Filtering out Erratic Observables: Wormholes from Gauging Nonlocal Symmetries

Qi-Feng Wu

REVIEW 3 major objections 2 minor 1 cited by

Gauging nonlocal monodromy symmetries filters erratic large-N observables and leaves a wormhole Hilbert subspace whose filtered partition function is an ensemble average over entangling gates.

Reviewed by Pith at T0; open to challenge. T0 means a machine referee read the full paper against a public rubric. the ladder, T0–T4 →

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

T0 review · grok-4.5

2026-07-12 15:46 UTC pith:3MVFHWBP

load-bearing objection Abstract-only: clean algebraic story for wormholes via monodromy completion and gauging=filtering, but positivity cut is the uncheckable linchpin. the 3 major comments →

arxiv 2605.28748 v2 pith:3MVFHWBP submitted 2026-05-27 hep-th math-phmath.MPmath.QA

Filtering out Erratic Observables: Wormholes from Gauging Nonlocal Symmetries

Qi-Feng Wu This is my paper

classification hep-th math-phmath.MPmath.QA

keywords wormholesnonlocal symmetriesmonodromy databoundary gravitonserratic large-N observablesensemble averagingAdS3/CFT2gauging

verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal T4 reserved

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The paper argues that the wormhole term in the gravitational path integral is the smooth remnant of correlations among the erratic large-N behaviors of dual CFTs, and it shows how this works explicitly in (2+1)-dimensional gravity. One-sided boundary gravitons are incomplete: their observable algebra always has a nontrivial center. Completing that algebra with monodromy data (an effective description of one-sided black holes) and imposing a positivity restriction produces precisely the erratic observables. Restricting to the subspace on which those observables act trivially is equivalent to gauging the nonlocal symmetries generated by the monodromy data. For a single CFT this removes all black-hole states and yields an apparent ensemble average; for two CFTs a wormhole subspace survives and the filtered partition function becomes an ensemble average over quantum gates that entangle the monodromy degrees of freedom, with the preserved correlation supplying the wormhole contribution.

Core claim

In (2+1)-dimensional gravity the algebra of one-sided boundary gravitons is intrinsically incomplete, possessing a nontrivial center independent of boundary conditions. Its simplest completion is generated by monodromy observables that describe one-sided black holes. Restricting those monodromy data by a positivity condition produces emergent erratic large-N observables; filtering them out by restricting to the subspace on which they act trivially is equivalent to gauging the nonlocal symmetries they generate. For two CFTs the global part of this gauging leaves a Hilbert subspace of wormholes whose filtered partition function is an ensemble average over entangling quantum gates, with the res

What carries the argument

The monodromy observable algebra (the commutant of the completed boundary-graviton algebra) together with the positivity restriction that selects the Lorentzian multi-boundary sector; gauging the nonlocal symmetries it generates is identical to projecting out the erratic observables.

Load-bearing premise

The claim rests on the premise that monodromy data cut by a positivity restriction are all that is needed to describe Lorentzian multi-boundary wormholes, and that this cut is what creates the erratic large-N behaviors that must then be filtered.

What would settle it

An explicit computation of the two-CFT filtered partition function (or of the spectrum of the residual wormhole Hilbert space) that fails to reproduce the known gravitational wormhole contribution, or a demonstration that a different completion of the boundary-graviton algebra yields no positivity-induced erratic sector.

Watch this falsifier — get emailed when new claim-graph text bears on it.

If this is right

For a single CFT, gauging the nonlocal monodromy symmetries removes every black-hole microstate from the spectrum.
The filtered two-CFT partition function is exactly an ensemble average over quantum gates that entangle the monodromy degrees of freedom of the two sides.
The correlation between the erratic observables of the two CFTs is preserved by the filter and appears directly as the wormhole contribution.
Apparent ensemble averaging of CFT partition functions can be reinterpreted as the result of projecting out the erratic sector rather than averaging over an external ensemble of theories.

Where Pith is reading between the lines

These are editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

The same monodromy-gauging construction may supply a microscopic origin for the factorisation puzzle in higher-dimensional AdS/CFT.
Because the residual wormhole subspace is defined by a positivity cut on monodromy data, the construction suggests a natural order parameter that distinguishes connected and disconnected geometries already at the level of the dual CFT Hilbert space.
If the nonlocal symmetries can be realised as ordinary gauge symmetries after a suitable extension of the CFT, the wormhole contribution would become an ordinary projection rather than an ad-hoc filter.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit.

