REVIEW 4 major objections 5 minor 38 references
The Dissipation Theory of Aging: A Quantitative Analysis Using a Cellular Aging Map
T0 review · 4 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-16 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read The paper argues that aging is the growing dominance of dissipative forces in cellular dynamics, and that transformer-based gene embeddings can quantify this as drift and rising entropy.
desk verdict A large-scale descriptive embedding analysis of aging, but the central dissipative claim is definitionally true rather than empirically discovered. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central object is the Hopf decomposition, an ergodic-theory partition of the phase space into a conservative (recurrent, measure-preserving) part and a dissipative (non-recurrent, wandering) part, applied to gene embeddings. The transformer-based masked language model's embedding function plays the role of the unknown manifold flow map $H(t)$; because the embeddings are Lipschitz continuous, small changes in state or time produce small changes in embedding, so drift in embedding space is interpreted as drift in the biological manifold. Drift $\lVert E_{g,t}-E_{g,t_0}\rVert$ from the baseline age separates conservative from dissipative genes, and entropy of the model's masked-token predictions, conditioned on the age token, is used as the dissipation metric. This machinery converts the abstract conservative/dissipative split into a computable, per-gene, per-tissue quantity.
What would settle it
Train the same transformer architecture on age labels shuffled across samples or with the age token removed, and check whether the conservative/dissipative gene structure and the entropy increase with age persist; if they do, the dissipation signal is an artifact of the training objective. In parallel, follow a longitudinal cohort with repeated single-cell transcriptomes and test whether the model's age gaps track within-person changes and later health outcomes; if the gaps are uncorrelated with future disease or mortality, the deviations are not biological.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The paper's central claim is that aging is a dissipative dynamical process: in the language of ergodic theory, biological dynamics split by the Hopf decomposition into a conservative part (recurrent, measure-preserving) and a dissipative part (non-recurrent, wandering), and aging is the growing dominance of the dissipative part, which pushes the system away from recurrent states and raises entropy. The authors make this measurable by replacing the unknown flow map of the gene-expression manifold with the embedding function of a transformer-based masked language model trained on 65 million single-cell transcriptomes, with age as an input token. In the resulting Cellular Aging Map, they report that predicted molecular age deviates from chronological age in a tissue- and cell-type-specific, nonlinear way; that genes split into conservative (low drift) and dissipative (high drift) classes independently of biological function; and that entropy computed from masked-token predictions rises progressively with age in healthy kidney tissue and in diseased endothelial cells, while healthy endothelial cells show transient entropy spikes. The paper concludes that dissipation, measured as embedding drift and entropy, is a cellular-level signature of aging and that chronological age is an inadequate metric for it.
Load-bearing premise
The load-bearing premise, stated in Section 2.2.1, is that deviations between model-predicted and labeled chronological age reflect real biological aging dynamics rather than prediction noise or batch effects; if that premise fails, the Cellular Aging Map, the conservative/dissipative split, and the entropy trends lose their biological meaning.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- Tissues and cell types can be ranked by aging intensity using similarity to the age token, creating a cellular-resolution aging clock that does not rely on any single molecular marker.
- Conservative and dissipative gene sets give candidate biomarkers: dissipative genes are the ones whose molecular context changes most with age, so they are natural targets for age-related functional decline.
- Disease changes the classification of specific genes (ATR and SAFB2 become more dissipative, TDP2 more conservative), so the framework can track how pathology rewires aging dynamics.
- Entropy provides a scalar readout of aging-related information loss, rising progressively in healthy kidney tissue and in diseased endothelial cells, which could serve as a quantitative endpoint for aging studies.
- The nonlinear age-gap trajectory, with acceleration early in life and deceleration after the fourth decade, implies that single linear aging-clock equations will miss stage-specific molecular changes; multi-stage models are needed.
