Recognition: 2 theorem links
· Lean TheoremThe propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling I: The relevance of uncertain aspects of stellar evolution and the IMF to the derived physical properties of galaxies
Pith reviewed 2026-05-09 17:44 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
Uncertainties in stellar evolution and the IMF produce 0.3 dex errors in low-redshift galaxy masses and 0.6 dex at z~2 for bright red galaxies
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
By sampling uncertainties in key stellar evolution phases and the IMF within stellar population synthesis models and fitting them via Monte Carlo Markov Chain methods to near-UV through near-IR photometry, the paper establishes that galaxy stellar masses at z~0 carry uncertainties of ~0.3 dex at 95% confidence level with little dependence on luminosity or color, while at z~2 the masses of bright red galaxies reach uncertainties of ~0.6 dex. Current stellar evolution models or observational libraries do not adequately capture the metallicity dependence of the TP-AGB phase. Conservative variations in the local IMF slope produce ~0.4 mag uncertainty in K-band luminosity evolution per unit of z,
What carries the argument
Monte Carlo Markov-Chain sampling of stellar population synthesis models that include variations in stellar evolution phases and the IMF, applied to multi-band photometry fitting
If this is right
- Stellar masses at z~0 carry ~0.3 dex errors at 95% CL largely independent of luminosity and color.
- Masses of bright red galaxies at z~2 are uncertain at the ~0.6 dex level.
- IMF slope variations in the solar neighborhood produce ~0.4 mag uncertainty in K-band luminosity evolution per unit redshift.
- Adopting a distribution of stellar metallicities instead of a single value alters interpretation of galaxy colors blueward of the V-band.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- Reducing mass uncertainties at high redshift will require new stellar evolution calculations that better track the TP-AGB phase across a range of metallicities.
- Galaxy evolution studies that compare observed stellar mass functions to simulations must fold in these SPS uncertainties to avoid over-interpreting apparent discrepancies.
- Photometric surveys aiming to measure the buildup of stellar mass across cosmic time will need to propagate these modeling errors explicitly into their derived quantities.
Load-bearing premise
Uncertainties in stellar evolution phases and the IMF can be adequately represented by Monte Carlo sampling from the range of existing models even though those models do not fully characterize the metallicity dependence of the TP-AGB phase.
What would settle it
Comparison of the paper's predicted mass uncertainties against independent dynamical or spectroscopic mass estimates for the same sample of low- and high-redshift galaxies.
read the original abstract
The stellar masses, mean ages, metallicities, and star formation histories of galaxies are now commonly estimated via stellar population synthesis (SPS) techniques. SPS relies on stellar evolution calculations from the main sequence to stellar death, stellar spectral libraries, phenomenological dust models, and stellar initial mass functions (IMFs). The present work is the first in a series that explores the impact of uncertainties in key phases of stellar evolution and the IMF on the derived physical properties of galaxies and the expected luminosity evolution for a passively evolving set of stars. A Monte-Carlo Markov-Chain approach is taken to fit near-UV through near-IR photometry of a representative sample of low- and high-redshift galaxies with this new SPS model. Significant results include the following: 1) including uncertainties in stellar evolution, stellar masses at z~0 carry errors of ~0.3 dex at 95% CL with little dependence on luminosity or color, while at z~2, the masses of bright red galaxies are uncertain at the ~0.6 dex level; 2) either current stellar evolution models, current observational stellar libraries, or both, do not adequately characterize the metallicity-dependence of the thermally-pulsating asymptotic giant branch phase; 3) conservative estimates on the uncertainty of the slope of the IMF in the solar neighborhood imply that luminosity evolution per unit redshift is uncertain at the ~0.4 mag level in the K-band, which is a substantial source of uncertainty for interpreting the evolution of galaxy populations across time; 4) The more plausible assumption of a distribution of stellar metallicities, rather than a fixed value as is usually assumed, can have significant effects on the interpretation of colors blueward of the V-band. (ABRIDGED)
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript develops a Monte Carlo Markov Chain (MCMC) framework to propagate uncertainties in stellar evolution phases and the initial mass function (IMF) through stellar population synthesis (SPS) models when fitting near-UV to near-IR photometry. It reports that, when these uncertainties are included, stellar masses at z~0 have ~0.3 dex errors at 95% CL with weak dependence on luminosity or color, while bright red galaxies at z~2 have ~0.6 dex uncertainties; it further concludes that current models or libraries inadequately capture the metallicity dependence of the thermally-pulsating asymptotic giant branch (TP-AGB) phase, that IMF slope uncertainty implies ~0.4 mag uncertainty in K-band luminosity evolution, and that a distribution of metallicities (rather than a single value) affects colors blueward of the V band.
