REVIEW 3 major objections 4 minor 2 cited by
Hole mobility of strained GaN from first principles
T0 review · 3 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-14 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read Strain engineering can more than double the hole mobility of wurtzite GaN, from about 50 to over 110 cm²/Vs at room temperature.
desk verdict A carefully executed first-principles study whose strained-mobility numbers are credible, but the headline mechanism—band inversion—is asserted rather than isolated, and the best numbers rely on an unverified ratio transfer. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central quantity is the crystal-field splitting $\Delta_{\rm cf}$, the energy separation between the split-off hole band and the light/heavy-hole doublet at the valence-band top in wurtzite GaN. The paper establishes that $\Delta_{\rm cf}$ is controlled by the internal structural parameter $u$ and the axial ratio $c/a$, which strain changes in opposite directions for biaxial and uniaxial distortions, and that $\Delta_{\rm cf}$ reverses sign within the investigated strain range. Transport is computed with the linearized Boltzmann transport equation including all electron-phonon scattering matrix elements, spin-orbit coupling, and GW quasiparticle band structures; the self-energy relaxation time approximation (SERTA) is used on dense non-uniform grids and benchmarked against full iterative BTE solutions on uniform grids.
What would settle it
Measure the room-temperature Hall mobility of dislocation-free wurtzite GaN films grown under biaxial tensile strain near +0.46%: a sharp rise in hole mobility as the split-off band crosses the light/heavy bands would confirm the mechanism, and its absence would refute it; a direct iterative BTE calculation on commensurate dense grids would settle whether the ratio transfer underlying the headline numbers is valid.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The paper claims that phonon-limited hole transport in wurtzite GaN is dominated by acoustic deformation-potential scattering in the heavy light-hole and heavy-hole bands, and that the mobility can be roughly doubled by reversing the crystal-field splitting $\Delta_{\rm cf}$ so that the split-off hole band moves above the light and heavy holes. That reversal happens under biaxial tensile strain, estimated at +0.46%, or uniaxial compressive strain, estimated at -0.62%, and once achieved the lighter split-off band carries the current with weaker scattering. The quantitative prediction is a room-temperature hole Hall mobility of 111 cm²/Vs under +2% biaxial tensile strain and 119 cm²/Vs under -2% uniaxial compressive strain, compared with 50 cm²/Vs for relaxed GaN, while the electron mobility stays nearly unchanged under biaxial strain.
Load-bearing premise
The headline numbers assume the ratio between iterative and SERTA mobilities computed on uniform momentum grids is unchanged when moved to the denser non-uniform grids used for the final values; if that ratio is not transferable, the specific values 111 and 119 cm²/Vs would shift.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- Room-temperature hole Hall mobility rises from 50 cm²/Vs in relaxed GaN to 111 cm²/Vs at +2% biaxial tensile strain and 119 cm²/Vs at -2% uniaxial compressive strain, a more than twofold increase.
- The valence-band reversal sets in at modest strains of about +0.46% (biaxial tensile) and -0.62% (uniaxial compressive), corresponding to critical film thicknesses of roughly 38 nm and 27 nm, within reach of epitaxial growth.
- Because acoustic deformation-potential scattering dominates the low mobility, the design principle is to replace the heavy hole bands at the valence-band top with a lighter, less scattered band.
- The wurtzite phase remains thermodynamically stable over the strain and temperature range studied, so the enhancement is not tied to a structural phase transition.
- A strain-free alternative follows from the same mechanism: coherent excitation of the A1 optical phonon could transiently reverse the crystal-field splitting and modulate the hole mobility with light.
Reading between the lines
- The same valence-band-ordering mechanism should apply to other wurtzite nitrides and their alloys, where $\Delta_{\rm cf}$ is similarly sensitive to internal parameters, so strain or phonon pumping may raise p-type mobility across the (Al,Ga,In)N family.
- Because the uniform-grid BTE results alone already show the qualitative doubling, from 42 to 113 and 117 cm²/Vs, the central conclusion still holds even if the ratio-transfer assumption shifts the precise headline numbers.
- A sharp test would be to measure the Hall mobility as strain is tuned through the inversion threshold: a discontinuous rise when $\Delta_{\rm cf}$ crosses zero would confirm that band ordering, not just strain, is the cause.
- Time-resolved Hall or terahertz-conductivity measurements after femtosecond infrared excitation of the A1 phonon could reveal a transient mobility enhancement, turning the proposal into an optically addressable switch.
Signed reviews
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper presents first-principles calculations of the phonon-limited carrier mobility of wurtzite GaN, using DFT, G0W0 quasiparticle corrections, and both the self-energy relaxation time approximation (SERTA) and the iterative Boltzmann transport equation (BTE). The authors benchmark their unstrained results against experiment (electron Hall mobility 1034 cm2/Vs vs. 1265 cm2/Vs; hole Hall mobility 52 cm2/Vs vs. 31 cm2/Vs) and then investigate biaxial and uniaxial strain. They predict that reversing the crystal-field splitting lifts the split-off hole band above the light and heavy hole bands, and that this increases the room-temperature hole Hall mobility by more than 200%, from about 50 cm2/Vs in relaxed GaN to 111 cm2/Vs at +2% biaxial tensile strain and 119 cm2/Vs at -2% uniaxial compressive strain. The paper also estimates the critical film thicknesses for pseudomorphic growth and proposes coherent A1-phonon excitation as an alternative route to the same band inversion.
