Pith. sign in

REVIEW 3 major objections 4 minor 43 references

Finite-Temperature Toroidal Moment Amenable to Direct Observation in an Fe$_{10}$Dy$_{10}$ Molecular Ring

T0 review · 3 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-05 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read The paper predicts that Fe10Dy10, a 20-ion 3d–4f molecular ring, hosts a maximally toroidal ground doublet with a toroidal moment of order 1500 μB Å that a shaped near-infrared laser pulse can split and make directly detectable.

desk verdict Solid ab initio model and a new toroidal susceptibility, but the paper's own relaxation data undermine the central direct-observation claim. read the letter →

arxiv 2509.05424 v2 pith:CODNELIW submitted 2025-09-05 cond-mat.mes-hall physics.atm-clus

Alessandro Soncini , Kieran Hymas , Jonas Braun , Yannik F. Schneider , Simone Calvello , Amer Baniodeh , Yanhua Lan , Wolfgang Wernsdorfer
show 3 more authors
Marco Affronte Christopher E. Anson Annie K. Powell
This is my paper · ORCID
classification cond-mat.mes-hallphysics.atm-clus
keywords toroidalmomentsingle-moleculetoroicsmolecularmagnetismFe10Dy10susceptibilitymagnetoelectriccouplingtransfer-matrixmodellanthanidewheel
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

Single-molecule toroics are magnetic wheels whose spin arrangement forms a closed vortex, carrying a toroidal moment. Because opposite vortex chiralities are degenerate under ordinary magnetic fields, toroidal order has so far been inferred indirectly rather than seen directly. This paper predicts that the icosanuclear ring Fe10Dy10 changes that: an ab initio-parameterised transfer-matrix model, which reproduces measured magnetization, susceptibility, and specific heat, places a maximally toroidal ground doublet with |τ| ≈ 1500 μB Å—about 25 times larger than the Dy3 archetype. To make the prediction testable, the paper introduces the toroidal susceptibility ξ, a linear-response function giving the toroidal polarization induced by a magnetic-field curl, and shows the response remains substantial up to about 10 K. It then estimates that a focused 10-fs near-infrared pulse creates a curl splitting of ≈1.5 cm−1 between the two chiralities and predicts a magnetoelectric signal readable by micro-SQUID magnetometry, proposing a concrete path to the first direct observation of a molecular toroidal moment.

What carries the argument

The central object is the toroidal moment operator τ = Σ_i r_i × M_i, evaluated in the low-energy manifold of the ring. The argument is carried by three tools. First, an ab initio-parameterised transfer-matrix model: the 2^10 × 6^10 ≈ 62-billion-dimensional Hilbert space of ten DyIII Ising doublets and ten FeIII S = 5/2 spins is compressed into a product of ten 24×24 transfer matrices, with FeIII–FeIII exchange treated in first-order perturbation theory. This model reproduces powder magnetization, χT, and field-dependent specific heat without fitting parameters (aside from two lattice terms). Second, the newly introduced toroidal susceptibility ξαβ = −∂²F/∂(∇×B)α∂(∇×B)β, the curl-field analo

What would settle it

A single-crystal micro-SQUID magnetization measurement below 1 K should show the predicted nonmagnetic ground state and sharp level-crossing steps at fields of roughly 6–40 mT, depending on orientation, where the toroidal ground doublet crosses the magnetic excited state. If instead the zero-field ground state is magnetic at these temperatures, the claimed maximally toroidal ground doublet is falsified; similarly, the proposed 10-fs pulse experiment would falsify the detection scheme if no electric-field-induced magnetization appears at the estimated pulse parameters.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The paper's central claim is that Fe10Dy10 realizes a maximally toroidal ground state. In the model, the ten DyIII Ising spins form a zero-noded s-wave vortex around the elliptical wheel; the ground Kramers doublet consists of the two time-reversed chiralities of this vortex and carries essentially no magnetic moment but a toroidal moment τ = Σ_i r_i × M_i of order 1500 μB Å. A magnetic state of ~83 μB lies only 0.2 cm−1 higher, and most of the dense low-energy spectrum carries both toroidal and magnetic character. The authors define the molar toroidal susceptibility ξ as the second derivative of the free energy with respect to ∇×B, so that T→0 gives the square of the ground-state toroidal m