Desk Editor's Note

Abstract-only: clean algebraic story for wormholes via monodromy completion and gauging=filtering, but positivity cut is the uncheckable linchpin.

read the letter

Only the abstract is in front of us, so this is provisional. The core claim is that one-sided boundary gravitons always leave a nontrivial center no matter the boundary conditions; the simplest completion is monodromy data that the author reads as an effective one-sided black-hole algebra. Positivity on that monodromy is then said to be exactly what is needed for Lorentzian multi-boundary wormholes, and the same cut makes some observables erratic at large N. Filtering the erratic sector (restricting to the subspace where they act trivially) is claimed to be equivalent to gauging the nonlocal monodromy symmetries that lack local currents. For one CFT the quantum gauging kills all black-hole states and produces apparent ensemble averaging; for two CFTs a wormhole Hilbert subspace survives and the filtered partition function becomes an ensemble of entangling gates on the monodromy degrees of freedom, with the preserved erratic correlations supplying the wormhole term.

What looks genuinely new is the package: incompleteness independent of boundary conditions, the asymptotic-symmetry bootstrap of a general Poisson bracket, the monodromy algebra as black-hole effective description, and the explicit equivalence of filtering with gauging nonlocal symmetries. If those steps are cleanly derived, the paper supplies a precise algebraic origin for wormhole contributions and ensemble-like averaging inside AdS3/CFT2 without inserting the ensemble by hand.

The soft spot is exactly the positivity restriction. It is asked to do three jobs at once: select the classical phase space for multi-boundary wormholes, generate the erratic observables that later need filtering, and leave a nontrivial wormhole subspace after quantum gauging of the residual global symmetries. Without the body we cannot inspect the Poisson-bracket construction, the argument that non-positive monodromy is excluded from Lorentzian multi-boundary geometries, the identification of the erratic operators, or the quantum implementation of the gauging. If that cut is incomplete or ad hoc, both the equivalence and the wormhole term collapse. The one-CFT claim that all black-hole states disappear also needs careful comparison with known BTZ spectra.

Citation pattern and explicit calculations cannot be audited from the abstract. The logical chain appears constructive rather than circular, which is a plus. This is for people working on wormholes, ensemble averaging, and algebraic holography in 3d gravity. It deserves a serious referee once the full text is available; the abstract alone is not enough to accept or reject. I would bring it to reading group after the body appears, and I would cite the monodromy-completion idea if the derivations hold. Send it out for peer review.

Referee Report

3 major / 2 minor

Summary. The manuscript argues that, in (2+1)-dimensional gravity, the algebra of one-sided boundary gravitons is intrinsically incomplete (nontrivial center independent of boundary conditions). Completions are constructed by bootstrapping a Poisson bracket from asymptotic symmetries; the simplest completion has a commutant consisting of monodromy data, interpreted as an effective description of one-sided black holes. A positivity restriction on the monodromy data is claimed to be necessary and sufficient for Lorentzian multi-boundary wormholes and to induce emergent erratic large-N observables. Filtering those observables (restriction to the subspace on which they act trivially) is asserted to be equivalent to gauging the nonlocal symmetries generated by the monodromy observables. For a single CFT this removes all black-hole states and produces an apparent ensemble average; for two CFTs a wormhole Hilbert subspace survives after gauging the global part of the symmetries, and the filtered partition function becomes an ensemble average over entangling quantum gates on the monodromy degrees of freedom, with residual correlations of the erratic observables supplying the wormhole term.

Significance. If the claimed equivalence between gauging monodromy-generated nonlocal symmetries and filtering erratic observables holds, and if the positivity cut cleanly isolates the Lorentzian multi-boundary sector while generating the erratic operators that must be filtered, the work would supply a concrete, algebraically controlled mechanism for the appearance of wormhole contributions as remnants of large-N correlations in AdS3/CFT2. That would be a useful addition to the growing literature that seeks to derive ensemble averaging and wormhole saddles from the structure of boundary observable algebras rather than from an a-priori gravitational path integral. The construction is potentially falsifiable once the explicit Poisson brackets, the spectrum of the monodromy algebra, and the quantum implementation of the gauging are written down.

major comments (3)

