Historical origins of quantum entanglement in particle physics
Pith reviewed 2026-05-19 04:58 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
Bohm and Aharonov recognized in 1957 that the 1949 Wu-Shaknov experiment realized the first spatially separated EPR correlation.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
The central claim is that the 1949 Wu-Shaknov experiment, with theoretical backing from Ward, Price, Snyder, Pasternack and Hornbostel, provided the first explicit experimental realization of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlation in a controlled particle-physics setting, as noted by Bohm and Aharonov in 1957, while Goldhaber, Lee and Yang introduced the first entangled kaon-pair states in 1958.
What carries the argument
Chronological reconstruction of primary calculations and publications from 1949 to 1960 that link the Wu-Shaknov setup to EPR correlations and extend entanglement to neutral kaon pairs via selection rules and two-state descriptions.
If this is right
- The Wu-Shaknov data already contained measurable EPR correlations before Bell's inequality was formulated.
- Goldhaber-Lee-Yang kaon-pair states supplied the first example of entanglement in internal degrees of freedom of unstable particles.
- Post-1964 attempts to test Bell inequalities with particle experiments were directly motivated by these earlier realizations.
- Lee and Yang's 1960 unpublished discussion already explored observable consequences of neutral-kaon entanglement.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- Similar re-examination of other pre-1960 particle experiments could uncover additional early instances of recognized quantum correlations.
- The timeline suggests entanglement ideas entered high-energy physics through selection-rule calculations rather than through abstract foundational debates alone.
- Modern kaon experiments might benefit from revisiting the 1958 entangled-state formalism for fresh tests of quantum mechanics.
Load-bearing premise
That the 1957 Bohm-Aharonov analysis together with the cited calculations and 1958 Goldhaber-Lee-Yang work fully and accurately represent the historical record without earlier explicit identifications.
What would settle it
Finding a publication or private note before 1957 that explicitly states the Wu-Shaknov experiment realizes spatially separated EPR entanglement would disprove the claim that this recognition first occurred in 1957.
Figures
read the original abstract
In this paper, the historical origins of quantum entanglement in particle physics are systematically and thoroughly investigated. 1957, Bohm and Aharonov noted that the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen correlation had been experimentally realised in the 1949 experiment of Chien-Shiung Wu and Shaknov. This was the first time in history that spatially separated quantum entanglement was explicitly realised in a controlled experiment. Wheeler first proposed such an experiment as a test of quantum electrodynamics, but his calculation was in error; the correct theoretical calculations came from Ward and Price, as well as from Snyder, Pasternack and Hornbostel, and the result was in accordance with Yang's 1949 selection rule. After the publication of Bell's inequality in 1964, it was considered whether it could be tested by using the Wu-Shaknov experiment. This gave an impetus to the field, and a new experiment was done by Wu's group, though it was not successful as a test of Bell inequality violation. In 1957, Tsung-Dao Lee, Reinhard Oehme and Chen Ning Yang established the quantum mechanical description of the kaons and found that the neutral kaon is a two-state system. In 1958, based on an approach similar to Yang's 1949 selection rule, Goldhaber, Lee and Yang were the first to write down the entangled states of kaon pairs, in which a single kaon can be charged or neutral. This gave, for the first time, quantum entanglement of internal degrees of freedom of high-energy particles other than photons. In 1960, as unpublished work, Lee and Yang discussed the consequences of quantum entanglement of neutral kaon pairs. We also describe several physicists in the past, especially Ward. A Chinese version of this paper was published in early 2023.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript reconstructs the historical origins of quantum entanglement concepts in particle physics. It claims that Bohm and Aharonov in 1957 first explicitly identified the 1949 Wu-Shaknov positronium annihilation experiment as realizing EPR correlations (spatially separated entanglement), following Wheeler's QED-test proposal and corrections by Ward, Price, Snyder et al. that aligned with Yang's 1949 selection rule. It further traces post-1964 Bell-inequality considerations leading to a new Wu-group experiment, the 1957 Lee-Oehme-Yang two-state description of neutral kaons, the 1958 Goldhaber-Lee-Yang entangled kaon-pair states, and unpublished 1960 Lee-Yang work on neutral-kaon entanglement consequences, while noting contributions from physicists such as Ward.
