REVIEW 3 major objections 4 minor 37 references
Resolving High-Energy States of Interlayer Excitons in MoSe$_2$/WSe$_2$ Heterostructures
T0 review · 3 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-04 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read Photoluminescence excitation spectroscopy resolves a Rydberg-like series of excited interlayer exciton states in MoSe2/WSe2 heterostructures.
desk verdict Novel PLE experiment, but the reported IX2/IX3/IX4 spacings increase with n, contradicting the central Rydberg assignment. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central experimental tool is photoluminescence excitation (PLE) spectroscopy, where the integrated intensity of the ground-state IX emission is recorded as the excitation laser is tuned across the high-energy region. The central theoretical tool is a Wannier-exciton model based on an effective Bethe-Salpeter equation with parabolic bands and a screened Coulomb potential, solved on a 2D k-grid; this model produces a calculated Rydberg-like IX series (1s, 2s, 3s, 4s) with momentum-space wavefunctions shown in the paper. The PLE resonances are the load-bearing observable, and the Wannier-exciton calculation supplies the labeling of the peaks.
What would settle it
Measure the PLE spectrum while detecting emission from a different recombination channel (e.g., a trion or a localized state) or perform linear absorption spectroscopy (reflection contrast) on the same high-quality sample with enhanced sensitivity; if the PLE 'resonances' shift or disappear when the detection energy changes, or if reflection contrast shows no corresponding absorption features at those energies, the one-to-one absorption interpretation would be falsified.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The core claim is that PLE spectroscopy resolves a Rydberg-like series of excited interlayer exciton states in MoSe2/WSe2 heterostructures. The authors observe multiple PLE resonances below the intralayer exciton energies, which they assign to the 2s-, 3s-, and 4s-like states of the interlayer exciton (denoted IX2, IX3, IX4). These resonances are found in three heterostructures with different twist angles (1°, 14°, 56°), indicating that the excited-state spectrum is only weakly affected by twist angle, in contrast to the ground-state IX energy. Wannier-exciton calculations incorporating screened Coulomb interactions reproduce the overall energy scale and qualitative trends of the measured se
Load-bearing premise
The assignment of the weak PLE features to specific 2s, 3s, and 4s interlayer exciton states presumes that each PLE enhancement peak corresponds one-to-one to an interlayer exciton absorption resonance, an assumption the paper does not directly calibrate for these states.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- If correct, PLE spectroscopy becomes a routine direct probe of the high-energy interlayer exciton spectrum, complementing reflection contrast which cannot resolve these weak states.
- The near-independence of the excited-state ladder from twist angle implies that dielectric screening, disorder, and hybridization with intralayer excitons dominate over moiré potential effects in setting the high-energy IX state energies.
- The non-hydrogenic spacing of the series (deviating from 1/n²) provides a quantitative constraint on the screened Coulomb interaction and dielectric environment of the heterostructure.
- The strong calculated sensitivity to dielectric screening suggests that encapsulating or suspending the heterostructure can tune the entire Rydberg ladder, offering a design knob for experiments.
- The demonstration that PLE resonances can be offset from absorption resonances (shown for intralayer excitons) implies that PLE-based energy assignments for interlayer states should be calibrated against a direct absorption measurement when possible.
Reading between the lines
- An implicit corollary is that the same PLE approach could resolve excited states of interlayer excitons in other TMDC heterobilayers (e.g., MoS2/WSe2 or MoSe2/WS2), provided the intralayer exciton is higher in energy than the interlayer Rydberg series.
- A testable extension would be to measure PLE on samples with a continuous range of twist angles, especially near small angles where moiré reconstruction is strongest, to see whether the claimed twist-angle robustness survives in the moiré-localized regime.
- The paper's logic suggests that the observed PLE modulations might also arise from phonon-assisted absorption or continuum-edge effects rather than bound 2s/3s/4s states; a decisive check would be comparing PLE spectra with two-photon absorption or nonlinear spectroscopy that directly probes even-parity exciton states.