Significance. If the central claim holds, the paper provides a concrete, experimentally testable design rule for improving p-type GaN mobility, which is a recognized bottleneck for GaN power electronics. The numerical pipeline is unusually careful: SERTA is benchmarked against the iterative BTE, local and exact band velocities are compared, grid convergence is documented, and the unstrained mobilities are validated against experiment before being applied to strained cases. The calculations are parameter-free in the sense that no mobility value is fitted. The qualitative conclusion that the strained geometries with reversed crystal-field splitting raise the hole mobility is supported already by the direct uniform-grid BTE results (42 cm2/Vs relaxed to 113 cm2/Vs at +2% biaxial and 117 cm2/Vs at -2% uniaxial strain), independent of the Cauchy-grid scaling. The paper also gives falsifiable thresholds for the band inversion (about +0.46% biaxial tensile and -0.62% uniaxial compressive strain).
major comments (3)
- [Sec. V.C, Table I, Fig. 10] The central causal claim — that reversing the crystal-field splitting and lifting the split-off band above the light and heavy hole bands is what increases the hole mobility — is not isolated in the presented calculations. In the strained-geometry runs, phonon frequencies, dielectric constants, Born effective charges, deformation potentials, and effective masses all change together with the band ordering, so the observed correlation between Δcf reversal and mobility cannot by itself identify the ordering as the cause. Moreover, the mass rationale in Sec. V.C is in tension with Table I: for in-plane transport the split-off band has m⊥_sh = 1.16 m_e, which is heavier than m⊥_hh = 0.45 m_e and m⊥_lh = 0.37 m_e; the quoted conductivity mass of 0.45 m_e is dominated by the light c-axis component m∥_sh = 0.20 m_e. The statement that the effective mass quickly decreases to 0.22 m_e away from Γ needs a quantitative derivation, and the attribution would be much stronger with a counterfactual calculation that fixes the band ordering or with a decomposition separating band-structure effects from strain-driven changes in electron-phonon coupling. The unpublished Ref. 29 is also cited for the key scattering analysis, so the manuscript is not fully self-contained on this point.
- [Sec. IV.E, Table IV] The headline strained Hall mobilities (111 and 119 cm2/Vs in Fig. 10) are not obtained directly from the iterative BTE. Because Eq. (10) requires commensurate k and q grids, the BTE/SERTA ratio computed on uniform 100x100x100 grids is applied to the dense Cauchy-grid SERTA values (labeled 'BTE†'). The transferability of this ratio is an assumption; the statement that the ratio converges faster than the mobilities themselves is not documented. The uniform-grid BTE results (drift mobilities of 113 and 117 cm2/Vs for +2% biaxial and -2% uniaxial strain) do support the qualitative enhancement, but the quantitative factor of more than two in Hall mobility should be presented with an explicit uncertainty estimate or with a convergence test of the ratio.
- [Sec. IV.E, Table II] The unstrained hole Hall mobility is computed as 52 cm2/Vs against an experimental reference of 31 cm2/Vs, an overestimate of about 68%. Since the strained predictions use the same LDA-based electron-phonon matrix elements, GW-scissor band structures, and Hall factor, the absolute strained values (96–102 cm2/Vs drift, 111–119 cm2/Vs Hall) inherit a comparable calibration uncertainty. The robust statement is the relative enhancement with respect to the relaxed calculation, and the manuscript should present the quantitative predictions with this caveat explicitly stated.
minor comments (4)
- [Abstract and Sec. VI] The coherent A1-phonon route to band inversion is presented as a prediction, but the manuscript contains no calculation of the phonon dynamics, of the transient band structure, or of the transient mobility; it should be explicitly labeled as a speculative proposal.
- [Conclusion] The concluding sentence 'reaching values of 120 cm2/Vs under 2% biaxial tensile or uniaxial compressive strain' does not match Table IV and Fig. 10, where the 2% biaxial and -2% uniaxial room-temperature values are drift 96/102 cm2/Vs and Hall 111/119 cm2/Vs; please quote the Hall values consistently and specify which quantity is meant.
- [Throughout] There are several typos and grammatical errors, including 'moblity' in Sec. IV.B, 'wurzite' in Sec. VII, 'the the crystal-field splitting' in Sec. VII, and 'coherent excitation the A1 optical phonon' in the abstract.
- [Sec. IV.D, Eq. (16)] The Hall factor in Eq. (16) is the isotropic single-band result τ^2/τ^2; a brief justification for applying this expression to the multi-band, strained wurtzite case would strengthen the comparison with Hall experiments.
Circularity Check
No significant circularity: the strained-GaN mobility predictions come from a parameter-free ab initio BTE pipeline benchmarked on unstrained GaN, and the band-inversion mechanism is supported by computed mobilities rather than imposed by construction.
