Generalizing the Penrose cut-and-paste method: Null shells with pressure and energy flux

Argam Ohanyan; Miguel Manzano; Roland Steinbauer

REVIEW 3 major objections 3 minor 52 references

Generalizing the Penrose cut-and-paste method: Null shells with pressure and energy flux

T0 review · 3 major / 3 minor · reviewed 2026-08-06 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

Pith's one-line read This paper generalizes the Penrose cut-and-paste method to null thin shells with arbitrary matter content, deriving a locally Lipschitz continuous metric for the matched spacetime and transforming it into a Dirac-delta form.

desk verdict Claims a real generalization of Penrose's cut-and-paste method to shells with pressure and flux, with a Minkowski example that makes the key junction-condition question testable. read the letter →

arxiv 2508.00231 v1 pith:VHPVQJGL submitted 2025-08-01 math.DG gr-qcmath-phmath.MP

Miguel Manzano , Argam Ohanyan , Roland Steinbauer This is my paper · ORCID

classification math.DGgr-qcmath-phmath.MP MSC 53C5053C80

keywords Penrosecut-and-pastemethodnullthinshellslocallyLipschitzmetricDistributionalDirac-deltatermconstant-curvaturespacetimesshellpressureandenergyfluxmathematicalgeneralrelativity

verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This paper extends Penrose's cut-and-paste method, a way to build null thin shells by gluing two regions of spacetime along a null hypersurface, to shells carrying arbitrary gravitational or matter content. Previously the method could handle only pure gravitational shells and null dust; the authors now allow pressure and energy flux. The central technical step is a locally Lipschitz continuous form of the matched spacetime metric, derived for the most general gluing of two constant-curvature spacetimes with totally geodesic null boundaries. A coordinate transformation then brings this metric into the cut-and-paste form, where the shell's content appears as a Dirac-delta term. A worked example places a null shell with non-trivial energy density, energy flux, and pressure in Minkowski space.

What carries the argument

The central object is the locally Lipschitz continuous metric of the glued spacetime, constructed in a single coordinate patch that extends across the null hypersurface. This continuous form allows the matched geometry to be described without a singular chart at the shell. The second piece of machinery is the explicit coordinate transformation from this continuous form to the cut-and-paste representation, where the metric contains a Dirac-delta term supported on the shell; that distributional term is what carries the matter content, namely pressure, flux, and energy density, of the shell.

What would settle it

Compute the surface stress-energy tensor of the Minkowski null-shell example directly from the Dirac-delta term and verify the junction conditions against the declared pressure and energy flux; if they disagree, the transformation is inconsistent. A second check is to test the construction on non-constant-curvature backgrounds, where the Lipschitz form is expected to fail.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The paper's central claim is that the Penrose cut-and-paste construction can be generalized to null shells with arbitrary matter content, not just the purely gravitational and null-dust shells treated before. For the most general matching of two constant-curvature spacetimes whose null boundaries are totally geodesic, the authors derive a locally Lipschitz continuous metric for the resulting spacetime, a single continuous chart that is well behaved across the shell. They then find the coordinate transformation that converts this continuous metric into the distributional cut-and-paste form, in which the shell's energy density, energy flux, and pressure are encoded in a Dirac-delta term. The demonstration of the method is a null shell with non-trivial energy density, flux, and pressure embedded in Minkowski space.

Load-bearing premise

The construction assumes both matched spacetimes have constant curvature and that their null boundaries are totally geodesic; if a matching uses non-constant-curvature backgrounds or non-totally-geodesic boundaries, the claimed extension is not shown to hold.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

Null thin shells with pressure and energy flux become constructible in constant-curvature backgrounds by cut-and-paste, going beyond the earlier pure-gravitational and null-dust cases.
The locally Lipschitz continuous metric gives a well-defined continuous geometry of the matched spacetime that is amenable to distributional methods.
The Dirac-delta form makes the shell's matter content explicit, so junction-condition calculations can read off energy density, flux, and pressure directly.
The Minkowski example supplies an explicit template for null shells with non-trivial matter content.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

A natural extension the paper does not take is to relax the constant-curvature assumption; if the Lipschitz construction is stable under small curvature perturbations, the method might reach asymptotically flat or de Sitter backgrounds.
The continuous form of the metric could be useful numerically, since distributional metrics are hard to represent; a locally Lipschitz chart might let weak-form solvers handle null shells without regularization.
As a consistency check, turning off pressure and flux in the new formalism should recover the known null-dust cut-and-paste results, a reduction the authors do not explicitly perform.

Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Desk Editor's Note

read the letter

The headline: this paper claims a real extension of Penrose's cut-and-paste method—from vacuum and null dust to shells carrying pressure and energy flux—and backs it with an explicit Minkowski-space example. If the distributional calculation holds up, it gives the community a usable tool. If it doesn't, the example will reveal exactly where.

What is genuinely new: the authors derive a locally Lipschitz continuous metric for the most general matching of two constant-curvature spacetimes along totally geodesic null boundaries, then construct the coordinate transformation to the standard Dirac-delta form. That is constructive and concrete, and including a worked example is the right way to test the claim. The scope is constant-curvature backgrounds with totally geodesic boundaries, which is narrower than "arbitrary matter content" in full generality, but the abstract states that limitation clearly.

The soft spot, as the stress-test notes, is the junction condition. In the Barrabès-Israel formalism, the surface stress tensor is sourced by jumps of transverse fundamental forms. If totally geodesic boundaries force those jumps to vanish, then the shell is sourceless, and the advertised pressure and flux cannot appear. The abstract does not display the distributional Einstein tensor, so I can't tell whether the authors have computed it or waved at it. That is the single most important thing to verify before trusting the paper. The good news is that the Minkowski example makes the issue empirically testable: run the computation, and see whether the delta-term coefficient gives nonzero pressure and flux. I'd want to see that calculation in the paper, step by step.

On the citation pattern: I have no concerns. The extension is placed relative to Penrose's original construction and prior dust-only treatments, which is the relevant context. Self-citation is not an issue here.

Who this is for: relativists working on null thin shells and anyone teaching or using Penrose's method. It is a techniques paper, not a paradigm shift, and the significance is moderate but real if correct.

My recommendation: yes, send this to peer review. The question is sharply posed and checkable, the authors have supplied an example, and even a referee who finds an error will be doing the field a service. But the referee must demand the explicit distributional Einstein tensor calculation, not a promise.

Referee Report

3 major / 3 minor

Summary. The paper proposes an extension of Penrose's cut-and-paste construction to null thin shells with arbitrary gravitational/matter content. The authors claim to derive a locally Lipschitz continuous metric for the most general matching of two constant-curvature spacetimes whose null boundaries are totally geodesic, and then to obtain a coordinate transformation that brings this metric into the standard cut-and-paste form with a Dirac-delta term. An example in Minkowski space with nonzero energy density, energy flux, and pressure is advertised.

Significance. If the central claim is correct, this would materially extend a standard tool in null-shell physics, permitting shells with pressure and energy flux rather than only pure gravitational or null-dust shells. The approach is constructive and appears to introduce no fitted parameters, which are strengths. However, the significance is conditional on the resolution of the tension between totally geodesic null boundaries and nonzero surface stress-energy; if that tension is resolved, the result would be of considerable interest to the null-shell community.

major comments (3)

[Abstract] The claim of 'arbitrary gravitational/matter content' is not evidently realizable by the stated geometric setup. In the Barrabès-Israel null junction conditions, the surface stress-energy tensor is sourced by the jump of the transverse null fundamental form across the shell. A null boundary that is totally geodesic in each of the two constant-curvature regions has vanishing transverse fundamental form on both sides, which would make the jump identically zero and the shell sourceless. The authors must display the distributional Einstein tensor computation and show explicitly how nonzero pressure and energy flux emerge from the gluing of two totally geodesic null boundaries; otherwise the central claim is unsupported.
[Abstract] The phrase 'most general matching' is not defined. The actual range of admissible shell stress-energy tensors should be characterized (e.g., which components can be nonzero and what constraints exist). Without such a characterization, the reader cannot assess whether the advertised example is representative or special.
[Example] The advertised Minkowski-space example must be accompanied by a computation of the junction conditions at the shell, including the distributional Einstein tensor, to verify that the resulting energy density, energy flux, and pressure indeed satisfy the field equations. The abstract alone does not permit such verification.

minor comments (3)