Significance. If the central results hold, the work is significant because it supplies quantitative, observationally grounded estimates of systematic uncertainties that affect widely used SPS-derived quantities such as stellar mass and star-formation history. The MCMC propagation of multiple stellar-evolution and IMF variations is a methodological strength, and the explicit identification of TP-AGB modeling deficiencies provides a concrete target for future stellar-library improvements. The reported 0.4 mag K-band evolution uncertainty is directly relevant to interpretations of galaxy luminosity functions across cosmic time.
major comments (2)
- [Abstract] Abstract, result 1: the reported ~0.6 dex stellar-mass uncertainty at z~2 for bright red galaxies rests on MCMC sampling of current stellar-evolution models; however, result 2 states that these same models fail to characterize the metallicity dependence of the TP-AGB phase, which dominates near-IR light and mass-to-light ratios for ~0.5–2 Gyr populations. Because the sampling does not vary this phase beyond existing libraries, the quoted posterior widths may understate the true systematic uncertainty.
- [Abstract] Abstract, result 3: the claim that conservative IMF-slope uncertainties produce ~0.4 mag uncertainty in K-band luminosity evolution per unit redshift requires explicit demonstration that the adopted IMF variation distribution is independent of the stellar-evolution uncertainties already sampled; any covariance between IMF and TP-AGB parameters would alter the combined error budget.
minor comments (2)
- The abstract is labeled 'ABRIDGED'; the main text should state whether the four numbered results are exhaustive or whether additional quantitative findings appear later.
- Define all acronyms (SPS, MCMC, TP-AGB, IMF, CL) on first use in the body of the paper.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for their careful and constructive review. The two major comments raise important points about the interpretation of our uncertainty estimates. We address each below and outline targeted revisions to improve clarity without altering the core results.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: [Abstract] Abstract, result 1: the reported ~0.6 dex stellar-mass uncertainty at z~2 for bright red galaxies rests on MCMC sampling of current stellar-evolution models; however, result 2 states that these same models fail to characterize the metallicity dependence of the TP-AGB phase, which dominates near-IR light and mass-to-light ratios for ~0.5–2 Gyr populations. Because the sampling does not vary this phase beyond existing libraries, the quoted posterior widths may understate the true systematic uncertainty.
Authors: We agree that the ~0.6 dex figure is derived solely from variations present in existing stellar-evolution models and libraries. Result 2 already states that these models/libraries inadequately capture the metallicity dependence of the TP-AGB phase. The quoted posterior therefore represents the uncertainty obtainable within the current framework and is best viewed as a lower limit. We will revise the abstract and add a sentence in the discussion to explicitly note that deficiencies in TP-AGB modeling imply the true systematic uncertainty is likely larger. revision: partial
-
Referee: [Abstract] Abstract, result 3: the claim that conservative IMF-slope uncertainties produce ~0.4 mag uncertainty in K-band luminosity evolution per unit redshift requires explicit demonstration that the adopted IMF variation distribution is independent of the stellar-evolution uncertainties already sampled; any covariance between IMF and TP-AGB parameters would alter the combined error budget.