full rationale
The paper's central claims are derived from a self-contained first-principles pipeline: LDA band structures, G0W0+Δk quasiparticle corrections, DFPT phonons and electron-phonon matrix elements, and an iterative solution of the linearized Boltzmann equation (Eqs. 9-12). No empirical parameter is fitted to the target mobility values. The unstrained results are checked against independent experiments (Table II: computed electron/hole Hall mobilities 1034 and 52 cm2/Vs vs measured 1265 and 31 cm2/Vs) before the pipeline is applied to strained structures. The strained calculations recompute band structures, phonons, dielectric constants, Born charges, velocities (Eq. 15), and Hall factors, rather than reusing or rescaling the unstrained result. The sign of Δcf is obtained from the computed band eigenvalues via Eq. 8, so the association between reversed Δcf and split-off band inversion is definitional, but the mobility enhancement is not defined by that relation: it is evaluated by solving the BTE at each strain. The only approximation that resembles a 'prediction from a fit' is the BTE† estimate in Table IV, where the BTE/SERTA ratio from uniform grids is applied to dense Cauchy-grid SERTA results; this is explicitly stated as a numerical estimate, and the uniform-grid BTE values alone (42 to 113 and 117 cm2/Vs) already support the qualitative enhancement, so the conclusion does not reduce to that ratio. Self-citations to Ref. 29 (same authors) and to method papers (Refs. 85, 66) are present, but the prior prediction is independently re-derived and validated here by new ab initio calculations, and the cited method papers are standard formalism rather than an assumed conclusion. A remaining scientific concern is that the paper does not perform a counterfactual with fixed band ordering, so the attribution of the enhancement specifically to band inversion is partly correlational; that is a mechanistic underdetermination, not circular reasoning. Overall, the derivation chain does not reduce to its inputs by definition or by fitted parameters.
Assumptions & free parameters
assumptions (6)
- standard math The adiabatic separation and quasi-harmonic approximation for vibrational free energy.
- domain assumption LDA plus G0W0 with a k-dependent scissor shift gives accurate valence band ordering and effective masses.
- domain assumption LDA electron-phonon matrix elements interpolated with Wannier functions are accurate enough for BTE mobility.
- domain assumption Defect and dislocation scattering is negligible in the proposed ultra-thin films.
- ad hoc to paper The BTE-to-SERTA mobility ratio on uniform grids transfers to Cauchy grids.
- ad hoc to paper Coherent A1 phonon excitation can reverse the crystal-field splitting by changing the internal parameter u.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Hole mobility of strained GaN from first principles." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/MCAL4FLN
@misc{pith2026190802072,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Hole mobility of strained GaN from first principles},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/MCAL4FLN}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:1908.02072}
}
abstract
Nitride semiconductors are ubiquitous in optoelectronic devices such as LEDs and Blu-Ray optical disks. A major limitation for further adoption of GaN in power electronics is its low hole mobility. In order to address this challenge, here we investigate the phonon-limited mobility of wurtzite GaN using the ab initio Boltzmann transport formalism, including all electron-phonon scattering processes, spin-orbit coupling, and many-body quasiparticle band structures. We demonstrate that the mobility is dominated by acoustic deformation-potential scattering, and we predict that the hole mobility can significantly be increased by lifting the split-off hole states above the light and heavy holes. This can be achieved by reversing the sign of the crystal-field splitting via strain or via coherent excitation the A$_1$ optical phonon through ultrafast infrared optical pulses.
Figures
Figures from the paper (8 more)
Forward citations
Cited by 2 Pith papers
-
Route to high hole mobility in GaN via reversal of crystal-field splitting
Reversing the crystal-field splitting of wurtzite GaN by 2% biaxial strain is predicted to lift the split-off hole band above the light and heavy holes and raise the hole Hall mobility by 230%.
-
Boron Arsenide Heterostructures: Lattice-Matched Heterointerfaces, and Strain Effects on Band Alignments and Mobility
First-principles calculations predict that tensile strain raises in-plane electron and hole mobilities in boron arsenide by 60 to 80 percent, and that boron arsenide forms nearly lattice-matched type-II junctions with...
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Zhou , author A
author C. Zhou , author A. Ghods , author V. G. Saravade , author P. V. Patel , author K. L. Yunghans , author C. Ferguson , author Y. Feng , author B. Kucukgok , author N. Lu , and author I. T. Ferguson , journal ECS J. Solid State Sci. Technol. volume 6 , pages 149 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[2]
Ikeda , author Y
author N. Ikeda , author Y. Niiyama , author H. Kambayashi , author Y. Sato , author T. Nomura , author S. Kato , and author S. Yoshida , journal Proc. IEEE volume 98 , pages 1151 ( year 2010 )
2010
-
[3]
Ishida , author R
author H. Ishida , author R. Kajitani , author Y. Kinoshita , author H. Umeda , author S. Ujita , author M. Ogawa , author K. Tanaka , author T. Morita , author S. Tamura , author M. Ishida , et al. , in booktitle 2016 IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM) ( year 2016 ), pp. pages 20.4.1--20.4.4