- If the assignment holds, the excited IX states could serve as sensitive local probes of dielectric disorder, since their large Bohr radii make them more affected by spatial variations in screening than the 1s state.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper reports photoluminescence excitation (PLE) measurements on MoSe2/WSe2 heterostructures with twist angles of 1°, 14°, and 56°, claiming to resolve a Rydberg-like series of excited interlayer exciton states (IX2, IX3, IX4) below the intralayer exciton energies. The states are assigned to the 2s, 3s, and 4s excitons by comparison with Wannier-exciton calculations that incorporate screened Coulomb interactions and dielectric environment effects. The authors argue that the excited-state ladder is robust against twist-angle variation, and that PLE provides direct experimental access to these high-energy interlayer exciton states.
Significance. If the assignment is correct, the paper would provide a new experimental window onto excited interlayer exciton states, which have been difficult to access experimentally due to weak oscillator strength. The use of PLE rather than reflection contrast is a sensible strategy, and the comparison of three twist angles is a strength. The Wannier-exciton calculations are based on parameters from earlier literature (Refs. [33,34]) and are not fitted to the IX2–IX4 data, so the theoretical predictions are independent to a degree. The manuscript also includes supporting evidence from linewidth and emission-energy modulations in the SI. These elements make the claim potentially important if the assignment withstands scrutiny.
major comments (3)
- [Section IV] The reported IX2/IX3/IX4 energies for the 56° sample are (1.464±0.002) eV, (1.523±0.002) eV, and (1.601±0.001) eV. The successive spacings are E3−E2 = 59 meV and E4−E3 = 78 meV, i.e., the spacing increases with n. This contradicts the very next sentence in the same paragraph ('As expected for a Rydberg-like series, the spacing between successive states decreases with increasing principal quantum number') and also contradicts all models invoked in the paper, including the 2D-hydrogenic and Wannier ladders. If these numbers are accurate, the n=2,3,4 assignment is internally inconsistent. If they are a typo or a fitting artifact, the assignment must be rederived from the raw data before the central claim can be evaluated. This is load-bearing and cannot be left as is.
- [Section III] The paper documents that PLE resonance energies are offset from absorption energies by 43 meV (XWSe2) and 15 meV (XMoSe2), and states that PLE resonances need not coincide with absorption resonances. Nevertheless, the assignment of IX2/IX3/IX4 relies on 'excellent agreement' between the measured PLE energies and the calculated absorption spectrum (Fig. 1d). Since the PLE offset for interlayer states is unconstrained and could be tens of meV, the absolute-energy comparison is not a valid test. The analysis should either use the energy separations between excited states and the ground state, which are insensitive to a common offset, or independently calibrate the PLE offset for interlayer excitons.
- [Methods B and Figure 3] The PLE resonances used to extract IX2/IX3/IX4 are weak modulations on a log-scale after subtraction of an exponentially decaying baseline (Fig. 3b). The manuscript does not report the uncertainty in the baseline model or the statistical significance of the fitted Gaussians. Given that the resonances are weak and are the sole experimental evidence for the central claim, the paper should present quantitative measures of fit robustness (e.g., residuals, confidence intervals, or replicate measurements) to rule out baseline-fitting artifacts. The linewidth modulations in SI Fig. S2 are qualitative and do not by themselves establish the peak energies.
minor comments (4)
- [Throughout] There are numerous typos and proofreading errors: 'assembaly', 'continues wave', 'on the the MoSe2', 'wavlength', 'close-cycle cryostat', 'Manthai' in the SI author list, and '3H type stacking' in SI. These should be corrected.
- [Figure 2 caption and text] The caption describes panel (d) as showing 'two additional PLE resonances corresponding to IX2, IX3 and IX4'—the wording is inconsistent (two vs three). Please clarify.
- [SI Fig. S2] The energy axis in SI Fig. S2(a) appears mislabeled: the values 1.3225–1.3375 eV are far below the XWSe2/XMoSe2 range discussed in the caption. Check the axis units.
- [Methods C] The choice of Lorentzian broadening parameters Γ1=1.5 meV and Γ2=Γ3=20 meV is stated but not justified. A brief explanation or reference would help the reader assess the calculated spectra.
