Pith.

Submit a paper

Have a paper's references checked, have it reviewed by machine, or ask for a signed review by a person.

After a Pith Review you can publish the paper on Pith with its review beside it, or keep both private.

1. What you need

Reference check Free

Every reference looked up and checked for a retraction.

While you wait · listed nowhere

Every reference is looked up in Crossref, DataCite, OpenAlex and arXiv and checked against retraction notices. No language model is used.

Cost
Free
Time
While you wait
Account
Sign in to start
Publishing
Listed nowhere

Pith Review $5

A review by machine: what the paper claims, where it could break, what to fix.

Half finish within 29 min · publish when you choose

A review of the whole paper, written by language models: what it claims, where it could break and what to fix. Yours to keep private or to publish with the paper.

Cost
$5; first free with ORCID
Time
Half finish within 29 min
Account
Sign in at payment
Publishing
When you choose

Human review From $200

A signed review by a person, for a paper on arXiv or on Pith.

7 to 14 days · the review is public

A signed review by a listed reviewer in the paper's field, for a paper on arXiv or on Pith. Due 7, 10 or 14 days after a reviewer accepts, at Pith's price for each.

Cost
From $200
Time
7 to 14 days
Account
Sign in to continue
Publishing
The review is public

2. Your paper

Pith reads the paper's own reference list: from arXiv for an arXiv number, or the list its publisher gave Crossref for a DOI. A paper whose list cannot be read needs the file.

A review reads the whole paper. For a DOI, Pith finds the paper's arXiv version or a free copy that the publisher or a repository posts; a paper with neither needs the file. A paper that already has a publisher's DOI is not posted again on Pith, and you can make its review public.

Human Review is for papers already on arXiv or published on Pith: give the arXiv ID, the Pith address or the Pith DOI. Neither yet? Start with Pith Review. Once the paper is published on Pith, you can order a human review from its page.

The bench opens a paper by its arXiv number, or from the file.

A PDF, a .tex file or a source archive, up to 60 MB. It stays private unless you publish it.A file that holds the reference list (.bbl, .bib, .docx, .pdf, .ris, .tex or .txt), up to 20 MB.A PDF, a .tex file or a source archive, up to 60 MB.

3. Finish

The check starts when you press the button, and its count shows here as it runs. Each problem is quoted with the reference it was found in. It reads up to 150 references. The report gets an address of its own, which Pith lists nowhere; anyone you give the address to can read it.

Pith reads the paper and writes a review: what it claims, what those claims rest on, where it could break and what to fix. The review is emailed to you when it is ready and stays private unless you publish it.

Half of the last 100 reviews finished within 29 minutes of being sent, 9 in 10 within 66 minutes. measured 15 Oct to 15 Nov 2026

Your first review is free when you sign in with ORCID: one free review for each account.

How publishing works

When the review finishes, its page has a button, Publish on Pith. It publishes the paper with its review beside it, free, whatever the review concludes: there is no score a paper has to reach. For $10 Pith also puts the paper on the record: a DOI for a paper that is not on arXiv, and the exact PDF anchored in Bitcoin.

A paper that already has a publisher's DOI is not posted again: you can make its review public. The full rules.

Next you say who is asking for the review, pick a deadline (7, 10 or 14 days, counted from the hour a reviewer accepts) and see Pith's price for each.

The bench opens the paper with its sentences labelled, yes-or-no answers on any passage, and analyses written on request. It is open to invited teams.

Leave it empty if you have already opened the bench in this browser.