Moduli space of Conformal Field Theories and non-commutative Riemannian geometry

Yan Soibelman

REVIEW 4 major objections 6 minor 9 references

Moduli space of Conformal Field Theories and non-commutative Riemannian geometry

T0 review · 4 major / 6 minor · reviewed 2026-08-07 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

Pith's one-line read The paper proposes that collapsing unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories, in the limit where the spectral gap of the Virasoro energy goes to zero, have boundary points described by singular Riemannian manifolds with…

desk verdict Programmatic review, not a results paper, honest about that; the central collapse-to-non-negative-Ricci claim is a well-motivated conjecture but rests on an undefined topology and an unverified private communication. read the letter →

arxiv 2506.00896 v1 pith:UQIDZRVW submitted 2025-06-01 hep-th math-phmath.MGmath.MPmath.OAquant-ph

Yan Soibelman This is my paper

classification hep-thmath-phmath.MGmath.MPmath.OAquant-ph MSC 81T4053C2346L8753C21 PACS 11.25.Hf

keywords conformalfieldtheorymodulispacecompactificationGromov-Hausdorffconvergencenon-negativeRiccicurvaturequantumRiemanniangeometryspectraltriplesVirasorooperatormirrorsymmetry

verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

The paper proposes a geometric compactification of the moduli space of unitary two-dimensional conformal field theories. The central claim is that when the spectral gap of the Virasoro operator $L_0+\bar L_0$ tends to zero, a family of CFTs collapses to a quantum Riemannian space whose smooth part is a singular Riemannian manifold with non-negative Ricci curvature. If correct, bounded central charge and bounded spectral gap give a precompact moduli space whose boundary strata are toroidal and $\sigma$-model geometries, and mirror symmetry appears as movement between boundary strata. The paper is framed by the author as a review and set of conjectures rather than a finished theorem; it also defines quantum Riemannian $d$-geometry by functorial axioms generalizing those of CFT and connects it to spectral triples and curvature-dimension inequalities.

What carries the argument

The load-bearing object is a quantum Riemannian 1-space: a monoidal functor from metrized graphs to Hilbert spaces, assigning a trace-class amplitude $S(\Gamma)$ to each metrized graph, with a compact Riemannian manifold giving an example through heat-kernel propagators. The collapse itself is carried by the rescaled Virasoro operator $(L_0+\bar L_0)/\lambda_{\min}$, whose limit plays the role of a generalized Laplacian $L$. The Bakry bilinear forms, especially $B_2(f,f)\ge 0$, encode non-negative Ricci curvature, and the graph axioms QFT6--QFT8 (spectral gap, a seven-term relation, and convexity of the four-edge amplitude) convert CFT data into differential-geometric data.

What would settle it

Find a sequence of unitary CFTs with fixed central charge bound and spectral gap bounded below by a positive constant whose amplitudes have no convergent subsequence in the strong spectral sense of Definition 4.2.1, or exhibit a collapsing sequence where the limit of $(L_0+\bar L_0)/\lambda_{\min}$ fails the Bakry inequality $B_2(f,f)\ge 0$ for some smooth function $f$ on the limiting space.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

On the paper's own terms, unitary CFTs should be regarded as quantum metric-measure spaces: the central charge plays the role of dimension, the smallest positive eigenvalue of $L_0+\bar L_0$ plays the role of the inverse squared diameter, and unitarity (reflection positivity) is analogous to non-negative Ricci curvature. Collapsing a family by letting the spectral gap $\lambda_{\min}$ approach zero and rescaling $L_0+\bar L_0$ by $\lambda_{\min}^{-1}$ produces a commutative algebra $H_{\mathrm{small}}$ whose spectrum is a compact space $X$ with a generalized Laplacian on its smooth part. The paper asserts that Segal's axioms force this limit to satisfy the graph axioms QFT1--QFT8, including the Bakry curvature-dimension inequality $CD(0,\infty)$, so the boundary of the compactified moduli stack is described by quantum Riemannian 1-spaces whose non-negative Ricci curvature is inherited from unitarity.