2016
-
[4]
author T. J. Flack , author B. N. Pushpakaran , and author S. B. Bayne , journal J. Electron. Mater. volume 45 , pages 2673 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[5]
Amano , author Y
author H. Amano , author Y. Baines , author E. Beam , author M. Borga , author T. Bouchet , author P. R. Chalker , author M. Charles , author K. J. Chen , author N. Chowdhury , author R. Chu , et al. , journal J. Phys. D Appl. Phys. volume 51 , pages 163001 ( year 2018 )
2018
-
[6]
Gassmann , author P
author J. Gassmann , author P. Watson , author L. Kehias , and author G. Henry , in booktitle 2007 IEEE/MTT-S International Microwave Symposium ( year 2007 ), pp. pages 615--618
2007
-
[7]
author B. N. Pantha , author R. Dahal , author J. Li , author J. Y. Lin , author H. X. Jiang , and author G. Pomrenke , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 92 , pages 042112 ( year 2008 )
2008
-
[8]
Sztein , author H
author A. Sztein , author H. Ohta , author J. Sonoda , author A. Ramu , author J. E. Bowers , author S. P. DenBaars , and author S. Nakamura , journal Appl. Phys. Express volume 2 , pages 111003 ( year 2009 )
2009
Show all 143 references
-
[9]
author E. N. Hurwitz , author M. Asghar , author A. Melton , author B. Kucukgok , author L. Su , author M. Orocz , author M. Jamil , author N. Lu , and author I. T. Ferguson , journal J. Electron. Mater. volume 40 , pages 513 ( year 2011 )
2011
-
[10]
Atsumi , author Y
author K. Atsumi , author Y. Inoue , author H. Mimura , author T. Aoki , and author T. Nakano , journal APL Mater. volume 2 , pages 032106 ( year 2014 )
2014
-
[11]
Nakamura and author G
author S. Nakamura and author G. Fasol , title The Blue Laser Diode ( publisher Springer , year 1997 )
1997
-
[12]
Lingrong , author L
author J. Lingrong , author L. Jianping , author T. Aiqin , author C. Yang , author L. Zengcheng , author Z. Liqun , author Z. Shuming , author L. Deyao , author M. Ikeda , and author Y. Hui , journal J. Semiconduc. volume 37 , pages 111001 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[13]
Sun , author D
author X. Sun , author D. Li , author Z. Li , author H. Song , author H. Jiang , author Y. Chen , author G. Miao , and author Z. Zhang , journal Sci. Rep. volume 5 , pages 16819 ( year 2015 )
2015
-
[14]
author E. F. Schubert , title Light-Emitting Diodes ( publisher Cambridge University Press , year 2006 )
2006
-
[15]
Yan , author G
author R. Yan , author G. Khalsa , author S. Vishwanath , author Y. Han , author J. Wright , author S. Rouvimov , author D. S. Katzer , author N. Nepal , author B. P. Downey , author D. A. Muller , et al. , journal Nature volume 555 , pages 183 ( year 2018 )
2018
-
[16]
Kozodoy , author S
author P. Kozodoy , author S. Keller , author S. DenBaars , and author U. Mishra , journal J. Cryst. Growth volume 195 , pages 265 ( year 1998 )
1998
-
[17]
Look , title Properties, Processing and applications of Gallium Nitride and related semiconductors ( publisher INSPEC , year 1999 )
author D. Look , title Properties, Processing and applications of Gallium Nitride and related semiconductors ( publisher INSPEC , year 1999 )
1999
-
[18]
Rubin , author N
author M. Rubin , author N. Newman , author J. S. Chan , author T. C. Fu , and author J. T. Ross , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 64 , pages 64 ( year 1994 )
1994
-
[19]
Kozodoy , author S
author P. Kozodoy , author S. P. DenBaars , and author U. K. Mishra , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 87 , pages 770 ( year 2000 )
2000
-
[20]
Cheong , author K
author M. Cheong , author K. Kim , author N. Namgung , author M. Han , author G. Yang , author C.-H. Hong , author E.-K. Suh , author K. Lim , author H. Lee , and author A. Yoshikawa , journal J. Cryst. Growth volume 221 , pages 734 ( year 2000 )
2000
-
[21]
author M. G. Cheong , author K. S. Kim , author C. S. Kim , author R. J. Choi , author H. S. Yoon , author N. W. Namgung , author E.-K. Suh , and author H. J. Lee , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 80 , pages 1001 ( year 2002 )
2002
-
[22]
Horita , author S
author M. Horita , author S. Takashima , author R. Tanaka , author H. Matsuyama , author K. Ueno , author M. Edo , author T. Takahashi , author M. Shimizu , and author J. Suda , journal J. J. Appl. Phys. volume 56 , pages 031001 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[23]
author E. C. H. Kyle , author S. W. Kaun , author P. G. Burke , author F. Wu , author Y.-R. Wu , and author J. S. Speck , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 115 , pages 193702 ( year 2014 )
2014
-
[24]
Ilegems and author H
author M. Ilegems and author H. Montgomery , journal J. Phys. Chem. Sol. volume 34 , pages 885 ( year 1973 )
1973
-
[25]
author T. T. Mnatsakanov , author M. E. Levinshtein , author L. I. Pomortseva , author S. N. Yurkov , author G. S. Simin , and author M. A. Khan , journal Solid-State Electronics volume 47 , pages 111 ( year 2003 )
2003
-
[26]
Farahmand , author C
author M. Farahmand , author C. Garetto , author E. Bellotti , author K. F. Brennan , author M. Goano , author E. Ghillino , author G. Ghione , author J. D. Albrecht , and author P. P. Ruden , journal IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices volume 48 , pages 535 ( year 2001 )
2001
-
[27]
Schwierz , journal Solid-State Electron
author F. Schwierz , journal Solid-State Electron. volume 49 , pages 889 ( year 2005 )
2005
-
[28]
author V. A. Jhalani , author J.-J. Zhou , and author M. Bernardi , journal Nano Letters volume 17 , pages 5012 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[29]
Ponc\'e , author D
author S. Ponc\'e , author D. Jena , and author F. Giustino , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume - , pages TO BE ADDED BY EDITOR ( year 2019 a )