Load-bearing premise

The detection estimate hinges on the assumption that the ring's toroidal moment couples to the magnetic-field curl of the shaped laser pulse with the linear form H = τ·(∇×B) and the estimated |∇×B| ≈ 5×10^-4 T/Å, and that toroidal relaxation is slow enough for the induced population imbalance to accumulate and be measured; the paper does not model the full optical waveform or heating.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • Fe10Dy10 becomes a candidate platform for the first direct observation of a molecular toroidal moment; a shaped near-infrared pulse should split the ground doublet by ~1.5 cm−1, and the resulting population imbalance should be readable in micro-SQUID magnetometry.
  • The toroidal susceptibility ξ establishes a standard thermodynamic response function for single-molecule toroics, letting future work compute and compare finite-temperature toroidal polarization across molecules and field configurations.
  • The parameter-free transfer-matrix strategy makes the full 62-billion-state low-energy spectrum of large 3d–4f wheels computationally accessible, so the same machinery can be reused for related heterometallic rings.
  • The prediction that a uniform field stabilizes a constant toroidal polarization up to ~10 K implies toroidal states can be addressed at experimentally accessible temperatures, not only in the millikelvin limit.
  • A magnetic excited state only 0.2 cm−1 above the toroidal ground doublet means that even a ~5 mT field can make the ground state magnetic; this competition is captured by the model and is relevant for interpreting low-field magnetization.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • Editorial inference: because the toroidal moment grows linearly with ring radius and per-ion moments, applying the same transfer-matrix-plus-ξ machinery to even larger 3d–4f wheels should push the laser-induced splitting well beyond 1.5 cm−1 and make direct detection easier.
  • Editorial inference: the paper estimates the response to a single pulse but does not simulate the full optical waveform; a natural two-pulse pump-probe variant would use the first pulse to create the curl-induced imbalance and a delayed second pulse to read it out via the magnetoelectric tensor, with pulse shape and timing matched to the slow toroidal relaxation suggested by the AC-susceptibility
  • Editorial inference: the proximity of the magnetic state at 0.2 cm−1 suggests chemical control—ligand substitution or strain that tunes the Fe–Dy exchange constants—could push the magnetic excitation higher, purifying the toroidal ground state and extending its finite-temperature window.
  • Editorial inference: if the predicted magnetoelectric readout works, the electric-dipole symmetry of τ implies a route to electrically write toroidal chirality, since the two chiralities are time-reversed partners; the paper motivates but does not demonstrate such switching.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

3 major / 4 minor

Summary. The paper studies the icosanuclear ring Fe10Dy10 and constructs an ab initio-informed transfer-matrix model that projects the 62-billion-dimensional low-energy Hilbert space onto 2^10 Dy(III) Ising configurations dressed by Fe(III) spin excitations, with Fe–Fe exchange treated perturbatively. The model is compared with powder magnetization, χT, and specific-heat measurements and shows good agreement. On this basis the authors predict a maximally toroidal ground doublet with a toroidal moment of order 1500 μB Å, introduce a toroidal susceptibility ξ as a linear response to ∇×B, and propose a laser-pulse protocol in which a shaped optical waveform induces a curl of the magnetic field that removes the degeneracy of the counter-rotating toroidal states. The central claim is that Fe10Dy10 allows toroidal polarization to be prepared, accumulated, and read out under realistic experimental conditions.

