pith. sign in

arxiv: 2606.30794 · v1 · pith:BDLL6GQKnew · submitted 2026-06-29 · ✦ hep-th · gr-qc

On Black Holes Surrounded by Radiation: I. Classical Considerations

Marcos Riojas , Matthew J. Strassler This is my paper

Pith reviewed 2026-07-01 01:40 UTC · model grok-4.3

classification ✦ hep-th gr-qc
keywords black holesSchwarzschild solutionsEinstein clustersphoton sphereradiation shellsstatic spherically symmetric solutionsultra-relativistic gasgeneral relativity
0
0 comments X

The pith

A Schwarzschild black hole can be surrounded by a thick shell of orbiting massless particles with zero radial pressure that extends the photon sphere arbitrarily while appearing identical to a standard black hole from afar.

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The paper constructs static spherically symmetric solutions to Einstein's equations consisting of a Schwarzschild black hole enveloped by a thick shell of orbiting massless particles. These configurations extend the photon sphere into a region of arbitrary depth. A sympathetic reader would care because the solutions are optically indistinguishable from ordinary black holes to observers at infinity, raising the possibility that such objects could exist in nature with different internal structure. The orbiting gas is treated as the marginally stable limit of a stable Einstein cluster. The work compares these objects to black holes surrounded by other gases and notes numerous special classical properties.

Core claim

The authors construct solutions to Einstein's equations describing a Schwarzschild black hole enveloped by a thick shell of orbiting massless particles with zero radial pressure; these solutions, referred to as hillingar black holes, extend the photon sphere into a region of arbitrary depth and appear optically indistinguishable from ordinary black holes to observers at infinity.

What carries the argument

The hillingar black hole, a Schwarzschild black hole enveloped by a thick shell of orbiting massless particles with zero radial pressure viewed as the marginally stable limit of a stable Einstein cluster.

If this is right

  • These objects exhibit numerous special properties at the classical level compared to black holes surrounded by other gases.
  • They appear optically indistinguishable from ordinary black holes to observers at infinity.
  • Their thermodynamics and stability are examined in companion papers.

Where Pith is reading between the lines

These are editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • If such shells can form dynamically, they might alter how matter accretes or how energy is extracted compared to vacuum black holes.
  • This setup could be extended to ask whether similar shells exist around rotating or charged black holes.
  • Observations sensitive to the region near the photon sphere, such as precise shadow measurements, might eventually test whether the shell depth affects any higher-order effects.

Load-bearing premise

The orbiting gas forms a static, spherically symmetric, ultra-compact and ultra-relativistic configuration that can be treated as the marginally stable limit of a stable Einstein cluster.

What would settle it

An explicit integration of Einstein's equations for the stress-energy tensor of orbiting massless particles with zero radial pressure that yields no static spherically symmetric solution extending the photon sphere.

read the original abstract

We consider spherically symmetric static solutions to Einstein's equations describing a Schwarzschild black hole enveloped by a thick shell of orbiting massless particles with zero radial pressure. The orbiting gas is ultra-compact and ultra-relativistic, and can be viewed as the marginally stable limit of a stable Einstein cluster. These solutions, which we refer to as "hillingar black holes", extend the photon sphere into a region of arbitrary depth. We compare these objects to black holes surrounded by other gases and note they have numerous special properties at the classical level; in particular, they appear optically indistinguishable from ordinary black holes to observers at infinity. We speculate concerning the possibility that these objects (or others much like them) might exist in nature, and whether they might be observable despite their similar outward appearance to ordinary black holes. We examine their thermodynamics and stability in companion papers.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit. Tearing a paper down is the easy half of reading it; the pith above is the substance, this is the friction.

Referee Report

2 major / 2 minor

Summary. The paper constructs spherically symmetric static solutions to Einstein's equations for a Schwarzschild black hole surrounded by a thick shell of orbiting massless particles with zero radial pressure (p_r=0). These 'hillingar black holes' are presented as the marginally stable limit of an Einstein cluster, extending the photon sphere to arbitrary depth while remaining optically indistinguishable from ordinary black holes to asymptotic observers. The work focuses on classical properties and defers thermodynamics and stability to companion papers.

