REVIEW 8 cited by
Accuracy limitations of existing numerical relativity waveforms on the data analysis of current and future ground-based detectors
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
Signed reviews
abstract
As gravitational wave detectors improve in sensitivity, signal-to-noise ratios of compact binary coalescences will dramatically increase, reaching values in the hundreds and potentially thousands. Such strong signals offer both exciting scientific opportunities and pose formidable challenges to the template waveforms used for interpretation. Current waveform models are informed by calibrating or fitting to numerical relativity waveforms and such strong signals may unveil computational errors in generating these waveforms. In this paper, we isolate a single source of computational error, that of the finite grid resolution, and investigate its impact on parameter estimation for aLIGO and Cosmic Explorer. We demonstrate that increasing the inclination angle or decreasing the mass ratio $q$ ($q \leq 1 $) raises the resolution required for unbiased parameter estimation. We quantify the error associated with the highest-resolution waveform utilized in our study using an extrapolation procedure on the median of recovered posteriors and confirm the accuracy of current waveforms for the synthetic sources. We introduce a measure to predict the necessary numerical resolution for unbiased parameter estimation and use it to predict that current waveforms are suitable for equal and moderately unequal mass binaries for both detectors. However, current waveforms fail to meet accuracy requirements for high signal-to-noise ratio signals from highly unequal mass ratio binaries $(q \lesssim 1/6)$, for all inclinations in Cosmic Explorer, and for high inclinations in future updates to LIGO. Given that the resolution requirement becomes more stringent with more unequal mass ratios, current waveforms may lack the necessary accuracy, even at median signal-to-noise ratios for future detectors.
Forward citations
Cited by 8 Pith papers
-
Actions of spinning compact binaries: Spinning particle in Kerr matched to dynamics at 1.5 post-Newtonian order
Closed-form action and frequency formulas for spinning particles in Kerr spacetime are matched to the 1.5 post-Newtonian Hamiltonian of spinning binaries, yielding a gauge-invariant action dictionary.
-
Post-adiabatic dynamics and waveform generation in self-force theory: an invariant pseudo-Hamiltonian framework
A pseudo-Hamiltonian reformulation of 1PA self-force dynamics yields local, invariant action-angle evolution equations and an embedded conservative Hamiltonian whose on-shell energy equals the first-law binding energy.
-
Impact of numerical-relativity waveform calibration on parametrized post-Einsteinian tests
NR late-inspiral calibration systematics in IMRPhenomD produce false ppE GR violations at O5 SNRs ≳60; an uncertainty-aware baseline restores consistency with GR up to SNR 330.
-
Systematic biases in parameter estimation on LISA binaries. II. The effect of excluding higher harmonics for spin-aligned, high-mass binaries
Omitting higher-order waveform harmonics can cause severe, spin-dependent parameter biases for massive LISA black-hole binaries, including confident localization in the wrong sky region.
-
A comprehensive look into the accuracy of SpEC binary black hole waveforms
Simulated black-hole merger waveforms accumulate numerical error over time, but the merger stage is not intrinsically less accurate once aligned on its own, and resolution-exchanged differences show no systematic bias...
-
Dendro-GR at high mass ratios with high spins
Dendro-GR evolves its first binaries with mass ratio 24 and with mass ratio 12 and spins up to 0.8, demonstrating stable, low-cost inspirals with plausible waveforms.
-
On the use and interpretation of signal-model indistinguishability measures for gravitational-wave astronomy
Using mismatch distances computed at best-fit parameters, per parameter, the paper predicts accurate bias SNRs for aligned-spin binary black hole measurements and derives waveform accuracy requirements for next-genera...
-
Multimode ringdown modelling with $\texttt{qnmfits}$ and $\texttt{KerrRingdown}$
qnmfits and KerrRingdown are two independently written, cross-verified software packages for performing multimode ringdown fits to numerical relativity waveforms.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.