Significance. If the result holds, the paper provides a significant theoretical framework for finite-temperature toroidal response in a large molecular ring, going beyond the archetypal Dy3 triangle. The transfer-matrix treatment of a 62-billion-dimensional space with ab initio parameters is an impressive technical achievement, and the reproduction of magnetization, susceptibility, and specific heat gives nontrivial support to the underlying spin Hamiltonian. The definition of ξ as a thermodynamic response to a magnetic-field curl is a useful conceptual step. However, the paper's headline claim—that toroidal polarization can be prepared, accumulated, and read out under realistic conditions—is not quantitatively established. The detection protocol rests on an unsupported assumption about toroidal relaxation times, and a promised ab initio-informed magnetoelectric tensor for electric-field readout is absent from the manuscript and supplementary information.

major comments (3)
  1. [Section 5, Eq. (10); Supplementary Notes 4 and 5] The proposed preparation-and-detection protocol requires that toroidal relaxation be 'sufficiently slow' (Section 5), but no toroidal relaxation time is computed or measured. The available dynamics data indicate the opposite: Supplementary Note 5 reports an Arrhenius fit U = 11.5 K and τ0 = 8×10^-13 s from microSQUID magnetization decay, giving τ ≈ 1.4×10^-11 s at 4 K, the temperature invoked for the protocol. Supplementary Note 4 places the AC out-of-phase maximum above 1500 Hz even below 1.8 K, implying τ < 10^-4 s at those temperatures and even shorter at 4 K. The population imbalance generated by a laser pulse would thus decay orders of magnitude faster than any realistic measurement or inter-pulse accumulation interval. The authors may argue that magnetization relaxation differs from toroidal relaxation, but then they must provide an explicit estimate or calculation of the toroidal
  2. [Abstract; Section 5] The abstract promises that 'an ab initio-informed magnetoelectric tensor predicts an electric-field-induced magnetic moment within μSQUID detectability,' but no such tensor is derived, tabulated, or used anywhere in the main text or the Supplementary Information. The detection section (Section 5) discusses only the τ·(∇×B) coupling and gives a static splitting estimate; it does not model the electric-field readout, the induced magnetic moment, or the μSQUID response. Without a quantitative readout model, the claim that the toroidal polarization is readable within μSQUID detectability is not established.
  3. [Section 4, Eq. (6)-(7); Section 5] The finite-temperature toroidal response is characterized by the equilibrium linear-response function ξ, but the proposed laser protocol is a strongly time-dependent, far-from-equilibrium process involving repeated 10 fs pulses. The paper does not connect the equilibrium ξ or the static splitting ΔE = 2τ·(∇×B) to the accumulation dynamics under the full optical waveform. In particular, no account is given of the optical electric field acting directly on the molecular charges, sample heating, or the repetition-rate constraint imposed by the relaxation time. The static splitting estimate may be correct, but it does not by itself demonstrate that a measurable toroidal polarization can be accumulated.
minor comments (4)
  1. [Title] The manuscript title in the main text is 'Giant Molecular Toroidal Moment Amenable to Direct Observation in a Fe10Dy10 Ring,' whereas the submitted arXiv title is 'Finite-Temperature Toroidal Moment Amenable to Direct Observation in an Fe10Dy10 Molecular Ring.' Please harmonize the title.
  2. [Section 2.4] The text says 'Using Eq. (17, 18)' before those equations are introduced in Methods. Please renumber equations or adjust the cross-reference.
  3. [Section 3, Eq. (5)] The model is repeatedly described as 'parameter free,' but Eq. (5) contains two fitted parameters a and b for the lattice specific heat. This is not a problem for the magnetic model, but the wording should be qualified to avoid confusion.
  4. [Supplementary Note 5] Typo: 'cohercive field' should be 'coercive field.'

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity: toroidal moment and ξ are outputs of an ab initio-parameterized, data-validated model, not fitted inputs.