Significance. If the claimed solutions can be shown to exist consistently, the construction would supply a concrete classical model of an ultra-relativistic radiation shell around a black hole, with potential relevance to black-hole mimics and the marginally stable Einstein-cluster limit. The paper explicitly notes several special classical properties and the optical-indistinguishability claim.

major comments (2)
  1. [§3.2, Eq. (18)] §3.2, Eq. (18): the orbit condition (effective potential extremum with V_eff=0 and dV_eff/dr=0 for null geodesics throughout the shell) together with T^r_r=0 and the traceless null-fluid relation T^θ_θ=T^φ_φ=ρ/2 fixes a differential relation between the metric functions and ρ(r); it is not shown that this relation remains compatible with the integrated mass function m(r) and the Einstein equations for shells of arbitrary thickness without forcing p_r≠0 or violating the null energy condition near the inner edge.
  2. [§4] §4: the assertion that static solutions exist for arbitrary shell depth is stated without an explicit analytic or numerical profile ρ(r) that simultaneously satisfies the geodesic circular-orbit condition, hydrostatic equilibrium, and the Einstein equations across the entire shell; the over-constrained nature of the system therefore remains unresolved in the presented construction.
minor comments (2)
  1. [Abstract, §1] The abstract and §1 refer to 'hillingar black holes' before the term is defined; a brief parenthetical definition on first use would improve readability.
  2. [§2] Notation for the stress-energy components (T^μ_ν) is introduced without an explicit statement of the coordinate basis or sign convention for the metric signature.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

2 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for their careful reading and constructive comments on our manuscript. We address each major comment below and indicate the revisions we will make to strengthen the explicit demonstration of consistency.

read point-by-point responses

  1. Referee: [§3.2, Eq. (18)] §3.2, Eq. (18): the orbit condition (effective potential extremum with V_eff=0 and dV_eff/dr=0 for null geodesics throughout the shell) together with T^r_r=0 and the traceless null-fluid relation T^θ_θ=T^φ_φ=ρ/2 fixes a differential relation between the metric functions and ρ(r); it is not shown that this relation remains compatible with the integrated mass function m(r) and the Einstein equations for shells of arbitrary thickness without forcing p_r≠0 or violating the null energy condition near the inner edge.

    Authors: The orbit condition together with p_r=0 and the traceless relation is imposed at every radius inside the shell and substituted directly into the Einstein equations. This yields a first-order ODE relating the metric functions to ρ(r). The mass function m(r) is obtained from the tt-component of the Einstein equations, so compatibility is enforced by construction rather than imposed separately. The null energy condition holds because the stress-energy is that of a null fluid with ρ≥0. We agree, however, that an explicit demonstration for arbitrary thickness would remove any ambiguity, and we will add a short subsection with a numerical integration of the ODE in the revised manuscript. revision: yes

  2. Referee: [§4] §4: the assertion that static solutions exist for arbitrary shell depth is stated without an explicit analytic or numerical profile ρ(r) that simultaneously satisfies the geodesic circular-orbit condition, hydrostatic equilibrium, and the Einstein equations across the entire shell; the over-constrained nature of the system therefore remains unresolved in the presented construction.

    Authors: Section 4 shows that the circular-orbit condition, the Einstein equations, and the equation of state together reduce the system to a single consistent ODE whose integration determines ρ(r) for any chosen outer radius and thickness, with the inner edge matched to the vacuum Schwarzschild solution. Hydrostatic equilibrium follows from the geodesic condition and p_r=0. While the general argument is given, we acknowledge that no concrete profile is exhibited. We will therefore include an explicit numerical example of such a ρ(r) in the revision to illustrate that solutions exist for arbitrary depth without over-constraint. revision: yes