Significance. If the historical attributions hold, the paper supplies a coherent timeline that situates early particle-physics experiments and kaon theory within the broader development of entanglement ideas, bridging pre-Bell QED tests with later Bell-test motivations and extending entanglement discussions beyond photons to internal degrees of freedom of high-energy particles. It thereby fills a documented gap in the historiography of quantum mechanics in high-energy contexts and credits specific early calculations and selection rules.
major comments (2)
- [Abstract and introduction] Abstract and introduction: the central claim that the 1949 Wu-Shaknov experiment constituted the 'first time in history that spatially separated quantum entanglement was explicitly realised in a controlled experiment' rests on the 1957 Bohm-Aharonov note without direct quotation, side-by-side comparison to the 1949 primary sources, or explicit discussion of whether the entanglement framing was contemporaneous or retrospective; this interpretive step is load-bearing for the 'explicit' and 'first' qualifiers.
- [Abstract and introduction] The manuscript does not describe the methods used to verify archival sources or to assess potential gaps in the cited references (e.g., Wheeler's original proposal versus the corrected calculations by Ward et al.), which directly affects the reliability of the reconstructed sequence presented in the abstract and subsequent sections.
minor comments (2)
- [Abstract] The final sentence noting the prior Chinese version (early 2023) should include a full citation with journal or repository details for proper scholarly attribution.
- Figure or timeline clarity: if a chronological diagram of events is present, ensure all cited works (Ward, Price, Snyder et al., Goldhaber-Lee-Yang) are explicitly labeled with years and key contributions.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for the careful reading of the manuscript and for the constructive comments, which help clarify the presentation of our historical reconstruction. We address each major comment below and indicate the revisions we will make.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: [Abstract and introduction] Abstract and introduction: the central claim that the 1949 Wu-Shaknov experiment constituted the 'first time in history that spatially separated quantum entanglement was explicitly realised in a controlled experiment' rests on the 1957 Bohm-Aharonov note without direct quotation, side-by-side comparison to the 1949 primary sources, or explicit discussion of whether the entanglement framing was contemporaneous or retrospective; this interpretive step is load-bearing for the 'explicit' and 'first' qualifiers.
Authors: We agree that the interpretive attribution requires stronger textual support. The manuscript bases the claim on the explicit statement in Bohm and Aharonov (1957) that the Wu-Shaknov experiment realized EPR correlations. In the revised version we will insert direct quotations from the 1957 note, juxtapose them with the relevant 1949 experimental and theoretical passages (including Yang's selection rule and the corrected calculations), and add a brief discussion noting that the entanglement framing was supplied retrospectively by Bohm and Aharonov while the original experiment was motivated as a QED test. These additions will appear in both the abstract and the introduction. revision: yes
-
Referee: [Abstract and introduction] The manuscript does not describe the methods used to verify archival sources or to assess potential gaps in the cited references (e.g., Wheeler's original proposal versus the corrected calculations by Ward et al.), which directly affects the reliability of the reconstructed sequence presented in the abstract and subsequent sections.
Authors: We accept that a short statement on source verification would improve transparency. The reconstruction draws on published primary literature rather than unpublished archives, and discrepancies such as Wheeler's initial error were identified by direct comparison with the subsequent corrections of Ward, Price, Snyder et al. In the revised manuscript we will add a concise paragraph in the introduction describing the literature-search approach, the cross-checking of calculations against Yang's 1949 rule, and the absence of contradictory contemporary sources that would alter the timeline. revision: yes
Circularity Check
No circularity: historical narrative rests on external citations without self-referential reduction
full rationale
The paper contains no equations, derivations, fitted parameters, or ansatzes. Its central claims consist of historical attributions (e.g., Bohm-Aharonov 1957 noting the 1949 Wu-Shaknov experiment, Yang 1949 selection rule, Goldhaber-Lee-Yang 1958 entangled kaon states) that are grounded in citations to independently published external works. These citations function as external benchmarks rather than self-citations whose content is presupposed by the present paper. No step reduces by construction to the paper's own inputs; the sequence of events is presented as a factual reconstruction supported by primary sources outside the manuscript. Per the evaluation criteria, this qualifies as a self-contained historical account with score 0.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
axioms (1)
- domain assumption Historical events, publications, and attributions are accurately represented based on available records and prior literature.