The entire logical chain rests on the assertion (abstract and implied body) that monodromy data subject to a positivity restriction are the only data needed for Lorentzian multi-boundary wormholes and that this same restriction is what produces the erratic large-N observables. No derivation, classical phase-space argument, or explicit check that non-positive monodromy cannot appear in Lorentzian multi-boundary geometries is supplied in the provided text. Without that step the subsequent identification of erratic operators, the filtering procedure, and the claimed equivalence to gauging all remain unanchored.
The bootstrap of a general Poisson bracket from asymptotic symmetries that completes the boundary-graviton algebra is announced but never exhibited. The resulting monodromy algebra, its center, and the precise sense in which it is the commutant are therefore unavailable for inspection; the claim that one-sided boundary gravitons are intrinsically incomplete cannot be verified.
The quantum implementation of the gauging (especially the distinction between local and global parts of the nonlocal symmetries, and the statement that for one CFT all black-hole states are removed while for two CFTs a wormhole subspace survives) is stated without any Hilbert-space construction, representation theory of the monodromy algebra, or explicit projector onto the filtered subspace. The ensemble-of-gates form of the two-CFT filtered partition function and the identification of the residual wormhole term likewise lack supporting formulae.

minor comments (2)

The manuscript body is absent from the review package; only the abstract is available. All technical claims therefore remain unchecked.
Notation for the monodromy observables, the positivity restriction, and the nonlocal symmetries is introduced in the abstract without definitions that would allow a reader to reconstruct the algebra even at the classical level.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No circularity identifiable; abstract presents a constructive chain (incompleteness → monodromy completion → positivity cut → filter=gauge) without self-definitional reduction or load-bearing self-citation visible in the supplied text.

full rationale

The supplied material consists solely of the abstract (full manuscript body is empty). From that text the logical steps are presented as sequential constructions rather than tautologies: (i) one-sided boundary-graviton algebras are claimed incomplete by a nontrivial-center argument independent of later choices; (ii) a Poisson bracket is bootstrapped from asymptotic symmetries to complete them, with monodromy data appearing as the commutant; (iii) a positivity restriction is then imposed to select Lorentzian multi-boundary geometries, after which erratic large-N observables emerge and are filtered by restriction to a trivial-action subspace; (iv) the same monodromy generators are said to produce nonlocal symmetries whose gauging is asserted equivalent to the filtering. None of these steps reduces, by the abstract’s own wording, to a definition of the target result, a fitted parameter renamed as prediction, or a uniqueness theorem imported solely from the author’s prior work. Without equations, section numbers or explicit self-citations in a body text, no concrete circular reduction (Eq. X = Eq. Y by construction, or self-citation chain) can be exhibited. Per the hard rules, absence of quotable circular steps yields score 0 and empty steps list. The positivity cut is load-bearing for the physical interpretation but is not, on the given text, circular.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 4 axioms · 3 invented entities

The work sits on standard AdS3 asymptotic symmetry analysis and the modern ensemble interpretation of wormholes. The load-bearing additions that are not free from the prior literature are the monodromy completion, the positivity restriction that generates erratic observables, and the identification of filtering with gauging of nonlocal symmetries that lack local currents. No numerical free parameters appear in the abstract.

axioms (4)

domain assumption Wormhole contributions to the gravitational path integral may be interpreted as smooth remnants of correlations among erratic large-N behaviors of dual CFTs
Stated as the motivating idea of the paper; standard in recent ensemble-averaging literature but taken as starting point rather than derived.
ad hoc to paper Asymptotic symmetries determine a general Poisson bracket that can be bootstrapped to complete the boundary-graviton algebra
The paper bootstraps this bracket; uniqueness or necessity of the chosen completion is not guaranteed by standard symplectic geometry alone.
domain assumption The observable algebra of one-sided boundary gravitons has a nontrivial center independent of boundary conditions
Claimed as shown from asymptotic analysis in (2+1)D gravity; relies on standard Chern–Simons / asymptotic-symmetry technology.
ad hoc to paper Monodromy data with a positivity restriction is sufficient to describe Lorentzian multi-boundary wormholes
Stated as a result of the analysis; the positivity cut is a modeling choice that induces the erratic behaviors later filtered.

invented entities (3)

