Minimal coarse-grained models for molecular self-organisation in biology
Pith reviewed 2026-05-25 17:59 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
Minimal coarse-grained models can identify the main driving forces of molecular self-organisation in cells.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
Minimal coarse-grained models, where a whole macromolecule is represented by a small number of particles, can be of great value in identifying the main driving forces behind self-organisation in cell biology. Such models can incorporate data from both molecular and continuum scales, and their results can be directly compared to experiments. The review outlines the key ingredients of each model and their main findings to illustrate the contribution of this class of simulations to identifying the physical mechanisms behind life and diseases.
What carries the argument
Minimal coarse-grained models that represent each macromolecule by a small number of particles to isolate dominant interactions driving assembly of cellular structures.
If this is right
- These models identify physical mechanisms that underlie both normal cellular function and disease states.
- They allow data from molecular and larger scales to be combined in one simulation framework.
- Results from the models can be tested directly against experimental observations of assembly.
- Further development of the models will extend their ability to explain self-organisation processes.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The approach could be used to test how specific changes in interaction strengths alter assembly outcomes in disease-related proteins.
- It suggests that similar minimal models might apply to designing artificial molecular assemblies with targeted functions.
- Larger-scale simulations built on these minimal units could reveal how local assembly rules produce cell-wide patterns.
Load-bearing premise
The dominant physical mechanisms of self-organisation can be captured accurately by these minimal representations without extra atomistic details or constraints that would change the conclusions.
What would settle it
An experimental measurement of a self-organising process in which the assembly structures or rates differ from those produced by the minimal model when only its proposed driving forces are included.
Figures
read the original abstract
The molecular machinery of life is largely created via self-organisation of individual molecules into functional assemblies. Minimal coarse-grained models, where a whole macromolecule is represented by a small number of particles, can be of great value in identifying the main driving forces behind self-organisation in cell biology. Such models can incorporate data from both molecular and continuum scales, and their results can be directly compared to experiments. Here we review the state of the art of models for studying the formation and biological function of macromolecular assemblies in cells. We outline the key ingredients of each model and their main findings. We illustrate the contribution of this class of simulations to identifying the physical mechanisms behind life and diseases, and discuss their future developments.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript is a review of minimal coarse-grained models for molecular self-organisation in biology. It claims that representing entire macromolecules by a small number of particles allows these models to identify the main physical driving forces behind self-organisation in cell biology, to incorporate data from both molecular and continuum scales, and to produce results that can be compared directly to experiments. The review outlines the key ingredients and main findings of models for the formation and biological function of macromolecular assemblies, illustrates their contribution to understanding mechanisms in life and disease, and discusses future developments.
Significance. If the summaries of existing models are accurate and balanced, the review would be a useful consolidation of how minimal CG approaches can isolate dominant physical mechanisms in biological self-organisation without requiring full atomistic resolution. The paper explicitly credits the models' multi-scale compatibility and experimental comparability, which are genuine strengths for the biophysics community. The central evaluative claim is general rather than a specific mechanistic prediction, so it carries no internal circularity or derivation burden.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for their positive review of our manuscript and for recommending it for acceptance without raising any major comments.
Circularity Check
No significant circularity
full rationale
The paper is explicitly a review article that summarizes existing minimal coarse-grained models from the literature. It presents no original derivations, equations, predictions, or first-principles results of its own. The central claim is evaluative (that such models can be of value), not a mechanistic derivation that could reduce to its inputs by construction. No self-citations function as load-bearing uniqueness theorems, and no fitted parameters are relabeled as predictions. The review format carries no internal circularity burden.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
C. V. Robinson, A. Sali, W. Baumeister, The molecular sociology of the cell, Nature 450 (7172) (2007) 973–982
work page 2007
-
[2]
P. Bassereau, R. Jin, T. Baumgart, M. Deserno, R. Dimova, V. A. Frolov, P. V. Bashkirov, H. Grub- müller, R. Jahn, H. J. Risselada, L. Johannes, M. M. Kozlov, R. Lipowsky, T. J. Pucadyil, W. F. Zeno, J. C. Stachowiak, D. Stamou, A. Breuer, L. Lauritsen, C. Simon, C. Sykes, G. A. Voth, T. R. Weikl, The 2018 biomembrane curvature and remodeling roadmap, Jou...