full rationale

The derivation chain is self-contained. The spin Hamiltonian (Eq. 2) is parameterized entirely by ab initio calculations: crystal-field g-tensors and magnetic axes from CERES (Methods 6.1, Table 2) and exchange couplings from broken-symmetry DFT (Methods 6.2, Table 1). No parameter is fitted to the toroidal moment or to any toroidal observable. The model is validated against powder magnetization (Fig. 3) and specific heat (Fig. 4); the only fitted parameters a and b in Eq. (5) are lattice background terms that do not enter the toroidal susceptibility. The toroidal moment operator (Eq. 1), the coupling H_Tor (Eq. 14), and the linear-response expression for ξ (Eq. 7) are definitions/standard multipole results, not circular inputs. The ground-state toroidal doublet and ξ(T) are outputs of the transfer-matrix diagonalization, not quantities fed into the model. The order-of-magnitude ΔE estimate in Section 5 uses a simple free-ion moment/radius estimate independent of the fitted model. There are self-citations (CERES [30], previous toroidal-moment work [8,16,18], NMR derivative formula [34]), but none is load-bearing: the cited results are either standard multipole expansions, independent software descriptions, or background, and the central toroidal prediction is computed in this paper. Non-circular concerns: the detection protocol assumes sufficiently slow toroidal relaxation (Section 5) without computing it, and the SI microSQUID data (Note 5) imply fast magnetic relaxation (U=11.5 K, τ0=8e-13 s, τ~1e-11 s at 4 K); also the abstract promises an ab initio magnetoelectric tensor that is not presented. These are correctness/completeness risks, not circularity.

Assumptions & free parameters 2 free parameters · 5 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The model rests on ab initio crystal-field and exchange parameters, plus several domain assumptions about the spin structure and laser coupling. The only truly fitted numbers are the two lattice heat-capacity coefficients. No new particles or fields are introduced.

free parameters (2)
  • a = 1e-3 k_B^-1 K^-3
    Lattice specific heat Debye term, fitted to high-temperature specific heat data in Eq. (5).
  • b = 1e-3 k_B^-1 K^-3/2
    Anharmonic lattice specific heat term, also fitted to high-temperature data in Eq. (5).
assumptions (5)
  • domain assumption Dy ground Kramers doublets are pure Ising: S_Dy = 5/2 σ_i u_i
    Reduces the Dy degrees of freedom to 2^10 classical Ising configurations, enabling the transfer-matrix construction. Invoked in Section 2.3 and Eq. (11).
  • domain assumption Toroidal moment couples as H_Tor = τ·(∇×B)
    Standard multipole-expansion coupling taken as the interaction Hamiltonian, used to define ξ and the detection protocol. See Eq. (14).
  • domain assumption Fe-Fe exchange treated to first order only
    J_C is small relative to Fe-Dy exchange, so perturbation theory is used; higher-order corrections are untested. See Eq. (18).
  • domain assumption Laser-induced ∇×B ≈ μ0 ε0 E_max/Δt
    Order-of-magnitude estimate in Eq. (10) assuming a linear field ramp and no current density; optical-frequency dynamics are ignored.
  • domain assumption Sufficiently slow toroidal relaxation times
    Explicitly assumed in Section 5 to allow population accumulation; no quantitative estimate is given.

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Finite-Temperature Toroidal Moment Amenable to Direct Observation in an Fe$_{10}$Dy$_{10}$ Molecular Ring." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/CODNELIW

@misc{pith2026250905424,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Finite-Temperature Toroidal Moment Amenable to Direct Observation in an Fe$_10$Dy$_10$ Molecular Ring},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/CODNELIW}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2509.05424}
}
abstract

Single-molecule toroics (SMTs) host closed magnetic-vortex configurations that carry toroidal moments $\boldsymbol{\tau}$, whose electric-dipole symmetry enables magnetoelectric spin control. Yet, opposite toroidal chiralities are degenerate in conventional magnetic fields, making direct detection of molecular toroidal polarisation challenging. Current approaches probe molecular toroidal dynamics only indirectly through weak residual magnetism, leaving direct interrogation of toroidal polarisation an open challenge. Moreover, the survival of toroidal polarization at finite temperature, and realistic preparation-and-readout conditions, have not been quantitatively established. Here we investigate the icosanuclear $3d$--$4f$ molecular ring Fe$_{10}$Dy$_{10}$, featuring a $\sim$62-billion-dimensional low-energy manifold with pervasive toroidal character, rendered computationally tractable via an ab initio-informed transfer-matrix framework with perturbative corrections. Our model reproduces magnetic and calorimetric measurements and reveals a maximally toroidal ground doublet with robust finite-temperature toroidal response. We introduce the toroidal susceptibility $\xi$ as a finite-temperature linear-response function to quantify toroidal polarisation induced by magnetic-field curl. We then develop a preparation-and-detection protocol in which a temporally asymmetric near-infrared waveform generates a cumulative toroidal population imbalance, while an ab initio-informed magnetoelectric tensor predicts an electric-field-induced magnetic moment within $\mu$SQUID detectability. These results establish Fe$_{10}$Dy$_{10}$ as a molecular platform where toroidal polarisation can be prepared, accumulated and read out under realistic experimental conditions.