2019
-
[30]
Brandt , author H
author O. Brandt , author H. Yang , author B. Jenichen , author Y. Suzuki , author L. D\"aweritz , and author K. H. Ploog , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 52 , pages R2253 ( year 1995 )
1995
-
[31]
Xia , author Q
author H. Xia , author Q. Xia , and author A. L. Ruoff , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 47 , pages 12925 ( year 1993 )
1993
-
[32]
author J. P. Perdew and author A. Zunger , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 23 , pages 5048 ( year 1981 )
1981
-
[33]
author J. P. Perdew , author K. Burke , and author M. Ernzerhof , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume 77 , pages 3865 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[34]
author D. R. Hamann , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 88 , pages 085117 ( year 2013 )
2013
-
[35]
van Setten , author M
author M. van Setten , author M. Giantomassi , author E. Bousquet , author M. Verstraete , author D. Hamann , author X. Gonze , and author G.-M. Rignanese , journal Comput. Phys. Commun. volume 226 , pages 39 ( year 2018 )
2018
-
[36]
Utsumi , author H
author W. Utsumi , author H. Saitoh , author H. Kaneko , author T. Watanuki , author K. Aoki , and author O. Shimomura , journal Nature Materials volume 2 , pages 735 ( year 2003 )
2003
-
[37]
Baroni , author P
author S. Baroni , author P. Giannozzi , and author E. Isaev , journal Rev. Miner. Geochem. volume 71 , pages 39 ( year 2010 )
2010
-
[38]
Palumbo and author A
author M. Palumbo and author A. D. Corso , journal Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter volume 29 , pages 395401 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[39]
Giannozzi , author O
author P. Giannozzi , author O. Andreussi , author T. Brumme , author O. Bunau , author M. B. Nardelli , author M. Calandra , author R. Car , author C. Cavazzoni , author D. Ceresoli , author M. Cococcioni , et al. , journal J. Phys-Condens. Mat. ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[40]
author A. D. Corso , journal Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter volume 28 , pages 075401 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[41]
author F. D. Murnaghan , journal Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA volume 30 , pages 244 ( year 1944 )
1944
-
[42]
Mounet , Ph.D
author N. Mounet , Ph.D. thesis, school Massachusetts Institute of Technology ( year 2005 )
2005
-
[43]
Mingo , author D
author N. Mingo , author D. A. Stewart , author D. A. Broido , and author D. Srivastava , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 77 , pages 033418 ( year 2008 )
2008
-
[44]
Liu , journal Computer Physics Communications volume 191 , pages 150 ( year 2015 )
author Z.-L. Liu , journal Computer Physics Communications volume 191 , pages 150 ( year 2015 )
2015
-
[45]
Qian , author M
author W. Qian , author M. Skowronski , and author G. Rohrer , journal Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. volume 423 , pages 475 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[46]
Wei and author A
author S. Wei and author A. Zunger , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 69 , pages 2719 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[47]
author G. D. Chen , author M. Smith , author J. Y. Lin , author H. X. Jiang , author S. Wei , author M. Asif Khan , and author C. J. Sun , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 68 , pages 2784 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[48]
Kim , author W
author K. Kim , author W. R. L. Lambrecht , author B. Segall , and author M. van Schilfgaarde , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 56 , pages 7363 ( year 1997 a )
1997
-
[49]
Rinke , author M
author P. Rinke , author M. Winkelnkemper , author A. Qteish , author D. Bimberg , author J. Neugebauer , and author M. Scheffler , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 77 , pages 075202 ( year 2008 )
2008
-
[50]
Svane , author N
author A. Svane , author N. E. Christensen , author I. Gorczyca , author M. van Schilfgaarde , author A. N. Chantis , and author T. Kotani , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 82 , pages 115102 ( year 2010 )
2010
-
[51]
Punya and author W
author A. Punya and author W. R. L. Lambrecht , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 85 , pages 195147 ( year 2012 )
2012
-
[52]
Monemar , journal Phys
author B. Monemar , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 10 , pages 676 ( year 1974 )
1974
-
[53]
Dingle , author D
author R. Dingle , author D. D. Sell , author S. E. Stokowski , and author M. Ilegems , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 4 , pages 1211 ( year 1971 )
1971
-
[54]
Gil , author O
author B. Gil , author O. Briot , and author R.-L. Aulombard , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 52 , pages R17028 ( year 1995 )
1995
-
[55]
author S. L. Chuang and author C. S. Chang , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 54 , pages 2491 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[56]
author D. C. Reynolds , author D. C. Look , author W. Kim , author O. Aktas , author A. Botchkarev , author A. Salvador , author H. Morkoç , and author D. N. Talwar , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 80 , pages 594 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[57]
author A. V. Rodina , author M. Dietrich , author A. G\"oldner , author L. Eckey , author A. Hoffmann , author A. L. Efros , author M. Rosen , and author B. K. Meyer , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 64 , pages 115204 ( year 2001 )
2001
-
[58]
Feneberg , author K