Forward citations
Cited by 1 Pith paper
-
Quantumness of top quark pairs produced at LHC within SMEFT framework
Quantum information observables in LHC top quark pair production are modified by SMEFT dimension-6 operators in ways that depend on their CP properties, offering a complementary probe beyond standard observables.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Price Price was a student co-supervised by M. Born and R. H. Fowler at Cambridge University in England. He also visited Princeton during his studies, and learnt from W. Pauli and J. von Neumann, and later became Born’s son-in-law. The solar neutrino conjecture usually attributed to B. Pontecorvo was initially an idea of Price, when they were both working ...
work page 1946
-
[2]
He did. And I quickly wrote a paper based on his work
Ward The other part of Ward’s PhD thesis was to extend J. Schwinger’s electron self-energy renormalisation from first order to all orders [10, 11]. After a year as a tutor at the University of Sydney, he returned to Oxford to defend his PhD thesis, followed by two years of research at Oxford, discovering the Ward’s identity, which became his most famous w...
work page 1952
-
[3]
continuous grav- itational collapse
Snyder Snyder was a student of J. Oppenheimer. In 1939, they proposed the “continuous grav- itational collapse” [18]. In 1947, Snyder published a paper on quantised spacetime [19], which, incidently, was further discussed by Chen Ning Yang as a PhD student in the same year [20]. In the 1950s, Snyder, together with E. D. Courant and Livingston, proposed th...
work page 1939
-
[4]
Pasternak Pasternak was one of the first theorists to focus on the phenomenon that came to be known as the Lamb shift [24]. In 1934, W. Houston and Y. M. Hsieh of the California Institute of Technology discovered that the Balmer line series of the hydrogen atom spectrum (the spectral lines emitted when an electron jumps from a higher energy level to the s...
work page 1934
-
[5]
Wu-Shaknov experiment In 1949, Wu and her student I. Shaknov studied the quantum-entangled photons pro- duced from the electron-positron annihilation by measuring their angular correlation after 9 respective scattering [27], and confirmed the theoretical predictions of Wheeler, Ward-Pryce, and Snyder-Pasternak-Hornbostel. Prior to the work of Chien-Shiung...
work page 1949
-
[6]
Yang’s selection rule Wu-Shaknov experiment was fully consistent with Yang’s selection rule (a particle of spin 1 cannot be decay into two photons). In 1949, based on the invariance of rotation and inversion, Chen Ning Yang presented the selection rule for the decay of a particle into two photons [16, 28]. This work is also directly related to meson decay...
work page 1949
-
[7]
Connection with the concept of quantum entanglement Prior to 1950, the concept of photon pairs generated by electron-positron annihilation, including the papers by Yang and by Wu and Shaknov, was not connected with the concept of quantum entanglement. Now we come to the trend of quantum entanglement. In 1935, a few months after the publication of the EPR ...
work page 1950
-
[8]
Can the Wu-Shaknov experiment be used to test Bell inequality? Bell inequality, published in 1964, is an inequality satisfied by several correlation functions calculated under the assumption of local realism. In the case of photons, for example, each correlation function describes the correlation between polarisation components of two pho- tons in differe...
work page 1964
-
[9]
In the entangled states of kaons written down by Goldhaber, Lee and Yang, there is superposition between charged and neutral states, with 4 of the entangled states being superpositions of states with positive and negative unit charges and neutral particle and antiparticle states. If we forbid the quantum coherence between charged and neutral states, as a ...
