Certification of genuine non-Gaussian entanglement
Pith reviewed 2026-05-08 12:08 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
A certification method identifies entangled states that no Gaussian process on separable inputs can produce.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
We characterize entanglement in the context of Gaussian and non-Gaussian processes and identify entangled states that cannot be produced by any Gaussian evolution acting on separable states. This distinction exposes intrinsic limitations of Gaussian operations and highlights the role of non-Gaussian operations as an important resource. We apply this framework to develop a certification method that connects entanglement theory with quantum non-Gaussianity. Our approach tailors the certification to experimentally relevant states that can be produced in current quantum optics experiments. We demonstrate this certification for recognizing the genuine non-Gaussian entanglement of various Fock and
What carries the argument
The distinction between entangled states reachable versus unreachable by Gaussian evolution on separable inputs, which directly certifies genuine non-Gaussian entanglement.
If this is right
- Gaussian operations are intrinsically limited in the entangled states they can generate from separable inputs.
- Non-Gaussian operations become necessary to reach certain classes of entangled states.
- The certification procedure can be applied directly to states produced in current quantum-optics setups.
- Demonstrations confirm the method works for multiple entangled Fock states and hybrid entangled states.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The method supplies a concrete experimental test for deciding whether a given entangled state genuinely requires non-Gaussian resources.
- It may be extended to certify non-Gaussian entanglement in other continuous-variable platforms beyond optics.
- The same reachability criterion could inform resource accounting in quantum information protocols that mix Gaussian and non-Gaussian gates.
Load-bearing premise
The framework correctly identifies which entangled states lie outside the set generatable by Gaussian operations on separable inputs.
What would settle it
An explicit sequence of Gaussian operations applied to a separable input state that reproduces one of the paper's example Fock or hybrid states would falsify the certification claim for that state.
Figures
read the original abstract
Entanglement is a key resource for many quantum applications. Understanding fundamental properties of entangled states is an important step towards their practical exploitation. We characterize entanglement in the context of Gaussian and non-Gaussian processes and identify entangled states that cannot be produced by any Gaussian evolution acting on separable states. This distinction exposes intrinsic limitations of Gaussian operations and highlights the role of non-Gaussian operations as an important resource. We apply this framework to develop a certification method that connects entanglement theory with quantum non-Gaussianity - an advanced quantum feature that is essential for several quantum applications. Our approach tailors the certification to experimentally relevant states that can be produced in current quantum optics experiments. We demonstrate this certification for recognizing the genuine non-Gaussian entanglement of various entangled Fock states and hybrid entangled states.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript develops a framework characterizing entanglement under Gaussian versus non-Gaussian processes, identifying states unreachable by Gaussian evolution on separable inputs. It uses this to construct a certification method linking entanglement theory to quantum non-Gaussianity, tailored for experimentally relevant states, and demonstrates the approach on entangled Fock states and hybrid entangled states.
Significance. If the certification witnesses and demonstrations are robust, the work usefully connects two active areas (entanglement certification and non-Gaussian resources) and emphasizes the necessity of non-Gaussian operations for certain entangled states. The focus on states accessible in current quantum-optics experiments is a practical strength; the distinction from Gaussian processes is standard and correctly applied without evident circularity.
minor comments (3)
- [Abstract] Abstract: the phrase 'various entangled Fock states' is vague; the main text should explicitly list the specific states (e.g., |n,m> or particular superpositions) used in the demonstrations so readers can immediately assess relevance.
- The manuscript should include a brief comparison table or paragraph contrasting the new certification with existing non-Gaussianity witnesses (e.g., those based on Wigner negativity or photon-number moments) to clarify incremental advance.
- Notation: ensure consistent use of symbols for Gaussian operations (e.g., G) versus non-Gaussian resources throughout; a short nomenclature table would aid readability.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for the positive assessment of our manuscript, the accurate summary of its contributions, and the recommendation for minor revision. No specific major comments were raised in the report.