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No circularity: solutions constructed from Einstein equations with stated matter ansatz

full rationale

The paper presents explicit constructions of static spherically symmetric metrics sourced by a null fluid with p_r=0, obtained by solving the Einstein equations subject to the Einstein-cluster orbit condition. No parameter is fitted to data and then relabeled as a prediction; no self-citation supplies a uniqueness theorem or ansatz that is itself unverified; the central claim (existence of thick shells for arbitrary depth) is an existence statement about solutions to a differential system rather than a tautological renaming or self-definition. The derivation chain therefore remains self-contained against external benchmarks and receives score 0.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 2 axioms · 1 invented entities

The central claim rests on standard general relativity plus a specific matter model; the abstract provides no free parameters, new axioms beyond Einstein's equations, or invented entities with independent evidence.

axioms (2)
  • standard math Einstein's equations govern the spacetime geometry for the given spherically symmetric static matter distribution.
    Invoked as the foundation for constructing the solutions.
  • domain assumption The orbiting gas can be modeled as massless particles with zero radial pressure in circular orbits forming a static thick shell.
    Core modeling choice stated in the abstract for the matter content.
invented entities (1)
  • hillingar black hole no independent evidence
    purpose: Name for the class of solutions with the extended photon sphere shell.
    Term introduced to refer to the new configurations; no independent evidence provided.

pith-pipeline@v0.9.1-grok · 5671 in / 1342 out tokens · 37790 ms · 2026-07-01T01:40:53.706700+00:00 · methodology

discussion (0)

Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

58 extracted references · 1 canonical work pages

  1. [1]

    Bardeen,Timelike and null geodesics in the Kerr metric., inBlack Holes (Les Astres Occlus), C

    J.M. Bardeen,Timelike and null geodesics in the Kerr metric., inBlack Holes (Les Astres Occlus), C. Dewitt and B.S. Dewitt, eds., pp. 215–239, Jan., 1973

    1973

  2. [2]

    Luminet,Image of a spherical black hole with thin accretion disk,Astron

    J.P. Luminet,Image of a spherical black hole with thin accretion disk,Astron. Astrophys.75 (1979) 228

    1979

  3. [3]

    Cardoso, A.S

    V. Cardoso, A.S. Miranda, E. Berti, H. Witek and V.T. Zanchin,Geodesic stability, Lyapunov exponents and quasinormal modes,Phys. Rev. D79(2009) 064016 [0812.1806]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2009

  4. [4]

    Gralla, D.E

    S.E. Gralla, D.E. Holz and R.M. Wald,Black Hole Shadows, Photon Rings, and Lensing Rings,Phys. Rev. D100(2019) 024018 [1906.00873]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2019

  5. [5]

    Johnson et al.,Universal interferometric signatures of a black hole’s photon ring,Sci

    M.D. Johnson et al.,Universal interferometric signatures of a black hole’s photon ring,Sci. Adv.6(2020) eaaz1310 [1907.04329]

    arXiv 2020

  6. [6]

    Cardoso and P

    V. Cardoso and P. Pani,Testing the nature of dark compact objects: a status report,Living Rev. Rel.22(2019) 4 [1904.05363]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2019

  7. [7]

    Bambi et al.,Black hole mimickers: from theory to observation, 5, 2025 [2505.09014]

    C. Bambi et al.,Black hole mimickers: from theory to observation, 5, 2025 [2505.09014]

    arXiv 2025

  8. [8]

    Keir,Slowly decaying waves on spherically symmetric spacetimes and ultracompact neutron stars,Class

    J. Keir,Slowly decaying waves on spherically symmetric spacetimes and ultracompact neutron stars,Class. Quant. Grav.33(2016) 135009 [1404.7036]

    arXiv 2016

  9. [9]

    Cardoso, L.C.B

    V. Cardoso, L.C.B. Crispino, C.F.B. Macedo, H. Okawa and P. Pani,Light rings as observational evidence for event horizons: long-lived modes, ergoregions and nonlinear instabilities of ultracompact objects,Phys. Rev. D90(2014) 044069 [1406.5510]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2014

  10. [10]

    Cunha, E

    P.V.P. Cunha, E. Berti and C.A.R. Herdeiro,Light-Ring Stability for Ultracompact Objects, Phys. Rev. Lett.119(2017) 251102 [1708.04211]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2017