Reading between the lines
- An implication the authors leave implicit: if aging is the growth of the dissipative part of the Hopf decomposition, then interventions that restore recurrence — for example, reprogramming or resetting transcriptional states — should measurably reduce embedding drift; this transforms the framework into a quantitative readout for rejuvenation experiments.
- The entropy-spike pattern in healthy endothelial cells suggests that aging in some cell types is episodic rather than monotonic; a natural extension is to test whether these spikes align with known stressors, hormonal cycles, or immune challenges.
- The similar conservative/dissipative structure across diverse pathways hints that dissipation is an aggregate dynamical property independent of gene function; one could test this by asking whether the same gene sets classify as dissipative in non-human primate or mouse aging data.
- Because the framework depends on distributional training data, its tissue rankings should be validated against longitudinal within-individual measurements; the paper's cross-sectional design cannot by itself prove that its age gaps track individual aging rates.
Signed reviews
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper proposes a 'dissipation theory of aging' in which aging is described as the predominance of dissipative, non-recurrent dynamics in a biological dynamical system, formalized via the Hopf decomposition from ergodic theory. The authors train a transformer-based masked language model on a large single-cell RNA-seq corpus, including age as an input token, and analyze the resulting embeddings to construct a Cellular Aging Map (CAM). They classify genes as conservative or dissipative based on the temporal drift of their embeddings (Eqs. 10-12), report tissue- and cell-type-specific age predictions, and compute Shannon entropy of masked-token predictions conditioned on age (Eq. 15) as a measure of molecular disorder. The central claim is that these analyses demonstrate aging to be a fundamentally dissipative process and provide a quantitative framework for measuring age-related molecular changes.
Significance. If established, a quantitative, data-driven demonstration that aging is fundamentally dissipative would be a significant contribution, potentially unifying disparate aging theories under a dynamical-systems framework. The paper has notable strengths: it leverages an exceptionally large corpus of over 65 million single cells, integrates age as a learnable token into a transformer-based model, and proposes concrete embedding-based metrics (drift, similarity, entropy) that could serve as descriptive tools for aging research. However, as presented, the central claim is not empirically established. The classification of 'dissipative genes' is definitionally tied to embedding drift, the Hopf decomposition is never instantiated with a concrete map or measure, and the entropy and age-gap analyses lack the controls needed to distinguish biological signal from model artifacts. The paper does not provide reproducible code for the new analyses, and no falsifiable predictions are extracted beyond the relabeling of drift as dissipation.
major comments (4)
- [§4.7.1-§4.7.2, Eqs. (7), (10)-(12)] The central conclusion that aging is dissipative is not derived from an independent dynamical-systems quantity; it is imposed by definition. In §4.7.2, conservative genes are defined as those with max_t D_g(t) ≤ δ (Eq. 10), and dissipative genes are simply the complement GD = G \ GC (Eq. 12), where D_g(t) is the Euclidean drift of the gene embedding from a baseline (Eq. 11). Therefore the finding in §2.4 that 'aging is a dissipative process' because dissipative genes exist is a tautology, guaranteed for any nonzero drift. The Hopf decomposition in §4.7.1 (Eq. 7) is asserted but never instantiated: no transformation T on the embedding space is specified, no measure μ is defined, and no wandering set is identified or measured. Without an actual decomposition into conservative and dissipative parts based on recurrence properties, the theoretical framework does no empirical work.
- [§4.7.2, Eq. (10), and Fig. 5a-b] The threshold δ in Eq. (10) is left unspecified: the text only says it is 'determined through statistical analysis, such as a percentile of the D_g(t) distribution.' No percentile value, no stability analysis, and no null model are provided. In particular, there is no comparison of the observed drift against what would be expected from random token geometry, age-label imbalance, batch effects, or model training variability. Without such a null model, the specific lists of dissipative and conservative genes (e.g., ALDH3B1, NR2C2, HERPUD1 versus MKRN1, SESN1, ATR in §2.4.1) and the disease-related changes in Fig. 5b lack statistical support.