Circularity Check
No significant circularity detected
full rationale
The paper's core framework identifies entangled states unreachable by Gaussian evolution acting on separable inputs, then uses this to certify genuine non-Gaussian entanglement for Fock and hybrid states. This distinction follows directly from the established property that Gaussian operations preserve Gaussianity, without any reduction of a claimed prediction or result to a fitted parameter, self-definition, or self-citation chain. The certification method is tailored to experimentally relevant states but does not rename known patterns or smuggle ansatzes via citation; the derivation remains self-contained against standard quantum optics benchmarks.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
Forward citations
Cited by 1 Pith paper
-
Non-Gaussian Entanglement Hierarchy Based on the Schmidt Number
Introduces witness E_NG whose ceiling bounds the Gaussian-irreducible Schmidt number, defining a hierarchy of non-Gaussian entanglement in continuous-variable systems.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Quantum communication
Nicolas Gisin and Rob Thew. “Quantum communication”. Nat. Photonics1, 165– 171 (2007)
2007
-
[2]
The quantum technologies roadmap: a Eu- ropean community view
Antonio Acín, Immanuel Bloch, Harry Buhrman, Tommaso Calarco, Christopher Eichler, Jens Eisert, Daniel Esteve, Nicolas Gisin, Steffen J Glaser, Fedor Jelezko, Ste- fan Kuhr, Maciej Lewenstein, Max F Riedel, Piet O Schmidt, Rob Thew, Andreas Wall- raff, Ian Walmsley, and Frank K Wilhelm. “The quantum technologies roadmap: a Eu- ropean community view”. New ...
2018
-
[3]
Motional Fock states for quantum-enhanced amplitude and phase measurements with trapped ions
Fabian Wolf, Chunyan Shi, Jan C. Heip, Manuel Gessner, Luca Pezzè, Augusto Smerzi, MariusSchulte, KlemensHammerer, and Piet O. Schmidt. “Motional Fock states for quantum-enhanced amplitude and phase measurements with trapped ions”. Nat. Commun.10(2019)
2019
-
[4]
Quantum-enhanced sensing of a single-ion mechanical oscillator
Katherine C. McCormick, Jonas Keller, Shaun C. Burd, David J. Wineland, An- drew C. Wilson, and Dietrich Leibfried. “Quantum-enhanced sensing of a single-ion mechanical oscillator”. Nature572, 86– 90 (2019). 8
2019
-
[5]
Heisenberg-limited single-mode quantum metrology in a superconducting circuit
W. Wang, Y. Wu, Y. Ma, W. Cai, L. Hu, X. Mu, Y. Xu, Zi-Jie Chen, H. Wang, Y. P. Song, H. Yuan, C.-L. Zou, L.-M. Duan, and L. Sun. “Heisenberg-limited single-mode quantum metrology in a superconducting circuit”. Nat. Commun.10(2019)
2019
-
[6]
Real- ization of versatile and effective quantum metrology using a single bosonic mode
Xiaozhou Pan, Tanjung Krisnanda, An- drea Duina, Kimin Park, Pengtao Song, Clara Yun Fontaine, Adrian Copetudo, Radim Filip, and Yvonne Y. Gao. “Real- ization of versatile and effective quantum metrology using a single bosonic mode”. PRX Quantum6, 010304 (2025)
2025
-
[7]
Genuine quantum non-Gaussianity and metrological sensitivity of Fock states prepared in a me- chanical resonator
Q. Rumman Rahman, Igor Kladarić, Max- Emanuel Kern, Lukáš Lachman, Yiwen Chu, Radim Filip, and Matteo Fadel. “Genuine quantum non-Gaussianity and metrological sensitivity of Fock states prepared in a me- chanical resonator”. Phys. Rev. Lett.134, 180801 (2025)
2025
-
[8]
Advances in quantum cryptography
