REVIEW 4 major objections 5 minor 23 references
Extracting more information from entropy
T0 review · 4 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-10 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read The paper claims that a thermalizing plasma's entropy stairway encodes twice the lowest quasinormal-mode frequency, and that a quadratic ansatz in the pressure anisotropy reproduces the stairway.
desk verdict Credible new observation of QNM doubling in the entropy stairway, but the explanatory model is a post-hoc fit whose central relation is never tested pointwise. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central object is the model ansatz of Eq. (3): $d\hat{s}/d\tau = K P^2$, where $P$ is the dimensionless pressure anisotropy (or, at finite density, the scalar condensate anisotropy $\Phi$) fitted as a single damped sinusoid $A e^{-a\tau}\sin(b\tau+B)$ with $a$ and $b$ fixed to the lowest quasinormal mode. Squaring the sinusoid produces a term that oscillates at frequency $2b$ and decays at rate $2a$, which is precisely the observed stairway structure; integration yields plateaus whenever $|P|$ transiently vanishes, and entropy production peaks at anisotropy extrema. The fitted constant $K$ comes out near $\pi$, and a residual phase deficit of about 1.2 is left unexplained.
What would settle it
Use a holographic model whose lowest quasinormal mode is known and purely imaginary, with no oscillation, and check whether the entropy stairway still shows periodic treads; the central relation predicts a monotonic rise at rate twice the imaginary part with no periodic plateaus, so any observed periodicity would falsify it. More directly, at late times compare the numerically computed $d\hat{s}/d\tau$ pointwise with $K P^2$ using independently known $a$ and $b$: if a single $K$ cannot fit the data or residuals grow with time, the quadratic ansatz fails.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
On its own terms, the discovery is that the complex frequency of the lowest quasinormal mode is imprinted in the equilibrium approach of the entropy density. For the purely thermal supersymmetric Yang-Mills plasma, the entropy stairway has slope about 17.3 and period about 0.32, which are exactly twice the decay rate 8.64 and twice the angular frequency 9.81 that characterize the lowest quasinormal mode of the pressure anisotropy, with the pair $(9.81,8.64)/\pi \approx (3.12,2.75)$ matching the known SYM result. The proposed encoding is $d\hat{s}/d\tau = K P^2$, with $P = A e^{-a\tau}\sin(b\tau+B)$; integrating it gives a rising, oscillating entropy whose late-time slope is $2a$ and frequency is $2b$. At finite chemical potential the same ansatz is applied to the scalar condensate anisotropy, whose lowest quasinormal mode $(3.81 - i 1.44)$ drives the stairway, and the dominant dissipation channel can switch from pressure anisotropy to scalar condensate depending on $\mu/T$.
Load-bearing premise
The argument stands or falls on the assumption that entropy production is proportional to the square of one damped sinusoid whose frequency and decay are those of the lowest quasinormal mode, with amplitude, phase, and proportionality constant fitted to the same entropy data the model is meant to explain.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- Entropy time series alone can be used to read off the lowest quasinormal-mode frequency of the dominant dissipative channel, without separately computing pressure anisotropy or scalar condensate.
- Each plateau in the stairway marks a transient isotropization where entropy production nearly ceases; maximum entropy production coincides with anisotropy extrema, so isotropy is isentropic while anisotropy is dissipative.
- At finite chemical potential, the stairway's slope can change during a single evolution when the pressure anisotropy and scalar condensate anisotropies cross, indicating a shift in the dominant dissipation channel.
- The model predicts that any homogeneous isotropization process approaching equilibrium should form an entropy stairway encoding the lowest complex quasinormal mode of the dominant channel, a universality that can be checked in other holographic models.
Reading between the lines
- Our inference: if the relation holds generally, transport coefficients and relaxation times of strongly coupled plasmas could be extracted from entropy measurements alone, turning the stairway into a thermodynamic quasinormal-mode spectrometer.
- Our inference: the unexplained constant phase shift of about 1.2 likely encodes nonlinear early-time information; tracking its dependence on initial conditions might give a new probe of far-from-equilibrium physics beyond linear response.
