REVIEW 3 cited by
Comment on "Energy-speed relationship of quantum particles challenges Bohmian mechanics"
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
Comment on "Energy-speed relationship of quantum particles challenges Bohmian mechanics"
read the original abstract
In their recent paper [Nature 643, 67 (2025)], Sharaglazova et al. report an optical microcavity experiment yielding an "energy-speed relationship" for quantum particles in evanescent states, which they infer from the observed population transfer between two coupled waveguides. The authors argue that their findings challenge the validity of Bohmian particle dynamics because, according to the Bohmian guiding equation, the velocities in the classically forbidden region would be zero. In this note, we explain why this claim is false and the experimental findings are in perfect agreement with Bohmian mechanics. We also clarify why the operationally defined speeds reported in the paper are unrelated to particle velocities in the sense described by Bohmian mechanics. In contrast to other recent replies, our analysis relies solely on the standard Bohmian guidance equation for single particles.
Forward citations
Cited by 3 Pith papers
-
Modular Variables and the Limits of Phase Detectability in Open Quantum Systems
Modular variables retain phase sensitivity in non-overlapping wave-packet superpositions under gravity and Caldeira-Leggett decoherence when evaluated locally via Bohmian trajectories, unlike probability density or current.
-
Actual and weak actual values in Bohmian mechanics
In Bohmian mechanics, Holland's local expectation values equal the real part of position-postselected weak values, and the disputed waveguide experiment's 'speed' parameter is identified as the amplitude decay rate in...
-
Trajectories in coupled waveguides: an application to a recent experiment and Hiley's lessons on the falsification of the Bohmian model
Bohmian trajectories computed for coupled waveguides reproduce standard quantum predictions and refute a recent experimental claim of falsification.
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.