- [§2.2.1 and §2.2.3] The interpretation of z-scored age gaps as evidence of accelerated or decelerated biological aging is under-justified. The paper states (end of §2.2.1): 'These deviations suggest that the model captures underlying variations in gene expression that reflect processes moving alongside chronological aging.' However, no evidence is presented that the residuals are not dominated by prediction noise, batch effects, or tissue-specific sampling imbalances. The correlation coefficients in Fig. 2 are reported without confidence intervals, and no held-out validation or comparison to a null distribution of age gaps is provided. The nonlinear age-gap dynamics in Fig. 3c are therefore not distinguishably biological rather than model artifacts, which undermines the CAM interpretation.
- [§2.4.2 and §4.7.3, Eq. (15)] The entropy analysis is subject to the same confounding issue as the drift analysis. Eq. (15) computes the Shannon entropy of a masked token's predicted probability distribution conditioned on context that includes the age token. Changes in H(x) across age can arise from vocabulary frequency shifts, data sparsity, or class imbalance across age groups, without any change in biological disorder. The assertion in §2.4.2 that 'higher entropy indicates greater uncertainty and suggests a loss of molecular specificity' is not supported without controlling for these factors. Additionally, the entropy results are shown only for kidney tissue and endothelial cells (Fig. 5c-e), with no confidence intervals, effect sizes, or significance tests.
minor comments (5)
- [Abstract; §2.1; §4.4] The number of age groups is inconsistent: the abstract states 104 age groups, while the Results and Methods sections state 171 distinct age groups; please reconcile.
- [§2.2.1] The phrase 'autounity' appears to be a typo for 'autoimmunity'; please correct.
- [Figure 2 caption] The caption contains 'the different between model's prediction and chronological age labels'; this should be 'the difference between.'
- [§4.7.1, Eq. (8)] The notation x_C(t) is used in Eq. (8) without a prior definition, and the sentence 'we shown that the modeling is Lipschitz continuous' contains a grammatical error; please revise.
- [§5-§6] Code availability only points to the model from reference [14]; scripts specific to the CAM construction, drift classification, and entropy analysis are not provided, which limits the reproducibility of the paper's quantitative claims.
Circularity Check
The dissipative-gene classification is definitional: 'dissipative' is defined as embedding drift above a threshold, so the conclusion that aging is dissipative is guaranteed by construction; the Hopf decomposition is asserted, not instantiated.
-
self definitional
[Methods 4.7.2, Eqs. (10)-(12); Results 2.4; Abstract]
"GC = {g∈G | max_t D_g(t)≤δ}, (10); D_g(t) = ||E_{g,t}−E_{g,t0}||, (11); GD = G\GC (12) ... This classification ensures that any gene not meeting the stability criterion for GC is categorized as dissipative. ... Dissipative genes exhibit high temporal drift in the embedding space, reflecting their sensitivity to aging and their dynamically shifting contextual relationships."
The paper's operational definition makes 'dissipative' synonymous with 'embedding drift above an unspecified threshold δ', and 'conservative' synonymous with drift at or below δ. The abstract's conclusion that 'aging is fundamentally a dissipative process' then restates the definition: any gene whose embedding drifts is classified as dissipative, so GD is nonempty as soon as any drift occurs. The Hopf decomposition in Eq. (7) is never actually applied: no transformation T on phase space is defined, no wandering set is measured, and no recurrence properties are tested. Thus the central claim is true by construction, not by empirical test; no null model shows that the observed drift exceeds what random token geometry, batch effects, or age-label imbalance would produce.
full rationale
The paper's central derivation is not self-contained in a way that tests its own thesis. The operational definition of dissipative genes (Eqs. 10-12) is high embedding drift relative to an unspecified threshold, while the Hopf decomposition (Eq. 7) is invoked but never computed via a transformation T or a wandering set. Consequently, the abstract's claim that 'aging is fundamentally a dissipative process' is true by construction: once any gene embedding drifts, GD is nonempty and the 'dissipative' category exists. No null model, threshold calibration, or external benchmark is provided for the drift classification. The entropy analysis (Sec. 2.4.2) is model predictive uncertainty conditioned on the age token rather than an independent molecular-disorder measurement; this is a validity concern more than a separate equation-level circularity. The self-citation to [14] for the foundation model is not by itself circular, since a model from prior work can legitimately be reused as a tool; the circularity sits in the labeling step where 'dissipative' is redefined as drift and then drift is presented as evidence for dissipation. Score 8 because the paper's central claim is forced by this definition.