S. Pirandola, U. L. Andersen, L. Banchi, M. Berta, D. Bunandar, R. Colbeck, D. En- glund, T. Gehring, C. Lupo, C. Ottaviani, J. L. Pereira, M. Razavi, J. Shamsul Shaari, M. Tomamichel, V. C. Usenko, G. Vallone, P. Villoresi, and P. Wallden. “Advances in quantum cryptography”. Adv. Opt. Photon. 12, 1012 (2020)
2020
-
[9]
Quantum internet: Technologies, protocols, and re- search challenges
Vinay Kumar, Claudio Cicconetti, Marco Conti, and Andrea Passarella. “Quantum internet: Technologies, protocols, and re- search challenges”. Int. J. Netw. Distrib. Comput.13(2025)
2025
-
[10]
Practical quantum advantage in quantum simulation
AndrewJ.Daley, ImmanuelBloch, Christian Kokail, Stuart Flannigan, Natalie Pearson, MatthiasTroyer, andPeterZoller. “Practical quantum advantage in quantum simulation”. Nature607, 667–676 (2022)
2022
-
[11]
Fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computing with continuous-variable cluster states
Nicolas C. Menicucci. “Fault-tolerant measurement-based quantum computing with continuous-variable cluster states”. Phys. Rev. Lett.112, 120504 (2014)
2014
-
[12]
The futureofquantumcomputingwithsupercon- ducting qubits
Sergey Bravyi, Oliver Dial, Jay M. Gam- betta, Darío Gil, and Zaira Nazario. “The futureofquantumcomputingwithsupercon- ducting qubits”. J. Appl. Phys.132(2022)
2022
-
[13]
Quantum computa- tional advantage with a programmable pho- tonic processor
Lars S. Madsen, Fabian Laudenbach, Mohsen Falamarzi. Askarani, Fabien Ror- tais, Trevor Vincent, Jacob F. F. Bul- mer, Filippo M. Miatto, Leonhard Neuhaus, Lukas G. Helt, Matthew J. Collins, Adri- ana E. Lita, Thomas Gerrits, Sae Woo Nam, Varun D. Vaidya, Matteo Menotti, Ish Dhand, Zachary Vernon, Nicolás Quesada, and Jonathan Lavoie. “Quantum computa- ti...
2022
-
[14]
IBM quantum computers: evolution, performance, and fu- ture directions
Muhammad AbuGhanem. “IBM quantum computers: evolution, performance, and fu- ture directions”. J. Supercomput.81(2025)
2025
-
[15]
Toward quantum ad- vantage with photonic state injection
Léo Monbroussou, Eliott Z. Mamon, Hugo Thomas, Verena Yacoub, Ulysse Chabaud, and Elham Kashefi. “Toward quantum ad- vantage with photonic state injection”. Phys. Rev. Res.7, 033051 (2025)
2025
-
[16]
Integrated photonic source of Gottesman–Kitaev–Preskill qubits
M. V. Larsen, J. E. Bourassa, S. Koc- sis, J. F. Tasker, R. S. Chadwick, C. González-Arciniegas, J. Hastrup, C. E. Lopetegui-González, F. M. Miatto, A. Mo- tamedi, R. Noro, G. Roeland, R. Baby, H. Chen, P. Contu, I. Di Luch, C. Drago, M. Giesbrecht, T. Grainge, I. Krasnokut- ska, M. Menotti, B. Morrison, C. Puvi- raj, K. Rezaei Shad, B. Hussain, J. McMa- ...
2025
-
[17]
Logical states for fault-tolerant quantum computa- tion with propagating light
Shunya Konno, Warit Asavanant, Fumiya Hanamura, Hironari Nagayoshi, Kosuke Fukui, Atsushi Sakaguchi, Ryuhoh Ide, Fu- mihiro China, Masahiro Yabuno, Shigehito Miki, Hirotaka Terai, Kan Takase, Mamoru Endo, Petr Marek, Radim Filip, Peter van Loock, and Akira Furusawa. “Logical states for fault-tolerant quantum computa- tion with propagating light”. Science3...
2024
-
[18]
Robust preparation of Wigner-negative states with optimized SNAP-displacement sequences
Marina Kudra, Mikael Kervinen, Ingrid Strandberg, Shahnawaz Ahmed, Marco Scigliuzzo, Amr Osman, Daniel Pérez Lozano, Mats O. Tholén, Riccardo Bor- gani, David B. Haviland, Giulia Ferrini, Jonas Bylander, Anton Frisk Kockum, Fer- nando Quijandría, Per Delsing, and Si- mone Gasparinetti. “Robust preparation of Wigner-negative states with optimized SNAP-disp...