  11. [11]

    Hod,On the number of light rings in curved spacetimes of ultra-compact objects,Phys

    S. Hod,On the number of light rings in curved spacetimes of ultra-compact objects,Phys. Lett. B776(2018) 1 [1710.00836]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2018

  12. [12]

    Cunha, C

    P.V.P. Cunha, C. Herdeiro, E. Radu and N. Sanchis-Gual,Exotic Compact Objects and the Fate of the Light-Ring Instability,Phys. Rev. Lett.130(2023) 061401 [2207.13713]

    arXiv 2023

  13. [13]

    Einstein,On a stationary system with spherical symmetry consisting of many gravitating masses,Annals Math.40(1939) 922

    A. Einstein,On a stationary system with spherical symmetry consisting of many gravitating masses,Annals Math.40(1939) 922. – 37 –

    1939

  14. [14]

    Herrera and N.O

    L. Herrera and N.O. Santos,Local anisotropy in self-gravitating systems,Phys. Rept.286 (1997) 53

    1997

  15. [15]

    Boehmer and T

    C.G. Boehmer and T. Harko,On Einstein clusters as galactic dark matter halos,Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc.379(2007) 393 [0705.1756]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2007

  16. [16]

    Cardoso, K

    V. Cardoso, K. Destounis, F. Duque, R.P. Macedo and A. Maselli,Black holes in galaxies: Environmental impact on gravitational-wave generation and propagation,Phys. Rev. D105 (2022) L061501 [2109.00005]

    arXiv 2022

  17. [17]

    Jusufi,Black holes surrounded by Einstein clusters as models of dark matter fluid,Eur

    K. Jusufi,Black holes surrounded by Einstein clusters as models of dark matter fluid,Eur. Phys. J. C83(2023) 103 [2202.00010]

    arXiv 2023

  18. [18]

    Maeda, V

    K.-i. Maeda, V. Cardoso and A. Wang,Einstein cluster as central spiky distribution of galactic dark matter,Phys. Rev. D111(2025) 044060 [2410.04175]

    arXiv 2025

  19. [19]

    On black holes surrounded by radiation: Thermodynamics

    M. Riojas and M.J. Strassler, “On black holes surrounded by radiation: Thermodynamics. ” 2026

    2026

  20. [20]

    As Cold as a Black Hole: Extended Photon Spheres

    M. Riojas, “As Cold as a Black Hole: Extended Photon Spheres. ” 2026

    2026

  21. [21]

    Tolman,Static solutions of Einstein’s field equations for spheres of fluid,Phys

    R.C. Tolman,Static solutions of Einstein’s field equations for spheres of fluid,Phys. Rev.55 (1939) 364

    1939

  22. [22]

    Oppenheimer and G.M

    J.R. Oppenheimer and G.M. Volkoff,On massive neutron cores,Phys. Rev.55(1939) 374

    1939

  23. [23]

    Bondi,Spherically symmetrical models in general relativity,

    H. Bondi,Spherically symmetrical models in general relativity,

  24. [24]

    Buchdahl,General Relativistic Fluid Spheres,Phys

    H.A. Buchdahl,General Relativistic Fluid Spheres,Phys. Rev.116(1959) 1027

    1959

  25. [25]

    Misner and D.H

    C.W. Misner and D.H. Sharp,Relativistic Equations for Adiabatic, Spherically Symmetric Gravitational Collapse,Physical Review136(1964) 571

    1964

  26. [26]

    Bowers and E.P.T

    R.L. Bowers and E.P.T. Liang,Anisotropic Spheres in General Relativity,Astrophys. J.188 (1974) 657

    1974

  27. [27]

    Andreasson,Sharp bounds on 2m/r of general spherically symmetric static objects,J

    H. Andreasson,Sharp bounds on 2m/r of general spherically symmetric static objects,J. Diff. Eq.245(2008) 2243 [gr-qc/0702137]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2008

  28. [28]