Load-bearing premise

The argument rests on there being a workable definition of 'close' for conformal field theories, one in which the energy spectrum moves continuously and the limiting spaces converge as metric-measure spaces, and the paper states explicitly that this topology is not defined.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

The moduli space of unitary CFTs with bounded central charge and spectral gap bounded below should be precompact in a natural topology, and its boundary should be stratified by quantum Riemannian spaces.
Sigma models with Calabi-Yau targets and toroidal Narain-lattice models appear as open boundary strata, giving a geometric explanation of why these families sit near the boundary of the CFT moduli space.
Mirror symmetry can be described through flows along the boundary connecting A-models, B-models, and toroidal T-models, without constructing the full superconformal field theory.
Connes-style spectral triples become examples of quantum Riemannian 1-geometry, so non-commutative geometry gains a route toward defining Ricci curvature and diameter in spectral terms.
Compactness of the CFT moduli space would make the counting of string vacua a well-defined finite problem, since the Zamolodchikov volume would control the number of critical points of the prepotential.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

If the compactification picture is right, the physically relevant topology on the space of QFTs may be much coarser than the algebraic moduli topologies used in string theory, which would reframe finiteness questions about the string landscape as metric precompactness questions.
The undefined topology named in the paper suggests the next concrete step is to build a spectral metric on CFT moduli from the heat-kernel or amplitude data themselves, rather than importing measured Gromov-Hausdorff convergence from outside.
Because the central charge is allowed to be non-integer, the framework naturally permits fractional-dimensional quantum Riemannian spaces interpolating between ordinary integer-dimensional geometries, a feature that could be tested on minimal-model and WZW sequences.
The seven-term and convexity axioms QFT6--QFT8 look like a finite axiomatic core from which a non-commutative calculus could be recovered; checking them explicitly on lattice CFTs and rational CFTs would be a concrete program of verification.

Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Desk Editor's Note

read the letter

Dear [Name],

You asked about arXiv:2506.00896. Short version: this is a programmatic review, not a results paper, and the author says so in Section 1.1. If you go in expecting the central slogan to be a theorem, you'll be disappointed. If you want a clear statement of a research program that connects collapsing CFTs to metric geometry, with worked examples and an honest list of open problems, it's worth reading.

What it does well: it lays out a dictionary between degeneration of unitary CFTs (E_min -> 0) and measured Gromov-Hausdorff collapse. The examples are concrete: toroidal models give flat tori, WZW gives SU(2) with the standard metric, minimal models give an interval with the sine-squared metric. These give substance to the analogy. The definitions of quantum Riemannian d-spaces via Segal-style functors are coherent working definitions. The appendix with Kontsevich on QFTs on metric spaces is a historical document with some ideas (cluster expansions, OPE on metric spaces) that may deserve more attention. The paper is honest about what is conjecture and what is review.

The soft spots are real. The central claim that collapsing CFTs have non-negative Ricci curvature in the limit is not proven; Section 6.6 attributes the key implication to a private communication from Kontsevich, with no proof or citable source. Since QFT8 is exactly the non-negative Ricci condition, the slogan rests on an unverified assertion. More seriously, the moduli space of unitary CFTs is never given a topology. Section 3.2 says 'without giving a definition of the topology...', and Section 2.2 notes it wasn't specified in [KoSo1]. Without such a topology, Conjectures 2.2.2, 3.2.2, and 6.6.2 lack a precise meaning. The paper's own convergence definition (Section 4.2) applies to quantum Riemannian spaces, but no argument shows that a degenerating family of CFTs yields a convergent family of functors on Riem_1 graphs independent of the degeneration. The stress-test note is on target. This is not a hidden flaw; the author flags the topology issue explicitly and frames the whole picture as a program. Still, the Section 1.2 slogan overstates what is currently established.

The citation practice is fine: self-citations to [So1] and [KoSo1] are disclosed, and since this is explicitly a revised version of [So1], that's appropriate.

Who this is for: people working on CFT moduli, distance conjectures, or non-commutative geometry. It is a useful survey and a source of conjectures. A serious referee could push for at least a concrete proposal for the missing topology, and ask the author to mark the Kontsevich assertion as an open problem rather than an established theorem. I'd send it to peer review with those expectations. Bottom line: worth engaging with, but as a program and a survey, not a proof of the slogan.

Referee Report

4 major / 6 minor

Summary. The paper presents a programmatic review and further development of the author's earlier work [So1] on the analogy between degenerating families of two-dimensional unitary CFTs and measured Gromov-Hausdorff limits of Riemannian manifolds with non-negative Ricci curvature. It proposes definitions of 'quantum Riemannian d-spaces' and 'quantum Riemannian 1-spaces' via monoidal functors on categories of Riemannian bordisms and metrized graphs, discusses the examples of toroidal, WZW, and minimal models, and relates the proposed structures to Connes's spectral triples, Bakry-Emery calculus, and Wasserstein geometry. The central slogan, stated in Section 1.2, is that collapsing unitary CFTs give rise to Riemannian manifolds (possibly singular) with non-negative Ricci curvature. The paper also formulates several conjectures on the precompactness of moduli spaces of such objects (Conjectures 2.2.2, 3.2.2, 6.6.2) and includes an appendix, based on unfinished joint work with M. Kontsevich, on deformation theory of QFTs and on QFTs on arbitrary compact metric spaces. The author states explicitly that the paper contains no results that are new by mathematical or physical standards and that it is mostly a review and discussion.