2022
-
[19]
Encoding a qubit in a trapped-ion mechan- ical oscillator
C. Flühmann, T. L. Nguyen, M. Marinelli, 9 V. Negnevitsky, K. Mehta, and J. P. Home. “Encoding a qubit in a trapped-ion mechan- ical oscillator”. Nature566, 513–517 (2019)
2019
-
[20]
PositiveWignerfunc- tions render classical simulation of quantum computationefficient
A.MariandJ.Eisert. “PositiveWignerfunc- tions render classical simulation of quantum computationefficient”. Phys.Rev.Lett.109, 230503 (2012)
2012
-
[21]
Resources for bosonic quantum computa- tional advantage
Ulysse Chabaud and Mattia Walschaers. “Resources for bosonic quantum computa- tional advantage”. Phys. Rev. Lett.130, 090602 (2023)
2023
-
[22]
Non-Gaussian quantum states and where to find them
Mattia Walschaers. “Non-Gaussian quantum states and where to find them”. PRX Quan- tum2, 030204 (2021)
2021
-
[23]
Quantum non-gaussianity of light and atoms
Lukáš Lachman and Radim Filip. “Quantum non-gaussianity of light and atoms”. Prog. Quantum Electron.83, 100395 (2022)
2022
-
[24]
Faith- ful hierarchy of genuine n-photon quantum non-Gaussian light
Lukáš Lachman, Ivo Straka, Josef Hloušek, Miroslav Ježek, and Radim Filip. “Faith- ful hierarchy of genuine n-photon quantum non-Gaussian light”. Phys. Rev. Lett.123, 043601 (2019)
2019
-
[25]
Stellar representation of non-Gaussian quantum states
Ulysse Chabaud, Damian Markham, and Frédéric Grosshans. “Stellar representation of non-Gaussian quantum states”. Phys. Rev. Lett.124, 063605 (2020)
2020
-
[26]
Quantum non-Gaussianity of mul- tiphonon states of a single atom
L. Podhora, L. Lachman, T. Pham, A. Lešundák, O. Číp, L. Slodička, and R. Filip. “Quantum non-Gaussianity of mul- tiphonon states of a single atom”. Phys. Rev. Lett.129, 013602 (2022)
2022
-
[27]
Colloquium: Quantum coherence as a resource
Alexander Streltsov, Gerardo Adesso, and Martin B. Plenio. “Colloquium: Quantum coherence as a resource”. Rev. Mod. Phys. 89, 041003 (2017)
2017
-
[28]
New class of quantum error-correcting codes for a bosonic mode
Marios H. Michael, Matti Silveri, R. T. Brierley, Victor V. Albert, Juha Salmilehto, Liang Jiang, and S. M. Girvin. “New class of quantum error-correcting codes for a bosonic mode”. Phys. Rev. X6, 031006 (2016)
2016
-
[29]
Hierarchi- cal verification of non-Gaussian coherence in bosonic quantum states
Beate E. Asenbeck, Lukáš Lachman, Am- broise Boyer, Priyanka Giri, Alban Urvoy, Radim Filip, and Julien Laurat. “Hierarchi- cal verification of non-Gaussian coherence in bosonic quantum states”. Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 233604 (2025)
2025
-
[30]
Hierar- chies of quantum non-Gaussian coherences for bosonic systems: A theoretical study
Lukáš Lachman, Beate E. Asenbeck, Am- broise Boyer, Priyanka Giri, Alban Urvoy, Julien Laurat, and Radim Filip. “Hierar- chies of quantum non-Gaussian coherences for bosonic systems: A theoretical study”. Phys. Rev. A111(2025)
2025
-
[31]
Entanglement-assisted quantum commu- nication with simple measurements
Amélie Piveteau, Jef Pauwels, Emil Håkansson, Sadiq Muhammad, Mo- hamed Bourennane, and Armin Tavakoli. “Entanglement-assisted quantum commu- nication with simple measurements”. Nat. Commun.13(2022)
2022
-
[32]
Quantum metrology with non- classical states of atomic ensembles
Luca Pezzè, Augusto Smerzi, Markus K. Oberthaler, Roman Schmied, and Philipp Treutlein. “Quantum metrology with non- classical states of atomic ensembles”. Rev. Mod. Phys.90, 035005 (2018)
2018
-
[33]
Beating the standard quantum limit with four-entangled photons
Tomohisa Nagata, Ryo Okamoto, Jeremy L. O’Brien, Keiji Sasaki, and Shigeki Takeuchi. “Beating the standard quantum limit with four-entangled photons”. Science316, 726– 729 (2007)
2007
-
[34]
Quantum su(1,1) interferometers: Basic principles and appli- cations
