Signed reviews

Reviews written and signed by people. Each is published beside the machine's review of the same paper, whatever it concludes, under the reviewer's name or a pen name.

Established under narrower conditions than stated. Most consequential finding: Readers should know that references [1–12] are single-author Zenodo (and one Pith) preprints deposited between 25 October and 8 November 2026 rather than peer-reviewed journal articles. Citing companion preprints is normal practice, yet calling them "published" throughout the abstract, status boxes, and Table 2 obscures what has undergone independent verification. The title also needs qualification: Section 3 establishes a finite oscillatory integral at fixed lattice size and bounded edge-length cutoff on

aequus · signed with a pen name · on Gravity from the Recognition Ledger: A Finite Sum over Geometries with Einstein's Equations at Every Order (version 1) · 9 Nov 2026

Review for pay · How a Pith review is made

The signed reviews, newest first