REVIEW
Radiatively Induced Neutrino Masses and Large Higgs-Neutrino Couplings in the Standard Model with Majorana Fields
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology · Submitted 2 Jan 1999 · 27 references
Pith's verdict: Solid one-loop derivation, but the numerical example looks off by two to three orders of magnitude and the degeneracy's radiative stability is never discussed.
T0 · AI review
Why Pith says this
Highlight any text to comment on it.
Referee report
The paper
The paper claims
The paper argues that in the Standard Model extended by one right-handed neutrino per family, light neutrinos can acquire their observed tiny Majorana masses not from a very heavy seesaw scale but from a one-loop electroweak correction, so
The reading
What carries the argument
The load-bearing object is the one-loop neutrino self-energy in the presence of the light–heavy mixing matrix $C_{ u_i N_k}$, combined with the unitarity identity $sum_k m_{N_k} C_{iN_k} C_{jN_k} = 0$. That identity does two jobs at once: it cancels the subtraction-point dependence in the loop function $f(m_N^2, M^2)$, and it converts the masslessness of the light neutrinos into a statement about heavy-neutrino degeneracy. The mixing matrix itself comes from expanding the diagonalizing matrix $U^ u$ in powers of $xi = m_D m_M^{-1}$, with $xi_{ij}$ bounded above by about $0.1$–$0.2$ from charge-current universality and neutral-current data. The same expansion produces the enhanced Higgs vertices, so one structure supplies both the small mass and the large collider coupling.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The central claim is that a radiatively generated neutrino mass matrix, computed from the one-loop self-energy graphs with $Z^0$ and Higgs exchange in Feynman gauge, can reproduce $m_ u < 10$ eV while the heavy Majorana neutrinos have masses of order $100$ GeV. The one-loop result is $m_{ u_i u_j} = (lpha_W/16pi) sum_k (m_{N_k}/M_W^2) C_{ u_i N_k} C_{ u_j N_k} F(m_{N_k}^2, M_Z^2, M_H^2)$, and the unitarity identity $sum_k m_{N_k} C_{iN_k} C_{jN_k} = 0$ makes the answer vanish when the heavy neutrinos are exactly degenerate. Small neutrino masses therefore follow from near-degeneracy of the heavy states, not from an enormous mass scale. In the two-generation illustration the mass matrices are chosen so that both light neutrinos are massless at tree level, with $d = bc/a$ and $B = -(b^2/a^2)A$, and a small perturbation $arepsilon = (b-a)/a$ of order $10^{-4}$ around the family-independent limit gives $m_{ u_2} sim 1$–$10$ eV for $a = c = 10$ GeV and $A = 100$ GeV. The second claim is that in this same regime the $H^0$–$ u$–$N$ coupling is larger than the corresponding $Z^0$ coupling by roughly $m_N/M_W$, and the $H^0$–$N$–$N$ coupling by roughly $2m_N/M_W$, so Higgs-mediated production of heavy neutrinos is not negligible.
Load-bearing premise
The mechanism only produces light neutrinos if the heavy neutrinos are nearly degenerate, and that degeneracy is put in by hand through the family-independent limit plus a small perturbation, not enforced by any symmetry of the model.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- Heavy Majorana neutrinos with masses near $100$ GeV and mixings of order $0.1$ would be produced at the LHC and at a 1–2 TeV $e^+e^-$ collider, giving like-sign dilepton pairs plus jets with no missing transverse momentum.
- For a Higgs boson in the intermediate mass range $100 \le M_H \le 150$ GeV, the decay $H^0 \to \nu N$ can be the dominant channel, with $\mathrm{Br}(H \to \nu N)$ peaking near $3 \times 10^{-2}$ at $M_H \simeq 1.5\,m_N$.
- The $W$-exchange process $pp \to W^{-*} \to l^- N X$ gives up to roughly $10^{4}$ lepton-number-violating events per year at the LHC for $m_N = 150$ GeV with unsuppressed $W$–$l$–$N$ coupling, about a hundred times the Higgs-mediated rate.
- Because the loop mass is proportional to the heavy-neutrino mass splitting, the observed light-neutrino mass scale becomes a measurement of how nearly degenerate the heavy states are, rather than of how heavy they are.