Circularity Check
No significant circularity: the Wannier-exciton comparison is an independent forward calculation with externally sourced parameters, not a fit of the PLE data.
full rationale
The central derivation is not circular. PLE peaks are extracted by multi-Gaussian fitting (Section III); the theoretical Wannier-exciton ladder is computed in Methods C from parameters explicitly taken from Ref. [33] (effective masses, dielectric constants, layer thicknesses) and band-gap reductions attributed to Ref. [34] (140 meV for air/SiO2, 230 meV for hBN/hBN). These parameters are not determined by the IX2-4 PLE data; no equation in the paper fits the model to the measured peak positions or renames a fitted parameter as a prediction. The assignment of the resonances to 2s/3s/4s states is a labeling based on comparison to this independent forward calculation, not a derivation from the calculation's outputs. Self-citations (Refs [4,7,10,20]) are contextual or ancillary (e.g., prior reports of IX energies, twist-angle tuning, relaxation/energy-transfer processes); none is load-bearing for the Rydberg-series claim. The paper itself flags a limitation in Section III: PLE resonances of XWSe2 and XMoSe2 are red-shifted by 43 and 15 meV from reflection-contrast absorption, and 'PLE resonances do not necessarily coincide with the corresponding absorption resonances'; this weakens direct energy comparison but is not a circular reduction. Section IV contains an internal tension: the 56° values (1.464, 1.523, 1.601 eV) give successive spacings of 59 and 78 meV, while the text says 'as expected for a Rydberg-like series, the spacing between successive states decreases with increasing principal quantum number.' That is a correctness problem for the assignment, not circularity. Because the theoretical support is a real forward prediction with external inputs, the circularity score is 0.
Assumptions & free parameters
free parameters (3)
- Band-gap reduction from dielectric screening (air/SiO2) =
140 meV
- Band-gap reduction from dielectric screening (hBN/hBN) =
230 meV
- Lorentzian broadening parameters =
Gamma1 = 1.5 meV, Gamma2 = Gamma3 = 20 meV, E0 = 20 meV
assumptions (4)
- domain assumption The effective BSE with parabolic bands and screened Coulomb potentials (Refs [31,32]) correctly describes the spectrum of high-energy interlayer excitons in MoSe2/WSe2.
- domain assumption Electronic structure parameters (effective masses, dielectric constants, layer thicknesses, band gaps) from Ref [33] are valid for the fabricated samples.
- domain assumption The dielectric environment of the measured samples is well modeled by the air/SiO2 configuration with a 140 meV band-gap reduction.
- domain assumption PLE intensity modulations below XMoSe2 originate from optical absorption into IX excited states that subsequently relax to IX1.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Resolving High-Energy States of Interlayer Excitons in MoSe$_2$/WSe$_2$ Heterostructures." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/FTHOVLTQ
@misc{pith2026260802040,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Resolving High-Energy States of Interlayer Excitons in MoSe$_2$/WSe$_2$ Heterostructures},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/FTHOVLTQ}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2608.02040}
}
abstract
High-energy states of interlayer excitons (IXs) in van der Waals heterostructures remain largely unexplored despite their importance for understanding many-body interactions and nonlinear optical phenomena. Here, we use photoluminescence excitation (PLE) spectroscopy to resolve a Rydberg-like series of excited IX states in MoSe$_2$/WSe$_2$ heterostructures. We observe multiple PLE resonances below the intralayer exciton energies, which we assign to the 2s-, 3s-, and 4s-like states of the IXs. These resonances are consistently observed across heterostructures with different twist angles, indicating that the high-energy state spectrum is only weakly affected by the twist angle. Wannier-exciton calculations incorporating screened Coulomb interactions reproduce the overall energy scale and qualitative trends of the measured Rydberg-like series, supporting the assignment of the observed resonances. Our findings demonstrate that PLE provides direct experimental access to the previously unexplored high-energy IX states in van der Waals heterostructures.