Z. Y. Ou and Xiaoying Li. “Quantum su(1,1) interferometers: Basic principles and appli- cations”. APL Photonics5(2020)
2020
-
[35]
Quantum enhanced multiple-phase estimation with multi-mode N00N states
Seongjin Hong, Junaid ur Rehman, Yong- Su Kim, Young-Wook Cho, Seung-Woo Lee, HojoongJung, SungMoon, Sang-WookHan, and Hyang-Tag Lim. “Quantum enhanced multiple-phase estimation with multi-mode N00N states”. Nat. Commun.12(2021)
2021
-
[36]
Quantum supremacy using a pro- grammable superconducting processor
Frank Arute, Kunal Arya, Ryan Bab- bush, Dave Bacon, Joseph C. Bardin, Rami Barends, Rupak Biswas, Sergio Boixo, Fer- nando G. S. L. Brandao, David A. Buell, Brian Burkett, Yu Chen, Zijun Chen, Ben Chiaro, Roberto Collins, William Courtney, Andrew Dunsworth, Edward Farhi, Brooks Foxen, AustinFowler, CraigGidney, Marissa Giustina, Rob Graff, Keith Guerin, ...
2019
-
[37]
Mode- independent quantum entanglement for light
Jan Sperling, Armando Perez-Leija, Kurt Busch, and Christine Silberhorn. “Mode- independent quantum entanglement for light”. Phys. Rev. A100, 062129 (2019)
2019
-
[38]
Holomorphic representation of quantum computations
Ulysse Chabaud and Saeed Mehraban. “Holomorphic representation of quantum computations”. Quantum6, 831 (2022)
2022
-
[39]
Statistical signa- tures of multimode single-photon-added and -subtracted states of light
Mattia Walschaers, Claude Fabre, Valentina Parigi, and Nicolas Treps. “Statistical signa- tures of multimode single-photon-added and -subtracted states of light”. Phys. Rev. A96, 053835 (2017)
2017
-
[40]
Geomet- ric characterization of non-Gaussian entan- glement for finite stellar rank states
Carlos E. Lopetegui-Gonzalez, Massimo Frigerio, and Mattia Walschaers. “Geomet- ric characterization of non-Gaussian entan- glement for finite stellar rank states” (2025). arXiv:2511.02076
-
[41]
Complexity of quan- tum tomography from genuine non-gaussian entanglement
Xiaobin Zhao, Pengcheng Liao, Francesco Anna Mele, Ulysse Chabaud, and Quntao Zhuang. “Complexity of quan- tum tomography from genuine non-gaussian entanglement”. Nat. Commun. (2025)
2025
-
[42]
De- tection of mode-intrinsic quantum entangle- ment
Carlos E. Lopetegui, Mathieu Isoard, Nico- las Treps, and Mattia Walschaers. “De- tection of mode-intrinsic quantum entangle- ment”. Opt. Quantum3, 312 (2025)
2025
-
[43]
The canonical form of an antisymmetric tensor anditsapplicationtothetheoryofsupercon- ductivity
Claude Bloch and Albert Messiah. “The canonical form of an antisymmetric tensor anditsapplicationtothetheoryofsupercon- ductivity”. Nucl. Phys.39, 95–106 (1962)
1962
-
[44]
Squeezing as an irreducible resource
Samuel L. Braunstein. “Squeezing as an irreducible resource”. Phys. Rev. A71, 055801 (2005)
2005
-
[45]
Separable multipartite mixed states: Operational asymptotically neces- sary and sufficient conditions
Fernando G. S. L. Brandão and Reinaldo O. Vianna. “Separable multipartite mixed states: Operational asymptotically neces- sary and sufficient conditions”. Phys. Rev. Lett.93, 220503 (2004)
2004
-
[46]
The cma evolution strat- egy: A comparing review
Nikolaus Hansen. “The cma evolution strat- egy: A comparing review”. Pages 75–102. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. Berlin, Heidel- berg (2006)
2006
-
[47]
Optical quantum com- puting
Jeremy L. O’Brien. “Optical quantum com- puting”. Science318, 1567–1570 (2007)
2007
-
[48]
Perce- val: A Software Platform for Discrete Vari- able Photonic Quantum Computing
Nicolas Heurtel, Andreas Fyrillas, Gré- goire de Gliniasty, Raphaël Le Bihan, Sébastien Malherbe, Marceau Pailhas, Eric Bertasi, Boris Bourdoncle, Pierre-Emmanuel Emeriau, RawadMezher, LukaMusic, Nadia Belabas, Benoît Valiron, Pascale Senellart, Shane Mansfield, and Jean Senellart. “Perce- val: A Software Platform for Discrete Vari- able Photonic Quantum ...