- A large $H^0$–$\nu$–$N$ coupling would also produce lepton-flavour-violating Higgs decays with no missing transverse momentum and no hard jets, a clean experimental signature.
Reading between the lines
- The mechanism trades a hierarchy in mass scales for a hierarchy in mass splittings: the same small parameter that makes the light neutrinos light also has to be protected from radiative corrections, so the naturalness question simply moves from the seesaw scale to the degeneracy of the heavy states.
- If the heavy neutrinos are instead found to be widely split, the loop contribution would not be small, and the model would need either a much lower cutoff or additional symmetry to keep the light masses at the eV scale.
- The prediction that the Higgs can decay dominantly into $\nu N$ in the $100$–$150$ GeV window is a sharper target than the generic heavy-neutrino search, because it would appear as a deficit in standard Higgs branching ratios together with large missing transverse momentum.
- The near-degeneracy required here resembles the degenerate heavy-spectrum limit used in leptogenesis-style scenarios, where small mass splittings control the size of CP violation; the same parameters that fix the light masses would then also constrain the cosmological lepton asymmetry.
Original abstract
The Higgs sector of the Standard Model with one right-handed neutrino per family is systematically analyzed. In a model with intergenerational independent mixings between families, we can account for very light neutrinos acquiring Majorana masses radiatively at the first electroweak loop level. We also find that in such a scenario the Higgs coupling to the light-heavy neutrinos and to the heavy-heavy ones may be remarkably enhanced with significant implications for the production of these heavy neutrinos at high energy colliders.
The compiled record
The paper's own sentences, arranged, kept beside the review and separate from it. Each label is drawn from a closed vocabulary; the number beside it is the probability the classifier gave that label. Numbers in the tables are the authors', checked by code. No sentence in this record was written by a model.
The abstract, sentence by sentence
The Higgs sector of the Standard Model with one right-handed neutrino per family is systematically analyzed. In a model with intergenerational independent mixings between families, we can account for very light neutrinos acquiring Majorana masses radiatively at the first electroweak loop level. We also find that in such a scenario the Higgs coupling to the light-heavy neutrinos and to the heavy-heavy ones may be remarkably enhanced with significant implications for the production of these heavy neutrinos at high energy colliders.
background contribution method result interpretation main claim
| # | sentence | role | the authors' own work | states the main conclusion | strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| s0 | The Higgs sector of the Standard Model with one right-handed neutrino per family is systematically analyzed. | contribution 0.90 | 0.78 | 0.04 | asserted 0.91 |
| s1 | In a model with intergenerational independent mixings between families, we can account for very light neutrinos acquiring Majorana masses radiatively at the first electroweak loop level. | result 0.95 | 0.81 | 0.43 | hedged possibility 0.77 |
| s2 | We also find that in such a scenario the Higgs coupling to the light-heavy neutrinos and to the heavy-heavy ones may be remarkably enhanced with significant implications for the production of these heavy neutrinos at high energy colliders. | result 0.68 | 0.94 | 0.45 | hedged possibility 0.72 |
What was examined, and what was not
- arXiv listing abstract v1
- full text
- figures and tables
- references and citing sentences
- relations to other papers
- P abstract
- S sections
- T body sentences
- C citations
- R cross-paper relations
Figures
Figures reproduced from arXiv:hep-ph/9901206 by the authors.
References
How later papers used it
138 later papers cite it
2 later papers by other authors are listed below: 2 compared their own results with it.
Compares with it 2 papers
-
Computed the one-loop induced mass for neutrinos and found it to agree with this paper.
Equivalence between massless neutrinos and lepton number conservation in fermionic singlet extensions of the Standard Model (2017) · 0.99 · paraphrased: the licence does not allow quoting
-
Recovered the expression for the Type-I seesaw case of this paper by turning off the g' gauge coupling.
Neutrino Masses from a Dark Neutrino Sector below the Electroweak Scale (2019) · 0.81 · paraphrased: the licence does not allow quoting
How the literature uses it
119 arXiv papers cite this in 173 sentences
Papers citing it · 126 sentences without a confident label
Contests it 1 paper
-
This result shows that current data clearly favours the NP hypothesis, exclude conventional models with right-handed neutrinos leading to necessary destructive interference [ref] and promote the search for NP models as the ones presented in Refs. [ref] .