Figures
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Rivera, J
P. Rivera, J. R. Schaibley, A. M. Jones, J. S. Ross, S. Wu, G. Aivazian, P. Klement, K. Seyler, G. Clark, N. J. Ghimire, J. Yan, D. G. Mandrus, W. Yao, and X. Xu, Observation of long-lived interlayer excitons in monolayer mose2–wse2 heterostructures, Nature Communications6, 6242 (2015)
2015
-
[2]
P. K. Nayak, Y. Horbatenko, S. Ahn, G. Kim, J.-U. Lee, K. Y. Ma, A.-R. Jang, H. Lim, D. Kim, S. Ryu, H. Cheong, N. Park, and H. S. Shin, Probing evolution of twist-angle-dependent interlayer excitons in mose2 /wse2 van der waals heterostructures (supporting information), ACS Nano11, 4041 (2017)
2017
-
[3]
Jiang, S
Y. Jiang, S. Chen, W. Zheng, B. Zheng, and A. Pan, Interlayer exciton formation, relaxation, and transport in tmd van der waals heterostructures, Light: Science & Applications10, 1 (2021)
2021
-
[4]
B. L. Rosa, P. E. F. Junior, A. R. Cadore, Y. Yang, A. Koulas-Simos, C. C. Palekar, S. A. Tongay, J. Fabian, and S. Reitzenstein, Electrical manipulation of interval- ley trions in twisted mose 2 homobilayers at room tem- perature, Advanced Physics Research , 2400135 (2025)
2025
-
[5]
Rivera, H
P. Rivera, H. Yu, K. L. Seyler, N. P. Wilson, W. Yao, and X. Xu, Interlayer valley excitons in heterobilayers of transition metal dichalcogenides, Nature Nanotechnology 13, 1004 (2018)
2018
-
[6]
L. A. Jauregui, A. Y. Joe, K. Pistunova, D. S. Wild, A. A. High, Y. Zhou, G. Scuri, K. De Greve, A. Sushko, C.-H. Yu,et al., Electrical control of interlayer exciton dynam- ics in atomically thin heterostructures, Science366, 870 (2019)
2019
-
[7]
P. E. Faria Junior and J. Fabian, Signatures of elec- tric field and layer separation effects on the spin- valley physics of MoSe 2/WSe2 heterobilayers: From en- ergy bands to dipolar excitons, Nanomaterials13, 1187 (2023)
2023
-
[8]
H. Yu, G. B. Liu, J. Tang, X. Xu, and W. Yao, Moir´ e excitons: From programmable quantum emitter arrays to spin-orbit–coupled artificial lattices, Science Advances3, DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.1701696 (2017)
Show all 37 references
-
[9]
K. Tran, G. Moody, F. Wu, X. Lu, J. Choi, K. Kim, A. Rai, D. A. Sanchez, J. Quan, A. Singh, J. Emb- ley, A. Zepeda, M. Campbell, T. Autry, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, N. Lu, S. K. Banerjee, K. L. Silverman, S. Kim, E. Tutuc, L. Yang, A. H. MacDonald, and X. Li, Evidence for moi...
