REVIEW 15 cited by
Robot Learning as an Empirical Science: Best Practices for Policy Evaluation
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
Robot Learning as an Empirical Science: Best Practices for Policy Evaluation
read the original abstract
The robot learning community has made great strides in recent years, proposing new architectures and showcasing impressive new capabilities; however, the dominant metric used in the literature, especially for physical experiments, is "success rate", i.e. the percentage of runs that were successful. Furthermore, it is common for papers to report this number with little to no information regarding the number of runs, the initial conditions, and the success criteria, little to no narrative description of the behaviors and failures observed, and little to no statistical analysis of the findings. In this paper we argue that to move the field forward, researchers should provide a nuanced evaluation of their methods, especially when evaluating and comparing learned policies on physical robots. To do so, we propose best practices for future evaluations: explicitly reporting the experimental conditions, evaluating several metrics designed to complement success rate, conducting statistical analysis, and adding a qualitative description of failures modes. We illustrate these through an evaluation on physical robots of several learned policies for manipulation tasks.
Forward citations
Cited by 15 Pith papers
-
RoboLab: A High-Fidelity Simulation Benchmark for Analysis of Task Generalist Policies
RoboLab is a new simulation benchmark with 120 tasks across visual, procedural, and relational axes that quantifies generalization gaps and perturbation sensitivity in task-generalist robotic policies.
-
PhAIL: A Real-Robot VLA Benchmark and Distributional Methodology
PhAIL provides an open benchmark and distributional evaluation method for real-robot VLA policies using time-to-success CDF, HRT scoring, and KS significance tests.
-
Betting for Sim-to-Real Performance Evaluation
Betting mechanisms can yield provably more accurate and efficient estimates of real-world robot behavior than Monte Carlo sampling under specified conditions, with practical approximations demonstrated on synthetic da...
-
FELT: Generating Tactile Signals from Vision for Visuo-Tactile Manipulation
FELT predicts finger pressure maps from RGB images and uses them or their learned features to improve manipulation policies without real tactile sensors at deployment.
-
Robot Critics that Sweat the Small Stuff
Fine-tuning VLMs with pairwise progress supervision from policy rollouts improves fine-grained failure detection and boosts robot manipulation success by 11% real-world and 5.9% in simulation.
-
iMaC: Translating Actions into Motion and Contact Images for Embodied World Models
iMaC introduces image-based action tokens in a dual-branch architecture to improve future state prediction and control in embodied world models over vector-based baselines.
-
CLAW: Learning Continuous Latent Action World Models via Adversarial Latent Regularization
CLAW is an end-to-end self-supervised method that learns semantically meaningful continuous latent actions and predictive world models from action-free videos to support imitation learning and goal-directed planning.
-
Instrumentation for Imitation Learning: Enhancing Training Datasets for Clothes Hanger Insertion
Instrumented objects boost diffusion policy success in robotic hanger insertion by 14-25 percentage points over vision-only baselines, and augmenting datasets with instrumented expert rollouts lets a vision-only stude...
-
RoboLab: A High-Fidelity Simulation Benchmark for Analysis of Task Generalist Policies
RoboLab is a photorealistic simulation benchmark with 120 tasks and perturbation analysis to evaluate true generalization and robustness of robotic foundation models.
-
Neuro-Symbolic Control with Large Language Models for Language-Guided Spatial Tasks
A neuro-symbolic system pairing LLMs for symbolic reasoning with neural delta controllers for execution delivers over 70% step reduction and up to 8.83x speedup in language-guided planar object manipulation while rema...
-
AFFORD2ACT: Affordance-Guided Automatic Keypoint Selection for Generalizable and Lightweight Robotic Manipulation
AFFORD2ACT distills a minimal set of affordance-guided 2D keypoints from text and a single image to train a 38-dimensional gated transformer policy that achieves 82% success on unseen objects and scenes.
-
Active Real-World Factor-Based Evaluation for Generalist Robot Policies
An active evaluation framework selects the most informative task configurations for real-robot tests, matching random testing's accuracy in 20-40% fewer trials.
-
A Careful Examination of Large Behavior Models for Multitask Dexterous Manipulation
Multi-task pretraining of diffusion policies on diverse robot data produces more successful, robust, and data-efficient policies for dexterous manipulation than single-task baselines, with performance scaling with pre...
-
Position: Good Embodied Reward Models Need Bad Behavior Data
Embodied reward models systematically over-reward unsafe, suboptimal, and shortcut robot behaviors due to training on successful data only, and modest inclusion of bad behavior data improves alignment with human preferences.
-
Robustness of Robotic Manipulation: Foundations and Frontiers
A survey that formalizes manipulation robustness from probabilistic and control perspectives and reviews mechanisms, metrics, and open problems across robotics subfields.
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.