REVIEW
More Dual Fluxes and Moduli Fixing
High Energy Physics - Theory · Submitted 9 Feb 2006 · 49 references
Pith's verdict: A careful, honest extension of non-geometric fluxes that adds an S-dual P sector and finds Kahler-fixing Minkowski vacua, with the main caveat flagged by the authors themselves.
T0 · AI review
Why Pith says this
Highlight any text to comment on it.
Referee report
The paper
The paper claims
Type IIB S-duality forces a second family of non-geometric fluxes, and with it the Kähler moduli can be fixed.
The reading
What carries the argument
The machinery is a T-duality chain relating $H_{MNP}$, the metric flux $omega_{MN}{}^P$, the non-geometric $Q_M{}^{NP}$ and $R_{MNP}$ across the type IIA/O6, type IIB/O3 and type IIB/O9 orientifolds, promoted to an $SL(2, Z)_S$ doublet structure by pairing $Q$ with a new $P$. Contraction rules such as $(QX)_{L M_1 ... M_{p-2}} = (1/2) Q^{AB}{}_{[L} X_{M_1 ... M_{p-2}]AB}$ let the fluxes be wedged with the complexified forms $Omega$, $J_c$, $J_c^{(2)}$ and $J_c^{(3)}$ to produce superpotential terms and tadpole contributions as integrals over $T^6$. The same contraction, applied to the extended algebra of isometry and B-field generators $[Z_M, Z_N]$, $[Z_M, X^P]$ and $[X^M, X^N]$, generates the Bianchi identities that constrain the fluxes, and $SL(2, Z)_S$ covariance then dictates the constraints obeyed by $P$ and by mixed $Q$-$P$ combinations.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The central claim is that the non-geometric flux programme is incomplete without a second tensor, $P^{MNP}$, with exactly the same index structure as the non-geometric $Q^{MNP}$ but opposite behaviour under S-duality. The proposed superpotential in eq. (4.5) pairs $(F_3, H_3)$ and $(Q, P)$ as $SL(2, Z)$ doublets, so that $S$ to $1/S$ exchanges $F_3$ with $H_3$ and $Q$ with $-P$. The $P$ terms contribute monomials of the form $S T_i$ times a cubic polynomial in the $U_j$, which is precisely the ingredient missing from earlier superpotentials that were at most quadratic in the $T_i$. Using an isotropic ansatz with $T_i = T$ and $U_i = U$, the authors exhibit explicit Minkowski vacua with all moduli fixed, for instance taking $a = -8$, $b = -4$, $h = -4$, $gamma = -4$, $bar a = 12$, $h_0 = 8$ and $e = -16$ gives $U = S = sqrt{2}$ and $T = (14 sqrt{2} + 16 i)/9$. They also report that the flux contribution to the $C_4$ tadpole can take either sign, unlike the purely imaginary-self-dual case where it is always positive.
Load-bearing premise
The constraints obeyed by the new $P$ fluxes, and hence the vacua built on them, are obtained by applying S-duality to the known $Q$-flux Bianchi identities rather than derived independently from a ten-dimensional reduction, a gap the authors state explicitly in section 4.2.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- Every flux-induced superpotential term of the form $S T_i$ times a polynomial in the $U_j$ becomes available, so Kähler moduli need no longer be flat directions in type IIB toroidal orientifolds.
- The $C_8$ and $tilde C_8$ tadpoles become an $SL(2, Z)_S$ triplet with $C_8$, sourcing D7-, NS7- and I7-branes, and the flux contributions to all three can have either sign, vanish, or cancel.
- The Bianchi identities close under S-duality into a triplet of conditions $Q cdot Q = 0$, $P cdot P = 0$ and $Q cdot P + P cdot Q = 0$, plus the singlet $Q cdot H_3 - P cdot F_3 = 0$.
- Comparison with M-theory on $T^7/(Z_2 ^{-3})$ identifies the $f_i$ fluxes with ordinary metric fluxes $omega_{K+1,K,11}$ of the seven-torus, and heterotic self-T-duality requires still further fluxes $F'_3$, $Q'$, $H'_3$ and $P'$.
- The full duality-invariant superpotential is conjectured to contain $2^7 = 128$ flux parameters, one for each monomial in the seven moduli that is at most linear in each field, filling a spinorial representation of $SO(7,7;Z)$.