Significance. If the conjectural picture is eventually established, it would provide a metric-geometric compactification of moduli spaces of CFTs and a dictionary between collapsing CFTs and non-commutative Riemannian geometry, potentially connecting to the string landscape and the swampland program. The paper's examples (toroidal, WZW, minimal models) are explicit and support the analogy, and the author is commendably honest about the conjectural status of the central claims and about the unpublished nature of some key inputs. The appendix contains intriguing, if speculative, ideas about deformation theory and QFTs on metric spaces. However, the central slogan is not a theorem: the paper does not define a topology on the moduli space of CFTs, and the key implication from Segal's axioms to the curvature condition QFT 8 is attributed to a private communication. The main value of the paper at this stage is as a clearly written research proposal and a synthesis of existing ideas, rather than as a proof of the stated conjectures.

major comments (4)

[Section 3.2, Conjecture 3.2.2] The central notion of 'collapse' and the asserted limit of a family of unitary CFTs to a quantum Riemannian 1-space are not well-defined because no topology on the moduli space of unitary CFTs is supplied. The text itself states at the beginning of Section 3.2: 'Without giving a definition of the topology on the moduli space of unitary CFTs...', and Section 2.2 notes that the topology was not specified in [KoSo1]. Since Conjecture 3.2.2 asserts the existence of a limit in the sense of Section 4.2, and Section 4.2 defines convergence only for quantum Riemannian d-spaces (functors on Riem_NC_d), this gap is load-bearing for the paper's main claim. The author should either define the required topology, or reformulate the conjecture conditionally on the existence of a suitable topology, or state explicitly that the conjecture is a heuristic expectation rather than a precise mathematical statement.
[Section 6.6, paragraph after Remark 6.6.1(c)] The key assertion that Segal's axioms of unitary CFT imply that a collapsing sequence gives rise to a commutative Riemannian 1-space satisfying QFT1)-QFT8) is attributed to Kontsevich via a 'private communication', with no proof and no citable reference. Since QFT 8 is exactly the non-negative Ricci curvature condition, this unverified attribution carries the central physical conclusion of the paper. The author should either supply a proof (or a detailed sketch), state the result as a conjecture, or give a reference to a written version of the argument. In its current form, the claim cannot be checked by the reader.
[Section 4.2 and Section 3.2] The convergence topology defined in Section 4.2 applies to sequences of quantum Riemannian d-spaces, i.e. monoidal functors on Riem_NC_d. However, a unitary CFT is a functor on Riem_2, not on Riem_1. To make sense of the claim that a collapsing family of CFTs converges to a quantum Riemannian 1-space, the author needs to explain how a family of functors on Riem_2 restricts to a convergent family of functors on Riem_1 graphs (e.g. through the degenerations of surfaces to metrized graphs), and why the resulting limit is independent of the chosen degeneration. This issue directly affects the meaning of Conjectures 3.2.2 and 6.6.2.
[Section 6.6, Conjecture 6.6.2] The conjecture asserts precompactness of quantum Riemannian 1-spaces with measure, non-negative Ricci curvature, a spectral gap bound, and a bounded dimension spectrum, 'in the topology defined in Section 4.2'. However, the topology of Section 4.2 is defined for arbitrary quantum Riemannian d-spaces via strong convergence of amplitudes; the author does not verify that this topology has the required precompactness properties for the class in question, and the only supporting result, Theorem 6.6.3, concerns the weaker 'weak topology' for spaces of geometric origin, with the proof attributed to [En]. The manuscript should clarify the relationship between the strong topology of Section 4.2, the weak topology of Section 6.6, and the measured Gromov-Hausdorff topology, and should state clearly which parts of Conjecture 6.6.2 are known and which are open.

minor comments (6)

