Reid , author R. Li , author T. Vecchione , author X. Shen , author S. Weathersby , author R. Coffee , author N. Hartmann , author D. A. \ Reis , author X. J. \ Wang ,\ and\ author H. A. \ D \" u rr ,\ title title Ultra...

    2016

  14. [21]

    Waldecker , author R

    author author L. Waldecker , author R. Bertoni , author H. H \" u bener , author T. Brumme , author T. Vasileiadis , author D. Zahn , author A. Rubio ,\ and\ author R. Ernstorfer ,\ title title Momentum-Resolved View of Electron-Phonon Coupling in Multilayer WSe _2 ,\ @noop jo...

    2017

  15. [22]

    author author M. J. \ Stern , author L. P. \ Ren \' e de Cotret , author M. R. \ Otto , author R. P. \ Chatelain , author J.-P. \ Boisvert , author M. Sutton ,\ and\ author B. J. \ Siwick ,\ title title Mapping momentum-dependent electron-phonon coupling and nonequilibrium pho...

    2018

  16. [23]

    Konstantinova , author J

    author author T. Konstantinova , author J. D. \ Rameau , author A. H. \ Reid , author O. Abdurazakov , author L. Wu , author R. Li , author X. Shen , author G. Gu , author Y. Huang , author L. Rettig , author I. Avigo , author M. Ligges , author J. K. \ Freericks , author A. F...

    2018

  17. [24]

    author author G. H. \ Kassier , author K. Haupt , author N. Erasmus , author E. Rohwer , author H. Von Bergmann , author H. Schwoerer , author S. M. \ Coelho ,\ and\ author F. D. \ Auret ,\ title title A compact streak camera for 150 fs time resolved measurement of bright puls...

    2010

  18. [25]

    author author R. P. \ Chatelain , author V. R. \ Morrison , author C. Godbout ,\ and\ author B. J. \ Siwick ,\ title title Ultrafast electron diffraction with radio-frequency compressed electron pulses ,\ @noop journal journal Applied Physics Letters \ volume 101 ,\ pages 0819...

    2012

  19. [26]

    author author V. R. \ Morrison , author R. P. \ Chatelain , author C. Godbout ,\ and\ author B. J. \ Siwick ,\ title title Direct optical measurements of the evolving spatio-temporal charge density in ultrashort electron pulses ,\ @noop journal journal Optics Express \ volume ...

    2013

  20. [27]

    author author M. R. \ Otto , author L. P. \ Ren \' e de Cotret , author M. J. \ Stern ,\ and\ author B. J. \ Siwick ,\ title title Solving the jitter problem in microwave compressed ultrafast electron diffraction instruments: Robust sub-50 fs cavity-laser phase stabilization ,...

    2017

  21. [28]

    note The intensity fluctuations of pixel values across scattering patterns acquired before photoexcitation are 10^8 times smaller than the brightest Bragg reflection NoStop

  22. [29]

    Giannozzi , author O

    author author P. Giannozzi , author O. Andreussi , author T. Brumme , author O. Bunau , author M. B. \ Nardelli , author M. Calandra , author R. Car , author C. Cavazzoni , author D. Ceresoli , author M. Cococcioni , author N. Colonna , author I. Carnimeo , author A. D. \ Cors...

    2017

  23. [30]

    note The space group of this structure is P6_3/mmc (Hermann-Mauguin symbol) or D_ 6h ^4 (Schoenflies symbol). Stop

  24. [31]

    author author A. D. \ Becke ,\ title title On the large gradient behavior of the density functional exchange energy ,\ @noop journal journal The Journal of Chemical Physics \ volume 85 ,\ pages 7184 ( year 1986 ) NoStop

    1986

  25. [32]

    author author J. P. \ Perdew , author K. Burke ,\ and\ author M. Ernzerhof ,\ title title Generalized gradient approximation made simple ,\ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Lett. \ volume 77 ,\ pages 3865 ( year 1996 ) NoStop

    1996

  26. [33]

    author author P. E. \ Bl\"ochl ,\ title title Projector augmented-wave method ,\ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. B \ volume 50 ,\ pages 17953 ( year 1994 ) NoStop

    1994

  27. [34]

    author author A. D. \ Becke \ and\ author E. R. \ Johnson ,\ title title Exchange-hole dipole moment and the dispersion interaction revisited ,\ @noop journal journal The Journal of Chemical Physics \ volume 127 ,\ pages 154108 ( year 2007 ) NoStop