work page 2018
-
[3]
C. M. Dobson, T. P. J. Knowles, M. Vendruscolo, The Amyloid Phenomenon and Its Significance in Biology and Medicine., Cold Spring Harbor perspectives in biology (2019) a033878
work page 2019
-
[4]
U. D. Schiller, T. Krüger, O. Henrich, Mesoscopic modelling and simulation of soft matter, Soft Matter 14 (1) (2018) 9–26
work page 2018
-
[5]
A. J. Pak, G. A. Voth, Advances in coarse-grained modeling of macromolecular complexes, Current Opinion in Structural Biology 52 (2018) 119–126
work page 2018
-
[6]
S. J. Marrink, V. Corradi, P. C. Souza, H. I. Ingólfsson, D. P. Tieleman, M. S. Sansom, Computational Modeling of Realistic Cell Membranes, Chemical Reviews 119 (9) (2019) 6184–6226
work page 2019
-
[7]
J. D. Perlmutter, C. Qiao, M. F. Hagan, Viral genome structures are optimal for capsid assembly, eLife 2 (2013) 1–21
work page 2013
- [8]
- [9]
-
[10]
A. Paraschiv, S. Hegde, R. Ganti, T. Pilizota, A. Saric, Dynamic clustering regulates activity of mechanosensitive membrane channels, bioRxiv (2019) 553248 • Coarse-grainedmodeltostudycooperativeactivityofmembranemechanosensitivechan- nels. The authors found that channel aggregation regulates the flux of solutes across the membrane. 15
work page 2019
-
[11]
A. J. Dear, A. Šarić, T. C. T. Michaels, C. M. Dobson, T. P. J. Knowles, Statistical Mechanics of Globular Oligomer Formation by Protein Molecules, The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 122 (49) (2018) 11721–11730
work page 2018
-
[12]
L. K. Davis, I. J. Ford, A. Šarić, B. W. Hoogenboom, Intrinsically disordered nuclear pore proteins show ideal-polymer morphologies and dynamics, bioRxiv (2019) 571687
work page 2019
-
[13]
M. Pannuzzo, Z. A. McDargh, M. Deserno, The role of scaffold reshaping and disassembly in dynamin driven membrane fission, eLife 7 (2018) 1–23 •• Here, coarse-grainedsimulationsareemployedtostudytheconstrictionandsubsequent fission of a lipid bilayer membrane by geometrically realistic dynamin helices. The authors find that a combination of membrane constrict...
work page 2018
-
[14]
L. Harker-Kirschneck, B. Baum, A. Saric, Transitions in filament geometry drive ESCRT-III-mediated membrane remodelling and fission, bioRxiv (2019) 559898 •• First coarse-grained model of ESCRT-III filaments that perform "inverse membrane scission". The authors found that filament geometry change is needed for the force pro- duction, which recovered many expe...
work page 2019
-
[15]
R. Wedlich-Söldner, T. Betz, Self-organization: the fundament of cell biology, Philosophical Transac- tions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 373 (1747) (2018) 20170103
work page 2018
-
[16]
A. Šarić, A. K. Buell, G. Meisl, T. C. T. Michaels, C. M. Dobson, S. Linse, T. P. J. Knowles, D. Frenkel, Physical determinants of the self-replication of protein fibrils, Nature Physics 12 (9) (2016) 874–880 •• Coarse-grained model for self-replication of amyloid fibrils via amorphous oligomers. Simulations were used to explain kinetic experimental data. T...
work page 2016
- [17]
-
[18]
V. VanBuren, L. Cassimeris, D. J. Odde, Mechanochemical Model of Microtubule Structure and Self- Assembly Kinetics, Biophysical Journal 89 (5) (2005) 2911–2926
work page 2005
-
[19]
G. Margolin, I. V. Gregoretti, T. M. Cickovski, C. Li, W. Shi, M. S. Alber, H. V. Goodson, The mecha- nisms of microtubule catastrophe and rescue: implications from analysis of a dimer-scale computational model, Molecular Biology of the Cell 23 (4) (2011) 642–656 16
work page 2011
-
[20]
C. E. Coombes, A. Yamamoto, M. R. Kenzie, D. J. Odde, M. K. Gardner, Evolving Tip Structures Can Explain Age-Dependent Microtubule Catastrophe, Current Biology 23 (14) (2013) 1342–1348
work page 2013
-
[21]
P. Zakharov, N. Gudimchuk, V. Voevodin, A. Tikhonravov, F. I. Ataullakhanov, E. L. Grishchuk, Molecular and Mechanical Causes of Microtubule Catastrophe and Aging, Biophysical Journal 109 (12) (2015) 2574–2591
work page 2015
- [22]
-
[23]