[Section 1.1] The author notes that the paper is 'a slightly revised version of [So1]' and apologizes for not updating the references. Since the submission is dated 2025, the reference list should at least be checked for accuracy; several entries are preprints that were later published (e.g. [Kok], [U]).
[Section 3.2] Typo: 'wordlsheets' should be 'worldsheets' in the sentence 'Let us consider the set W of isomorphism classes of wordlsheets'.
[Section 6.3] Typo: 'coinsides' should be 'coincides' in 'this measured Laplacian coinsides with 1/(n+2) Δ_g'.
[Section 6.6, Remark 6.6.1(c)] Typo: 'subforset' should be 'subforest' in 'if we contract a subforset of Γ'.
[Section 6.5] Typo: 'meatric-measure spaces' should be 'metric-measure spaces' in the sentence 'the natural forgetful map from "geometric" spectral structures to the corresponding metric-measure spaces'.
[Section 7.7] Typo: 'asymptoric expansion' should be 'asymptotic expansion' in the sentence 'Suppose that the measure dμ_X ... admits an asymptoric expansion'.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No circular reduction: the paper is an explicitly labelled review/proposal; the collapse-to-Ricci claim is imported from prior work and a private communication, but is nowhere equated with its assumptions by construction.

full rationale

I find no circular step in which a prediction or derived quantity reduces to its own input by definition or by construction. The paper is explicit about its status: Section 1.1 says it 'does not contain results which can be called new' and is 'mostly a review and discussion of various existing concepts'. The central slogan in Section 1.2, 'Collapsing unitary two-dimensional CFTs give rise to Riemannian manifolds (possibly singular) with non-negative Ricci curvature', is presented as a summary of arguments from [KoSo1] rather than as a derivation performed here. Section 6.6 attributes the key implication to a private communication: 'It was shown by Kontsevich that Segal's axioms of the unitary CFT imply that the collapsing sequence of unitary CFTs gives rise to a commutative Riemannian 1-space, which satisfies axioms QFT1)-QFT8)', and QFT8 is exactly the non-negative Ricci condition. This is an omitted or unavailable proof, not a circular one: nothing in the paper's definitions of collapsing, spectral gap, or the quantum Riemannian 1-space axioms contains the conclusion as a definiens. Similarly, the absence of a topology on the moduli space of unitary CFTs, acknowledged in Section 3.2 ('Without giving a definition of the topology on the moduli space of unitary CFTs...') and in Section 2.2, makes the precompactness conjectures imprecise, but imprecision is a completeness/correctness issue, not circularity. No parameter is fitted and then renamed a prediction, no uniqueness theorem from the authors is used to forbid alternatives, and the self-citations, while load-bearing in a review sense, are disclosed and do not force the conclusion by construction. Score 0.

Assumptions & free parameters 0 free parameters · 5 assumptions · 2 invented entities

The paper introduces no fitted parameters. Its axioms are mostly domain assumptions from Segal's framework and Bakry-Emery theory; the key ad hoc assumptions are the unproved existence of a suitable topology on CFT moduli space and the collapse description. The two invented entities are mathematical definitions, not physical objects, and neither has independent falsifiable evidence.

assumptions (5)

domain assumption Unitary CFTs are defined by Segal's axioms with Riemannian surfaces
Section 3.1 states this is the working definition of CFT for the paper.
ad hoc to paper The collapsing limit of a unitary CFT is described by the leading terms of the OPE giving a commutative algebra H_small whose spectrum is a compact space
Section 2.3 introduces this as a 'first approximation to the real picture'.
domain assumption The minimal eigenvalue of L0+L0 plays the role of inverse squared diameter and its vanishing drives the collapse
Section 1.2 states the spectral gap of the Virasoro operator is the analog of the diameter, following [KoSo1].
ad hoc to paper Precompactness of the moduli space of CFTs in a suitable topology can be transferred from Gromov-Hausdorff compactness theorems
Conjectures 2.2.2, 3.2.1, 3.2.2, and 6.6.2 are stated but not proved; the topology is not defined.
domain assumption Non-negative Ricci curvature for the limiting space is equivalent to the Bakry-Emery CD(0, inf) inequality
Section 6.1 and Remark 2.3.1 review this equivalence for Riemannian manifolds.

invented entities (2)

Quantum Riemannian d-space
purpose: To axiomatize CFT and its degenerations as monoidal functors from Riemannian bordisms to Hilbert spaces.
Defined in Sections 4.1 and 4.2 as a working definition; no falsifiable prediction outside the framework.
Quantum metric space (Appendix)
purpose: To define QFTs on arbitrary compact metric spaces via OPE cluster data.
Section 7.7 speculates about this category; it is an unfinished draft and not tested against data.

how reviews work

0 comments

Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Moduli space of Conformal Field Theories and non-commutative Riemannian geometry." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/UQIDZRVW