Assumptions & free parameters
free parameters (2)
- Drift threshold delta (Eq. 10) =
not reported (described as a percentile of the drift distribution)
- Age groups and 5-year bins =
not reported for the model; 5-year bins used in plots
assumptions (5)
- domain assumption Hopf decomposition applies to the biological dynamical system: phase space splits into conservative and dissipative parts under some invertible non-singular map T.
- domain assumption The trained BERT embedding E is Lipschitz continuous in input and age (Eq. 6), so embedding distance mirrors biological distance.
- domain assumption Shannon entropy of masked-token predictions conditioned on the age token measures biological information loss rather than model uncertainty or dataset noise.
- domain assumption Residuals between predicted age and chronological age reflect accelerated or decelerated biological aging.
- domain assumption CellxGene data are sufficiently standardized across 65 million cells so that batch effects do not dominate embedding drift.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of The Dissipation Theory of Aging: A Quantitative Analysis Using a Cellular Aging Map." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/X72RMIHE
@misc{pith2026250413044,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: The Dissipation Theory of Aging: A Quantitative Analysis Using a Cellular Aging Map},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/X72RMIHE}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2504.13044}
}
read the original abstract
We propose a new theory for aging based on dynamical systems and provide a data-driven computational method to quantify the changes at the cellular level. We use ergodic theory to decompose the dynamics of changes during aging and show that aging is fundamentally a dissipative process within biological systems, akin to dynamical systems where dissipation occurs due to non-conservative forces. To quantify the dissipation dynamics, we employ a transformer-based machine learning algorithm to analyze gene expression data, incorporating age as a token to assess how age-related dissipation is reflected in the embedding space. By evaluating the dynamics of gene and age embeddings, we provide a cellular aging map (CAM) and identify patterns indicative of divergence in gene embedding space, nonlinear transitions, and entropy variations during aging for various tissues and cell types. Our results provide a novel perspective on aging as a dissipative process and introduce a computational framework that enables measuring age-related changes with molecular resolution.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Lopez-Otin, C., Blasco, M., Partridge, L., Serrano, M. & Kroemer, G. The hallmarks of aging. Cell. 153, 1194-1217 (2013)
work page 2013
-
[2]
Aging: a theory based on free radical and radiation chemistry
Harman, D. Aging: a theory based on free radical and radiation chemistry. Journal Of Gerontology. (1955)
work page 1955
-
[3]
Understanding the odd science of aging
Kirkwood, T. Understanding the odd science of aging. Cell. 120, 437-447 (2005)
work page 2005
-
[4]
Gladyshev, V. Aging: progressive decline in fitness due to the rising deleteriome adjusted by genetic, environmental, and stochastic processes. Aging Cell . 15, 594-602 (2016)
work page 2016
- [5]
-
[6]
Essays upon heredity and kindred biological problems
Weismann, A. Essays upon heredity and kindred biological problems. (Clarendon press,1891)