[Abstract] The abstract uses 'arbitrary gravitational/matter content' but then restricts to constant-curvature spacetimes with totally geodesic null boundaries; this apparent contradiction should be clarified in the introduction.
[Abstract] The authors should cite the standard Barrabès-Israel null junction conditions (e.g., Barrabès & Israel, Phys. Rev. D 43, 1129 (1991)) in the abstract or introduction to situate the claim within the existing literature.
[Abstract] The term 'cut-and-paste form with a Dirac-delta term' should be defined precisely; the coordinate transformation that produces this form should be written explicitly in the introduction or abstract.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity: the construction is a direct matching procedure with no fitted parameters or self-citation chain evident from the abstract.

full rationale

The abstract describes a constructive derivation: starting from a general matching of two constant-curvature spacetimes with totally geodesic null boundaries, the authors derive a locally Lipschitz continuous metric and then transform it into the cut-and-paste form with a Dirac-delta term. No fitted parameter is renamed as a prediction, no uniqueness theorem from the authors' prior work is invoked to force the choice, and no result is defined in terms of the quantity it purports to derive. The skeptic's concern about totally geodesic boundaries forcing the transverse fundamental form jump to vanish is a physical correctness question about the reachable shell stress-energy, not a circularity of the derivation chain. Without full-text evidence of self-citation or equation-level reduction, the honest finding is no significant circularity.

Assumptions & free parameters 0 free parameters · 3 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The paper's method postulates a specific class of matched spacetimes (constant-curvature, totally geodesic null boundaries) and assumes the existence of Lipschitz and distributional metric forms. No new particles or fields are introduced. These assumptions are natural in the cut-and-paste framework but restrict the claimed generality.

assumptions (3)

domain assumption The two spacetimes being matched have constant curvature.
The abstract restricts the construction to constant-curvature spacetimes, which is a modeling assumption rather than a universal property of null shells.
domain assumption The null boundaries along which the spacetimes are cut and pasted are totally geodesic.
The abstract specifies totally geodesic null boundaries; if real shells have non-totally-geodesic boundaries, this method may not apply.
domain assumption The resulting glued metric admits a locally Lipschitz continuous representative and a coordinate transformation to a Dirac-delta form.
The existence of these representations is the core technical claim of the paper; the abstract does not prove it, it states that it is derived.

how reviews work

0 comments

Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Generalizing the Penrose cut-and-paste method: Null shells with pressure and energy flux." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/VHPVQJGL

@misc{pith2026250800231,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Generalizing the Penrose cut-and-paste method: Null shells with pressure and energy flux},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/VHPVQJGL}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2508.00231}
}

read the original abstract

The cut-and-paste method is a procedure for constructing null thin shells by matching two regions of the same spacetime across a null hypersurface. Originally proposed by Penrose, it has so far allowed to describe purely gravitational and null-dust shells in constant-curvature backgrounds. In this paper, we extend the cut-and-paste method to null shells with arbitrary gravitational/matter content. To that aim, we first derive a locally Lipschitz continuous form of the metric of the spacetime resulting from the most general matching of two constant-curvature spacetimes with totally geodesic null boundaries, and then obtain the coordinate transformation that turns this metric into the cut-and-paste form with a Dirac-delta term. The paper includes an example of a null shell with non-trivial energy density, energy flux and pressure in Minkowski space.

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

52 extracted references · 52 canonical work pages

[1]

C., and Balasin, H

Aichelburg, P. C., and Balasin, H. Generalized symmetries of impulsive gravitational waves. Classical Quantum Gravity 14 , 1A (1997), A31--A41. Geometry and physics

work page 1997
[2]

C., and Sexl, R

Aichelburg, P. C., and Sexl, R. U. On the gravitational field of a massless particle. General Relativity and Gravitation 2\/ (1971), 303--312

work page 1971
[3]

Barrab \'e s, C., and Hogan, P. A. S ingular null hypersurfaces in G eneral R elativity: light-like signals from violent astrophysical events . World Scientific, (2003)

work page 2003
[4]

T hin shells in general relativity and cosmology: the lightlike limit

Barrab \'e s, C., and Israel, W. T hin shells in general relativity and cosmology: the lightlike limit. Physical Review D 43\/ (1991), 1129--1142

work page 1991
[5]

B., and Vickers, P

Bonnor, W. B., and Vickers, P. A. J unction conditions in G eneral R elativity. General Relativity and Gravitation 13 , 1 (1981), 29--36

work page 1981
[6]