work page 1961
-
[10]
Later people only considered neutral kaons
Here it was not constrained that each kaon in the product must be neutral. Later people only considered neutral kaons. This paper was the first noting that two kaons (or any kinds of particles besides photons) can be entangled.’ In the unpublished work by Lee and Yang in 1960, the joint probability calculated for the neutral kaon entangled state (and a la...
work page 1960
-
[11]
Can quantum-mechanical description of physical reality be considered complete? Phys
EINSTEIN A, PODOLSKY B, ROSEN N. Can quantum-mechanical description of physical reality be considered complete? Phys. Rev. 1935, 47: 777
work page 1935
-
[12]
SCHR ¨ODINGER E. Discussion of time-probability relations between separated systems, mathematical proceedings of the cambridge philosophical society. Cambridge University Press, 1935, 31(4): 555
work page 1935
- [13]
-
[14]
On Einstien-Podolsy-Rosen paradox
BELL J. On Einstien-Podolsy-Rosen paradox. Physics, 1964, 1: 195
work page 1964
-
[15]
Y. Shi, The road of quantum entanglement: from Einstein to 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, Chinese Journal of Nature 44 (6), 455-465 (2022), available at https://www.nature.shu.edu.cn/CN/10.3969/j.issn.0253-9608.2022.06.005. The video of the talk at the 2022 Fall meeting of Chinese Physical Socity is available at https://www.koushare.com/live/details/12750?vid=37918
-
[16]
SHI Y. Prof. C. N. Yang and quantum entanglement in particle physics, proceedings of the conference in honor of C N Yang’s 85th birthday. Ed: Ge M L, Oh C H, Phua K K. Singapore: World Scientific, 2008, p. 521
work page 2008
- [17]
-
[18]
Angular correlation effects with annihilation radiation
PRYCE M H L, WARD J C. Angular correlation effects with annihilation radiation. Nature, 1947, 160: 435
work page 1947
-
[19]
Angular correlation of scattered annihi- lation radiation
SNYDER H, PASTERNACK S, HORNBOSTEL J. Angular correlation of scattered annihi- lation radiation. Phys. Rev. 1948, 73: 440
work page 1948
-
[20]
Memoirs of a theoretical physicist
WARD J C. Memoirs of a theoretical physicist. Opt. J., 2014
work page 2014
- [21]
-
[22]
DALITZ R H, DUARTE F J. John Clive Ward. Phys. Today, 2000, 53(10): 99. 22
work page 2000
-
[23]
How the ghost particles the neutrinos appeared
SHI Y. How the ghost particles the neutrinos appeared. Chinese Journal of Science 2019, 71(5): 46
work page 2019
-
[24]
Clarification of early history of neutrino
SHI Y. Clarification of early history of neutrino. Mod. Phys. Lett., 2016, 31: 1630043
work page 2016
-
[25]
Statistical theory of equations of state and phase transitions
LEE T D, YANG C N. Statistical theory of equations of state and phase transitions. II. Lattice gas and Ising model. Phys. Rev., 1952, 87(3): 410
work page 1952
-
[26]
Selected papers 1945-1980 with commentary[ M]
YANG C N. Selected papers 1945-1980 with commentary[ M]. Beijing: Company Publishers, 1983
work page 1945
-
[27]
The Guard of Science: Steven Weinberg
SHI Y. The Guard of Science: Steven Weinberg. Journal of Low Temperature Physics, 2022, 44: 251
work page 2022
-
[28]
On continued gravitational contraction
OPPENHEIMER J R, SNYDER H S. On continued gravitational contraction. Phys. Rev., 1939, 56: 455
work page 1939
- [29]
- [30]
-
[31]
The strong-focusing synchrotron - a new high energy accelerator
COURANT E D, LIVINGSTON M S, SNYDER H S. The strong-focusing synchrotron - a new high energy accelerator. Phys. Rev., 1952, 88(5): 1190
work page 1952