B. T. Castle, S. McCubbin, L. S. Prahl, J. N. Bernens, D. Sept, D. J. Odde, Mechanisms of kinetic stabilization by the drugs paclitaxel and vinblastine, Molecular Biology of the Cell 28 (9) (2017) 1238– 1257
work page 2017
-
[24]
B. T. Castle, D. J. Odde, Brownian dynamics of subunit addition-loss kinetics and thermodynamics in linear polymer self-assembly, Biophysical Journal 105 (11) (2013) 2528–2540
work page 2013
-
[25]
G. Lan, B. R. Daniels, T. M. Dobrowsky, D. Wirtz, S. X. Sun, Condensation of FtsZ filaments can drive bacterial cell division, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 106 (1) (2009) 121–126
work page 2009
- [26]
-
[27]
E. Fischer-Friedrich, N. Gov, Modeling FtsZ ring formation in the bacterial cellâĂŤanisotropic aggre- gation via mutual interactions of polymer rods, Physical Biology 8 (2) (2011) 026007
work page 2011
-
[28]
F. Nedelec, D. Foethke, Collective Langevin dynamics of flexible cytoskeletal fibers, New Journal of Physics 9 (11) (2007) 427–427
work page 2007
-
[29]
D. Vavylonis, J.-Q. Wu, S. Hao, B. O’Shaughnessy, T. D. Pollard, Assembly mechanism of the contrac- tile ring for cytokinesis by fission yeast., Science (New York, N.Y.) 319 (5859) (2008) 97–100
work page 2008
-
[30]
T. Kim, W. Hwang, H. Lee, R. D. Kamm, Computational Analysis of Viscoelastic Properties of Crosslinked Actin Networks, PLoS Computational Biology 5 (7) (2009) e1000439
work page 2009
- [31]
-
[32]
K. Popov, J. Komianos, G. A. Papoian, MEDYAN: Mechanochemical Simulations of Contraction and Polarity Alignment in Actomyosin Networks, PLOS Computational Biology 12 (4) (2016) e1004877 • The open-source software package MEDYAN uses a stochastic, compartment-based reaction-diffusion scheme to model cytoskeletal self-organisation
work page 2016
-
[33]
S. L. Freedman, S. Banerjee, G. M. Hocky, A. R. Dinner, A Versatile Framework for Simulating the Dynamic Mechanical Structure of Cytoskeletal Networks, Biophysical Journal 113 (2) (2017) 448–460 (jul 2017). 17 • The mechanics of simulated cytoskeletal networks is studied by introducing the open- source computer simulation package AFINES
work page 2017
-
[34]
J. M. Belmonte, M. Leptin, F. Nédélec, A theory that predicts behaviors of disordered cytoskeletal networks, Molecular Systems Biology 13 (9) (2017) 941 (sep 2017)
work page 2017
-
[35]
S. L. Freedman, G. M. Hocky, S. Banerjee, A. R. Dinner, Nonequilibrium phase diagrams for actomyosin networks, Soft Matter 14 (37) (2018) 7740–7747
work page 2018
-
[36]
S. Stam, S. L. Freedman, S. Banerjee, K. L. Weirich, A. R. Dinner, M. L. Gardel, Filament rigidity and connectivity tune the deformation modes of active biopolymer networks, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114 (47) (2017) E10037–E10045
work page 2017
-
[37]
J. Roostalu, J. Rickman, C. Thomas, F. Nédélec, T. Surrey, Determinants of Polar versus Nematic Organization in Networks of Dynamic Microtubules and Mitotic Motors, Cell 175 (3) (2018) 796– 808.e14
work page 2018
-
[38]
R. Blackwell, C. Edelmaier, O. Sweezy-Schindler, A. Lamson, Z. R. Gergely, E. O’Toole, A. Crapo, L. E. Hough, J. R. McIntosh, M. A. Glaser, M. D. Betterton, Physical determinants of bipolar mitotic spindle assembly and stability in fission yeast, Science Advances 3 (1) (2017) e1601603
work page 2017
-
[39]
P.Bun, S.Dmitrieff, J.M.Belmonte, F.J.Nédélec, P.Lénárt, Adisassembly-drivenmechanismexplains F-actin-mediated chromosome transport in starfish oocytes, eLife 7 (2018) 1–27
work page 2018
-
[40]
C. P. Descovich, D. B. Cortes, S. Ryan, J. Nash, L. Zhang, P. S. Maddox, F. Nedelec, A. S. Maddox, Cross-linkers both drive and brake cytoskeletal remodeling and furrowing in cytokinesis, Molecular Biology of the Cell 29 (5) (2018) 622–631
work page 2018
-
[41]
M. Mund, J. A. van der Beek, J. Deschamps, S. Dmitrieff, P. Hoess, J. L. Monster, A. Picco, F. Nédélec, M. Kaksonen, J. Ries, Systematic Nanoscale Analysis of Endocytosis Links Efficient Vesicle Formation to Patterned Actin Nucleation, Cell 174 (4) (2018) 884–896.e17