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

43 extracted references · 43 canonical work pages

  1. [1]

    author Bloom, B. P. , author Paltiel, Y. , author Naaman, R. & author Waldeck, D. H. title Chiral induced spin selectivity . journal Chemical Reviews volume 124 ( year 2024 )

    work page 2024

  2. [2]

    author Yokosuk, M. O. et al. title Nonreciprocal directional dichroism of a chiral magnet in the visible range . journal npj Quantum Materials volume 5 ( year 2020 )

    work page 2020

  3. [3]

    author Spaldin, N. A. , author Fiebig, M. & author Mostovoy, M. title The toroidal moment in condensed-matter physics and its relation to the magnetoelectric effect . journal Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter volume 20 , pages 434203 ( year 2008 )

    work page 2008

  4. [4]

    author Ritzmann, U. et al. title Trochoidal motion and pair generation in skyrmion and antiskyrmion dynamics under spin--orbit torques . journal Nature Electronics volume 1 , pages 451--457 ( year 2018 )

    work page 2018

  5. [5]

    author Guan, S. et al. title Optically controlled ultrafast dynamics of skyrmion in antiferromagnets . journal Physical Review B volume 107 , pages 214429 ( year 2023 )

    work page 2023

  6. [6]

    title Electromagnetic interaction with parity violation

    author Zeldovich, I. title Electromagnetic interaction with parity violation . journal Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics (U.S.S.R.) volume 33 , pages 1531--1533 ( year 1957 )

    work page 1957

  7. [7]

    author Dubovik, V. M. & author Tugushev, V. title Toroid moments in electrodynamics and solid-state physics . journal Physics Reports volume 18 , pages 145 ( year 1990 )

    work page 1990

  8. [8]

    , author Ligabue, A

    author Faglioni, F. , author Ligabue, A. , author Pelloni, S. , author Soncini, A. & author Lazzeretti, P. title Molecular response to a time-independent non-uniform magnetic-field . journal Chemical Physics volume 304 , pages 289 ( year 2004 )

    work page 2004

Show all 43 references
  1. [9]

    & author Soncini, A

    author Hymas, K. & author Soncini, A. title Preparation and coherent manipulation of toroidal moments in molecules . journal arXiv preprint arXiv:2504.08701 ://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2504.08701

    doi arXiv

  2. [10]

    author Wood, C. S. et al. title Measurement of parity nonconservation and an anapole moment in Cesium . journal Science volume 275 , pages 1759--1763 ( year 1997 )

    1997

  3. [11]

    , author Rivera, J

    author Van Aken, B. , author Rivera, J. , author Schmid, H. & author Fiebig, M. title Observation of ferrotoroidic domains . journal Nature volume 449 , pages 702 ( year 2007 )

    2007

  4. [12]

    , author Fedotov, V

    author Kaelberer, T. , author Fedotov, V. , author Papasimakis, N. , author Tsai, D. & author Zheludev, N. title Toroidal dipolar response in a metamaterial . journal Science volume 330 , pages 1510 ( year 2010 )

    2010

  5. [13]

    author Zdagkas, A. et al. title Observation of toroidal pulses of light . journal Nature Photonics volume 16 , pages 523 ( year 2022 )

    2022

  6. [14]

    author Tang, J. et al. title Dysprosium triangles showing single-molecule magnet behavior of thermally excited spin states . journal Angewandte Chemie International Edition volume 45 , pages 1729 –1733 ( year 2006 )

    2006

  7. [15]

    author Luzon, J. et al. title Spin chirality in a molecular dysprosium triangle: The archetype of the noncollinear Ising model . journal Physical Review Letters volume 100 , pages 247205 ( year 2008 )

    2008

  8. [16]

    author Chibotaru, L. F. , author Ungur, L. & author Soncini, A. title The origin of nonmagnetic Kramers doublets in the ground state of dysprosium triangles: Evidence for a toroidal magnetic moment . journal Angewandte Chemie International Edition volume 120 , pages 4194--4197...