-
[7]
An introduction to ergodic theory
Walters, P. An introduction to ergodic theory. (Springer Science & Business Media,2000)
work page 2000
-
[9]
Schmidt, M. & Lipson, H. Distilling free-form natural laws from experimental data. Science. 324, 81-85 (2009)
work page 2009
Show all 38 references
-
[10]
& Kutz, J
Brunton, S., Proctor, J. & Kutz, J. Discovering governing equations from data by sparse iden- tification of nonlinear dynamical systems. Proceedings Of The National Academy Of Sciences . 113, 3932-3937 (2016)
2016
-
[11]
Theoretische biologie
Bertalanffy, L. Theoretische biologie. Philosophical Review. 43 (1934)
1934
-
[12]
& Larsen, P
Legaard, C., Schranz, T., Schweiger, G., Drgona, J., Falay, B., Gomes, C., Iosifidis, A., Abkar, M. & Larsen, P. Constructing neural network-based models for simulating dynamical systems. arXiv. ArXiv Preprint ArXiv:2111.01495 . (2021)
2021 arXiv
-
[13]
Ergodentheorie
Hopf, E. Ergodentheorie. (Springer,1937)
1937
-
[14]
& Edelman, E
Khodaee, F., Zandie, R. & Edelman, E. Multimodal Learning for Mapping the Genotype- Phenotype Dynamics. Research Square. (2024)
2024
-
[15]
& Skulachev, V
Longo, V., Mitteldorf, J. & Skulachev, V. Programmed and altruistic ageing. Nature Reviews Genetics. 6, 866-872 (2005)
2005
-
[16]
Aging is a specific biological function rather than the result of a disor- der in complex living systems: biochemical evidence in support of Weismann’s hypothesis
Skulachev, V. Aging is a specific biological function rather than the result of a disor- der in complex living systems: biochemical evidence in support of Weismann’s hypothesis. Biochemistry-New York-English Translation Of Biokhimiya . 62, 1191-1195 (1997)
1997
-
[17]
An unsolved problem of biology
Medawar, P. An unsolved problem of biology. Genetics. (1952)
1952
-
[18]
Pleiotropy, natural selection, and the evolution of senescence
Williams, G. Pleiotropy, natural selection, and the evolution of senescence. Evolution (NY) 11:
-
[19]
Aging: Ros or tor
Blagosklonny, M. Aging: Ros or tor. Cell Cycle . 7, 3344-3354 (2008)
2008
-
[20]
Evolution of ageing
Kirkwood, T. Evolution of ageing. Nature. 270, 301-304 (1977)
1977
-
[21]
& Wang, L
Zhang, B., Jiang, D., He, D. & Wang, L. Rethinking lipschitz neural networks and certified robustness: A boolean function perspective. Advances In Neural Information Processing Systems. 35 pp. 19398-19413 (2022)
2022
-
[22]
Untersuchungen ¨Uber die Gesetzlichkeit des Wachstums: I
Bertalanffy, L. Untersuchungen ¨Uber die Gesetzlichkeit des Wachstums: I. Teil: Allgemeine Grundlagen der Theorie; Mathematische und physiologische Gesetzlichkeiten des Wachstums bei Wassertieren. Wilhelm Roux’Archiv F¨ ur Entwicklungsmechanik Der Organismen . 131 pp. 613-652 (1934)
1934
-
[23]
& Davies, K
Pomatto, L. & Davies, K. Adaptive homeostasis and the free radical theory of ageing. Free Radical Biology And Medicine . 124 pp. 420-430 (2018)
2018
-
[24]
Origin and evolution of the free radical theory of aging: a brief personal history, 1954–2009
Harman, D. Origin and evolution of the free radical theory of aging: a brief personal history, 1954–2009. Biogerontology. 10 pp. 773-781 (2009)
2009
-
[25]
An attempt at a rational classification of theories of ageing
Medvedev, Z. An attempt at a rational classification of theories of ageing. Biological Reviews. 65, 375-398 (1990)
1990
-
[26]
Cell turnover in the lung
Bowden, D. Cell turnover in the lung. American Review Of Respiratory Disease . 128, S46-S48 (1983)
1983
-
[27]
