REVIEW 3 major objections 5 minor 30 references
MiraSOL: a DMD-based spectrograph for resolved solar spectroscopy
T0 review · 3 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-06 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read A prototype built around a digital micromirror device demonstrates pixel-level masking of the full solar disk, the core of a planned solar feed for spatially resolved extreme-precision radial-velocity spectroscopy and simulated transits.
desk verdict A solid proof-of-concept for DMD solar masking with a useful new flicker measurement, but the instrument's spectrograph channel is untested, so the paper is a pathfinder, not a validation of the full science concept. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central object is the DLP801RE digital micromirror device used as a spatial light modulator. Each micromirror toggles between an ON state, which sends light into an integrating sphere and then a fiber-fed spectrograph, and an OFF state, which sends light to an imaging camera; because the same mask defines both channels, the image shows the exact spatial origin of each spectrum. Supporting mechanisms include the 3-arcsecond-per-mirror sampling, the requirement that a simulated planet span at least a $3\times3$ mirror region, and the 'pond of mirrors' buffer zone that keeps stray light from the inactive area out of the science beam.
What would settle it
Point the prototype at the Sun, command a small group of micromirrors ON, and record the fiber-coupled spectrum: if the selected region cannot be recovered at the projected signal-to-noise and radial-velocity stability, the core science case fails. A second check: replace or reprogram the evaluation board to remove the 60 Hz reset flicker and remeasure the ON/OFF contrast; if it stays near 250:1, the simulated-transit mode cannot reach the 1000 ppm sensitivity claimed.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
On its own terms, the paper establishes that a high-efficiency-pixel DMD can be used as a dynamic spatial mask for the full solar disk at 3 arcsecond sampling per micromirror. The prototype, built from commercial off-the-shelf optics, produced images in which sunspots are visible and in which a commanded three-letter pattern removes light from a chosen region, demonstrating pixel-level control of the solar image. In parallel, high-speed photometry of the DMD in an all-ON state revealed a 60 Hz flicker — two phase-offset 60 Hz trains that appear as 120 Hz — attributed to an automated micromirror reset sequence in the evaluation firmware. The paper presents this as validation of the core conce
Load-bearing premise
The ON-state light reflected by selected micromirrors can be coupled through an integrating sphere into a fiber-fed spectrograph with acceptable throughput and stability; those optics are still under optimization and no spectrographic measurement is presented.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- MiraSOL would let observers isolate sunspots, plage, and other active regions for high-resolution spectra, directly probing how magnetic activity suppresses convective blueshift.
- By rapidly switching mirrors OFF along a moving chord, it can synthesize transits of known size and shape — including oblate planets — providing ground truth for the transit light source effect and for oblateness models.
- The dual-channel design gives real-time verification of where each spectrum came from, since masked regions appear dark in the imaging arm.
- A deployable fold mirror lets the same instrument run as a conventional full-disk Sun-as-a-star feed when spatial modulation is not needed.
- The 60 Hz evaluation-board flicker, if uncorrected, limits contrast and imprints banding on short exposures, so a scientific controller or timing solution is a prerequisite for the extreme-precision radial-velocity and transit-depth goals.
Reading between the lines
- If the flicker is indeed an anti-stiction reset routine in the evaluation firmware, a scientific-grade DMD controller or exposure synchronization to the reset phase should remove it; that is a direct test the paper does not run.
- The same spatial-mask capability could map convective blueshift limb-to-limb by occulting concentric annuli, giving a center-to-limb curve without needing eclipse events.
- If removing the flicker raises the contrast well above 250:1, simulated transits could reach below 1000 ppm and approach the roughly 200 ppm oblateness signature the paper cites, making the prototype a testbed for transit models used by space-based observatories.