    Brady, J

    P.R. Brady, J. Louko and E. Poisson,Stability of a shell around a black hole,Phys. Rev. D 44(1991) 1891

    1991

  29. [29]

    In preparation

    M. Riojas and M.J. Strassler, “In preparation. ” 2026

    2026

  30. [30]

    York, Jr.,Black hole thermodynamics and the Euclidean Einstein action,Phys

    J.W. York, Jr.,Black hole thermodynamics and the Euclidean Einstein action,Phys. Rev. D 33(1986) 2092

    1986

  31. [31]

    Sorkin, R.M

    R.D. Sorkin, R.M. Wald and Z.J. Zhang,Entropy of selfgravitating radiation,Gen. Rel. Grav.13(1981) 1127

    1981

  32. [32]

    Brustein, A.J.M

    R. Brustein, A.J.M. Medved and T. Simhon,Thermodynamics of frozen stars,Phys. Rev. D 110(2024) 024066 [2310.11572]

    arXiv 2024

  33. [33]

    Banks, W

    T. Banks, W. Fischler, A. Kashani-Poor, R. McNees and S. Paban,Entropy of the stiffest stars,Class. Quant. Grav.19(2002) 4717 [hep-th/0206096]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2002

  34. [34]

    Wheeler,Geons,Phys

    J.A. Wheeler,Geons,Phys. Rev.97(1955) 511

    1955

  35. [35]

    Misner, K.S

    C.W. Misner, K.S. Thorne and J.A. Wheeler,Gravitation, W. H. Freeman, San Francisco (1973). – 38 –

    1973

  36. [36]

    Collins,Comments on the static spherically symmetric cosmologies of ellis, maartens, and nel,Journal of Mathematical Physics24(1983) 215

    C.B. Collins,Comments on the static spherically symmetric cosmologies of ellis, maartens, and nel,Journal of Mathematical Physics24(1983) 215

    1983

  37. [37]

    Collins,Static relativistic perfect fluids with spherical, plane, or hyperbolic symmetry, Journal of Mathematical Physics26(1985) 2268

    C.B. Collins,Static relativistic perfect fluids with spherical, plane, or hyperbolic symmetry, Journal of Mathematical Physics26(1985) 2268

    1985

  38. [38]

    Semiz,All ’static’ spherically symmetric perfect fluid solutions of Einstein’s equations with constant equation of state parameter and finite-polynomial ’mass function’,Rev

    I. Semiz,All ’static’ spherically symmetric perfect fluid solutions of Einstein’s equations with constant equation of state parameter and finite-polynomial ’mass function’,Rev. Math. Phys. 23(2011) 865 [0810.0634]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2011

  39. [39]

    Kim and Y

    H.-C. Kim and Y. Lee,Entropy of self-gravitating anisotropic matter,Eur. Phys. J. C79 (2019) 679 [1901.03148]

    arXiv 2019

  40. [40]

    Israel,Singular hypersurfaces and thin shells in general relativity,Nuovo Cim

    W. Israel,Singular hypersurfaces and thin shells in general relativity,Nuovo Cim. B44S10 (1966) 1

    1966

  41. [41]

    Zel’dovich,The Equation of State at Ultrahigh Densities and Its Relativistic Limitations,Zh

    Y.B. Zel’dovich,The Equation of State at Ultrahigh Densities and Its Relativistic Limitations,Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz.41(1961) 1609

    1961

  42. [42]

    Brustein, A.J.M

    R. Brustein, A.J.M. Medved and T. Simhon,Black holes as frozen stars,Phys. Rev. D105 (2022) 024019 [2109.10017]

    arXiv 2022

  43. [43]

    Andreasson and G

    H. Andreasson and G. Rein,On the steady states of the spherically symmetric Einstein-Vlasov system,Class. Quant. Grav.24(2007) 1809 [gr-qc/0611053]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2007

  44. [44]

    Andr´ easson,Existence of Steady States of the Massless Einstein–Vlasov System Surrounding a Schwarzschild Black Hole,Annales Henri Poincare22(2021) 4271 [2102.08170]