@misc{pith2026250600896,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Moduli space of Conformal Field Theories and non-commutative Riemannian geometry},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/UQIDZRVW}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2506.00896}
}

read the original abstract

We discuss the analogy between collapsing Conformal Field Theories and measured Gromov-Hausdorff limit of Riemannian manifolds with non-negative Ricci curvature. Motivated by this analogy we propose the notion of non-commutative (``quantum") Riemannian d-geometry. We explain how this structure is related to Connes's spectral triples in the case d=1. In the Appendix based on the unpublished joint work with Maxim Kontsevich we discuss deformation theory of Quantum Field Theories as well as an approach to QFTs in the case when the space-time is an arbitrary compact metric space.

Discussion (0). Sign in to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

9 extracted references · 7 canonical work pages

[6]

Kontsevich, G.Segal, Wick rotation and the positivity of energy in quantum field theory, arXiv:2105.10161

[KoSe] M. Kontsevich, G.Segal, Wick rotation and the positivity of energy in quantum field theory, arXiv:2105.10161. [KoSo1] M. Kontsevich, Y. Soibelman, Homological Mirror Symmetry and torus fibrations, math.SG/0011041. [KoSo2] M. Kontsevich, Y. Soibelman, Deformations of algebras over operads and Deligne conjecture, math.QA/0001151, published in Lett. M...

arXiv 2000
[7]

Random walks on random groups

[Seg] G.Segal, The definition of Conformal Field Theory, in: Topology, Ge- ometry and Quantum Field Theory, Cambridge Univ. Press, 2004, 421-577. [Si] L. Silberman, Addendum to “Random walks on random groups” by M. Gromov, Geom. Funct. Anal., 13:1,

work page 2004
[1994]

Connes, D

[CoKr] A. Connes, D. Kreimer, Renormalization in quantum field theory and the Riemann-Hilbert problem, hep-th/9909126. [CoMar] A. Connes, M. Marcolli, A walk in the non-commutative garden, math.QA/0601054. [Dou 1] M. Douglas, The statistics of string/M theory vacua, hep-th/0303194. [Dou 2] M. Douglas, Talk at the String-2005 Conference, http://www.fields....

arXiv 2005
[1998]

Kasue, H.Kumura, Spectral convergence of Riemannian mani- folds, Tohoku Math

[KaKu1] A. Kasue, H.Kumura, Spectral convergence of Riemannian mani- folds, Tohoku Math. J., 46, 1994, 147-179. [KaKu2] A. Kasue, H.Kumura, Spectral convergence of Riemannian mani- folds, II Tohoku Math. J., 48.1996, 71-120. [Kok] S. Kokkendorff, A Laplacian on metric measure spaces. Preprint of Technical University of Denmark, March

work page 1994
[1999]

Classification of operator algebraic conformal field theories in dimensions one and two

[Gro2] M. Gromov, Random walks in random groups, Geom. Funct. Anal. 13:1, 2003, 73-146. [Kaw 1] Y. Kawahigashi, Classification of operator algebraic conformal field theories in dimensions one and two, math-ph/0308029. [Kaw 2] Y. Kawahigashi, Classification of operator algebraic conformal field theories, math.OA/0211141. [Kaw-Lo] Y. Kawahigashi, R. Longo, ...

work page Pith review arXiv 2003
[2003]

[So1] Y. Soibelman, Collapsing conformal field theories, spaces with non- negative Ricci curvature and non-commutative geometry, in: Mathematical foundations of quantum field theory and perturbative string theory, vol. 83 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., pp. 245–278, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, (2011). [St] K-T. Sturm, On the geometry of metric measure ...

work page 2011
[2004]

Stolz, P

[ST] S. Stolz, P. Teichner, Supersymmetric field theories and integral mod- ular functions, in preparation. [T] D. Tamarkin, Formality of chain operad of small squares, math.QA/9809164. [U] H. Urakawa, Convergence rates to equilibrium of the heat kernels on compact Riemannian manifolds, preprint. [V] C. Villani, Optimal transport, old and new, book in pre...

work page arXiv
[2005]

Berard, G

[BBG] P. Berard, G. Besson, S. Gallot, Embedding Riemannian manifolds by their heat kernel, Geom. Funct. Anal., 4:4, 1994, 373-398. [Ba] D. Bakry, Functional inequalities for Markov semigroups, preprint, available at: http://www.lsp.ups-tlse.fr/Bakry/ 46 [BaEm] D. Bakry, M. ´Emery, Diffusions hypercontractives, Lect. Notes in Math. no. 1123, 1985, 177-206...

work page arXiv 1994

Show all 9 references

[2006]

Fjelstad, J

[FFRS] J. Fjelstad, J. Fuchs, I. Runkel, C. Schweigert, Topological and con- formal field theory as Frobenius algebras, math.CT/0512076. [FG] J. Fr¨ olich, K. Gawedzki, Conformal Field Theory and geometry of strings, hep-th/9310187. [FM] W. Fulton, R. Macpherson, A compactific...