- A direct next step, implied but not built, is swapping the visible-coated window for an NIR-coated one; the paper's efficiency simulation indicates this would make the same DMD competitive for near-infrared spectrographs.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. This proceedings paper presents the science motivation, preliminary design requirements, laboratory characterization, and a first prototype for MiraSOL, a proposed solar feed that uses a DLP801RE digital micromirror device (DMD) for spatially resolved spectroscopy and synthetic transit simulation. The authors report a 60 Hz optical flicker (appearing as two phase-offset 60 Hz signals, i.e., a 120 Hz pattern) in the DMD when driven by a TI evaluation board, which they hypothesize is an automated micromirror reset sequence. They also simulate the efficiency gain of a hypothetical NIR-coated window. The prototype, built from COTS components, images the full solar disk onto the DMD and demonstrates dynamic spatial masking by darkening a pattern ('PSU') in the imaging channel. No spectrograph-channel data are presented; the integrating-sphere coupling optics are explicitly stated to be under optimization, and the spectrographic performance is acknowledged as untested on sky.
Significance. If the full instrument is realized, MiraSOL would provide a unique capability for spatially resolved solar spectroscopy and controllable synthetic transits, directly addressing stellar-variability limits in EPRV and the transit light source effect. The prototype does validate the core DMD-based spatial-modulation concept: full-disk solar imaging with pixel-level control is clearly shown. The lab detection of the 60 Hz flicker is a useful practical characterization for anyone repurposing HEP DMDs. The paper's explicit acknowledgment of the untested ON-state science path is a strength; the claims are mostly scoped to spatial modulation. The main weakness is that the fiber-fed spectrograph channel—central to the instrument's stated science goals—remains entirely unvalidated, and the flicker amplitude is not quantified. For a preliminary proceedings paper, this is acceptable if the framing is carefully limited.
major comments (3)
- [Sec. 3, Fig. 3] The amplitude of the 60 Hz flicker is not quantified. The y-axis is 'Fractional Current' with no absolute scale or stated peak-to-peak modulation. Since this flicker affects the ON-state science path and the paper presents it as a key discovery, please report the modulation depth (e.g., percent), the DC level, and ideally a power spectrum or a comparison with the direct-light bypass path to confirm it is not a setup artifact.
- [Sec. 4 / Sec. 5] The ON-state science path is not tested. Sec. 4 states the spectrometer-channel imaging optics are 'currently under optimization', and Sec. 5 confirms only the imaging channel was populated on sky. Thus the feasibility of efficiently coupling the ON-state beam into an integrating sphere and fiber-fed EPRV spectrograph—a core requirement for the stated science goals—remains unvalidated. Please either add a laboratory throughput/stability measurement of this path or explicitly limit the paper's central claim to spatial modulation, with a prominent statement that the spectrograph function is a future design goal, not a demonstrated capability.
- [Sec. 5, Fig. 7] The horizontal banding in Fig. 7 is attributed to the 60 Hz reset sequence, but the text says 'likely' and proposes a future test. Because banding could also arise from camera readout or other electronics, please provide direct evidence for this attribution (e.g., images at exposure times that are integer multiples or half-integers of the 60 Hz period, or a time series of a static DMD state) or clearly separate the banding observation from the lab flicker measurement.
minor comments (5)
- [Abstract] Typo: 'an new experimental platform' should be 'a new experimental platform'.
- [Sec. 2.2] Heading 'T ransmission' contains an unintended space; should be 'Transmission'.
- [Sec. 3, Fig. 4] Clarify that the NIR-coating curve is a hypothetical configuration and state the assumed window transmission values; the current simulation depends on an unstated coating model.
- [Sec. 2.1] The abbreviation 'EPR V' with a space appears in several places; use 'EPRV' consistently.
- [Sec. 2.3] The term 'pond of mirrors' is introduced without a definition; a brief parenthetical explanation would help readers unfamiliar with DMD terminology.
