SoK: Systematizing LLM Prompt Security: Taxonomies, Datasets, and Unified Evaluation of Attacks and Defenses

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used as interfaces to information, code, and real-world services, making prompt-level security failures a practical concern. Although jailbreak attacks, defenses, datasets, and automated judgers have advanced rapidly, evaluation remains fragmented across threat models, access assumptions, cost budgets, datasets, and success criteria. This makes reported attack success rates and defense gains hard to compare. This SoK systematizes LLM prompt security across concepts, data, tooling, and measurement. We propose linked taxonomies for jailbreak attacks, defenses, and model vulnerabilities, while separating technical mechanisms from attacker and defender capabilities. We also formalize threat, access, and cost assumptions as explicit evaluation metadata. To support reproducible evaluation, we release JailbreakDB, PromptSecurity-Eval, and PromptSecurity, a modular platform that represents each experiment as a tuple of model, attack, defense, dataset, and judger. Using matched evaluations across models, attacks, defenses, and judgers, we show that access regime, native harmful-query behavior, attack cost, defense backfire, taxonomy subcategory, and judger choice all materially affect security conclusions. Together, these artifacts support reproducible, cost-aware, and taxonomy-grounded evaluation of LLM prompt security. Leaderboard: https://datasec-lab.github.io/PromptSecurityLeaderboard/. Dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/youbin2014/JailbreakDB. GitHub: https://github.com/datasec-lab/PromptSecurity.