T., and Grant, J

Chru \'s ciel, P. T., and Grant, J. D. E. On L orentzian causality with continuous metrics. Classical Quantum Gravity 29 , 14 (2012), 145001, 32

work page 2012
[7]

Clarke, C. J. S., and Dray, T. J unction conditions for null hypersurfaces. Classical and Quantum Gravity 4\/ (1987), 265

work page 1987
[8]

L es \'e quations de la gravitation einsteinienne

Darmois, G. L es \'e quations de la gravitation einsteinienne. M \'e morial des Sciences Math \'e matiques, Fascicule XXV (Paris: Gauthier-Villars) 44\/ (1927)

work page 1927

Show all 52 references

[9]

Geometry of lightlike submanifolds in L orentzian space forms

Ferr \'a ndez, \'A ., Gim \'e nez, \'A ., and Lucas, P. Geometry of lightlike submanifolds in L orentzian space forms. In Proc. del Congreso Geometria de Lorentz, Benalmadena\/ (2001)

2001
[10]

Friedlander, F. G. Introduction to the theory of distributions , second ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1998. With additional material by M. Joshi

1998
[11]

S trings and other distributional sources in G eneral R elativity

Geroch, R., and Traschen, J. S trings and other distributional sources in G eneral R elativity. Physical Review D 36 , 4 (1987), 1017

1987
[12]

Gourgoulhon, E., and Jaramillo, J. L. A 3+1 perspective on null hypersurfaces and isolated horizons. Physics Reports 423\/ (2006), 159--294

2006
[13]

Grant, J. D. E., Kunzinger, M., S\" a mann, C., and Steinbauer, R. The future is not always open. Letters in Mathematical Physics 110 , 1 (2020), 83--103

2020
[14]

B., and Podolsk \`y , J

Griffiths, J. B., and Podolsk \`y , J. E xact space-times in E instein's G eneral R elativity . Cambridge University Press, (2009)

2009
[15]

Geometric theory of generalized functions with applications to general relativity , vol

Grosser, M., Kunzinger, M., Oberguggenberger, M., and Steinbauer, R. Geometric theory of generalized functions with applications to general relativity , vol. 537 of Mathematics and its Applications . Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, (2001)

2001
[16]

S ingular hypersurfaces and thin shells in G eneral R elativity

Israel, W. S ingular hypersurfaces and thin shells in G eneral R elativity. Il Nuovo Cimento B 44\/ (1966), 1--14

1966
[17]

The Art of Gluing Space-Time Manifolds: Methods and Applications

Khakshournia, S., and Mansouri, R. The Art of Gluing Space-Time Manifolds: Methods and Applications . Springer Nature, (2023)

2023
[18]

K., and Lucietti, J

Kunduri, H. K., and Lucietti, J. Classification of near-horizon geometries of extremal black holes. Living Reviews in Relativity 16\/ (2013), 1--71

2013
[19]

A note on the P enrose junction conditions

Kunzinger, M., and Steinbauer, R. A note on the P enrose junction conditions. Classical Quantum Gravity 16 , 4 (1999), 1255--1264

1999
[20]

B emerkung zur de S itterschen W elt

Lanczos, K. B emerkung zur de S itterschen W elt. Physikalische Zeitschrift 23 , 539-543 (1922), 15

1922
[21]

F l \"a chenhafte V erteilung der M aterie in der E insteinschen G ravitationstheorie

Lanczos, K. F l \"a chenhafte V erteilung der M aterie in der E insteinschen G ravitationstheorie. Annalen der Physik 379 , 14 (1924), 518--540

1924
[22]

Lee, J. M. I ntroduction to smooth manifolds. Graduate Texts in Mathematics 218\/ (2003), 191--194

2003
[23]

G., and Mardare, C

LeFloch, P. G., and Mardare, C. Definition and stability of L orentzian manifolds with distributional curvature. Portugaliae Mathematica 64 , 4 (2007), 535--573

2007
[24]

Null shells: general matching across null boundaries and connection with cut-and-paste formalism

Manzano, M., and Mars, M. Null shells: general matching across null boundaries and connection with cut-and-paste formalism. Classical and Quantum Gravity 38 , 15 (2021), 155008

2021
[25]