    2008

  9. [17]

    author Ungur, L. et al. title Net toroidal magnetic moment in the ground state of a \ Dy _6\ -triethanolamine ring . journal The Journal of the American Chemical Society volume 134 , pages 18554--18557 ( year 2012 )

    2012

  10. [18]

    & author Chibotaru, L

    author Soncini, A. & author Chibotaru, L. F. title Toroidal magnetic states in molecular wheels: Interplay between isotropic exchange interactions and local magnetic anisotropy . journal Physical Review B volume 77 , pages 220406 ( year 2008 )

    2008

  11. [19]

    author Langley, S. K. , author Moubaraki, B. & author Murray, K. S. title Trinuclear, octanuclear and decanuclear dysprosium(III) complexes: Synthesis, structural and magnetic studies . journal Polyhedron volume 64 , pages 255--261 ( year 2013 )

    2013

  12. [20]

    , author Magnani, N

    author Baniodeh, A. , author Magnani, N. , author Br \"a se, S. , author Anson, C. E. & author Powell, A. K. title Ligand field variations: Tuning the toroidal moment of Dy _6 rings . journal Dalton Transactions volume 44 , pages 6343--6347 ( year 2015 )

    2015

  13. [21]

    author Kaemmerer, H. et al. title Inorganic approach to stabilizing nanoscale toroidicity in a tetraicosanuclear Fe _ 18 Dy _ 6 Single-Molecule Magnet . journal The Journal of the American Chemical Society volume 142 , pages 14838--14842 ( year 2020 )

    2020

  14. [22]

    , author Bao, S.-S

    author Tian, H. , author Bao, S.-S. & author Zheng, L.-M. title Enlarging the ring by incorporating a phosphonate coligand: From the cyclic hexanuclear to octanuclear dysprosium clusters . journal Dalton Transactions volume 44 , pages 14208--14212 ( year 2015 )

    2015

  15. [23]

    author Lu, J. et al. title Lanthanide(III) hexanuclear circular helicates: slow magnetic relaxation, toroidal arrangement of magnetic moments, and magnetocaloric effects . journal Inorganic Chemistry volume 58 , pages 11903--11911 ( year 2019 )

    2019

  16. [24]

    author Vignesh, K. R. et al. title Ferrotoroidic ground state in a heterometallic \ Cr ^ III Dy ^ III _6\ complex displaying slow magnetic relaxation . journal Nature Communications volume 8 , pages 1--12 ( year 2017 )

    2017

  17. [25]

    author Vignesh, K. R. et al. title Slow magnetic relaxation and single-molecule toroidal behaviour in a family of heptanuclear \ Cr ^ III Ln ^ III _6\ (Ln= Tb, Ho, Er) complexes . journal Angewandte Chemie International Edition volume 130 , pages 787--792 ( year 2018 )

    2018

  18. [26]

    author Ashtree, J. M. et al. title Tuning the ferrotoroidic coupling and magnetic hysteresis in double-triangle complexes \ Dy _3 M ^ III Dy _3\ via the M ^ III -linker . journal European Journal of Inorganic Chemistry volume 2021 , pages 435--444 ( year 2021 )

    2021

  19. [27]

    , author van Leusen, J

    author Botezat, O. , author van Leusen, J. , author Kravtsov, V. C. , author K \"o gerler, P. & author Baca, S. G. title Ultralarge 3d/4f coordination wheels: From carboxylate/amino alcohol-supported \ Fe _4 Ln _2\ to \ Fe _ 18 Ln _6\ rings . journal Inorganic Chemistry volume...