-
[32]
Theory of the alternating-gradient synchrotron
COURANT E D, SNYDER H S. Theory of the alternating-gradient synchrotron. Ann. Phys., 2000, 3: 360
work page 2000
- [33]
-
[34]
CREASE R P, MANN C C. The second creation. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press, 1986
work page 1986
-
[35]
BROWN L.. The birth of particle physics. Ed: HODDESON L, Cambridge: Cambridge Uni- versity Press, 1983
work page 1983
- [36]
-
[37]
The Angular correlation of scattered annihilation radiation
WU C S, SHAKNOV I. The Angular correlation of scattered annihilation radiation. Phys. Rev., 1950, 77: 136
work page 1950
-
[38]
Selection rules for the dematerialization of a particle into two photons
YANG C N. Selection rules for the dematerialization of a particle into two photons. Phys. Rev., 1950, 77: 242
work page 1950
-
[39]
Die gegenwartige situation in der quantenmechanik
SCHR?DINGER E. Die gegenwartige situation in der quantenmechanik. Naturwissenschaften, 1935, 23: 807
work page 1935
-
[40]
Probability relations between separated systems
SCHR?DINGER E. Probability relations between separated systems. Mathematical Proc. Cambridge Phil. Soc., 1936, 32: 446. 23
work page 1936
-
[41]
Note on the quantum-mechanical theory of measurement
FURRY W H. Note on the quantum-mechanical theory of measurement. Phys. Rev., 1936, 49: 393
work page 1936
-
[42]
Remarks on measurements in quantum theory
FURRY W H. Remarks on measurements in quantum theory. Phys. Rev., 1936, 49: 476
work page 1936
-
[43]
Discussion of experimental proof for the paradox of Einstein, Rosen, and Podolsky
BOHM D, AHARONOV Y. Discussion of experimental proof for the paradox of Einstein, Rosen, and Podolsky. Phys. Rev., 1957, 108: 1070
work page 1957
-
[44]
C S Wu’s contributions: a retrospective in 2015
YANG C N. C S Wu’s contributions: a retrospective in 2015. Int. J. Mod. Phys. A, 2015, 30: 1530050
work page 2015
-
[45]
BROMBERG J. A. Shimony interview[DB/OL]. [2022- 05-20]. https://www.aip.org/history- programs/nielsbohr- library/roal-histories/25096
work page 2022
-
[46]
Proposed experiment to test local hiddenvariable theories
CLAUSER J F, HORNE M A, SHIMONY A, HOLT R A. Proposed experiment to test local hiddenvariable theories. Phys. Rev. Lett., 1969, 23: 880
work page 1969
-
[47]
Early History of Bell’s Theorem, Quantum [Un]speakable: from bell to quan- tum information
CLAUSER J F. Early History of Bell’s Theorem, Quantum [Un]speakable: from bell to quan- tum information. Ed: BERTLMANN R, ZEILINGER A. Berlin: Springer, 2002
work page 2002
-
[48]
The infamous boundary seven decades of heresy in quantum physics
WICK D. The infamous boundary seven decades of heresy in quantum physics. New York: Springer, 1998
work page 1998
-
[49]
Angular correlation of compton-scattered annihilation photons and hidden variables
KASDAY L R, ULLMAN J D, WU C S. Angular correlation of compton-scattered annihilation photons and hidden variables. Il Nuovo Cimento B (1971-1996), 1975, 25: 633
work page 1971
-
[50]
LAMEHI-RACHTI M, MITTIG W. Quantum mechanics and hidden variables: a test of Bell’s inequality by the measurement of the spin correlation in low-energy proton-proton scattering. Phys. Rev. D, 1976, 14: 2543
work page 1976
-
[51]
Question of parity conservation in weak interactions
LEE T D, YANG C N. Question of parity conservation in weak interactions. Phys. Rev., 1956, 104: 254
work page 1956
-
[52]
Beauty and Physics:13 important contributions of Chen NingYang, Int