Reading between the lines
- If the $P$ fluxes are genuine, the same doublet structure should appear in the four-dimensional gauged supergravity description, where $Q$ and $P$ would be electric and magnetic counterparts of one another; checking the embedding tensor against the paper's Bianchi identities would be an independent test.
- The observation that flux tadpoles can mimic orientifold planes rather than branes suggests a model-building route: flux contributions of the wrong sign could cancel the charge of an orientifold plane locally, allowing brane configurations that would otherwise be forbidden by tadpole cancellation.
- Because the superpotential is only linear in the $T_i$, at most one linear combination of the three Kähler moduli is fixed in the general non-isotropic case; the remaining flat directions may be exactly what is needed for the Green-Schwarz mechanism that gives mass to anomalous $U(1)$ gauge bosons on D-branes.
- The paper's duality-extrapolated constraints are a natural target for a direct worldsheet or ten-dimensional derivation; if such a derivation produces a different set of conditions on $P$, the numerical vacua in section 5 would have to be revisited.
Original abstract
We generalize the recent proposal that invariance under T-duality leads to additional non-geometric fluxes required so that superpotentials in type IIA and type IIB orientifolds match. We show that invariance under type IIB S-duality requires the introduction of a new set of fluxes leading to further superpotential terms. We find new classes of N=1 supersymmetric Minkowski vacua based on type IIB toroidal orientifolds in which not only dilaton and complex moduli but also Kahler moduli are fixed. The chains of dualities relating type II orientifolds to heterotic and M-theory compactifications suggests the existence of yet further flux degrees of freedom. Restricting to a particular type IIA/IIB or heterotic compactification only some of these degrees of freedom have a simple perturbative and/or geometric interpretation.
The compiled record
The paper's own sentences, arranged, kept beside the review and separate from it. Each label is drawn from a closed vocabulary; the number beside it is the probability the classifier gave that label. Numbers in the tables are the authors', checked by code. No sentence in this record was written by a model.
The abstract, sentence by sentence
We generalize the recent proposal that invariance under T-duality leads to additional non-geometric fluxes required so that superpotentials in type IIA and type IIB orientifolds match. We show that invariance under type IIB S-duality requires the introduction of a new set of fluxes leading to further superpotential terms. We find new classes of N=1 supersymmetric Minkowski vacua based on type IIB toroidal orientifolds in which not only dilaton and complex moduli but also Kahler moduli are fixed. The chains of dualities relating type II orientifolds to heterotic and M-theory compactifications suggests the existence of yet further flux degrees of freedom. Restricting to a particular type IIA/IIB or heterotic compactification only some of these degrees of freedom have a simple perturbative and/or geometric interpretation.
background contribution method result interpretation main claim
| # | sentence | role | the authors' own work | states the main conclusion | strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| s0 | We generalize the recent proposal that invariance under T-duality leads to additional non-geometric fluxes required so that superpotentials in type IIA and type IIB orientifolds match. | contribution 0.84 | 0.60 | 0.15 | asserted 0.92 |
| s1 | We show that invariance under type IIB S-duality requires the introduction of a new set of fluxes leading to further superpotential terms. | contribution 0.59 | 0.93 | 0.20 | asserted 1.00 |
| s2 | We find new classes of N=1 supersymmetric Minkowski vacua based on type IIB toroidal orientifolds in which not only dilaton and complex moduli but also Kahler moduli are fixed. | result 0.97 | 0.95 | 0.47 | asserted 1.00 |
| s3 | The chains of dualities relating type II orientifolds to heterotic and M-theory compactifications suggests the existence of yet further flux degrees of freedom. | interpretation 0.67 | 0.16 | 0.08 | hedged possibility 1.00 |
| s4 | Restricting to a particular type IIA/IIB or heterotic compactification only some of these degrees of freedom have a simple perturbative and/or geometric interpretation. | interpretation 0.49 | 0.28 | 0.06 | asserted 0.95 |
What was examined, and what was not
- arXiv listing abstract v1
- full text
- figures and tables
- references and citing sentences
- relations to other papers
- P abstract
- S sections
- T body sentences
- C citations
- R cross-paper relations
References
How the literature uses it
86 arXiv papers cite this in 319 sentences
Papers citing it · 233 sentences without a confident label
Contests it 1 paper
-
However, the Minkowski vacua given in [ref] are not under good perturbative control.
