Brittleness of metallic glasses dictated by their state at the fragile-to-strong transition temperature

The effect of cooling on the brittleness of glasses in general, and bulk metallic glasses (BMGs) in particular, is usually studied with continuously varying cooling rates; slower cooling rates lead to stiffer, harder, and more brittle glasses than higher cooling rates. These protocols obscure any potential discontinuity that a glass might experience depending on whether its microstructure resembles that of a fragile or a strong glass-forming liquid. Here, we use large-scale molecular dynamics to simulate the nanoindentation behavior of model BMGs (Zr$_{0.6}$Cu$_{0.3}$Al$_{0.1}$) obtained by rapidly quenching equilibrium melts from temperatures above and below the fragile-to-strong transition temperature $T_\textrm{fst}$, leading to fragile and strong glasses, respectively. While the contact modulus deduced from the indentation simulation evolves smoothly with the temperature $T_\text{q}$ from which the melt is quenched, the plastic response changes quasi-discontinuously as $T_\text{q}$ passes through $T_\textrm{fst}$. In particular, strong glasses develop highly asymmetric flow profiles with mature shear bands, in contrast to fragile glasses. Quantitative differences reveal themselves not only through a formal von Mises localization parameter analysis but also through image analysis of flow patterns using pre-trained artificial intelligence models. Moreover, seemingly erratic flow profiles for our indentation geometry produced surprisingly reproducible and, thus, deterministic features. It remains to be determined to what extent other classes of glass formers follow our observation that the degree of brittleness is significantly influenced by whether the melt is fragile or strong when it falls out of equilibrium at the glass transition temperature.