work page 2018
- [42]
-
[43]
I. M. Ilie, A. Caflisch, Simulation Studies of Amyloidogenic Polypeptides and Their Aggregates, Chem- ical Reviews (2019) acs.chemrev.8b00731
work page 2019
- [44]
- [45]
-
[46]
S.I.A.Cohen, R.Cukalevski, T.C.T.Michaels, A.Šarić, M.Törnquist, M.Vendruscolo, C.M.Dobson, A. K. Buell, T. P. J. Knowles, S. Linse, Distinct thermodynamic signatures of oligomer generation in 18 the aggregation of the amyloid-β peptide, Nature Chemistry 10 (5) (2018) 523–531
work page 2018
-
[47]
T. C. T. Michaels, L. X. Liu, S. Curk, P. G. Bolhuis, A. Šarić, T. P. J. Knowles, Reaction rate theory for supramolecular kinetics: application to protein aggregation, Molecular Physics 116 (21-22) (2018) 3055–3065
work page 2018
- [48]
-
[49]
T. C. Michaels, A. Šarić, J. Habchi, S. Chia, G. Meisl, M. Vendruscolo, C. M. Dobson, T. P. Knowles, Chemical Kinetics for Bridging Molecular Mechanisms and Macroscopic Measurements of Amyloid Fibril Formation, Annual Review of Physical Chemistry 69 (1) (2018) 273–298
work page 2018
-
[50]
I. M. Ilie, W. K. den Otter, W. J. Briels, A coarse grained protein model with internal degrees of freedom. Application to α -synuclein aggregation, The Journal of Chemical Physics 144 (8) (2016) 085103
work page 2016
-
[51]
I. M. Ilie, W. K. den Otter, W. J. Briels, The attachment ofα-synuclein to a fiber: A coarse-grain approach, The Journal of Chemical Physics 146 (11) (2017) 115102
work page 2017
-
[52]
L. Lu, Y. Deng, X. Li, H. Li, G. E. Karniadakis, Understanding the Twisted Structure of Amyloid Fibrils via Molecular Simulations, The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 122 (49) (2018) 11302–11310
work page 2018
-
[53]
F. Mohajerani, M. F. Hagan, The role of the encapsulated cargo in microcompartment assembly, PLOS Computational Biology 14 (7) (2018) e1006351 (jul 2018)
work page 2018
-
[54]
C. A. Brackley, B. Liebchen, D. Michieletto, F. Mouvet, P. R. Cook, D. Marenduzzo, Ephemeral Protein Binding to DNA Shapes Stable Nuclear Bodies and Chromatin Domains, Biophysical Journal 112 (6) (2017) 1085–1093 • Large-scale Brownian dynamics simulations are used to model the interplay between chromatin fibres and multivalent DNA-binding proteins with va...
work page 2017
-
[55]
D. Michieletto, M. Lusic, D. Marenduzzo, E. Orlandini, Physical principles of retroviral integration in the human genome, Nature Communications 10 (1) (2019) 575 •• In this study a basic biophysical model for retroviral integration into host genomes is explored. It is found that local genome elasticity and chromatin accessibility serve as two physical det...
work page 2019
-
[56]
G. L. Dignon, W. Zheng, R. B. Best, Y. C. Kim, J. Mittal, Relation between single-molecule properties andphase behaviorofintrinsically disorderedproteins, Proceedings oftheNational Academyof Sciences 115 (40) (2018) 9929–9934 19 • A residue-specific coarse-grained simulation model is developed to disentangle the rela- tion between the protein sequence and ...
work page 2018
-
[57]
J. Weichsel, P. L. Geissler, The More the Tubular: Dynamic Bundling of Actin Filaments for Membrane Tube Formation, PLOS Computational Biology 12 (7) (2016) e1004982 • Coarse-grained model that combines the growth of cytoskeletal filaments and membrane deformation. The authors studied how the cell membrane drives bundling of actin filaments
work page 2016
-
[58]
H. Noguchi, Membrane tubule formation by banana-shaped proteins with or without transient network structure, Scientific Reports 6 (1) (2016) 20935 (aug 2016)
work page 2016
-
[59]
M. Giani, W. K. den Otter, W. J. Briels, Early stages of clathrin aggregation at a membrane in coarse-grained simulations, The Journal of Chemical Physics 146 (15) (2017) 155102 • In this work MD simulations are used to study the formation of clathrin coats on mem- brane facilitated by AP2 adaptor proteins. It is determined that the free energy released b...