2019
-
[10]
C. C. Palekar, J. Hagel, B. Rosa, S. Brem, C. W. Shih, I. Limame, M. von Helversen, S. Tongay, E. Malic, and S. Reitzenstein, Anomalous redshift in interlayer exciton emission with increasing twist angle in wse 2/mose2 het- 8 erostructures, 2D Materials11, 025034 (2024)
2024
-
[11]
K. L. Seyler, P. Rivera, H. Yu, N. P. Wilson, E. L. Ray, D. G. Mandrus, J. Yan, W. Yao, and X. Xu, Signatures of moir´ e−trapped valley excitons in MoSe2/WSe2 heter- obilayers, Nature567, 66 (2019)
2019
-
[12]
S. Brem, C. Linder¨ alv, P. Erhart, and E. Malic, Tunable phases of moir´ e excitons in van der waals heterostruc- tures, Nano Letters20, 8534 (2020)
2020
-
[13]
K. F. Mak, C. Lee, J. Hone, J. Shan, and T. F. Heinz, Atomically thin mos 2: A new direct-gap semiconductor, Physical Review Letters105, 136805 (2010)
2010
-
[14]
G. Wang, A. Chernikov, M. M. Glazov, T. F. Heinz, X. Marie, T. Amand, and B. Urbaszek, Colloquium : Excitons in atomically thin transition metal dichalco- genides, Reviews of Modern Physics90, 021001 (2018)
2018
-
[15]
Chernikov, T
A. Chernikov, T. C. Berkelbach, H. M. Hill, A. Rigosi, Y. Li, O. B. Aslan, D. R. Reichman, M. S. Hybertsen, and T. F. Heinz, Exciton binding energy and nonhydrogenic rydberg series in monolayer ws2, Physical Review Letters 113, 076802 (2014)
2014
-
[16]
Barr´ e, O
E. Barr´ e, O. Karni, E. Liu, A. L. O’Beirne, X. Chen, H. B. Ribeiro, L. Yu, B. Kim, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi, K. Barmak, C. H. Lui, S. Refaely- Abramson, F. H. da Jornada, and T. F. Heinz, Opti- cal absorption of interlayer excitons in transition-metal dichalcogenide heteros...
2022
-
[17]
K. S. Novoselov, A. K. Geim, S. V. Morozov, D. Jiang, Y. Zhang, S. V. Dubonos, I. V. Grigorieva, and A. A. Firsov, Electric field in atomically thin carbon films, Sci- ence306, 666 (2004)
2004
-
[18]
Castellanos-Gomez, M
A. Castellanos-Gomez, M. Buscema, R. Molenaar, V. Singh, L. Janssen, H. S. J. van der Zant, and G. A. Steele, Deterministic transfer of two-dimensional mate- rials by all-dry viscoelastic stamping, 2D Materials1, 011002 (2014)
2014
-
[19]
A. T. Hanbicki, H.-J. Chuang, M. R. Rosenberger, C. S. Hellberg, S. V. Sivaram, K. M. McCreary, I. I. Mazin, and B. T. Jonker, Double indirect interlayer exciton in a mose2 /wse2 van der waals heterostructure, ACS Nano 12, 4719 (2018)
2018
-
[20]
C. C. Palekar, P. E. F. Junior, B. Rosa, F. B. Sousa, L. M. Malard, J. Fabian, and S. Reitzenstein, Amplification of interlayer exciton emission in twisted wse 2/wse2/mose2 heterotrilayers, npj 2D Materials and Applications8, 49 (2024)
2024
-
[21]
H. Fang, B. Han, C. Robert, M. Semina, D. Lagarde, E. Courtade, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, T. Amand, B. Urbaszek,et al., Control of the exciton radiative life- time in van der waals heterostructures, Physical Review Letters123, 067401 (2019)
2019
-
[22]
H. M. Hill, A. F. Rigosi, C. Roquelet, A. Chernikov, T. C. Berkelbach, D. R. Reichman, M. S. Hybertsen, L. E. Brus, and T. F. Heinz, Observation of excitonic rydberg states in monolayer mos 2 and ws2 by photoluminescence excitation spectroscopy, Nano Letters15, 2992 (2015)
2015
-
[23]
W. Li, X. Lu, S. Dubey, L. Devenica, and A. Srivastava, Dipolar interactions between localized interlayer excitons in van der waals heterostructures, Nature Materials19, 624 (2020)
2020
-
[24]
Michl, C
J. Michl, C. C. Palekar, S. A. Tarasenko, F. Lo- hof, C. Gies, M. von Helversen, R. Sailus, S. Ton- gay, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, T. Heindel, B. Rosa, M. R¨ odel, T. Shubina, S. H¨ ofling, S. Reitzenstein, C. Anton-Solanas, and C. Schneider, Intrinsic circularly polarized ex...
2022
-
[25]
J. Choi, M. Florian, A. Steinhoff, D. Erben, K. Tran, D. S. Kim, L. Sun, J. Quan, R. Claassen, S. Ma- jumder, J. A. Hollingsworth, T. Taniguchi, K. Watan- abe, K. Ueno, A. Singh, G. Moody, F. Jahnke, and X. Li, Twist angle-dependent interlayer exciton lifetimes in van der waal...