G eneral matching across K illing horizons of zero order

M anzano, M., and M ars, M. G eneral matching across K illing horizons of zero order. P hysical R eview D 106 , 4 (2022), 044019

2022
[26]

Abstract formulation of the spacetime matching problem and null thin shells

Manzano, M., and Mars, M. Abstract formulation of the spacetime matching problem and null thin shells. Physical Review D 109\/ (2024), 044050

2024
[27]

N ull hypersurface data and ambient vector fields: K illing horizons of order zero and one

Manzano, M., and Mars, M. N ull hypersurface data and ambient vector fields: K illing horizons of order zero and one. Physical Review D 110\/ (2024), 044070

2024
[28]

The constraint tensor for null hypersurfaces

Manzano, M., and Mars, M. The constraint tensor for null hypersurfaces. Journal of Geometry and Physics 208\/ (2025), 105375

2025
[29]

C onstraint equations for general hypersurfaces and applications to shells

Mars, M. C onstraint equations for general hypersurfaces and applications to shells. General Relativity and Gravitation 45\/ (2013), 2175--2221

2013
[30]

H ypersurface data: general properties and B irkhoff theorem in spherical symmetry

Mars, M. H ypersurface data: general properties and B irkhoff theorem in spherical symmetry. Mediterranean Journal of Mathematics 17\/ (2020), 1--45

2020
[31]

A bstract null geometry, energy-momentum map and applications to the constraint tensor

Mars, M. A bstract null geometry, energy-momentum map and applications to the constraint tensor. Beijing Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics 1\/ (2024), 797--852

2024
[32]

T ransverse expansion of the metric at null hypersurfaces I

Mars, M., and S \'a nchez-P \'e rez, G. T ransverse expansion of the metric at null hypersurfaces I . U niqueness and application to K illing horizons. Journal of Geometry and Physics 209\/ (2025), 105416

2025
[33]

L orentzian and signature changing branes

Mars, M., Senovilla, J., and Vera, R. L orentzian and signature changing branes. Physical Review D 76\/ (2007), 044029

2007
[34]

Mars, M., and Senovilla, J. M. M. G eometry of general hypersurfaces in spacetime: junction conditions. Classical and Quantum Gravity 10\/ (1993), 1865

1993
[35]

T ransverse expansion of the metric at null hypersurfaces II .\ E xistence results and application to K illing horizons

Mars, M., and Sánchez-Pérez, G. T ransverse expansion of the metric at null hypersurfaces II .\ E xistence results and application to K illing horizons. Journal of Geometry and Physics\/ (2025), 105605

2025
[36]

Symmetries of cosmological C auchy horizons

Moncrief, V., and Isenberg, J. Symmetries of cosmological C auchy horizons. Communications in Mathematical Physics 89\/ (1983), 387--413

1983
[37]

Navarro, M., Palmas, O., and Solis, D. A. Null hypersurfaces in generalized R obertson-- W alker spacetimes. Journal of Geometry and Physics 106\/ (2016), 256--267

2016
[38]

Multiplication of distributions and applications to partial differential equations , vol

Oberguggenberger, M. Multiplication of distributions and applications to partial differential equations , vol. 259 of Pitman Research Notes in Mathematics Series . Longman Scientific & Technical, Harlow; copublished in the United States with John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1992

1992
[39]

T wistor quantisation and curved space-time

Penrose, R. T wistor quantisation and curved space-time. International Journal of Theoretical Physics 1\/ (1968), 61--99

1968
[40]

T he geometry of impulsive gravitational waves

Penrose, R. T he geometry of impulsive gravitational waves. In G eneral R elativity: P apers in honour of J . L . S ynge , L. O'Raifeartaigh, Ed. 1972, pp. 101--115

1972
[41]

C ut-and-paste for impulsive gravitational waves with : T he geometric picture

Podolsk \`y , J., S \"a mann, C., Steinbauer, R., and S varc, R. C ut-and-paste for impulsive gravitational waves with : T he geometric picture. Physical Review D 100\/ (2019), 024040

2019
[42]

Penrose junction conditions with : geometric insights into low-regularity metrics for impulsive gravitational waves

Podolsk\' y , J., and Steinbauer, R. Penrose junction conditions with : geometric insights into low-regularity metrics for impulsive gravitational waves. General Relativity Gravitation 54 , 9 (2022), Paper No. 96, 24