- Our inference: the quadratic dependence $d\hat{s}/d\tau \propto P^2$ resembles a power-loss relation across a black hole horizon; deriving it from the gravitational equations rather than fitting it would strengthen the claim and could reveal when higher-order terms in $P$ become necessary.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript analyzes previously computed holographic entropy-density data from the homogeneous isotropization dynamics of the 1RCBH model (Ref. [7]). Defining S = ln(seq/(seq - s)), the authors extract a late-time 'stairway' with slope ≈17.3 and period ≈0.32, which they identify with twice the imaginary and real parts of the lowest QNM of the pressure anisotropy, 9.81 − i 8.64. They then propose in Eq. (3) that the dimensionless entropy production rate is proportional to the square of the pressure anisotropy P, with P modeled as a single damped sinusoid (Eq. (4)) whose frequency and decay rate are set to the known QNM values. Integrating this ansatz yields a stairway with slope 2a and frequency 2b, and fitting A, B, K to the data gives the magenta curves in Figs. 1 and 2. The same construction is applied to the scalar condensate anisotropy Φ at finite chemical potential, using the singlet QNM 3.81 − i 1.44 (Fig. 5), and the manuscript claims that the dominant dissipation channel can shift between pressure anisotropy and scalar condensate depending on μ, as illustrated in Fig. 6. The paper candidly acknowledges that the modeled stairway is out of phase with the holographic one by ≈1.2 and that this phase shift is not explained by the model.
Significance. The reported numerical extraction from entropy—stairway slope 17.3 ≈ 2×8.64 and period 0.32 consistent with 2×9.81—is a credible and potentially useful empirical observation, and it is properly grounded in the known QNM spectrum. If the relation in Eq. (3) between entropy production and the square of the anisotropy were established pointwise and with error control, it would provide a concrete connection between dissipation channels and QNM data in holographic isotropization. The paper's strength is its transparent use of known QNM values and its candid discussion of limitations in Section V. However, the central explanatory claim is not currently established: the matching slope and period are inserted by hand through the choice of a and b, the parameters A, B, K, and the additive phase are fitted to the very data the model is meant to explain, and the admitted phase deficit of ≈1.2 indicates that Eq. (3) does not hold pointwise. The finite-μ extension in Section IV has the same structure. That the paper explicitly states the phase shift 'must be determined numerically' is an important self-acknowledged limitation, but it does not by itself validate the ansatz.
major comments (4)
- [Section III, Eqs. (3)–(7)] The evidence for the central ansatz dŝ/dτ = K P² is not a test of the relation; it is a consistency check. In Eq. (4), a = 8.64 and b = 9.81 are fixed to the QNM values extracted in Section II, and integrating P² then necessarily produces a stairway with slope 2a and frequency 2b. Therefore the agreement between the integrated model and the extracted slope/period shows only that the parametrization is self-consistent, not that entropy production is proportional to P². A pointwise comparison is needed: compute dŝ/dτ from the holographic s(τ) data, compare it with K P(τ)² for the fitted P, and report residuals, uncertainties, and a goodness-of-fit measure. Without this, the manuscript's central claim is unsupported.
- [Section III, Figs. 1–2 and text after Eq. (7)] The modeled stairway is out of phase with the holographic stairway by ≈1.2 in τ, as stated after Eq. (7). The authors concede that this phase deficit/excess is not explained and 'must be determined numerically' (Section V). Since this offset is comparable to the stairway's step width and since the slope and frequency are already inputs rather than outputs, the statement in the Conclusions that 'the model successfully explains the stairway structure' is too strong. The phase mismatch should be presented either as a quantitative failure of Eq. (3) for the full stairway, or the model's scope should be explicitly restricted to late-time envelope properties.