author M. Feneberg , author K. Lange , author C. Lidig , author M. Wieneke , author H. Witte , author J. Bläsing , author A. Dadgar , author A. Krost , and author R. Goldhahn , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 103 , pages 232104 ( year 2013 )
2013
-
[59]
van Schilfgaarde , author T
author M. van Schilfgaarde , author T. Kotani , and author S. Faleev , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume 96 , pages 226402 ( year 2006 )
2006
-
[60]
author A. N. Chantis , author M. van Schilfgaarde , and author T. Kotani , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume 96 , pages 086405 ( year 2006 )
2006
-
[61]
Carrier and author S.-H
author P. Carrier and author S.-H. Wei , journal Journal of Applied Physics volume 97 , pages 033707 ( year 2005 )
2005
-
[62]
Vurgaftman and author J
author I. Vurgaftman and author J. R. Meyer , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 94 , pages 3675 ( year 2003 )
2003
-
[63]
Marini , author C
author A. Marini , author C. Hogan , author M. Grüning , and author D. Varsano , journal Comput. Phys. Commun. volume 180 , pages 1392 ( year 2009 )
2009
-
[64]
author R. W. Godby and author R. J. Needs , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume 62 , pages 1169 ( year 1989 )
1989
-
[65]
Bruneval and author X
author F. Bruneval and author X. Gonze , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 78 , pages 085125 ( year 2008 )
2008
-
[66]
Ponc\'e , author M
author S. Ponc\'e , author M. Schlipf , and author F. Giustino , journal ACS Energy Letters volume 4 , pages 456 ( year 2019 b )
2019
-
[67]
Marzari , author A
author N. Marzari , author A. A. Mostofi , author J. R. Yates , author I. Souza , and author D. Vanderbilt , journal Rev. Mod. Phys. volume 84 , pages 1419 ( year 2012 )
2012
-
[68]
author J. P. Nery and author P. B. Allen , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 94 , pages 115135 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[69]
Hopfdeld , journal J
author J. Hopfdeld , journal J. Phys. Chem. Sol. volume 15 , pages 97 ( year 1960 )
1960
-
[70]
Shikanai , author T
author A. Shikanai , author T. Azuhata , author T. Sota , author S. Chichibu , author A. Kuramata , author K. Horino , and author S. Nakamura , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 81 , pages 417 ( year 1997 )
1997
-
[71]
Pankove , author S
author J. Pankove , author S. Bloom , and author G. Harbeke , journal R.C.A. Review volume 36 , pages 163 ( year 1975 )
1975
-
[72]
Xu and author W
author Y.-N. Xu and author W. Y. Ching , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 48 , pages 4335 ( year 1993 )
1993
-
[73]
author W. J. Fan , author M. F. Li , author T. C. Chong , and author J. B. Xia , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 79 , pages 188 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[74]
author Y. C. Yeo , author T. C. Chong , and author M. F. Li , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 83 , pages 1429 ( year 1998 )
1998
-
[75]
Drechsler , author D
author M. Drechsler , author D. M. Hofmann , author B. K. Meyer , author T. Detchprohm , author H. Amano , and author I. Akasaki , journal J. J. Appl. Phys. volume 34 , pages L1178 ( year 1995 )
1995
-
[76]
author W. R. L. Lambrecht , author C. Bhandari , and author M. van Schilfgaarde , journal Phys. Rev. Materials volume 1 , pages 043802 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[77]
Jena , author S
author D. Jena , author S. Heikman , author J. S. Speck , author A. Gossard , author U. K. Mishra , author A. Link , and author O. Ambacher , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 67 , pages 153306 ( year 2003 )
2003
-
[78]
Knap , author V
author W. Knap , author V. I. Fal’ko , author E. Frayssinet , author P. Lorenzini , author N. Grandjean , author D. Maude , author G. Karczewski , author B. L. Brandt , author J. Łusakowski , author I. Grzegory , et al. , journal J. Phys-Condens. Mat. volume 16 , pages 3421 ( ...
2004
-
[79]
Ziman , title Electrons and Phonons ( publisher Oxford University Press , year 1960 )
author J. Ziman , title Electrons and Phonons ( publisher Oxford University Press , year 1960 )
1960
-
[80]
Kaasbjerg , author K
author K. Kaasbjerg , author K. S. Thygesen , and author K. W. Jacobsen , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 85 , pages 115317 ( year 2012 )
2012
-
[81]
Li , journal Phys
author W. Li , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 92 , pages 075405 ( year 2015 )
2015
-
[82]
Fiorentini and author N
author M. Fiorentini and author N. Bonini , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 94 , pages 085204 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[83]
Zhou and author M
author J.-J. Zhou and author M. Bernardi , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 94 , pages 201201 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[84]
Gunst , author T
author T. Gunst , author T. Markussen , author K. Stokbro , and author M. Brandbyge , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 93 , pages 035414 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[85]
Ponc\'e , author E
author S. Ponc\'e , author E. R. Margine , and author F. Giustino , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 97 , pages 121201 ( year 2018 )
2018
-
[86]
Ma , author A
author J. Ma , author A. S. Nissimagoudar , and author W. Li , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 97 , pages 045201 ( year 2018 )
2018
-
[87]
Macheda and author N
author F. Macheda and author N. Bonini , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 98 , pages 201201 ( year 2018 )
2018
-
[88]
Xiao , author M.-C
author D. Xiao , author M.-C. Chang , and author Q. Niu , journal Rev. Mod. Phys. volume 82 , pages 1959 ( year 2010 )