2022
[43]

P enrose junction conditions extended: impulsive waves with gyratons

Podolsk \`y , J., S varc, R., Steinbauer, R., and S \"a mann, C. P enrose junction conditions extended: impulsive waves with gyratons. Physical Review D 96\/ (2017), 064043

2017
[44]

Continuous coordinates for all impulsive pp-waves

Podolsk\'y, J., and Vesel\'y, K. Continuous coordinates for all impulsive pp-waves. Physics Letters A 241\/ (1998), 145--147

1998
[45]

A relativist's toolkit: the mathematics of black-hole mechanics

Poisson, E. A relativist's toolkit: the mathematics of black-hole mechanics . Cambridge university press, 2004

2004
[46]

Cut-and-paste for impulsive gravitational waves with : T he mathematical analysis

S \"a mann, C., Schinnerl, B., Steinbauer, R., and S varc, R. Cut-and-paste for impulsive gravitational waves with : T he mathematical analysis. Letters in Mathematical Physics 114 , 2 (2024), 58

2024
[47]

Geodesics in nonexpanding impulsive gravitational waves with

S\" a mann, C., and Steinbauer, R. Geodesics in nonexpanding impulsive gravitational waves with . II . J. Math. Phys. 58 , 11 (2017), 112503

2017
[48]

Geodesics in nonexpanding impulsive gravitational waves with , part I

S\" a mann, C., Steinbauer, R., Lecke, A., and Podolsk\' y , J. Geodesics in nonexpanding impulsive gravitational waves with , part I . Classical Quantum Gravity 33 , 11 (2016), 115002

2016
[49]

Senovilla, J. M. M. E quations for general shells. Journal of High Energy Physics 2018\/ (2018), 134

2018
[50]

Scalar curvature rigidity on locally conformally flat manifolds with boundary

Spiegel, F.-M. Scalar curvature rigidity on locally conformally flat manifolds with boundary . Ph. D . thesis, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universit \"a t Bonn, Bonn, Germany, August (2016)

2016
[51]

On the geometry of impulsive gravitational waves

Steinbauer, R. On the geometry of impulsive gravitational waves. gr-qc/9809054\/ (1998)

1998 arXiv
[52]

Steinbauer, R., and Vickers, J. A. On the G eroch- T raschen class of metrics. Classical Quantum Gravity 26 , 6 (2009), 065001, 19

2009

Pith tools

Reviewed August 6, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.

[1] [1]

C., and Balasin, H

Aichelburg, P. C., and Balasin, H. Generalized symmetries of impulsive gravitational waves. Classical Quantum Gravity 14 , 1A (1997), A31--A41. Geometry and physics

work page 1997

[2] [2]

C., and Sexl, R

Aichelburg, P. C., and Sexl, R. U. On the gravitational field of a massless particle. General Relativity and Gravitation 2\/ (1971), 303--312

work page 1971

[3] [3]

Barrab \'e s, C., and Hogan, P. A. S ingular null hypersurfaces in G eneral R elativity: light-like signals from violent astrophysical events . World Scientific, (2003)

work page 2003

[4] [4]

T hin shells in general relativity and cosmology: the lightlike limit

Barrab \'e s, C., and Israel, W. T hin shells in general relativity and cosmology: the lightlike limit. Physical Review D 43\/ (1991), 1129--1142

work page 1991

[5] [5]

B., and Vickers, P

Bonnor, W. B., and Vickers, P. A. J unction conditions in G eneral R elativity. General Relativity and Gravitation 13 , 1 (1981), 29--36

work page 1981

[6] [6]

T., and Grant, J

Chru \'s ciel, P. T., and Grant, J. D. E. On L orentzian causality with continuous metrics. Classical Quantum Gravity 29 , 14 (2012), 145001, 32

work page 2012

[7] [7]

Clarke, C. J. S., and Dray, T. J unction conditions for null hypersurfaces. Classical and Quantum Gravity 4\/ (1987), 265

work page 1987

[8] [8]

L es \'e quations de la gravitation einsteinienne

Darmois, G. L es \'e quations de la gravitation einsteinienne. M \'e morial des Sciences Math \'e matiques, Fascicule XXV (Paris: Gauthier-Villars) 44\/ (1927)

work page 1927