- [Section III and Section IV, model parameters] The quantities A, B, K, and the additive phase are all fitted to the same entropy/anisotropy data that the model is supposed to explain, and no error bars or stability analysis are provided. In particular, the value K ≈ π is quoted without uncertainty (text after Eq. (7)), and the finite-μ extension in Fig. 5 quotes A = 4.95, B ≈ −0.70, K ≈ 0.30 without any fit-quality statistic. This leaves the predictive content of the model unclear. The authors should report parameter uncertainties and, ideally, test whether the fitted K is consistent across the different initial conditions and chemical potentials shown in Fig. 6.
- [Section IV, Fig. 6] The new finite-μ claim—that the stairway's rate of increase changes when ln|Φ| > ln|P|—is supported only by vertical lines marking estimated crossing times. The manuscript does not state how these crossing times are estimated from the anisotropy data, nor does it give uncertainties or a quantitative comparison between the crossing times and the visually inferred changes in the stairway slope. Since this is the central new feature of Section IV, it should be formulated quantitatively, for example by measuring the local slope of S before and after the crossing time and comparing it with the predicted QNM-driven values.
minor comments (5)
- [Figure 3 caption] The caption says 'based on extraction (Section I)', but the extraction is performed in Section II; the reference should be corrected.
- [Throughout] The manuscript contains several typographical errors that should be fixed: 'evelopments', 'Cosenquently', 'balck hole', and 'the the late-time'.
- [Section III, Eqs. (5)–(7)] The notation is confusing because K denotes both the constant in Eq. (3) and the function K(τ) in Eqs. (5)–(6); consider renaming the integral or the constant.
- [Section III, text after Eq. (7)] The statement that Eq. (5) coincides with Eq. (1) of Ref. [14] would be more useful with a brief explanation of what Eq. (1) of [14] represents, since the comparison is not self-evident from this manuscript alone.
- [Section II, extraction] The extraction is illustrated for only one initial condition, while the text claims 'for any initial data that was considered.' A supplementary figure or table summarizing the extracted slope and period for all initial conditions would make the claim easier to verify.
Circularity Check
Section II's entropy-to-QNM extraction is independent, but the 'explanation' in Sections III-IV reduces to integrating the square of the very QNM that was put in: the slope and frequency of the modeled stairway are inputs, not predictions.
-
fitted input called prediction
[Section III, Eqs. (3)-(7)]
"Based on the extraction, we propose the following ansatz d s /d τ = K P 2 ... P = A e −aτ sin(bτ + B) ... Note that, based on the previous section, we have used a = 8.64 and b = 9.81. ... Integrating (3) we obtain ..."
The values a = 8.64 and b = 9.81 are inserted into P as inputs, taken from the known lowest QNM and from the same stairway whose slope and period were extracted in Section II. Since dŝ/dτ = K P² integrates to a term with linear growth 2a and oscillations of frequency 2b, the modeled slope ≈ 17.3 and frequency corresponding to period ≈ 0.32 are consequences of the chosen input, not outputs of the model. The remaining constants A, B, and K are fitted to the same holographic data, and the paper concedes that the modeled stairway is out of phase by ≈ 1.2. Thus the agreement is an algebraic identity plus fitting, not an independent test of dŝ/dτ = K P².
-
fitted input called prediction
[Section IV, around Eq. (8) and Fig. 5]
"For this plot the fitting parameters are A = 4.95, B ≈ −0.70, K ≈ 0.30, considering the extracted values of the lowest complex frequency for the singlet channel a 3.81 − i 1.44 [10]. The referential red dashed lines have slopes twice 1.44 and are shifted to be tangents to the stairway by above and below; the frequency of the stairway is twice 3.81."