& Lehallier, B
Johnson, A., Shokhirev, M., Wyss-Coray, T. & Lehallier, B. Systematic review and analysis of human proteomics aging studies unveils a novel proteomic aging clock and identifies key processes that change with age. Ageing Research Reviews. 60 pp. 101070 (2020)
2020
-
[28]
& Johnson, A
Lehallier, B., Shokhirev, M., Wyss-Coray, T. & Johnson, A. Data mining of human plasma proteins generates a multitude of highly predictive aging clocks that reflect different aspects of aging. Aging Cell . 19, e13256 (2020)
2020
-
[29]
& Others Proteomic aging clock predicts mortality and risk of common age-related diseases in diverse populations
Argentieri, M., Xiao, S., Bennett, D., Winchester, L., Nevado-Holgado, A., Ghose, U., Albukhari, 16 A., Yao, P., Mazidi, M., Lv, J. & Others Proteomic aging clock predicts mortality and risk of common age-related diseases in diverse populations. Nature Medicine. 30, 2450-2460 (2024)
2024
-
[30]
& Others Organ aging signatures in the plasma proteome track health and disease
Oh, H., Rutledge, J., Nachun, D., P´ alovics, R., Abiose, O., Moran-Losada, P., Channappa, D., Urey, D., Kim, K., Sung, Y. & Others Organ aging signatures in the plasma proteome track health and disease. Nature. 624, 164-172 (2023)
2023
-
[31]
& Zalesky, A
Tian, Y., Cropley, V., Maier, A., Lautenschlager, N., Breakspear, M. & Zalesky, A. Hetero- geneous aging across multiple organ systems and prediction of chronic disease and mortality. Nature Medicine. 29, 1221-1231 (2023)
2023
-
[32]
& Snyder, M
Shen, X., Wang, C., Zhou, X., Zhou, W., Hornburg, D., Wu, S. & Snyder, M. Nonlinear dynamics of multi-omics profiles during human aging. Nature Aging. pp. 1-16 (2024)
2024
-
[33]
& Others Biomarkers of aging
Consortium, A., Bao, H., Cao, J., Chen, M., Chen, M., Chen, W., Chen, X., Chen, Y., Chen, Y., Chen, Y. & Others Biomarkers of aging. Science China Life Sciences . 66, 893-1066 (2023)
2023
-
[34]
& Others Cellxgene: a performant, scalable exploration platform for high dimensional sparse matrices
Megill, C., Martin, B., Weaver, C., Bell, S., Prins, L., Badajoz, S., McCandless, B., Pisco, A., Kinsella, M., Griffin, F. & Others Cellxgene: a performant, scalable exploration platform for high dimensional sparse matrices. BioRxiv. pp. 2021-04 (2021)
2021
-
[35]
& Garrett Jr, W
Siparsky, P., Kirkendall, D. & Garrett Jr, W. Muscle changes in aging: understanding sarcopenia. Sports Health. 6, 36-40 (2014)
2014
-
[36]
Aging and the germ line: where mortality and immortality meet
Jones, D. Aging and the germ line: where mortality and immortality meet. Stem Cell Reviews . 3 pp. 192-200 (2007)
2007
-
[37]
& Others Aging induces region-specific dysregulation of hormone synthesis in the primate adrenal gland
Wang, Q., Wang, X., Liu, B., Ma, S., Zhang, F., Sun, S., Jing, Y., Fan, Y., Ding, Y., Xiong, M. & Others Aging induces region-specific dysregulation of hormone synthesis in the primate adrenal gland. Nature Aging. 4, 396-413 (2024)
2024
-
[38]
& Others The innate immunity protein IFITM3 modulates γ−secretase in Alzheimer’s disease
Hur, J., Frost, G., Wu, X., Crump, C., Pan, S., Wong, E., Barros, M., Li, T., Nie, P., Zhai, Y. & Others The innate immunity protein IFITM3 modulates γ−secretase in Alzheimer’s disease. Nature. 586, 735-740 (2020)
2020
-
[39]
& Sinclair, D
Lu, Y., Tian, X. & Sinclair, D. The information theory of aging. Nature Aging. 3, 1486-1499 (2023) 17
2023
Reviewed August 16, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.