1994

Pith tools

Reviewed August 7, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.

[1] [6]

Kontsevich, G.Segal, Wick rotation and the positivity of energy in quantum field theory, arXiv:2105.10161

[KoSe] M. Kontsevich, G.Segal, Wick rotation and the positivity of energy in quantum field theory, arXiv:2105.10161. [KoSo1] M. Kontsevich, Y. Soibelman, Homological Mirror Symmetry and torus fibrations, math.SG/0011041. [KoSo2] M. Kontsevich, Y. Soibelman, Deformations of algebras over operads and Deligne conjecture, math.QA/0001151, published in Lett. M...

arXiv 2000

[2] [7]

Random walks on random groups

[Seg] G.Segal, The definition of Conformal Field Theory, in: Topology, Ge- ometry and Quantum Field Theory, Cambridge Univ. Press, 2004, 421-577. [Si] L. Silberman, Addendum to “Random walks on random groups” by M. Gromov, Geom. Funct. Anal., 13:1,

work page 2004

[3] [1994]

Connes, D

[CoKr] A. Connes, D. Kreimer, Renormalization in quantum field theory and the Riemann-Hilbert problem, hep-th/9909126. [CoMar] A. Connes, M. Marcolli, A walk in the non-commutative garden, math.QA/0601054. [Dou 1] M. Douglas, The statistics of string/M theory vacua, hep-th/0303194. [Dou 2] M. Douglas, Talk at the String-2005 Conference, http://www.fields....

arXiv 2005

[4] [1998]

Kasue, H.Kumura, Spectral convergence of Riemannian mani- folds, Tohoku Math

[KaKu1] A. Kasue, H.Kumura, Spectral convergence of Riemannian mani- folds, Tohoku Math. J., 46, 1994, 147-179. [KaKu2] A. Kasue, H.Kumura, Spectral convergence of Riemannian mani- folds, II Tohoku Math. J., 48.1996, 71-120. [Kok] S. Kokkendorff, A Laplacian on metric measure spaces. Preprint of Technical University of Denmark, March

work page 1994

[5] [1999]

Classification of operator algebraic conformal field theories in dimensions one and two

[Gro2] M. Gromov, Random walks in random groups, Geom. Funct. Anal. 13:1, 2003, 73-146. [Kaw 1] Y. Kawahigashi, Classification of operator algebraic conformal field theories in dimensions one and two, math-ph/0308029. [Kaw 2] Y. Kawahigashi, Classification of operator algebraic conformal field theories, math.OA/0211141. [Kaw-Lo] Y. Kawahigashi, R. Longo, ...

work page Pith review arXiv 2003

[6] [2003]

[So1] Y. Soibelman, Collapsing conformal field theories, spaces with non- negative Ricci curvature and non-commutative geometry, in: Mathematical foundations of quantum field theory and perturbative string theory, vol. 83 of Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., pp. 245–278, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, (2011). [St] K-T. Sturm, On the geometry of metric measure ...

work page 2011

[7] [2004]

Stolz, P

[ST] S. Stolz, P. Teichner, Supersymmetric field theories and integral mod- ular functions, in preparation. [T] D. Tamarkin, Formality of chain operad of small squares, math.QA/9809164. [U] H. Urakawa, Convergence rates to equilibrium of the heat kernels on compact Riemannian manifolds, preprint. [V] C. Villani, Optimal transport, old and new, book in pre...

work page arXiv

[8] [2005]

Berard, G

[BBG] P. Berard, G. Besson, S. Gallot, Embedding Riemannian manifolds by their heat kernel, Geom. Funct. Anal., 4:4, 1994, 373-398. [Ba] D. Bakry, Functional inequalities for Markov semigroups, preprint, available at: http://www.lsp.ups-tlse.fr/Bakry/ 46 [BaEm] D. Bakry, M. ´Emery, Diffusions hypercontractives, Lect. Notes in Math. no. 1123, 1985, 177-206...

work page arXiv 1994