The pollen and the electron: a study in randomness

The random motion of a pollen grain in a glass of water is only apparently so. It results from coarse-graining an underlying deterministic motion - that of the molecules of water colliding with the grain. Not observing degrees of freedom on smaller scales can make deterministic evolution appear indeterministic on larger scales. In this essay we attempt to make the case that quantum indeterminism arises in an analogous manner, from coarse-graining a deterministic (but non-unitary) evolution at the Planck scale. The underlying evolution is described by the theory of trace dynamics, which is a deterministic matrix dynamics from which quantum theory and its indeterminism are emergent. One consequence of the theory is the Karolyhazy uncertainty relation, which implies a universal upper bound to the speed of computing, as noted also by other researchers.