The extension repeats the same reduction: the singlet QNM values (decay rate 1.44 and frequency 3.81) are inserted as a and b in the same quadratic ansatz, so integrating the square reproduces slope 2 × 1.44 and frequency 2 × 3.81 by construction. The constant K is fitted to the scalar-condensate data, and no independent pointwise comparison or error analysis is provided. Consequently the agreement of the modeled stairway with the holographic stairway does not independently confirm the model; it restates the assumed QNM parameters.
full rationale
The genuinely non-circular part is Section II: the slope and period of the entropy stairway are measured from the holographic data and then compared with independently known QNM values. That comparison is a real, meaningful observation. The circularity appears when Sections III and IV present the ansatz dŝ/dτ = K P², with P given by a damped sinusoid whose decay rate a and frequency b are set equal to the same QNM values one claims to recover. Integrating the square of that P necessarily yields linear growth 2a and oscillations of frequency 2b, so the 'predicted' stairway parameters are determined by the input. The constants A, B, and K are fitted to the same holographic data, and the paper explicitly notes the remaining phase deficit/excess of about 1.2 must be determined numerically. Hence the model's success is a consistency check of a mathematical identity, not an independent derivation. The self-citation to [7] supplies the numerical data and is not itself circular; the QNM frequencies from [12] and [10] are external inputs. Overall, the empirical extraction is sound, but the explanatory relation is not independently tested, making the circularity partial rather than total.
Assumptions & free parameters
free parameters (4)
- A =
30.0 (purely thermal); 4.95 for critical-point fit
- B =
1.65 (purely thermal); -0.70 for critical-point fit
- K =
π (purely thermal); 0.30 for critical-point fit
- additive phase =
1.2
assumptions (4)
- domain assumption Holographic gauge-gravity duality (AdS/CFT) is valid for this system.
- domain assumption The entropy density s computed from the apparent horizon is the non-equilibrium entropy.
- ad hoc to paper The pressure anisotropy and scalar condensate anisotropy each behave as a single damped sinusoid with the lowest QNM frequency at late times.
- ad hoc to paper The ansatz dŝ/dτ = K P² (Eq. 3).
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Extracting more information from entropy." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/4SDMYDRG
@misc{pith2026250102668,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Extracting more information from entropy},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/4SDMYDRG}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2501.02668}
}
read the original abstract
We extract the complex frequency of the lowest quasi-normal mode from the holographically computed entropy density near thermodynamic equilibrium. The system consists of a purely thermal Supersymmetric Yang-Mills N=4 plasma in homogeneous isotropization dynamics. The initial state is far-from-equilibrium, proceeding to thermalization over time. The system evolves to equilibrium entropy forming a stairway pattern. The analysis reveals that the rate of increase of the stairway is twice the decay rate of the lowest quasi-normal mode. This leads us to propose a model explaining how this information is encoded in entropy. The model is extended to consider finite temperature, R-charge density and scalar condensate of the medium, disclosing an additional feature. The system's main dissipation channel may shift to one driven by the scalar condensate, depending on the chemical potential.
Figures
Figures from the paper (4 more)
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[7]
Natsuume, AdS/CFT Duality User Guide, arXiv: 1409.3575 [hep-th]
M. Natsuume, AdS/CFT Duality User Guide, arXiv: 1409.3575 [hep-th]
-
[1]
Witten, Introduction to Black Hole Thermodynamics, arXiv: 2412.16795 [hep-th]
E. Witten, Introduction to Black Hole Thermodynamics, arXiv: 2412.16795 [hep-th]
-
[2]
The magenta dot-dashed line is the modeled stairway, but now using Eq. (8). For this plot the fitting parameters areA = 4.95, B ≈ −0.70, K ≈ 0.30, considering the extracted values of the lowest complex frequency for the singlet channel a 3.81 − i 1.44 [10]. The referential red dashed lines have slopes twice 1.44 and are shifted to be tangents to the stair...
