REVIEW 13 cited by
Properties of Dynamical Black Hole Entropy
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
Signed reviews
abstract
We study the first law for non-stationary perturbations of a stationary black hole whose event horizon is a Killing horizon, that relates the first-order change in the mass and angular momentum to the change in the entropy of an arbitrary horizon cross-section. Recently, Hollands, Wald and Zhang [1] have shown that the dynamical black hole entropy that satisfies this first law, for general relativity, is $S_{\text{dyn}}=(1-v\partial_v)S_{\text{BH}}$, where $v$ is the affine parameter of the null horizon generators and $S_{\text{BH}}$ is the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, and for general diffeomorphism covariant theories of gravity $S_{\text{dyn}}=(1-v\partial_v)S_{\text{Wall}}$, where $S_{\text{Wall}}$ is the Wall entropy. They obtained the first law by applying the Noether charge method to non-stationary perturbations and arbitrary cross-sections. In this formalism, the dynamical black hole entropy is defined as an ``improved'' Noether charge, which is unambiguous to first order in the perturbation. In the present article we provide a pedagogical derivation of the physical process version of the non-stationary first law for general relativity by integrating the linearised Raychaudhuri equation between two arbitrary horizon cross-sections. Moreover, we generalise the derivation of the first law in [1] to non-minimally coupled matter fields that are smooth on the horizon, using boost weight arguments rather than Killing field arguments, and we relax some of the gauge conditions on the perturbations by allowing for non-zero variations of the horizon Killing field and surface gravity. Finally, for $f(\text{Riemann})$ theories of gravity we show explicitly using Gaussian null coordinates that the improved Noether charge is $S_{\text{dyn}}=(1-v\partial_v)S_{\text{Wall}}$, which is a non-trivial check of [1].
Forward citations
Cited by 13 Pith papers
-
Horizon flux-balance laws in the multiscale perturbation
For two-timescale perturbations about Kerr, the coarse-grained leading-order horizon shear vanishes and the angular-velocity and inaffinity corrections are uniform on each cut, defining adiabatic rigidity; the paper a...
-
The BEF Symplectic Form: A Lagrangian Perspective
The BEF symplectic form is derived from L∞-Lagrangians via covariant phase space methods and coincides with the Barnich-Brandt form for second-order equations of motion.
-
Gravitational focusing and horizon entropy for higher-spin fields
Higher-spin fields introduce indefinite terms into the generalized Raychaudhuri equation on Killing horizons, blocking a focusing theorem and a well-defined Wall entropy unless a proposed focusing condition is imposed.
-
Gravitational Memory Beyond Null Infinity through Finite-Distance Carrollian Screens
Finite-distance null screens carry a Carrollian memory whose leading tracefree large-radius part reproduces the standard Bondi displacement memory in Robinson–Trautman spacetimes.
-
Black hole thermodynamics at null infinity. Part 2: Open systems, Markovian dynamics and work extraction from non-rotating black holes
Null-infinity black hole thermodynamics is recast as Markovian open-system thermodynamics, with chemical-potential terms identified as extractable work and used to formulate generalized grand-potential laws for Schwar...
-
Zeroth law of black hole thermodynamics for higher derivative Proca theories
The zeroth law of black hole thermodynamics holds to all perturbative orders for higher curvature Einstein-Proca effective field theories.
-
Gravitational EFT for dissipative open systems
A Schwinger-Keldysh EFT for dissipative systems coupled to dynamical gravity requires a dynamical environment sector, modeled here by HydroEFT, and yields dissipative scalar and gravitational wave dynamics plus a gene...
-
A comparison of two constructions for dynamical corrections to Wald entropy
For small perturbations, the dynamical entropy S_dyn and Wall's entropy S_Wall satisfy S_dyn = (1-v∂_v)S_Wall, and this paper gives a local algorithm that reconstructs S_Wall from S_dyn once a bifurcation-surface cond...
-
Dynamical Entropy Is a Noether Charge
A Noether-charge derivation of the known HWZ dynamical entropy for generic null surfaces, whose local second-law proof is invalid as printed because Eq. (19) has the wrong sign in K.
-
Black hole thermodynamics at null infinity. Part 1: Dual Generalized Second Law
At future null infinity, the generalized second law for a Schwarzschild black hole becomes the monotonic decrease of a free energy, or grand potential, constructed from the Bondi mass and angular-mode chemical potentials.
-
Dynamical black hole entropy beyond general relativity from the Einstein frame
For f(R) and scalar-tensor gravity, the dynamical black hole entropy formula is rederived via conformal frames and shown to equal the Wald entropy of a generalized apparent horizon.
-
GGI lectures on boundary and asymptotic symmetries
A lecture-note review of boundary and asymptotic symmetries that re-derives the BMS group as the asymptotic symmetry group of Minkowski spacetime alone and constructs an integral Hamiltonian generator for scalar-field...
-
Generalised focusing theorem and dynamical horizon entropy in diffeomorphism-invariant theories
A conference summary presenting the generalized focusing theorem and Wall entropy for diffeomorphism-invariant gravity theories, with a proposed condition for higher-spin fields.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.