work page 2017
-
[60]
C. A. Brackley, S. Taylor, A. Papantonis, P. R. Cook, D. Marenduzzo, Nonspecific bridging-induced attraction drives clustering of DNA-binding proteins and genome organization, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110 (38) (2013) E3605–E3611
work page 2013
-
[61]
T. L. Tootle, I. Rebay, Post-translational modifications influence transcription factor activity: A view from the ETS superfamily, BioEssays 27 (3) (2005) 285–298
work page 2005
- [62]
-
[63]
D. Michieletto, M. Chiang, D. Colì, A. Papantonis, E. Orlandini, P. R. Cook, D. Marenduzzo, Shaping epigenetic memory via genomic bookmarking, Nucleic Acids Research 46 (1) (2018) 83–93 (jan 2018)
work page 2018
-
[64]
G. Fudenberg, M. Imakaev, C. Lu, A. Goloborodko, N. Abdennur, L. A. Mirny, Formation of Chromo- somal Domains by Loop Extrusion, Cell Reports 15 (9) (2016) 2038–2049
work page 2016
-
[65]
M. F. Hagan, Modeling Viral Capsid Assembly, in: Advances in Chemical Physics, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, Ch. 1, pp. 1–68
work page 2014
-
[66]
M. F. Hagan, R. Zandi, Recent advances in coarse-grained modeling of virus assembly, Current Opinion in Virology 18 (2016) 36–43 (jun 2016). 20
work page 2016
-
[67]
G. R. Lázaro, B. Dragnea, M. F. Hagan, Self-assembly of convex particles on spherocylindrical surfaces, Soft Matter 14 (28) (2018) 5728–5740
work page 2018
-
[68]
C. Zeng, G. Rodriguez Lázaro, I. B. Tsvetkova, M. F. Hagan, B. Dragnea, Defects and Chirality in the Nanoparticle-Directed Assembly of Spherocylindrical Shells of Virus Coat Proteins, ACS Nano 12 (6) (2018) 5323–5332
work page 2018
-
[69]
V. Schubertová, F. J. Martinez-Veracoechea, R. Vácha, Design of Multivalent Inhibitors for Preventing Cellular Uptake, Scientific Reports 7 (1) (2017) 11689 • It is shown that multivalent inhibitors which block the receptor binding sites on the virus can prevent endocytosis
work page 2017
-
[70]
G. R. Lázaro, S. Mukhopadhyay, M. F. Hagan, Why Enveloped Viruses Need Cores–The Contribution of a Nucleocapsid Core to Viral Budding, Biophysical Journal 114 (3) (2018) 619–630 (feb 2018). • Within a coarse-grained molecular dynamics approach, the impact of capsids on viral budding is explored
work page 2018
- [71]
-
[72]
I. R. Cooke, M. Deserno, Solvent-free model for self-assembling fluid bilayer membranes: Stabilization of the fluid phase based on broad attractive tail potentials, The Journal of Chemical Physics 123 (22) (2005) 224710 (dec 2005)
work page 2005
-
[73]
H. Yuan, C. Huang, J. Li, G. Lykotrafitis, S. Zhang, One-particle-thick, solvent-free, coarse-grained model for biological and biomimetic fluid membranes, Physical Review E 82 (1) (2010) 011905
work page 2010
- [74]
-
[75]
W. K. den Otter, M. R. Renes, W. J. Briels, Self-assembly of three-legged patchy particles into poly- hedral cages, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 22 (10) (2010) 104103
work page 2010
- [76]
-
[77]
J. Schöneberg, M. Lehmann, A. Ullrich, Y. Posor, W.-T. Lo, G. Lichtner, J. Schmoranzer, V. Haucke, F. Noé, Lipid-mediated PX-BAR domain recruitment couples local membrane constriction to endocytic vesicle fission, Nature Communications 8 (May) (2017) 15873
work page 2017
-
[78]
F. Bonazzi, T. R. Weikl, Membrane Morphologies Induced by Arc-Shaped Scaffolds Are Determined by Arc Angle and Coverage, Biophysical Journal 116 (7) (2019) 1239–1247 (apr 2019)
work page 2019
-
[79]
H. Noguchi, J.-B. Fournier, Membrane structure formation induced by two types of banana-shaped proteins, Soft Matter 13 (22) (2017) 4099–4111 21
work page 2017
-
[80]
G. L. Dignon, W. Zheng, Y. C. Kim, R. B. Best, J. Mittal, Sequence determinants of protein phase behavior from a coarse-grained model, PLOS Computational Biology 14 (1) (2018) e1005941
work page 2018
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.