REVIEW 20 cited by
Analyzing black-hole ringdowns
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
read the original abstract
A perturbed black hole rings down by emitting gravitational waves in tones with specific frequencies and durations. Such tones encode prized information about the geometry of the source spacetime and the fundamental nature of gravity, making the measurement of black hole ringdowns a key goal of gravitational wave astronomy. However, this task is plagued by technical challenges that invalidate the naive application of standard data analysis methods and complicate sensitivity projections. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive account of the formalism required to properly carry out ringdown analyses, examining in detail the foundations of recent observational results, and providing a framework for future measurements. We build on those insights to clarify the concepts of ringdown detectability and resolvability -- touching on the drawbacks of both Bayes factors and naive Fisher matrix approaches -- and find that overly pessimistic heuristics have led previous works to underestimate the role of ringdown overtones for black hole spectroscopy. We put our framework to work on the analysis of a variety of simulated signals in colored noise, including analytic injections and a numerical relativity simulation consistent with GW150914. We demonstrate that we can use tones of the quadrupolar angular harmonic to test the no-hair theorem at current sensitivity, with precision comparable to published constraints from real data. Finally, we assess the role of modeling systematics, and project measurements for future, louder signals. We release ringdown, a Python library for analyzing black hole ringdowns using the the methods discussed in this paper, under a permissive open-source license at https://github.com/maxisi/ringdown
Forward citations
Cited by 20 Pith papers
-
Probing Direct Waves in Black Hole Ringdowns
Merger gravitational wave signals contain a 'direct wave' from the plunging companions, screened by the remnant's potential, with frequency near the superradiant value for high-spin remnants and SNR above 10 in GW1509...
-
GWTC-5.0: Tests of General Relativity
Tests of general relativity on 168 LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA gravitational-wave events (including 72 new from O4b) find GR consistent with all data, improving post-Newtonian and ringdown deviation bounds by 1.2–2.6×.
-
Testing General Relativity with GWTC-4.0 through mixture models
A mixture-model framework for combining gravitational-wave tests of General Relativity yields Bayes factors of 10-20 favoring GR, substantially lower than existing methods that assume uniform deviations across events.
-
Finite signal-to-noise ratio bias in parameter estimation for damped oscillations: cautionary remark about catalog-level black-hole spectroscopy
Damping-time estimates for ringdown signals carry unsuppressed O(ρ^{-2}) positive biases from priors and likelihood geometry, risking false Kerr violations after ~100 events at ρ≈10.
-
Computing spectral shifts for Johannsen-Psaltis black holes
Slowly rotating Johannsen–Psaltis black holes have definite-parity quasinormal modes with even/odd frequency shifts split by the deviation parameter, computed here through ℓ=10.
-
GW250114 reveals black hole horizon signatures
The merger signal of GW250114 contains a residual 'direct wave' component whose frequency and damping match the remnant horizon's rotation frequency and surface gravity.
-
GW230814: investigation of a loud gravitational-wave signal observed with a single detector
GW230814 is a binary black hole merger seen in a single detector, yielding the first confident l=4 mode detection and a ringdown damping anomaly that noise or waveform models can explain.
-
Detection of a Higher Harmonic Quasi-normal Mode in the Ringdown Signal of GW231123
The ringdown of GW231123 contains a detectable 200 quasinormal mode in addition to the fundamental 220 mode, with log10 Bayes factor 5.3, and the inferred remnant mass and spin agree with general relativity.
-
Compressive Meta-Learning
Meta-learned neural encoders and decoders for compressive learning aim to make parameter estimation from compact database sketches faster and more accurate than randomized, data-independent compressive learning.
-
Progress toward the detection of the gravitational-wave background from stellar-mass binary black holes: a mock data challenge
A mock data challenge shows that a phase-coherent search for the binary black hole background can recover injected signal fractions in realistic noise, using new treatments of noise uncertainty, finite-duration effect...
-
Statistical identification of ringdown modes with rational filters
A frequentist false-alarm framework for rational-filter ringdown analysis is validated on numerical relativity waveforms and shows only marginal evidence for the 221 overtone in GW150914.
-
Ringdown Analysis of Rotating Black Holes in Effective Field Theory Extensions of General Relativity
No evidence of higher-derivative EFT corrections in black hole ringdown spectra from GWTC-3; new physics length scale constrained to ℓ ≲ 35 km.
-
Overtones and Nonlinearities in Binary Black Hole Ringdowns
High-accuracy numerical relativity waveforms confirm the physical presence of many (2,2) overtones and reveal several second-order quasinormal modes.
-
Constraining deviations from the Teukolsky equation with GW250114
GW250114's fundamental ringdown mode bounds theory-agnostic deviations from the Teukolsky equation to be consistent with zero at characteristic scales of 60-100 km.
-
Extended parameterized spin expansion formalism for ringdown analysis with GW250114
Simultaneously sampling the EFT scaling index p̃ and length scale ℓ̃ in ParSpec shows p̃ is prior-dominated and the ℓ̃ ~ 83 km bound is mostly prior geometry.
-
Wavelets for power spectral density estimation of gravitational wave data
Wavelet smoothing of periodograms is shown to give higher frequency resolution and moderate improvements in matched-filter SNR and Bayesian evidence over Welch PSD for GW150914, while median wavelet packet PSD (especi...
-
Complementarity of Gravitation Collapse (II) XOB and the Damping Gravitational Waveform as Evidences
The paper argues that binary black-hole merger waveforms damp only if black holes have extended inner structure that deforms like a banana during merger.
-
Probing Spacetime Symmetries Using Gravitational Wave Ringdown
A Bayesian analysis of the GW150914 ringdown places broad limits on violations of Kerr black hole 'circularity' symmetries, but the constraints are weak and the proposed model contains an internal sign inconsistency.
-
Probing black holes via quasinormal modes in a dark energy-induced dark matter
For a dark-energy-induced dark matter black hole metric, quasinormal mode frequencies decrease in real part and damping as η and λG increase, relative to Schwarzschild.
-
Reanalyzing the ringdown signal of GW150914 using the F-statistic method
Applying the F-statistic method to GW150914's ringdown yields FIC = -0.3 for adding the first overtone, consistent with no overtone, while an injection with an overtone yields FIC = 0.3.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.