Authors: The IMF slope is sampled as an independent parameter with its own prior based on solar-neighborhood constraints, separate from the stellar-evolution parameters (including those affecting TP-AGB). These are physically distinct: IMF governs the initial mass distribution while TP-AGB uncertainties affect evolutionary tracks and luminosities of a limited mass range. We will add an explicit statement in the methods section confirming independence of the priors and briefly discuss why covariance is not expected in this setup. revision: yes
Circularity Check
No circularity: forward propagation of external model uncertainties via MCMC
full rationale
The paper constructs an SPS model that samples variations drawn from existing stellar evolution calculations and IMF constraints, then uses MCMC to fit galaxy photometry and reports the resulting posterior widths on stellar mass and other properties. These widths are direct outputs of the sampling procedure applied to independent inputs; they do not reduce by definition or self-citation to quantities already present in the fit. The paper explicitly flags that TP-AGB metallicity dependence is inadequately captured in the sampled libraries, but this is a stated limitation on the input models rather than a definitional loop. No self-citation load-bearing step, ansatz smuggling, or renaming of known results occurs in the derivation chain.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
free parameters (2)
- IMF slope uncertainty
- stellar evolution phase uncertainties
axioms (1)
- domain assumption SPS relies on stellar evolution calculations from the main sequence to stellar death, stellar spectral libraries, phenomenological dust models, and stellar initial mass functions.
Forward citations
Cited by 27 Pith papers
-
Resolving the Unresolved Galactic Winds in Multi-phase Models. I. Methodology and Application
A new fitting methodology applied to UV absorption data recovers radial trends in galactic wind velocities and mass-loading factors by constraining initial hot and cool phase parameters in a multiphase model.
-
Resolved Maps of Gas and Dust in a Massive Quiescent Galaxy at z=2 from INQUEST-JWST: Evidence of Accretion and Rejuvenation
Resolved gas and dust maps in a z=2 quiescent galaxy reveal accreted material from tidal interactions and a past star-formation rejuvenation, indicating that gas content variations are not solely due to consumption ti...
-
The functional form of galaxy and halo luminosity and mass functions
Exhaustive symbolic regression identifies low-complexity functional forms for luminosity and mass functions that outperform Schechter and Press-Schechter parametrizations while satisfying physical extrapolation and in...
-
A Census of Na D-traced neutral ISM and outflows at $0.6<z<4$
A JWST census detects neutral ISM absorption in 76 of 309 galaxies at 0.6<z<4 and outflows in 26, indicating AGN-driven neutral outflows dominate in quiescent systems at cosmic noon.
-
Massive Galaxies Form Early and Gray: Stellar Assembly and Dust Attenuation at $\mathbf{z>3.5}$ from CAPERS
Massive galaxies at z>3.5 assembled stars earlier than theoretical models predict and exhibit gray dust attenuation, especially at the highest masses.
-
Strong Progenitor Age Bias in Supernova Cosmology. III. Progenitor Age as the Physical Origin of the Type Ia Supernova Magnitude Steps with Host Properties
Progenitor age is the primary physical driver of the host-mass and host-sSFR magnitude steps in Type Ia supernovae, with the mass step eliminated by direct age correction.
-
Empirical estimates of how massive galaxies can be in {\Lambda}CDM
Corrected empirical limits show the most massive galaxies never exceed the theoretical baryonic maximum of 0.16 times halo virial mass, keeping observations consistent with LambdaCDM at all redshifts.
-
A Multiwavelength Assessment Disfavoring the X-ray Binary Origin of He III Regions in Metal-Poor Star-Forming Dwarf Galaxies
Accreting X-ray sources cannot supply enough EUV photons to account for He III regions in metal-poor star-forming dwarf galaxies.
-
Kinematic Stratification in Extremely Red Quasars Revealed by JWST
JWST observations of ERQs show stratified gas kinematics via deblended optical emission lines, with UV lines dominated by scattered light and optical lines mixing scattered and obscured emission.
-
Are Nucleosynthetic Yields Universal? Interpreting the Multi-Elemental Abundances of Quiescent Galaxies over Cosmic Time Using Milky Way Stars
Milky Way abundance trends act as effective empirical proxies for nucleosynthetic yields, recovering alpha and Fe-peak abundances in quiescent galaxies with 0.05 dex median offset versus 0.23 dex for theory, indicatin...