    2007

  28. [35]

    note Detector counts for the brightest Bragg peak reaches as much as 20 000 counts, while the average diffuse feature shown in Figure FIG:graphite is 0.2 counts. Stop

  29. [36]

    author author Z. L. \ Wang ,\ @noop title Elastic and Inelastic Scattering in Electron Diffraction and Imaging \ ( publisher Springer New York ,\ year 1995 ) NoStop

    1995

  30. [37]

    Xu \ and\ author T

    author author R. Xu \ and\ author T. C. \ Chiang ,\ title title Determination of phonon dispersion relations by X-ray thermal diffuse scattering ,\ @noop journal journal Zeitschrift fur Kristallographie \ volume 220 ,\ pages 1009 ( year 2005 ) NoStop

    2005

  31. [38]

    author author J. M. \ Cowley \ and\ author P. M. \ Fields ,\ title title Dynamical theory for electron scattering from crystal defects and disorder ,\ https://doi.org/10.1107/S0567739479000061 journal journal Acta Crystallographica Section A \ volume 35 ,\ pages 28 ( year 1979...

    doi

  32. [39]

    Paulatto , author F

    author author L. Paulatto , author F. Mauri ,\ and\ author M. Lazzeri ,\ title title Anharmonic properties from a generalized third-order ab initio approach: Theory and applications to graphite and graphene ,\ @noop journal journal PHYSICAL REVIEW B \ volume 87 ,\ pages MISSIN...

    2013

  33. [40]

    note The coverage of irreducible k -points is important. Only computing phonon properties along high-symmetry lines is fraught with peril, given that polarization vectors can vary significantly not only along high-symmetry lines, but over the entire Brillouin zone. Stop

  34. [41]

    author author L. P. \ Ren \'e de Cotret , author M. R. \ Otto , author M. J. \ Stern ,\ and\ author B. J. \ Siwick ,\ title title An open-source software ecosystem for the interactive exploration of ultrafast electron scattering data ,\ @noop journal journal Advanced Structura...

    2018

  35. [42]

    The discrepancy between maximum temperatures represents the fact that the heat capacity of acoustic modes is much higher

    note A maximum of 5000 for optical modes, and 1000 for acoustic modes. The discrepancy between maximum temperatures represents the fact that the heat capacity of acoustic modes is much higher. Stop

  36. [43]

    note The calculation of |F_ 1j ( q , t)| is trivial for out-of-plane modes ZA, ZO1 -- ZO3 because q e _ j,s, k 0 for these modes. Stop

  37. [44]

    Calizo , author A

    author author I. Calizo , author A. A. \ Balandin , author W. Bao , author F. Miao ,\ and\ author C. N. \ Lau ,\ title title Temperature dependence of the raman spectra of graphene and graphene multilayers ,\ https://doi.org/10.1021/nl071033g journal journal Nano Letters \ vol...

    doi

  38. [45]

    Judek , author A

    author author J. Judek , author A. P. \ Gertych , author M. Świniarski , author A. Łapińska , author A. Dużyńska ,\ and\ author M. Zdrojek ,\ title title High accuracy determination of the thermal properties of supported 2d materials ,\ https://doi.org/10.1038/srep12422 journa...

    doi

  39. [46]

    While not necessary, it leads to more reliable solutions

    note The positivity constraint n_ j, k (t) > 0 t means that the phonon population of a branch cannot drop below its equilibrium level. While not necessary, it leads to more reliable solutions. Stop

  40. [47]

    author author C. L. \ Lawson \ and\ author R. J. \ Hanson ,\ @noop title Solving Least Squares Problems \ ( publisher SIAM ,\ year 1987 )\ note chapter 23. Linear Least Squares with Linear Inequality Constraints NoStop

    1987

  41. [48]

    Kampfrath , author L

    author author T. Kampfrath , author L. Perfetti , author F. Schapper , author C. Frischkorn ,\ and\ author M. Wolf ,\ title title Strongly Coupled Optical Phonons in the Ultrafast Dynamics of the Electronic Energy and Current Relaxation in Graphite ,\ @noop journal journal Phy...

