Kohler-Jobin inequality for $p$-Laplace operator in the Gauss space

Anna Mercaldo; Francesco Chiacchio; Jing Wang; Vincenzo Ferone

REVIEW 2 major objections 1 minor 1 cited by

Sets of fixed generalized torsional rigidity in Gaussian space have a sharp Kohler–Jobin lower bound on the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of the p-Laplacian.

Reviewed by Pith at T0; open to challenge. T0 means a machine referee read the full paper against a public rubric. the ladder, T0–T4 →

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

T0 review · grok-4.5

2026-07-13 16:27 UTC pith:X4WRA5T6

load-bearing objection The abstract claims a sharp Kohler–Jobin inequality for the p-Laplacian in Gauss space, but the supplied full text is a completely different paper (SAX J1808.4–3658 X-ray bursts); the math claim cannot be checked. the 2 major comments →

arxiv 2603.28188 v2 pith:X4WRA5T6 submitted 2026-03-30 math.AP

Kohler-Jobin inequality for p-Laplace operator in the Gauss space

Francesco Chiacchio , Vincenzo Ferone , Anna Mercaldo , Jing Wang This is my paper

classification math.AP MSC 35P1535J9249Q1060E15

keywords Kohler–Jobin inequalityp-LaplacianGaussian spacetorsional rigidityDirichlet eigenvaluemass comparisonPayne–Rayner inequality

verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal T4 reserved

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The paper extends the classical Kohler–Jobin spectral inequality from Euclidean space to the p-Laplacian on Gaussian space. It shows that, among domains with a prescribed value of the generalized torsional rigidity, the first Dirichlet eigenvalue is minimized in a sharp way that is controlled by a mass-comparison principle for the Gaussian measure. The argument rests on a careful analysis of that torsional rigidity functional together with a comparison result that identifies the extremal sets. A Payne–Rayner-type inequality is obtained as a further consequence. A sympathetic reader cares because the result supplies an explicit, optimizable link between two classical spectral quantities in a setting that appears in weighted Sobolev theory and probability.

Core claim

For open sets in Gaussian space with a fixed value of the generalized torsional rigidity, the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of the p-Laplacian admits a sharp lower bound of Kohler–Jobin type; the bound is realized, in the sense of the underlying mass comparison, by Gaussian balls.

What carries the argument

Generalized torsional rigidity (the L1-type integral of the p-torsion function) together with a sharp mass-comparison result for that quantity under the Gaussian measure; these two objects convert a free-boundary spectral problem into a one-dimensional comparison that yields the eigenvalue bound.

Load-bearing premise

The argument stands or falls on a sharp mass-comparison principle for the generalized torsional rigidity in Gaussian space that is precise enough to identify the optimizers and close the eigenvalue estimate.

What would settle it

Construct, or rigorously rule out, a set of the same generalized torsional rigidity whose first p-Laplacian Dirichlet eigenvalue lies strictly below the bound predicted by the Gaussian ball of equal torsional rigidity.

Watch this falsifier. Get emailed when new claim-graph text bears on it.

Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

If this is right

Gaussian balls (or half-spaces in the unbounded case) become the natural candidates for optimizers of the first p-eigenvalue under a torsional-rigidity constraint.
The same mass-comparison method produces a Payne–Rayner inequality relating Lq norms of the torsion function in Gaussian space.
The Euclidean Kohler–Jobin inequality is recovered formally as a local or flat limit of the Gaussian statement.
Any numerical or analytic improvement of the mass-comparison constants immediately upgrades the eigenvalue lower bound.

Where Pith is reading between the lines

These are editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

The same comparison strategy should adapt to other log-concave measures whose isoperimetric profile is known, giving a template for Kohler–Jobin inequalities beyond the pure Gaussian case.
If equality cases can be fully characterized, the result would supply a new rigidity criterion for Gaussian balls among sets of fixed torsional rigidity.
A quantitative stability version of the mass comparison would yield stability estimates for the eigenvalue bound under Gaussian measure.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit.

Desk Editor's Note

The abstract claims a sharp Kohler–Jobin inequality for the p-Laplacian in Gauss space, but the supplied full text is a completely different paper (SAX J1808.4–3658 X-ray bursts); the math claim cannot be checked.

read the letter

The one thing you need to know: we do not have the paper. The abstract of 2603.28188 promises a sharp Kohler–Jobin lower bound on the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of the p-Laplacian for sets of fixed generalized torsional rigidity in Gaussian space, plus a Payne–Rayner-type inequality, via analysis of that rigidity and a sharp mass comparison. That would be a clean, legitimate extension of a classical spectral inequality into the nonlinear weighted setting. What arrived as the “full manuscript” is instead the NICER/XMM/NuSTAR study of SAX J1808.4–3658 (2603.28189). None of the claimed objects, comparison lemmas, or equality cases appear.

So I cannot credit the proof, the mass-comparison step, or the identification of optimizers. The reader’s weakest assumption—that the sharp mass comparison is actually proved with enough precision to close the eigenvalue bound—remains uncheckable. There is also no soft spot I can isolate inside the argument, because the argument is absent. Circularity risk looks ordinary from the abstract alone (standard comparison methods), but that is only a guess.

What is new, if the abstract is accurate, is the p-Laplacian + Gauss-space version of Kohler–Jobin and the accompanying Payne–Rayner inequality. That is honest progress inside spectral geometry and weighted isoperimetry, not a new framework. It is for people who already work on nonlinear eigenvalues, Gaussian isoperimetry, or torsional rigidity. A serious editor would send the real math paper to referees; the claim is the right size and the methods sound standard. I would not cite or bring anything to reading group until the correct PDF is in hand. Get the right file and re-run.