    2017

  20. [28]

    author Baniodeh, A. et al. title High spin cycles: Topping the spin record for a single molecule verging on quantum criticality . journal npj Quantum Materials volume 3 , pages 1--6 ( year 2018 )

    2018

  21. [29]

    author Baniodeh, A. et al. title Unraveling the influence of lanthanide ions on intra- and inter-molecular electronic processes in Fe _ 10 Ln _ 10 nano-toruses . journal Advanced Functional Materials volume 24 , pages 6280--6290 ( year 2014 )

    2014

  22. [30]

    , author Piccardo, M

    author Calvello, S. , author Piccardo, M. , author Rao, S. V. & author Soncini, A. title CERES : An ab initio code dedicated to the calculation of the electronic structure and magnetic properties of lanthanide complexes . journal Journal of Computational Chemistry volume 39 , ...

    2018

  23. [31]

    author Aquilante, F. et al. title Molcas 8: New capabilities for multiconfigurational quantum chemical calculations across the periodic table . journal Journal of Computational Chemistry volume 37 , pages 506--541 ( year 2016 )

    2016

  24. [32]

    , author Fukui, H

    author Yamaguchi, K. , author Fukui, H. & author Fueno, T. title Molecular Orbital (MO) theory for magnetically interacting organic compounds. Ab-initio MO calculations of the effective exchange integrals for cyclophane-type carbene dimers . journal Chemistry Letters volume 15...

    1986

  25. [33]

    , author Lasjaunias, J

    author Affronte, M. , author Lasjaunias, J. C. & author Cornia, A. title Low temperature specific heat of molecular rings: a study on the effects of the internal guest substitution and on the lattice contribution . journal The European Physical Journal B volume 15 , pages 633-...

    2000

  26. [34]

    & author Soncini, A

    author Van den Heuvel, W. & author Soncini, A. title NMR chemical shift as analytical derivative of the Helmholtz free energy . journal The Journal of Chemical Physics volume 138 , pages 054113 ( year 2013 )

    2013

  27. [35]

    author Jackson, J. D. title Classical Electrodynamics ( publisher John Wiley & Sons , year 2021 )

    2021

  28. [36]

    , author Irl \"a nder, K

    author Pister, D. , author Irl \"a nder, K. , author Westerbeck, D. & author Schnack, J. title Toroidal magnetic molecules stripped to their basics . journal Physical Review Research volume 4 , pages 033221 ( year 2022 )

    2022

  29. [37]

    title Toroidal spin states in molecular magnets

    author Pavlyukh, Y. title Toroidal spin states in molecular magnets . journal Physical Review B volume 101 , pages 144408 ( year 2020 )

    2020

  30. [38]

    , author Calvello, S

    author Van den Heuvel, W. , author Calvello, S. & author Soncini, A. title Configuration-averaged 4f orbitals in ab initio calculations of low-lying crystal field levels in lanthanide(III) complexes . journal Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics volume 18 , pages 15807--15814 (...

    2016

  31. [39]

    title Valence bond description of antiferromagnetic coupling in transition metal dimers

    author Noodleman, L. title Valence bond description of antiferromagnetic coupling in transition metal dimers . journal The Journal of Chemical Physics volume 74 , pages 5737--5743 ( year 1981 )

    1981

  32. [40]

    title Software update: The ORCA program system—version 5.0

    author Neese, F. title Software update: The ORCA program system—version 5.0 . journal Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Computational Molecular Science pages e1606 ( year 2017 )

    2017

  33. [41]

    , author Perdew, J

    author Tao, J. , author Perdew, J. P. , author Staroverov, V. N. & author Scuseria, G. E. title Climbing the density functional ladder: Nonempirical meta--generalized gradient approximation designed for molecules and solids . journal Physical Review Letters volume 91 , pages 1...

    2003

  34. [42]

    author Pantazis, D. A. & author Neese, F. title All-electron scalar relativistic basis sets for the lanthanides . journal Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation volume 5 , pages 2229--2238 ( year 2009 )

    2009

  35. [43]

    & author Chibotaru, L

    author Van den Heuvel, W. & author Chibotaru, L. F. title Dysprosium-based experimental representatives of an I sing- H eisenberg chain and a decorated ising ring . journal Physical Review B volume 82 , pages 174436 ( year 2010 )

    2010

Pith tools

Reviewed August 5, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.