Circularity Check
No circular derivation: the prototype imaging and flicker measurements are self-contained; the only self-citation (Robles & Mahadevan 2026) is minor and not load-bearing for the paper's central claim.
full rationale
The paper's central empirical claim is that a COTS prototype can image the Sun and produce dynamic, patterned masks on the solar disk with a DMD. That claim rests on direct images (Fig. 7a, 7b) and is not derived from any fitted parameter, self-citation, or definitional identity. The 60 Hz flicker finding is also an independent measurement: the paper describes a new high-speed photodiode/Moku:Pro setup that records photocurrent at 10 kHz, and the phase-folded data show two offset 60 Hz reset signals. This is used to explain the earlier 250:1 contrast value from Robles & Mahadevan (2026), not to predict it. The only self-citation is to Robles & Mahadevan (2026), invoked for (1) the previously reported contrast, (2) diffraction-efficiency input to a simulated NIR window comparison, and (3) 'expected performance' of the DMD spectrograph channel. These are external prior results, not equations in this paper that reduce to themselves. The paper explicitly acknowledges the spectrographic performance 'has yet to be tested on-sky' and that the ON-state coupling optics are 'currently under optimization,' so the unvalidated science path is a technical risk, not a circular step. No fitted input is relabeled as a prediction, no uniqueness theorem is imported from the authors' prior work, and no known result is renamed as new. The self-citation is minor and non-load-bearing: the demonstrated prototype validates spatial modulation, which is independent of the simulated efficiency curves. Score 2 reflects that minor self-citation, not any circular derivation.
Assumptions & free parameters
assumptions (3)
- domain assumption The solar angular diameter is approximately 1900 arcsec, requiring a field of view of at least 2375 arcsec.
- ad hoc to paper The observed 60 Hz flicker originates from the TI evaluation board's reset sequence rather than from the DMD itself.
- domain assumption The DMD can withstand solar illumination below 40 W/cm2 thermal load.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of MiraSOL: a DMD-based spectrograph for resolved solar spectroscopy." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/VIECQURL
@misc{pith2026260801493,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: MiraSOL: a DMD-based spectrograph for resolved solar spectroscopy},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/VIECQURL}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2608.01493}
}
read the original abstract
We present the science motivation, preliminary design requirements, device laboratory testing and a prototype for an new experimental platform for solar observations, MiraSOL. MiraSOL will use digital micromirror technology to actively select regions on the solar disk for spectroscopic observation to determine the spatially dependent radial velocity signatures of stellar variability, and can create transits on the solar disk to probe the effects of stellar contamination on exoplanet transmission spectra. MiraSOL uses the Texas Instruments DLP801RE as a spatial light modulator to allow a mask, with 3 arcsecond spatial sampling per micromirror, capable of resolving features on the solar disk. This instrument will have a fiber output which can then be coupled with state-of-the-art extreme precision radial velocity (EPRV) spectrometers, such as HPF or NEID, for high resolving power, stable spectra of sunspots and plage, or a low resolution spectrometer for studies of stellar contamination in transit spectra. We discuss a 60 Hz flicker signal we discovered, likely due to the commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) evaluation board of the digital micromirror device electronics. We also build a proof-of-concept prototype and demonstrate imaging and pixel-level control of the full solar disk to demonstrate the feasibility of this technology.
Figures
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, [Pathways to Discovery in Astronomy and Astrophysics for the 2020s], The National Academies Press, Washington, DC (2021)
work page 2021
-
[2]
Design of NEID, an extreme precision Doppler spectrograph for WIYN,
Schwab, C., Rakich, A., Gong, Q., Mahadevan, S., Halverson, S. P., Roy, A., Terrien, R. C., Robertson, P. M., Hearty, F. R., Levi, E. I., Monson, A. J., Wright, J. T., McElwain, M. W., Bender, C. F., Blake, C. H., St¨ urmer, J., Gurevich, Y. V., Chakraborty, A., and Ramsey, L. W., “Design of NEID, an extreme precision Doppler spectrograph for WIYN,” in [G...