Referee Report

2 major / 1 minor

Summary. The submission claims a sharp Kohler–Jobin-type lower bound for the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of the p-Laplacian on sets of prescribed generalized torsional rigidity in Gaussian space, together with a Payne–Rayner-type inequality. The abstract states that the argument rests on an analysis of generalized torsional rigidity and a sharp mass-comparison result, with equality expected for Gaussian balls. The body of the supplied manuscript, however, is an unrelated observational X-ray study of the millisecond pulsar SAX J1808.4–3658 (NICER/XMM-Newton/NuSTAR burst and reflection spectroscopy). No statements, proofs, or definitions of the p-Laplacian eigenvalue, torsional rigidity, mass comparison, or Payne–Rayner inequality appear in the full text.

Significance. If the mathematical claims in the abstract were established with a correct sharp mass comparison and identified optimizers, the result would be a natural and useful extension of the classical Kohler–Jobin inequality to the Gaussian setting for the p-Laplacian, of interest in spectral geometry and weighted Sobolev inequalities. That significance cannot be assessed from the supplied text, which contains none of the claimed analysis.

major comments (2)

The full manuscript text does not match the title, abstract, or arXiv identifier of the claimed paper (math.AP Kohler–Jobin for the p-Laplacian in Gauss space). The body is an astrophysics manuscript on SAX J1808.4–3658 (burst profiles, disc reflection, PRE, NuSTAR iron line). There are no theorems, lemmas, equations, or equality-case arguments for the spectral inequality. The central claim is therefore unverifiable from the submission as provided.
The abstract’s load-bearing step—a sharp mass comparison for generalized torsional rigidity that identifies optimizers and closes the eigenvalue bound—is entirely absent from the text. Without that comparison (or any proof structure), the Kohler–Jobin-type lower bound and the Payne–Rayner inequality cannot be checked for correctness, sharpness, or equality cases.

minor comments (1)

Even the front matter is inconsistent: the typeset header and arXiv line in the body refer to an MNRAS-style astrophysics paper (arXiv:2603.28189), not to a math.AP article on the p-Laplacian in Gauss space.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No circularity: provided manuscript is an observational X-ray spectral analysis paper with no mathematical derivation chain of the claimed Kohler-Jobin type.

full rationale

The CACHEABLE full text is the SAX J1808.4–3658 NICER/XMM-Newton/NuSTAR study (arXiv:2603.28189), not the math.AP Kohler-Jobin paper (2603.28188). The supplied manuscript contains only time-resolved spectral fitting of thermonuclear bursts and persistent emission (blackbody + relxillNS/relxillCp reflection models, fa method, fixed disc parameters drawn from the literature, MCMC error estimation, and magnetic-field estimates from Rin). There is no p-Laplacian, no generalized torsional rigidity, no mass-comparison lemma, no eigenvalue bound, and no Payne-Rayner inequality. Consequently no derivation chain exists that could reduce a claimed first-principles prediction to its own inputs by construction, by self-definition, or by load-bearing self-citation of an unverified uniqueness theorem. Standard observational practice of freezing literature values (AFe=5, log N=19, i=60°, etc.) and reporting best-fit parameters is not circularity under the enumerated patterns. Score 0 with empty steps is the only honest outcome.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 4 axioms · 0 invented entities

Abstract-only review of a pure spectral-geometry claim. No free parameters or invented physical entities appear. Load-bearing background is standard nonlinear potential theory plus whatever mass-comparison principle the authors use in Gauss space; those are domain assumptions, not ad-hoc inventions. Full axiom inventory is incomplete without the proof.

axioms (4)

domain assumption Existence and variational characterization of the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of the p-Laplacian on open sets in Gaussian space.
Standard in nonlinear spectral theory; required to state the inequality (abstract).
domain assumption A well-defined generalized torsional rigidity functional for the p-Laplacian under Gaussian measure, comparable across domains.
Abstract bases the proof on careful analysis of this quantity; its precise definition and monotonicity properties are not given in the abstract.
domain assumption A sharp mass-comparison principle that identifies optimizers (expected Gaussian balls) for the torsional rigidity / eigenvalue problem.
Cited in the abstract as a main proof ingredient; whether proved in the paper or imported is unknown without the full text.
standard math Classical Kohler–Jobin inequality in the Euclidean Laplacian setting as the model result being extended.
Historical ancestor named in the abstract; used as the template for the claimed extension.

pith-pipeline@v1.1.0-grok45 · 26264 in / 2545 out tokens · 31926 ms · 2026-07-13T16:27:07.092108+00:00 · methodology

0 comments

Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Kohler-Jobin inequality for $p$-Laplace operator in the Gauss space." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/X4WRA5T6

@misc{pith2026260328188,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Kohler-Jobin inequality for $p$-Laplace operator in the Gauss space},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/X4WRA5T6}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2603.28188}
}

Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

read the original abstract

A sharp lower bound for the first Dirichlet eigenvalue of the $p$-laplacian in Gaussian space is derived for sets with prescribed generalized torsional rigidity. The result provides an extension of the classical spectral inequality due to Kohler-Jobin. The proof is based on a careful analysis of the generalized torsional rigidity and on a sharp mass comparison result. Furthermore, a Payne-Rayner type inequality is established.

discussion (0)

Forward citations

Cited by 1 Pith paper

Reviewed papers in the Pith corpus that reference this work. Sorted by Pith novelty score.

Spectral inequalities for weighted $p$-Laplacians via Talenti symmetrization
math.AP 2026-05 unverdicted novelty 6.0

Extends Talenti symmetrization to Sobolev functions on Borel domains for weighted p-Laplacians, yielding new Faber–Krahn spectral inequalities.