Modified lepton couplings and the Cabibbo-angle anomaly · Results and Conclusions · contest 0.73
Uses its method or tool 2 papers
-
In this we closely follow the treatment of radiative corrections given in [ref] .
Generalised $\mu$-$\tau$ symmetries and calculable gauge kinetic and mass mixing in $U(1)_{L_\mu-L_\tau}$ models · Kinetic mixing in the standard seesaw model · 0.96
-
In our study of the parameter space we employ the usual Casas-Ibarra parametrization [ref] , [equation] where $U_ν$ is the PMNS matrix, $m_ν$ and $M_M$ are the mass matrices of the light and heavy neutrinos respectively.[ This parametrization can be modified to include radiative corrections [ref] by replacing $√(M_i) →M_i/√(M̃_i)$ [ref] , as well corrections from unitarity of the mixing matrix [ref] . ] The matrix $ℛ$ satisfies $ℛ ℛ^T=1$ and is usually parametrized by three complex Euler angles.
Mapping the viable parameter space for testable leptogenesis · Introduction · 1.00
Compares with it 2 papers
-
We computed the one-loop induced mass for neutrinos and found it to agree with [ref] , giving [equation] with $i,j ∈{ 1, 2, 3 }$, $α_W = g^2/4 π$ with $g$ the $SU(2)_L$ coupling constant, [equation] [equation] and [equation] where [equation] As $f(0)=0$, it is useful to define a diagonal matrix [equation] such that eq.([ref]) may be rewritten in matrix form as [equation]
Equivalence between massless neutrinos and lepton number conservation in fermionic singlet extensions of the Standard Model · The matrix $M$ as a necessary condition for massless light neutrinos: $M̂_l = 0 M$ · 0.99
-
Turning off the $g^'$ gauge coupling, we recover the expression for the Type-I seesaw case [ref] : [equation]
Neutrino Masses from a Dark Neutrino Sector below the Electroweak Scale · Radiative corrections · 0.81
Cites it as support 3 papers
-
If their decay can be detected, e.g., in LLP searches, we can probe the seesaw floor in a much broader range [ref] .
Testing Leptogenesis and Seesaw using Long-lived Particle Searches in the $B-L$ Model · Introduction · 0.96
-
This leads to the well-known decoupling of observable lepton number violation in the minimal, high-scale Type I Seesaw scenario at colliders experiments [ref] .
Lepton Number Violation: Seesaw Models and Their Collider Tests · The Canonical Type I Seesaw Mechanism · 0.96
-
This has been explicitly shown in Ref. [ref] with a calculation in the mass basis.
From the trees to the forest: a review of radiative neutrino mass models · Other 1-loop models · 0.98
Cites it as background 35 papers
-
On the other hand, the direct collider searches for heavy neutrinos at the energy frontier can provide a simultaneous probe of both the aspects of the seesaw mechanism, i.e. the Majorana nature of the heavy neutrinos $N$ and their mixing with the active neutrinos, provided the seesaw scale is accessible to the available center of mass energy; for a review, see e.g. [ref] .[For some examples of low-scale seesaw models with relatively large active-sterile neutrino mixing, which lead to observable effects at colliders as discussed here, see [ref] .] In particular, electroweak-scale heavy neutrinos can be produced on-shell at colliders with a cross section depending on the strength of their mixing with the active neutrinos in the minimal setup, while their subsequent decay pattern is governed by whether they are Majorana or Dirac particles.
Prospects of Heavy Neutrino Searches at Future Lepton Colliders · Introduction · 0.86
-
This fantastic issue has been discussed by taking into account fixed-scale corrections [ref] or renormalization-group (RG) running corrections without threshold effects [ref] (see, e.g., Refs. [ref] and [ref] for a review on these two kinds of quantum corrections, respectively).
Threshold Effects on the Massless Neutrino in the Canonical Seesaw Mechanism · Introduction · 0.94
-
Here I explore the consequences of assuming that the Majorana neutrino mass scale is generated at the electroweak scale [For previous work on the phenomenology of electroweak scale right-handed neutrinos, see [ref] .
Broadening the Higgs Boson with Right-Handed Neutrinos and a Higher Dimension Operator at the Electroweak Scale · Motivation · 0.93
Discussion
Disagree with the review, or know something it missed? Leave a comment, highlight any passage above to comment on it, or challenge this review formally.