-
DeepDive: Simultaneous Formation of Massive Quiescent Galaxies in High-Redshift Galaxy Proto-clusters
JWST data show massive quiescent galaxies in high-redshift proto-clusters formed and quenched simultaneously, with AGN signatures, indicating environmental triggering of quenching.
-
SAGUI: SED-based Segmentation of Multi-band Galaxy Images -- Application to JADES in GOODS-South
SAGUI introduces a two-stage segmentation framework for multi-band galaxy images that combines starlet decomposition, spectral similarity analysis, and copula statistics to identify structures and recover low-surface-...
-
A Natural $\gtrsim 100\times$ Telescope: Discovery of the Strongly Lensed Type II SN 2025mkn at $z=1.37$
Discovery of a gravitationally lensed Type II supernova at z=1.37 with magnification ≳100×, confirmed via multi-telescope spectra and imaging.
-
Winding Back the Clock: Recent Star Formation Histories of Massive Quiescent Galaxies Are Consistent With Their Rapid Number Density Evolution Since $\mathbf{z\sim7}$
Star formation histories inferred for z=2-5 massive quiescent galaxies imply past number densities that align with observed rapid evolution since z~7.
-
Low-mass Active Galaxies in the SAMI Galaxy Survey with Spatially-resolved Spectroscopy
Spatially-resolved spectroscopy detects AGNs in 4-9% of low-mass galaxies, higher than single-fiber rates because it catches extended emission missed by central-point observations.
-
First results of AMBRA: Abundant Seeds and Early Mergers as a Pathway to the First Massive Black Holes
Abundant early heavy seeds plus frequent mergers produce the massive black holes seen by JWST at z>9 and yield about four LISA events per year at z>=8.
-
Empirical estimates of how massive galaxies can be in {\Lambda}CDM
Empirical upper limits on galaxy stellar masses from extreme value statistics, after correcting for Eddington bias and halo mass scatter, remain below the theoretical baryonic maximum of 0.16 times halo mass at all re...
-
Morphological and Star Formation Properties of Cosmic Noon Massive Quiescent Galaxies
Massive quiescent galaxies at cosmic noon are compact and bulge-dominated with inside-out quenching, where inner regions formed stars ~0.5 Gyr earlier and quenched faster than outskirts.
-
Galaxy luminosity functions from far-UV to submillimetre at $z=0$ in the COLIBRE simulations
COLIBRE simulations with SKIRT post-processing match observed galaxy luminosity functions from FUV to submm at z=0, except underpredicting bright mid-IR galaxies.
-
The role of small-scale environments in the quenching of massive galaxies at $1<z<5$
Massive quiescent galaxies at high redshifts show elevated fractions in small-scale overdensities, indicating environmental quenching via galaxy interactions plays a major role.
-
The Galaxy Luminosity Functions in ASTRID: Predictions for LSST
ASTRID simulation with dust model calibrated to SDSS at z=0 produces validated luminosity functions and LSST-ready mock catalogs of 378 million galaxies with predicted number counts in ugrizy bands from z=0 to 2.
-
Prevailing thermally-pulsing-asymptotic-giant branch stars in the near-infrared rest-frame spectra of distant quiescent galaxies: towards robust galaxy ages and masses
Models with prominent TP-AGB phases best fit the near-IR spectra of high-redshift quiescent galaxies, yielding younger ages and lower stellar masses than models with weaker TP-AGB contributions.
-
Revisiting the distance and the globular cluster system of the remarkable galaxy UDG1 in the NGC 5846 group
New SBF distance confirms NGC5846_UDG1 lies in the NGC 5846 group and reconciles prior GC counts to ~50 members, supporting a massive dark matter halo.
-
Sparks II: Panchromatic SED modeling and galaxy physical properties across the starburst to post-starburst sequence
Panchromatic SED modeling yields SFRs with smaller offset and scatter than optical-only fits for starburst to post-starburst galaxies, while Prospector AGN torus models distinguish AGN but underpredict luminosities by...