work page 2016
-
[3]
ESPRESSO at VLT. On-sky performance and first results,
Pepe, F., Cristiani, S., Rebolo, R., Santos, N. C., Dekker, H., Cabral, A., Di Marcantonio, P., Figueira, P., Lo Curto, G., Lovis, C., Mayor, M., M´ egevand, D., Molaro, P., Riva, M., Zapatero Osorio, M. R., Amate, M., Manescau, A., Pasquini, L., Zerbi, F. M., Adibekyan, V., Abreu, M., Affolter, M., Alibert, Y., Aliverti, M., Allart, R., Allende Prieto, C...
work page 2021
-
[4]
Burt, J. A., Dumusque, X., and Halverson, S., “Precise Radial Velocities,”arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2511.01954 (Nov. 2025)
arXiv 2025
-
[5]
Extreme Precision Radial Velocity Working Group Final Report,
Crass, J., Gaudi, B. S., Leifer, S., Beichman, C., Bender, C., Blackwood, G., Burt, J. A., Callas, J. L., Cegla, H. M., Diddams, S. A., Dumusque, X., Eastman, J. D., Ford, E. B., Fulton, B., Gibson, R., Halverson, S., Haywood, R. D., Hearty, F., Howard, A. W., Latham, D. W., L¨ ohner-B¨ ottcher, J., Mamajek, E. E., Mortier, A., Newman, P., Plavchan, P., Q...
arXiv 2021
-
[6]
Ford, E. B., Bender, C. F., Blake, C. H., Gupta, A. F., Kanodia, S., Lin, A. S. J., Logsdon, S. E., Luhn, J. K., Mahadevan, S., Palumbo, Michael L., I., Terrien, R. C., Wright, J. T., Zhao, J., Halverson, S., Hunting, E., Robertson, P., Roy, A., and Stefansson, G., “Earths within Reach: Evaluation of Strategies for Mitigating Solar Variability using 3.5 y...
arXiv 2024
-
[7]
Zhao, L. L., Dumusque, X., Ford, E. B., Llama, J., Mortier, A., Bedell, M., Al Moulla, K., Bender, C. F., Blake, C. H., Brewer, J. M., Collier Cameron, A., Cosentino, R., Figueira, P., Fischer, D. A., Ghedina, A., Gonzalez, M., Halverson, S., Kanodia, S., Latham, D. W., Lin, A. S. J., Lo Curto, G., Lodi, M., Logsdon, S. E., Lovis, C., Mahadevan, S., Monso...
work page 2023
-
[8]
PoET: the Paranal solar ESPRESSO Telescope,
Santos, N. C., Cabral, A., Leite, I., Smette, A., Abreu, M., Alves, D., Martins, J. H. C., Monteiro, M., Silva, A., Wehbe, B., Arancibia, J., ´Avila, G., Brillant, S., C´ ardenas, C., Clara, R., Gafeira, R., Gaytan, D., Lovis, C., Miranda, N., Moreno, P., Oliveira, A., Otarola, A., Pepe, F., Rojas, P., Schmutzer, R., Sosnowska, D., van der Heyden, P., Al ...
arXiv 2025
Show all 30 references
-
[9]
ABO- RAS: polarimetric, 10cm/s R V observations of the Sun as a star,
Farret Jentink, C., Mortier, A., Snik, F., Dorval, P., Thompson, S. J., Navarro, R., and Naylor, T., “ABO- RAS: polarimetric, 10cm/s R V observations of the Sun as a star,” in [Ground-based and Airborne Telescopes IX], Marshall, H. K., Spyromilio, J., and Usuda, T., eds.,Socie...
2022
-
[10]
Observing the integrated and spatially resolved Sun with ultra-high spectral resolution,
Sch¨ afer, S., Royen, K., Zapke, A. H., Ellwarth, M., and Reiners, A., “Observing the integrated and spatially resolved Sun with ultra-high spectral resolution,” in [Ground-based and Airborne Instrumentation for As- tronomy VIII], Evans, C. J., Bryant, J. J., and Motohara, K.,...