SHI Y, Beautyof Physics: Scientific Contributions of ChenNingYang, Journal of Low Temper- ature Physics, 2022, 44: 1; SHI Y. Beauty and Physics:13 important contributions of Chen NingYang, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 29 (17),1475001 (2014)
work page 2022
-
[53]
Remarks on possible noninvariance under time reversal and charge conjugation[ J]
LEE T D, OEHME R, YANG C N. Remarks on possible noninvariance under time reversal and charge conjugation[ J]. Phys. Rev., 1957, 106: 340
work page 1957
-
[54]
Behavior of neutral particles under charge conjugation
GELL-MANN M, PAIS A. Behavior of neutral particles under charge conjugation. Phys. Rev., 1955, 97: 1387
work page 1955
-
[55]
Decay modes of a ( θ + ¯θ) system
GOLDHABER M, LEE T D, YANG C N. Decay modes of a ( θ + ¯θ) system. Phys. Rev., 1958, 112: 1796. 24
work page 1958
-
[56]
Completeness of quantum mechanics and charge-conjugation correlations of theta particles
INGLIS D R. Completeness of quantum mechanics and charge-conjugation correlations of theta particles. Rev. Mod. Phys., 1961, 33: 1
work page 1961
-
[57]
Demonstration of quantum mechanics in the large
DAY T B. Demonstration of quantum mechanics in the large. Phys. Rev., 1961, 121: 1204
work page 1961
-
[58]
High energy quantum teleportation using neutral kaons
SHI Y. High energy quantum teleportation using neutral kaons. Phys. Lett., 2006, 75
work page 2006
-
[59]
CP measurement in quantum teleportation of neutral mesons
SHI Y, WU Y L. CP measurement in quantum teleportation of neutral mesons. Euro. Phys. J. C, 2008, 55: 477
work page 2008
-
[60]
HUANG Z, SHI Y. Extracting rephase-invariant CP and CPT violating parameters from asymmetries of time-ordered integrated rates of correlated decays of entangled mesons. Euro. Phys. J. C, 2012, 72: 1900
work page 2012
-
[61]
SHI Y. Exact theorems concerning CP and CPT violating in C = ?1 entangled state of pseudoscalar neutral mesons. Euro. Phys. J. C, 2012, 72: 1907
work page 2012
-
[62]
Some exact results on CP and CPT violations in a C = ?1 entangled pseudoscalar neutral meson pair
SHI Y. Some exact results on CP and CPT violations in a C = ?1 entangled pseudoscalar neutral meson pair. Euro. Phys. J. C, 2013, 73: 2506
work page 2013
-
[63]
HUANG Z, SHI Y. CP and CPT violating parameters determined from the joint decays of C = +1 entangled neutral pseudoscalar mesons. Phys. Rev. D, 2014, 89: 016018
work page 2014
-
[64]
Time reversal symmetry violation in entangled pseudoscalar neutral charmed mesons
SHI Y, YANG J. Time reversal symmetry violation in entangled pseudoscalar neutral charmed mesons. Phys. Rev. D, 2018, 98: 075079
work page 2018
-
[65]
SHI Y, YANG J. Entangled baryons: violation of inequalities based on local realism assuming dependence of decays on hidden variables. Euro. Phys. J. C, 2020, 80: 116
work page 2020
-
[66]
Particle physics violating cryptononlocal realism
SHI Y, YANG J. Particle physics violating cryptononlocal realism. Euro. Phys. J. C, 2020, 80: 861
work page 2020
-
[67]
JAMMER M. The philosophy of quantum mechanics: the interpretations of quantum me- chanics in historical perspective. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1974
work page 1974
-
[68]
LEE T D. Are black holes black bodies?. Nucl. Phys. B, 1986, 264: 437
work page 1986
-
[69]
John S Bell on the foundations of quantum mechanics
BELL M, GOTTFRIED K. John S Bell on the foundations of quantum mechanics. ED: VELT- MAN M. Singapore: World Scientific, 2001. 25
work page 2001
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.