2023
-
[49]
Mul- tiphoton interference outperforms pairwise overlaps for distinguishability characteriza- tion
S. N. van den Hoven, M. C. Anguita, S. Marzban, and J. J. Renema. “Mul- tiphoton interference outperforms pairwise overlaps for distinguishability characteriza- tion” (2025). arXiv:2512.04903
-
[50]
Optimal multiple-phase estimation with multi-mode NOON states against photon loss
Min Namkung, Dong-Hyun Kim, Seongjin Hong, Yong-Su Kim, Changhyoup Lee, and Hyang-Tag Lim. “Optimal multiple-phase estimation with multi-mode NOON states against photon loss”. New J. Phys.26, 073028 (2024)
2024
-
[51]
Photon catalysis for gen- eral multimode multi-photon quantum state preparation
Andrei Aralov, Émilie Gillet, Viet Nguyen, Andrea Cosentino, Mattia Walschaers, and Massimo Frigerio. “Photon catalysis for gen- eral multimode multi-photon quantum state preparation” (2025). arXiv:2507.19397
-
[52]
Heralded three-photon entanglement from a single- photon source on a photonic chip
Si Chen, Li-Chao Peng, Y.-P. Guo, X.-M. Gu, X. Ding, R.-Z. Liu, J.-Y. Zhao, X. You, J. Qin, Y.-F. Wang, Yu-Ming He, Jelmer J. Renema, Yong-Heng Huo, Hui Wang, Chao- Yang Lu, and Jian-Wei Pan. “Heralded three-photon entanglement from a single- photon source on a photonic chip”. Phys. Rev. Lett.132, 130603 (2024)
2024
-
[53]
Creation of large-photon-number path entanglement conditioned on photode- tection
Pieter Kok, Hwang Lee, and Jonathan P. Dowling. “Creation of large-photon-number path entanglement conditioned on photode- tection”. Phys. Rev. A65, 052104 (2002)
2002
-
[54]
A quantum- bit encoding converter
TomDarras, BeateElisabethAsenbeck, Gio- vanni Guccione, Adrien Cavaillès, Hanna Le Jeannic, and Julien Laurat. “A quantum- bit encoding converter”. Nat. Photonics17, 165–170 (2022)
2022
-
[55]
Fault-tolerant quantum compu- tation by hybrid qubits with bosonic cat code and single photons
Jaehak Lee, Nuri Kang, Seok-Hyung Lee, Hyunseok Jeong, Liang Jiang, and Seung- Woo Lee. “Fault-tolerant quantum compu- tation by hybrid qubits with bosonic cat code and single photons”. PRX Quantum 5, 030322 (2024). 11
2024
-
[56]
Metrological detection of entanglement generated by non-Gaussian operations
David Barral, Mathieu Isoard, Giacomo Sorelli, Manuel Gessner, Nicolas Treps, and Mattia Walschaers. “Metrological detection of entanglement generated by non-Gaussian operations”. NewJ.Phys.26, 083012(2024). A Decomposition of two-mode Gaus- sian dynamics The Bloch-Messiah decomposition parametrizes any Gaussian dynamic ˜Gof two bosonic modes as: ˜G=U BS(...
2024
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.