1959
-
[89]
Grimvall , title The electron-phonon interaction in metals ( publisher North-Holland Publishing Company , year 1981 )
author G. Grimvall , title The electron-phonon interaction in metals ( publisher North-Holland Publishing Company , year 1981 )
1981
-
[90]
Giustino , journal Rev
author F. Giustino , journal Rev. Mod. Phys. volume 89 , pages 015003 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[91]
Giustino , author M
author F. Giustino , author M. L. Cohen , and author S. G. Louie , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 76 , pages 165108 ( year 2007 )
2007
-
[92]
author C. H. Rycroft , journal Chaos volume 19 ( year 2009 )
2009
-
[93]
author A. A. Mostofi , author J. R. Yates , author G. Pizzi , author Y.-S. Lee , author I. Souza , author D. Vanderbilt , and author N. Marzari , journal Comput. Phys. Commun. volume 185 , pages 2309 ( year 2014 )
2014
-
[94]
Ponc\'e , author E
author S. Ponc\'e , author E. R. Margine , author C. Verdi , and author F. Giustino , journal Comput. Phys. Commun. volume 209 , pages 116 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[95]
Wang , author J
author X. Wang , author J. R. Yates , author I. Souza , and author D. Vanderbilt , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 74 , pages 195118 ( year 2006 )
2006
-
[96]
author J. R. Yates , author X. Wang , author D. Vanderbilt , and author I. Souza , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 75 , pages 195121 ( year 2007 )
2007
-
[97]
author J. D. Wiley , title Semiconductors and Semimetals, Transport Phenomena , vol. volume 10 ( publisher Academic Press , year 1975 )
1975
-
[98]
author P. J. Price , journal IBM J. Res. Dev. volume 1 , pages 239 ( year 1957 )
1957
-
[99]
G\"otz , author L
author W. G\"otz , author L. T. Romano , author J. Walker , author N. M. Johnson , and author R. J. Molnar , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 72 , pages 1214 ( year 1998 )
1998
-
[100]
G\"otz , author N
author W. G\"otz , author N. M. Johnson , author C. Chen , author H. Liu , author C. Kuo , and author W. Imler , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 68 , pages 3144 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[101]
author M. S. Lundstrom , title Fundamentals of carrier transport ( publisher Cambridge University Press , year 2009 )
2009
-
[102]
Kim , author W
author K. Kim , author W. Lambrecht , and author B. Segall , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 53 , pages 16310 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[103]
Hill , journal Proceedings of the Physical Society
author R. Hill , journal Proceedings of the Physical Society. Section A volume 65 , pages 349 ( year 1952 )
1952
-
[104]
Nowak , author M
author R. Nowak , author M. Pessa , author M. Suganuma , author M. Leszczynski , author I. Grzegory , author S. Porowski , and author F. Yoshida , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 75 , pages 2070 ( year 1999 )
1999
-
[105]
Yonenaga , journal Materials Transactions volume 46 , pages 1979 ( year 2005 )
author I. Yonenaga , journal Materials Transactions volume 46 , pages 1979 ( year 2005 )
1979
-
[106]
author M. A. Moram , author Z. H. Barber , and author C. J. Humphreys , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 102 , pages 023505 ( year 2007 )
2007
-
[107]
Kisielowski , author J
author C. Kisielowski , author J. Kr\"uger , author S. Ruvimov , author T. Suski , author J. W. Ager , author E. Jones , author Z. Liliental-Weber , author M. Rubin , author E. R. Weber , author M. D. Bremser , et al. , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 54 , pages 17745 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[108]
Kim , author W
author K. Kim , author W. R. L. Lambrecht , and author B. Segall , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 56 , pages 7018 ( year 1997 b )
1997
-
[109]
author A. F. Wright , journal Journal of Applied Physics volume 82 , pages 2833 ( year 1997 )
1997
-
[110]
Wagner and author F
author J.-M. Wagner and author F. Bechstedt , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 66 , pages 115202 ( year 2002 )
2002
-
[111]
Qin , author X
author H. Qin , author X. Luan , author C. Feng , author D. Yang , and author G. Zhang , journal Materials volume 10 , pages 1419 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[112]
Polian , author M
author A. Polian , author M. Grimsditch , and author I. Grzegory , journal Journal of Applied Physics volume 79 , pages 3343 ( year 1996 )
1996
-
[113]
Yamaguchi , author T
author M. Yamaguchi , author T. Yagi , author T. Azuhata , author T. Sota , author K. Suzuki , author S. Chichibu , and author S. Nakamura , journal Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter volume 9 , pages 241 ( year 1997 )
1997
-
[114]
Deger , author E
author C. Deger , author E. Born , author H. Angerer , author O. Ambacher , author M. Stutzmann , author J. Hornsteiner , author E. Riha , and author G. Fischerauer , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 72 , pages 2400 ( year 1998 )
1998
-
[115]
Deguchi , author D
author T. Deguchi , author D. Ichiryu , author K. Toshikawa , author K. Sekiguchi , author T. Sota , author R. Matsuo , author T. Azuhata , author M. Yamaguchi , author T. Yagi , author S. Chichibu , et al. , journal Journal of Applied Physics volume 86 , pages 1860 ( year 1999 )
1999
-
[116]
Ruf , author J
author T. Ruf , author J. Serrano , author M. Cardona , author P. Pavone , author M. Pabst , author M. Krisch , author M. D'Astuto , author T. Suski , author I. Grzegory , and author M. Leszczynski , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume 86 , pages 906 ( year 2001 )
2001