Monodromy-data observable algebra as effective description of one-sided black holes no independent evidence
purpose: Serves as the commutant that completes the incomplete boundary-graviton algebra
Introduced as the simplest completion; the black-hole interpretation is by the authors and lacks independent external handle in the abstract.
Nonlocal symmetries generated by monodromy observables that lack corresponding local currents no independent evidence
purpose: Objects to be gauged in order to filter erratic observables
Constructed in the paper; absence of local currents is a defining claimed feature.
Filtering procedure that restricts to the subspace on which erratic observables act trivially no independent evidence
purpose: Removes erratic large-N behaviors while preserving wormhole correlations between two CFTs
Defined as equivalent to gauging the nonlocal symmetries; the equivalence is a central claim of the work.

pith-pipeline@v1.1.0-grok45 · 6677 in / 2824 out tokens · 47453 ms · 2026-07-12T15:46:26.029931+00:00 · methodology

0 comments

read the original abstract

The wormhole contribution to the gravitational path integral may be interpreted as smooth remnant of correlations among the erratic large-$N$ behaviors of dual CFTs. In this work, we investigate this idea in (2+1)-dimensional gravity. We show that one-sided boundary gravitons are intrinsically incomplete in the sense that the associated observable algebra has a nontrivial center regardless of choices of boundary conditions. Based on asymptotic symmetries, we bootstrap a general Poisson bracket to construct completions of the boundary gravitons. In the simplest completion, the commutant of the boundary graviton observable algebra is given by an observable algebra of monodromy data which we interpret as an effective description of one-sided black holes. We show that, to describe Lorentzian multi-boundary wormholes, only the monodromy data with a positivity restriction is needed. The positivity restriction results in emergent erratic large-$N$ behaviors for some observables. We filter out the erratic observables by restricting to a subspace on which they act trivially. The monodromy observables generate nonlocal symmetries lack of corresponding local currents. We show that gauging the nonlocal symmetries is equivalent to filtering out the erratic observables. For one CFT, gauging the nonlocal symmetries at the quantum level removes all black hole states. Filtering the partition function of CFTs leads to an apparent ensemble averaging. For two CFTs, a Hilbert subspace describing wormholes survives after gauging global part of the nonlocal symmetries. The filtered partition function of the two CFTs is an ensemble average over quantum gates entangling the monodromy degrees of freedom of the two CFTs. The correlation between the erratic observables of the two CFTs is preserved, which contributes to the filtered partition function as a wormhole term.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2605.28748 by Qi-Feng Wu.

**Figure 2.1.** Figure 2.1: The outer solid circle represents the asymptotic boundary where Eq. (2.34) holds. [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p013_2_1.png] view at source ↗

**Figure 2.2.** Figure 2.2: The outer black circle represents the asymptotic boundary. The green dot represents [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p014_2_2.png] view at source ↗

**Figure 2.3.** Figure 2.3: The outer black circle represents the asymptotic boundary. The green dot represents [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p016_2_3.png] view at source ↗

**Figure 3.1.** Figure 3.1: The outer black circle represents the asymptotic boundary. The green dot represents [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p021_3_1.png] view at source ↗

**Figure 3.2.** Figure 3.2: The outer black circle represents the asymptotic boundary. The green dot rep [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p025_3_2.png] view at source ↗

**Figure 4.1.** Figure 4.1: Erratic behavior of the real part of q˜ in the large N limit (GN → 0). Eqs. (4.34) and (4.39) imply that the modular dual operators m˜e, m˜f , and mKe are singular in the large N limit (k → ∞). The modular dual algebra Uq˜(sl(2, R)) does not have a classical limit (ℏ → 0) either, because the dual quantization parameter (4.40) is not analytic at ℏ = 0. See [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p035_4_1.png] view at source ↗

**Figure 6.1.** Figure 6.1: On the left is a schematic illustration of a bulk Cauchy slice dual to one CFT. The [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p045_6_1.png] view at source ↗

**Figure 6.2.** Figure 6.2: On the left is a schematic illustration of a bulk Cauchy slice dual to two CFTs. [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p052_6_2.png] view at source ↗

Review history (2 revisions) →

discussion (0)

Forward citations

Cited by 1 Pith paper

Reviewed papers in the Pith corpus that reference this work. Sorted by Pith novelty score.

A Holographic Map from AdS$_3$ to CFT$_2$
hep-th 2026-07 conditional novelty 6.0

Semiclassical pure AdS3 gravity states, labelled by fixed-area geodesic networks, are mapped to CFT2 primary states whose wavefunctions are networks of OPE coefficients.