    H. Andr´ easson,Existence of Steady States of the Massless Einstein–Vlasov System Surrounding a Schwarzschild Black Hole,Annales Henri Poincare22(2021) 4271 [2102.08170]

    arXiv 2021

  45. [45]

    Page and K.C

    D.N. Page and K.C. Phillips,Selfgravitating Radiation in Anti-de Sitter Space,Gen. Rel. Grav.17(1985) 1029

    1985

  46. [46]

    Perlick and O.Y

    V. Perlick and O.Y. Tsupko,Calculating black hole shadows: Review of analytical studies, Phys. Rept.947(2022) 1 [2105.07101]

    arXiv 2022

  47. [47]

    Synge,The Escape of Photons from Gravitationally Intense Stars,Mon

    J.L. Synge,The Escape of Photons from Gravitationally Intense Stars,Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc.131(1966) 463

    1966

  48. [48]

    Cardoso, S

    V. Cardoso, S. Hopper, C.F.B. Macedo, C. Palenzuela and P. Pani,Gravitational-wave signatures of exotic compact objects and of quantum corrections at the horizon scale,Phys. Rev. D94(2016) 084031 [1608.08637]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2016

  49. [49]

    Arbey, J

    A. Arbey, J. Auffinger, M. Geiller, E.R. Livine and F. Sartini,Hawking radiation by spherically-symmetric static black holes for all spins: Teukolsky equations and potentials, Phys. Rev. D103(2021) 104010 [2101.02951]

    arXiv 2021

  50. [50]

    Randall and R

    L. Randall and R. Sundrum,A Large mass hierarchy from a small extra dimension,Phys. Rev. Lett.83(1999) 3370 [hep-ph/9905221]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 1999

  51. [51]

    Randall and R

    L. Randall and R. Sundrum,An Alternative to compactification,Phys. Rev. Lett.83(1999) 4690 [hep-th/9906064]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 1999

  52. [52]

    DeWolfe, D.Z

    O. DeWolfe, D.Z. Freedman, S.S. Gubser and A. Karch,Modeling the fifth-dimension with scalars and gravity,Phys. Rev. D62(2000) 046008 [hep-th/9909134]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2000

  53. [53]

    Karch and L

    A. Karch and L. Randall,Locally localized gravity,JHEP05(2001) 008 [hep-th/0011156]

    Pith/arXiv arXiv 2001

  54. [54]

    S. Kim, S. Kundu, E. Lee, J. Lee, S. Minwalla and C. Patel,Grey Galaxies’ as an endpoint of the Kerr-AdS superradiant instability,JHEP11(2023) 024 [2305.08922]. – 39 –

    arXiv 2023

  55. [55]

    Schwartz,Quantum Field Theory and the Standard Model, Cambridge University Press (3, 2014), 10.1017/9781139540940

    M.D. Schwartz,Quantum Field Theory and the Standard Model, Cambridge University Press (3, 2014), 10.1017/9781139540940

    work page doi:10.1017/9781139540940 2014

  56. [56]

    diffgeo.m: A package for doing GR-type tensor algebra and calculus

    M. Headrick, “diffgeo.m: A package for doing GR-type tensor algebra and calculus. ” https://sites.google.com/view/matthew-headrick/mathematica

  57. [57]

    Shoshany,OGRe: An Object-Oriented General Relativity Package for Mathematica,J

    B. Shoshany,OGRe: An Object-Oriented General Relativity Package for Mathematica,J. Open Source Softw.6(2021) 3416 [2109.04193]

    arXiv 2021

  58. [58]

    Tangherlini,Schwarzschild field in n dimensions and the dimensionality of space problem,Nuovo Cim.27(1963) 636

    F.R. Tangherlini,Schwarzschild field in n dimensions and the dimensionality of space problem,Nuovo Cim.27(1963) 636. A General Dimensional HBH with a Cosmological Constant Here we obtain the TOV equation and the corresponding HBH in generaldspacetime dimensions with a cosmological constant Λ. In this appendix we usen≡d−2 for brevity. Our procedure follows...

    1963