2020
-
[11]
On the detection of an effect of rotation during eclipse in the velocity of the brighter component of beta Lyrae, and on the constancy of velocity of this system.,
Rossiter, R. A., “On the detection of an effect of rotation during eclipse in the velocity of the brighter component of beta Lyrae, and on the constancy of velocity of this system.,”The Astrophysical Journal60, 15–21 (July 1924)
1924
-
[12]
Some results of a spectrographic study of the Algol system.,
McLaughlin, D. B., “Some results of a spectrographic study of the Algol system.,”The Astrophysical Journal60, 22–31 (July 1924)
1924
-
[13]
Radial velocity observations of the 2015 Mar. 20 eclipse. A benchmark Rossiter-McLaughlin curve with zero free parameters,
Reiners, A., Lemke, U., Bauer, F., Beeck, B., and Huke, P., “Radial velocity observations of the 2015 Mar. 20 eclipse. A benchmark Rossiter-McLaughlin curve with zero free parameters,”Astronomy & Astro- physics595, A26 (Oct. 2016)
2015
-
[14]
SOAPv4: A new step toward modeling stellar signatures in exoplanet research,
Cristo, E., Faria, J. P., Santos, N. C., Dethier, W., Akinsanmi, B., Barka, A., Demangeon, O., Lucero, J. P., and Silva, A. M., “SOAPv4: A new step toward modeling stellar signatures in exoplanet research,” Astronomy & Astrophysics702, A84 (Oct. 2025)
2025
-
[15]
Modelling solar radial velocities and photometric variability with SOAP,
Barka, A., Cristo, E., Santos, ˆA. R. G., Santos, N. C., Al Moulla, K., Barata, T., Gafeira, R., and Cretig- nier, M., “Modelling solar radial velocities and photometric variability with SOAP,”Astronomy & Astro- physics707, A265 (Mar. 2026)
2026
-
[16]
The Transit Light Source Effect. II. The Impact of Stellar Heterogeneity on Transmission Spectra of Planets Orbiting Broadly Sun-like Stars,
Rackham, B. V., Apai, D., and Giampapa, M. S., “The Transit Light Source Effect. II. The Impact of Stellar Heterogeneity on Transmission Spectra of Planets Orbiting Broadly Sun-like Stars,”The Astrophysical Journal157, 96 (Mar. 2019)
2019
-
[17]
The habitable-zone planet finder: a stabilized fiber-fed NIR spectrograph for the Hobby-Eberly Telescope,
Mahadevan, S., Ramsey, L., Bender, C., Terrien, R., Wright, J. T., Halverson, S., Hearty, F., Nelson, M., Burton, A., Redman, S., Osterman, S., Diddams, S., Kasting, J., Endl, M., and Deshpande, R., “The habitable-zone planet finder: a stabilized fiber-fed NIR spectrograph for...
2012
-
[18]
EXPRES: a next generation R V spectrograph in the search for earth-like worlds,
Jurgenson, C., Fischer, D., McCracken, T., Sawyer, D., Szymkowiak, A., Davis, A., Muller, G., and Santoro, F., “EXPRES: a next generation R V spectrograph in the search for earth-like worlds,” in [Ground-based and Airborne Instrumentation for Astronomy VI], Evans, C. J., Simar...
2016
-
[19]
The Impact of Stellar Surface Magnetoconvection and Oscillations on the Detection of Temperate, Earth-Mass Planets Around Sun-Like Stars,
Cegla, H. M., “The Impact of Stellar Surface Magnetoconvection and Oscillations on the Detection of Temperate, Earth-Mass Planets Around Sun-Like Stars,”Geosciences9, 114 (Mar. 2019)
2019
-
[20]
The Third Signature of Stellar Granulation,
Gray, D. F., “The Third Signature of Stellar Granulation,”The Astrophysical Journal697, 1032–1043 (June 2009)
2009
-
[21]
Characterizing Solar Center-to-limb Radial-velocity Variability with SDO,
Palumbo, M. L., Saar, S. H., and Haywood, R. D., “Characterizing Solar Center-to-limb Radial-velocity Variability with SDO,”The Astrophysical Journal973, 11 (Sept. 2024)
2024
-
[22]
The Sun as a planet- host star: proxies from SDO images for HARPS radial-velocity variations,
Haywood, R. D., Collier Cameron, A., Unruh, Y. C., Lovis, C., Lanza, A. F., Llama, J., Deleuil, M., Fares, R., Gillon, M., Moutou, C., Pepe, F., Pollacco, D., Queloz, D., and S´ egransan, D., “The Sun as a planet- host star: proxies from SDO images for HARPS radial-velocity va...