work page 2022
-
[3]
Maldacena, The Large N Limit of Superconformal Field Theories and Supergravity , Adv
J. Maldacena, The Large N Limit of Superconformal Field Theories and Supergravity , Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 231 (1998), arXiv: hep-th/9711200
arXiv 1998
- [4]
-
[5]
Witten, Anti De Sitter Space And Holography, Adv
E. Witten, Anti De Sitter Space And Holography, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 253 (1998), arXiv: hep-th/9802150
arXiv 1998
-
[6]
Witten, Anti-de Sitter Space, Thermal Phase Transition, And Confinement In Gauge Theories, Adv
E. Witten, Anti-de Sitter Space, Thermal Phase Transition, And Confinement In Gauge Theories, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2, 505 (1998), arXiv: hep-th/9803131
arXiv 1998
-
[8]
Stairway to equilibrium entropy
R. Rougemont, W . Barreto,Stairway to equilibrium entropy, Phys. Rev. D 109, 126009 (2024), arXiv: 2402.04529 [hep-th]
work page Pith review arXiv 2024
Show all 23 references
-
[9]
Chesler, L
P . Chesler, L. Yaffe,Horizon formation and far-from-equilibrium isotropization in supersymmetric Yang-Mills plasma, Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 211601 (2009), arXiv: 0812.2053 [hep-th]
2009 arXiv
-
[10]
van der Schee, Gravitational collisions and the quark-gluon plasma, Ph
W . van der Schee, Gravitational collisions and the quark-gluon plasma, Ph. D. thesis, Utrecht U. (2014), arXiv: 1407.1849 [hep-th]
2014 arXiv
-
[11]
Critelli, R
R. Critelli, R. Rougemont, J. Noronha, Homogeneous isotropization and equilibration of a strongly coupled plasma with a critical point, JHEP 12, 029 (2017), arXiv: 1709.03131 [hep-th]
2017 arXiv
-
[12]
Johnson, Harminv: a program to solve the harmonic inversion problem via the filter diagonalization method (fdm), v1.4.2
S. Johnson, Harminv: a program to solve the harmonic inversion problem via the filter diagonalization method (fdm), v1.4.2
-
[13]
Starinets, Quasinormal modes of near extremal black branes, Phys
A. Starinets, Quasinormal modes of near extremal black branes, Phys. Rev. D 66, 124013 (2002), arXiv: hep-th/0207133
2002 arXiv
-
[14]
Jansen, J
J. Jansen, J. Magán, Black hole collapse and democratic models, Phys. Rev. D 94, 104007 (2016), arXiv: 1604.03772 [hep-th]
2016 arXiv
-
[15]
Jansen, B
J. Jansen, B. Meiring, Entropy production from quasinormal modes, Phys. Rev. D 101, 126012 (2020), arXiv: 2001.07220 [hep-th]
2020 arXiv
-
[16]
This was communicated by Lorenzo Gavassino to the authors of [7]
-
[17]
DeWolfe, S
O. DeWolfe, S. Gubser, C. Rosen, Phys. Rev. D 84, 126014 (2011), arXiv:1108.2029 [hep-th]
2011 arXiv
-
[18]
Barreto,Extended two-dimensional characteristic framework to study nonrotating black holes, Phys
W . Barreto,Extended two-dimensional characteristic framework to study nonrotating black holes, Phys. Rev. D 90, 024055 (2014), arXiv: 1407.1716 [gr-qc]
2014 arXiv
-
[19]
Herrera, A
L. Herrera, A. Di Prisco, J. Ospino, Irreversibility and gravitational radiation: A proof of Bondi’s conjecture , Phys. Rev. D 109, 024005 (2024), arXiv: 2401.05959 [gr-qc]
2024 arXiv
-
[20]
De Lescluze, M
M. De Lescluze, M. Heller, Quasinormal modes of nonthermal fixed points, arXiv: 2502.01622 [hep-th]
-
[21]
Godinho, W
G. Godinho, W . Barreto,Are these quasi-normal modes?, Rev. Bras. Física 4 (3) e202411040302 (2024), arXiv: 2409.05930 [hep-th]
2024 arXiv
-
[22]
de Oliveira, R
G. de Oliveira, R. Rougemont, New purely damped pairs of quasinormal modes in a hot and dense strongly-coupled plasma , JHEP 11, 079 (2024), arXiv: 2408.09498 [hep-th]
2024 arXiv
-
[23]
de Oliveira, W
G. de Oliveira, W . Barreto, R. Rougemont,Universality of the entropy stairway in homogeneous isotropization, arXiv:2506.10294 [hep- th]
Reviewed August 10, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.