Searching for Inflation in Simple String Theory Models: An Astrophysical Perspective · The potential energy challenge · contest 0.75
Uses its method or tool 7 papers
-
-1.0cm V_IIB^tad = 1/2 e^K^(Q) ∫_X_3 ⟨ [Im Φ_c^even ] , D F_RR ⟩, where the multi-form $D F_RR$ can be expanded using the flux actions in the generalized twisted differential operator given as under [ref] ,
Dictionary for the type II nongeometric flux compactifications · Tadpoles cancellation conditions and Bianchi identities : · 0.85
-
One way to derive these identities is via the Jacobi identities of the following Lie brackets for the NS-NS fluxes [ref] , [Z_i, Z_j ] = ω_ij^k Z_k - H_ijk X^k, [ Z_i, X^j ] = Q_i^jk Z_k - ω_ik^j X^k , [ X^i, X^j] = Q_k^ij X^k - R^ijk Z_k , where $Z_i$ and $X^i$'s are generators of the gauge transformations corresponding to the two gauge groups consisting of two sets of $d$-dimensional vectors obtained, from the metric and the $B$-field respectively, via the reduction of type II superstring theory on a $d$-dimensional torus.
On Missing Bianchi Identities in Cohomology Formulation · First formulation · 0.83
-
We will find that the general NS-NS fluxes are most naturally parametrized by their action on the untwisted cohomology, along the lines described in [ref] .
Toroidal Orientifolds in IIA with General NS-NS Fluxes · Introduction · 0.87
Uses its data or values 1 paper
-
D3-QP which are taken from [ref] .
IIB String Theory and Sequestered Inflation · Effective 4D theory and tadpole cancellation conditions · 0.91
Compares with it 7 papers
-
Comparing this potential, using the decomposition ([ref]) and the parametrization ([ref]), with those obtained from Scherk-Schwarz reductions with fluxes [ref] as well as with their non-geometric generalizations [ref] , leads us to identify $H_abc$ with the standard NS-NS flux, $τ_ab^abc$ with the geometric flux, $Q_c^cab$ with the locally geometric flux and $R^abc$ with the so-called non-geometric flux.
Conformal chiral boson models on twisted doubled tori and non-geometric string vacua · Twisted doubled tori and $N=4$ gauged supergravities · 1.00
-
In order to explicitly determine the structures of the $P^', Q^', H^'$ and $F^'$ flux components, we compare our results with the non-symplectic formulation presented in [ref] .
Symplectic formulation of the type IIB scalar potential with U-dual fluxes · More insights of the flux components in the cohomology basis · 0.97
-
In particular, one may check that ([ref]) reproduces the results derived by similar arguments in [ref] for the case of $Γ=ℤ_2×ℤ_2$ and $G=SL(2,ℝ)^7$.[For completeness we present here the embedding of $SL(2,ℝ)^7⊂E_7$ selected by the $ℤ_2×ℤ_2$ orbifold.
U-dual fluxes and Generalized Geometry · Type IIB orientifold compactifications · 0.97
Cites it as support 1 paper
-
It turns out that adding these extra ingredients really does alleviate some of the problems mentioned above [ref] .
D-Terms from Generalized NS-NS Fluxes in Type II · Introduction · 1.00
Cites it as background 41 papers
-
They arise from type IIB generalised flux compactifications on $𝕋^6/ (ℤ_2 ×ℤ_2)$ isotropic orientifolds with O3/O7-planes [ref] .
Complete classification of Minkowski vacua in generalised flux models · The $𝒩=1$ SUGRA models · 0.86
-
We are working with a type IIB string compactification on the $ℤ_2 ×ℤ_2$ orbifold considered in [ref] , where the space-time topology is $ℳ_10=ℳ_4 ×ℳ_6$, $ℳ_6$ our compact internal space, initially a $6$-torus, $𝕋^6$ and $ℳ_4$ the noncompact space-time.
Non-geometric flux vacua, S-duality and algebraic geometry · Conventions and 3-form fluxes. · 0.91
-
Implementing the successive chain of T- and S-dualities, leads to a U-dual completion of the flux superpotential which has been studied in [ref] .
Symplectic formulation of the type IIB scalar potential with U-dual fluxes · Introduction · 0.81
Discussion
Disagree with the review, or know something it missed? Leave a comment, highlight any passage above to comment on it, or challenge this review formally.