2021
-
[26]
Biswas, A
S. Biswas, A. Champagne, J. B. Haber, S. Pokawan- vit, J. Wong, H. Akbari, S. Krylyuk, K. Watanabe, T. Taniguchi, A. V. Davydov,et al., Rydberg excitons and trions in monolayer mote 2, ACS nano17, 7685 (2023)
2023
-
[27]
A. Raja, L. Waldecker, J. Zipfel, Y. Cho, S. Brem, J. D. Ziegler, M. Kulig, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, E. Malic, T. F. Heinz, T. C. Berkelbach, and A. Chernikov, Dielec- tric disorder in two-dimensional materials, Nature Nan- otechnology14, 832–837 (2019)
2019
-
[28]
Plankl, P
M. Plankl, P. E. Faria Junior, F. Mooshammer, T. Si- day, M. Zizlsperger, F. Sandner, F. Schiegl, S. Maier, M. A. Huber, M. Gmitra, J. Fabian, J. L. Boland, T. L. Cocker, and R. Huber, Subcycle contact-free nanoscopy of ultrafast interlayer transport in atomically thin het- er...
2021
-
[29]
L. M. Malard, T. V. Alencar, A. P. M. Barboza, K. F. Mak, and A. M. de Paula, Observation of intense second harmonic generation from MoS 2 atomic crystals, Phys. Rev. B87, 201401 (2013)
2013
-
[30]
W.-T. Hsu, Z. Zhao, L. Li, C.-H. Chen, M.-H. Chiu, P. Chang, Y.-C. Chou, and W. Chang, Second har- monic generation from artificially stacked transition metal dichalcogenide twisted bilayers., ACS nano8 3, 2951 (2014)
2014
-
[31]
Rohlfing and S
M. Rohlfing and S. G. Louie, Electron-hole excitations and optical spectra from first principles, Physical Review B62, 4927 (2000)
2000
-
[32]
Zollner, P
K. Zollner, P. E. Faria Junior, and J. Fabian, Gi- ant proximity exchange and valley splitting in transi- tion metal dichalcogenide/hBN/(co, ni) heterostructures, Phys. Rev. B101, 085112 (2020)
2020
-
[33]
Ovesen, S
S. Ovesen, S. Brem, C. Linder¨ alv, M. Kuisma, T. Korn, P. Erhart, M. Selig, and E. Malic, Interlayer exciton dy- namics in van der waals heterostructures, Communica- tions Physics2, 10.1038/s42005-019-0122-z (2019)
2019 doi
-
[34]
Gleb Wataghin
Y. Cho and T. C. Berkelbach, Environmentally sensitive theory of electronic and optical transitions in atomically thin semiconductors, Phys. Rev. B97, 041409(R) (2018). Supplementary Information: Resolving High-Energy States of Interlayer Excitons in MoSe2/WSe2 Heterostructure...
2018
-
[35]
W.-T. Hsu, Z. Zhao, L. Li, C.-H. Chen, M.-H. Chiu, P. Chang, Y.-C. Chou, and W. Chang, Second harmonic generation from artificially stacked transition metal dichalcogenide twisted bilayers., ACS nano8 3, 2951 (2014)
2014
-
[36]
L. M. Malard, T. V. Alencar, A. P. M. Barboza, K. F. Mak, and A. M. de Paula, Observation of intense second harmonic generation from mos 2 atomic crystals, Physical Review B87, 201401 (2013)
2013
-
[37]
Michl, C
J. Michl, C. C. Palekar, S. A. Tarasenko, F. Lohof, C. Gies, M. von Helversen, R. Sailus, S. Tongay, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, T. Heindel, B. Rosa, M. R¨ odel, T. Shubina, S. H¨ ofling, S. Reitzenstein, C. Anton-Solanas, and C. Schneider, Intrinsic circularly polarized excito...
2022
Reviewed August 4, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Sign in to comment.