-
[117]
Siegle , author G
author H. Siegle , author G. Kaczmarczyk , author L. Filippidis , author A. P. Litvinchuk , author A. Hoffmann , and author C. Thomsen , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 55 , pages 7000 ( year 1997 )
1997
-
[118]
Gonze and author C
author X. Gonze and author C. Lee , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 55 , pages 10355 ( year 1997 )
1997
-
[119]
Baroni , author S
author S. Baroni , author S. de Gironcoli , author A. Dal Corso , and author P. Giannozzi , journal Rev. Mod. Phys. volume 73 , pages 515 ( year 2001 )
2001
-
[120]
Yu , author H
author G. Yu , author H. Ishikawa , author T. Egawa , author T. Soga , author J. Watanabe , author T. Jimbo , and author M. Umeno , journal Japanese Journal of Applied Physics volume 36 , pages L1029 ( year 1997 )
1997
-
[121]
Hibberd , author V
author M. Hibberd , author V. Frey , author B. Spencer , author P. Mitchell , author P. Dawson , author M. Kappers , author R. Oliver , author C. Humphreys , and author D. Graham , journal Solid State Communications volume 247 , pages 68 ( year 2016 )
2016
-
[122]
Azuhata , author T
author T. Azuhata , author T. Sota , author K. Suzuki , and author S. Nakamura , journal Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter volume 7 , pages L129 ( year 1995 )
1995
-
[123]
author A. S. Barker and author M. Ilegems , journal Phys. Rev. B volume 7 , pages 743 ( year 1973 )
1973
-
[124]
Yan , author P
author Q. Yan , author P. Rinke , author M. Scheffler , and author C. G. Van de Walle , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 95 , pages 121111 ( year 2009 )
2009
-
[125]
author S. C. Jain , author M. Willander , author J. Narayan , and author R. V. Overstraeten , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 87 , pages 965 ( year 2000 )
2000
-
[126]
Li , author B
author G. Li , author B. Song , author S. Ganguly , author M. Zhu , author R. Wang , author X. Yan , author J. Verma , author V. Protasenko , author H. Grace Xing , and author D. Jena , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 104 , pages 193506 ( year 2014 )
2014
-
[127]
author J. A. Floro , author D. M. Follstaedt , author P. Provencio , author S. J. Hearne , and author S. R. Lee , journal J. Appl. Phys. volume 96 , pages 7087 ( year 2004 )
2004
-
[128]
Jena , author A
author D. Jena , author A. C. Gossard , and author U. K. Mishra , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 76 , pages 1707 ( year 2000 )
2000
-
[129]
Holec , author Y
author D. Holec , author Y. Zhang , author D. V. S. Rao , author M. J. Kappers , author C. McAleese , and author C. J. Humphreys , journal Journal of Applied Physics volume 104 , pages 123514 ( year 2008 )
2008
-
[130]
People and author J
author R. People and author J. C. Bean , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 47 , pages 322 ( year 1985 )
1985
-
[131]
Matthews and author A
author J. Matthews and author A. Blakeslee , journal J. Cryst. Growth volume 27 , pages 118 ( year 1974 )
1974
-
[132]
Fischer , author H
author A. Fischer , author H. K\"uhne , and author H. Richter , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume 73 , pages 2712 ( year 1994 )
1994
-
[133]
Cao and author D
author Y. Cao and author D. Jena , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 90 , pages 182112 ( year 2007 )
2007
-
[134]
author C. E. Dreyer , author A. Janotti , and author C. G. Van de Walle , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 106 , pages 212103 ( year 2015 )
2015
-
[135]
Sohi , author D
author P. Sohi , author D. Martin , and author N. Grandjean , journal Semi. Sci. Technol. volume 32 , pages 075010 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[136]
Qi , author G
author M. Qi , author G. Li , author S. Ganguly , author P. Zhao , author X. Yan , author J. Verma , author B. Song , author M. Zhu , author K. Nomoto , author H. G. Xing , et al. , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 110 , pages 063501 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[137]
author S. M. Islam , author K. Lee , author J. Verma , author V. Protasenko , author S. Rouvimov , author S. Bharadwaj , author H. (Grace) Xing , and author D. Jena , journal Appl. Phys. Lett. volume 110 , pages 041108 ( year 2017 )
2017
-
[138]
Sun , author Y
author G. Sun , author Y. Sun , author T. Nishida , and author S. E. Thompson , journal Journal of Applied Physics volume 102 , pages 084501 ( year 2007 )
2007
-
[139]
Natarajan , author M
author S. Natarajan , author M. Armstrong , author M. Bost , author R. Brain , author M. Brazier , author C.-H. Chang , author V. Chikarmane , author M. Childs , author H. Deshpande , author K. Dev , et al. , journal 2008 IEEE International Electron Devices Meeting pp. pages 1...
2008
-
[140]
Chu , author Y
author M. Chu , author Y. Sun , author U. Aghoram , and author S. E. Thompson , journal Annual Review of Materials Research volume 39 , pages 229 ( year 2009 )
2009
-
[141]
author C. E. Dreyer , author A. Janotti , and author C. G. Van de Walle , journal Applied Physics Letters volume 102 , pages 142105 ( year 2013 )
2013
-
[142]
author A. D. Caviglia , author R. Scherwitzl , author P. Popovich , author W. Hu , author H. Bromberger , author R. Singla , author M. Mitrano , author M. C. Hoffmann , author S. Kaiser , author P. Zubko , et al. , journal Phys. Rev. Lett. volume 108 , pages 136801 ( year 2012 )
2012
-
[143]
Cartella , author T
author A. Cartella , author T. F. Nova , author M. Fechner , author R. Merlin , and author A. Cavalleri , journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences volume 115 , pages 12148 ( year 2018 )
2018
Reviewed August 14, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.