2016
-
[23]
Observing the sun as a star: Design and early results from the neid solar feed,
Lin, A. S. J., Monson, A., Mahadevan, S., Ninan, J. P., Halverson, S., Nitroy, C., Bender, C. F., Logsdon, S. E., Kanodia, S., Terrien, R. C., Roy, A., Luhn, J. K., Gupta, A. F., Ford, E. B., Hearty, F., Laher, R. R., Hunting, E., McBride, W. R., Salazar Rivera, N. I., Rajagop...
2022
-
[24]
Three years of HARPS-N high-resolution spectroscopy and precise radial velocity data for the Sun,
Dumusque, X., Cretignier, M., Sosnowska, D., Buchschacher, N., Lovis, C., Phillips, D. F., Pepe, F., Alesina, F., Buchhave, L. A., Burnier, J., Cecconi, M., Cegla, H. M., Cloutier, R., Collier Cameron, A., Cosentino, R., Ghedina, A., Gonz´ alez, M., Haywood, R. D., Latham, D. ...
2021
-
[25]
An Extremely Low-density Exoplanet Spins Slow,
Liu, Q., Zhu, W., Masuda, K., Libby-Roberts, J. E., Bello-Arufe, A., and Ca˜ nas, C. I., “An Extremely Low-density Exoplanet Spins Slow,”The Astrophysical Journal Letters976, L14 (Nov. 2024)
2024
-
[26]
A General, Differentiable Transit Model for Ellipsoidal Occulters: Derivation, Application, and Forecast of Planetary Oblateness and Obliquity Constraints with JWST,
Dholakia, S., Dholakia, S., and Pope, B. J. S., “A General, Differentiable Transit Model for Ellipsoidal Occulters: Derivation, Application, and Forecast of Planetary Oblateness and Obliquity Constraints with JWST,”arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2410.03449 (Oct. 2024)
2024 arXiv
-
[27]
Slow Rotation for the Super-Puff Planet Kepler-51d,
Lammers, C. and Winn, J. N., “Slow Rotation for the Super-Puff Planet Kepler-51d,”arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2409.06697 (Sept. 2024)
2024 arXiv
-
[28]
The opto-mechanical design of SAMOS: a DMD-based spectrograph for the SOAR telescope,
Smee, S. A., Barkhouser, R., Harding, A., Hope, S., Robberto, M., Ninkov, Z., and Gennaro, M., “The opto-mechanical design of SAMOS: a DMD-based spectrograph for the SOAR telescope,” in [Ground-based and Airborne Instrumentation for Astronomy VII], Evans, C. J., Simard, L., an...
2018
-
[29]
The HEP DMD: a new DLP pixel optimized for performance,
Dewa, A. S., Ferri, J., McDonald, B., Martinez, J., and Dickerson, K., “The HEP DMD: a new DLP pixel optimized for performance,” in [Emerging Digital Micromirror Device Based Systems and Applications XVI], Ehmke, J. and Lee, B. L., eds.,Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation...
2024
-
[30]
HEP digital micromirror devices for precision solar spectroscopy,
Robles, C. and Mahadevan, S., “HEP digital micromirror devices for precision solar spectroscopy,”arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2601.23176 (Jan. 2026). 11
2026 arXiv
Reviewed August 6, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.