    2005

  42. [49]

    Bonini , author M

    author author N. Bonini , author M. Lazzeri , author N. Marzari ,\ and\ author F. Mauri ,\ title title Phonon Anharmonicities in Graphite and Graphene ,\ @noop journal journal Physical Review Letters \ volume 99 ,\ pages 176802 ( year 2007 ) NoStop

    2007

  43. [50]

    However, we were not able to measure population changes close enough to

    note On the other hand, a monotonic increase in LA population at is expected from the decay of the other SCOP, A_1' , which has a high probability to decay into a pair of LA-LO modes. However, we were not able to measure population changes close enough to . Stop

  44. [51]

    Lax , author P

    author author M. Lax , author P. Hu ,\ and\ author V. Narayanamurti ,\ title title Spontaneous phonon decay selection rule: N and U processes ,\ @noop journal journal Physical Review B \ volume 23 ,\ pages 3095 ( year 1981 ) NoStop

    1981

  45. [52]

    Khitun \ and\ author K

    author author A. Khitun \ and\ author K. L. \ Wang ,\ title title Modification of the three-phonon Umklapp process in a quantum wire ,\ @noop journal journal Applied Physics Letters \ volume 79 ,\ pages 851 ( year 2001 ) NoStop

    2001

  46. [53]

    author author P. B. \ Allen ,\ title title Theory of thermal relaxation of electrons in metals ,\ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Lett. \ volume 59 ,\ pages 1460 ( year 1987 ) NoStop

    1987

  47. [54]

    Waldecker , author R

    author author L. Waldecker , author R. Bertoni , author R. Ernstorfer ,\ and\ author J. Vorberger ,\ title title Electron-phonon coupling and energy flow in a simple metal beyond the two-temperature approximation ,\ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. X \ volume 6 ,\ pages 021003...

    2016

  48. [55]

    note The electronic system thermalizes in approximately 100 Stange2015 , and hence after we can consider the electronic system to be well-described by a single temperature T_e . Stop

  49. [56]

    Piscanec , author M

    author author S. Piscanec , author M. Lazzeri , author F. Mauri , author a. C. Ferrari ,\ and\ author J. Robertson ,\ title title Kohn Anomalies and Electron-Phonon Interactions in Graphite ,\ @noop journal journal Physical Review Letters \ volume 93 ,\ pages 185503 ( year 200...

    2004

  50. [57]

    author author A. D. \ Wunsch ,\ @noop title Complex Variables with Applications \ ( publisher Addison-Wesley ,\ year 2005 )\ note section 5.6: Laurent series NoStop

    2005

  51. [58]

    Nihira \ and\ author T

    author author T. Nihira \ and\ author T. Iwata ,\ title title Temperature dependence of lattice vibrations and analysis of the specific heat of graphite ,\ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. B \ volume 68 ,\ pages 134305 ( year 2003 ) NoStop

    2003

  52. [59]

    author author R. P. \ Chatelain , author V. R. \ Morrison , author B. L. M. \ Klarenaar ,\ and\ author B. J. \ Siwick ,\ title title Coherent and Incoherent Electron-Phonon Coupling in Graphite Observed with Radio-Frequency Compressed Ultrafast Electron Diffraction ,\ @noop jo...

    2014

  53. [60]

    author author J. M. \ Ziman ,\ @noop title Principles of the Theory of Solids \ ( publisher Cambridge university press ,\ year 1979 )\ note chapter 2 NoStop

    1979

  54. [61]

    note This effective heat capacity C_l is composed of 9\ to decay into two TA modes, 36\ mode, and 55\ LA. Stop

  55. [63]

    author author E. J. \ Heller , author Y. Yang , author L. Kocia , author W. Chen , author S. Fang , author M. Borunda ,\ and\ author E. Kaxiras ,\ title title Theory of graphene raman scattering ,\ https://doi.org/10.1021/acsnano.5b07676 journal journal ACS Nano \ volume 10 ,\...

    doi

  56. [64]

    author author A. H. C. \ Neto , author F. Guinea , author N. M. R. \ Peres , author K. S. \ Novoselov ,\ and\ author A. K. \ Geim ,\ title title The electronic properties of graphene ,\ @noop journal journal Rev. Mod. Phys. \ volume 81 ,\ pages 109 ( year 2009 ) NoStop

    2009

  57. [65]

    note Note that factors of are often ignored, including in the accompanying reference. Stop

Pith tools

Reviewed August 14, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.