-
Comparative Bayesian SED Fitting of PEARLSDG
Revised distance and SED fitting demonstrate PEARLSDG is a typical quenched dwarf galaxy on the mass-metallicity relation rather than an exotic outlier.
-
Calibrating Photometric Mid-Infrared Star Formation Rates for JWST
Rest-frame 6-8um MIRI luminosity provides broken power-law SFR calibrations with 0.2-0.3 dex scatter and UV+IR composites at 0.15 dex, supporting robust use above log M* ~9 up to z~3.
-
On the relative CNO underabundance in quasar absorption systems at $z \sim 3$ arising from Population III enrichment and attenuation by intermediate-mass black holes and primordial baryon accretion
Intermediate-mass black holes acting as permanent matter sinks, combined with updated cosmic star formation rates and primordial baryon accretion, reduce the overpredicted CNO abundances from Population III stars to m...
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Abazajian , K. et al. 2004, , 128, 502
work page 2004
-
[2]
Adelman-McCarthy , J. K. et al. 2006, , 162, 38
work page 2006
- [3]
-
[4]
Bailyn , C. D. 1995, , 33, 133
work page 1995
-
[5]
Baraffe , I., Chabrier , G., Allard , F., & Hauschildt , P. H. 1998, , 337, 403
work page 1998
-
[6]
Bell , E. F., McIntosh , D. H., Katz , N., & Weinberg , M. D. 2003, , 149, 289
work page 2003
-
[7]
F., Phleps , S., Somerville , R
Bell , E. F., Phleps , S., Somerville , R. S., Wolf , C., Borch , A., & Meisenheimer , K. 2006, , 652, 270
work page 2006
-
[8]
Bertelli , G., Bressan , A., Chiosi , C., Fagotto , F., & Nasi , E. 1994, , 106, 275
work page 1994
-
[9]
Bessell , M. S., Brett , J. M., Scholz , M., & Wood , P. R. 1991, , 89, 335
work page 1991
-
[10]
Blanton , M. R. & Roweis , S. 2007, , 133, 734
work page 2007
-
[11]
Blanton , M. R. et al. 2003, , 125, 2348
work page 2003
- [12]
- [13]
-
[14]
Borch , A. et al. 2006, , 453, 869
work page 2006
-
[15]
Brinchmann , J., Charlot , S., White , S. D. M., Tremonti , C., Kauffmann , G., Heckman , T., & Brinkmann , J. 2004, , 351, 1151
work page 2004
-
[16]
Brown , M. J. I., Dey , A., Jannuzi , B. T., Brand , K., Benson , A. J., Brodwin , M., Croton , D. J., & Eisenhardt , P. R. 2007, , 654, 858
work page 2007
-
[17]
Brown , T. M., Bowers , C. W., Kimble , R. A., Sweigart , A. V., & Ferguson , H. C. 2000, , 532, 308
work page 2000
-
[18]
Brown , T. M. et al. 2005, , 130, 1693
work page 2005
-
[19]
Bruzual , A. G. 2007, in IAU Symposium, Vol. 241, IAU Symposium, ed. A. Vazdekis & R. F. Peletier , 125--132
work page 2007
- [20]
- [21]
- [22]
- [23]
-
[24]
Bundy , K. et al. 2006, , 651, 120
work page 2006
-
[25]
Cassisi , S., Castellani , V., Ciarcelluti , P., Piotto , G., & Zoccali , M. 2000, , 315, 679
work page 2000
-
[26]
Catal \'a n , S., Isern , J., Garc \' a-Berro , E., & Ribas , I. 2008, , 387, 1693
work page 2008
-
[27]
Cattaneo , A., Dekel , A., Faber , S. M., & Guiderdoni , B. 2008, , 389, 567
work page 2008
- [28]
-
[29]
1996, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol
Charlot , S. 1996, in Astronomical Society of the Pacific Conference Series, Vol. 98, From Stars to Galaxies: the Impact of Stellar Physics on Galaxy Evolution, 275
work page 1996
- [30]
- [31]
-
[32]
Cid Fernandes , R., Mateus , A., Sodr \'e , L., Stasi \'n ska , G., & Gomes , J. M. 2005, , 358, 363
work page 2005
-
[33]
L., Girardi , L., Marigo , P., & Habing , H
Cioni , M.-R. L., Girardi , L., Marigo , P., & Habing , H. J. 2006, , 448, 77
work page 2006
-
[34]
Coelho , P., Bruzual , G., Charlot , S., Weiss , A., Barbuy , B., & Ferguson , J. W. 2007, , 382, 498
work page 2007
-
[35]
Cole , S. et al. 2001, , 326, 255
work page 2001
-
[36]
Cool , R. J. et al. 2008, , 682, 919
work page 2008
-
[37]
Daddi , E. et al. 2005, , 626, 680
work page 2005
- [38]
- [39]
-
[40]
B., Piotto , G., & de Angeli , F
Davies , M. B., Piotto , G., & de Angeli , F. 2004, , 349, 129
work page 2004
- [41]
-
[42]
W., Lee , H.-c., Worthey , G., Jevremovi \'c , D., & Baron , E
Dotter , A., Chaboyer , B., Ferguson , J. W., Lee , H.-c., Worthey , G., Jevremovi \'c , D., & Baron , E. 2007, , 666, 403
work page 2007
-
[43]
Drory , N., Bender , R., Feulner , G., Hopp , U., Maraston , C., Snigula , J., & Hill , G. J. 2004, , 608, 742
work page 2004
-
[44]
G., Moodley , K., & Skordis , C
Dunkley , J., Bucher , M., Ferreira , P. G., Moodley , K., & Skordis , C. 2005, , 356, 925
work page 2005
- [45]
-
[46]
Eisenstein , D. J. et al. 2001, , 122, 2267
work page 2001
-
[47]
Elmegreen , B. G. 2009, in The Evolving ISM in the Milky Way and Nearby Galaxies
work page 2009
-
[48]
R., Origlia , L., Testa , V., & Maraston , C
Ferraro , F. R., Origlia , L., Testa , V., & Maraston , C. 2004, , 608, 772
work page 2004
- [49]
-
[50]
Fontana , A. et al. 2004, , 424, 23
work page 2004
- [51]
-
[52]
Gallazzi , A., Charlot , S., Brinchmann , J., White , S. D. M., & Tremonti , C. A. 2005, , 362, 41
work page 2005
-
[53]
Girardi , L., Bressan , A., Bertelli , G., & Chiosi , C. 2000, , 141, 371
work page 2000
-
[54]
Girardi , L., Chiosi , C., Bertelli , G., & Bressan , A. 1995, , 298, 87
work page 1995
- [55]
-
[56]
Hao , L. et al. 2005, , 129, 1795
work page 2005
-
[57]
Harris , W. E. 1996, , 112, 1487
work page 1996
-
[58]
Hopkins , A. M. & Beacom , J. F. 2006, , 651, 142
work page 2006
-
[59]
H., Chester , T., Cutri , R., Schneider , S., Skrutskie , M., & Huchra , J
Jarrett , T. H., Chester , T., Cutri , R., Schneider , S., Skrutskie , M., & Huchra , J. P. 2000, , 119, 2498
work page 2000
-
[60]
H., Chester , T., Cutri , R., Schneider , S
Jarrett , T. H., Chester , T., Cutri , R., Schneider , S. E., & Huchra , J. P. 2003, , 125, 525
work page 2003
- [61]
-
[62]
S., Padoan , P., & Peacock , J
Jimenez , R., MacDonald , J., Dunlop , J. S., Padoan , P., & Peacock , J. A. 2004, , 349, 240
work page 2004
-
[63]
Kalirai , J. S. et al. 2007, , 671, 748
work page 2007
-
[64]
Kannappan , S. J. & Gawiser , E. 2007, , 657, L5
work page 2007
-
[65]
Kauffmann , G. et al. 2003 a , , 341, 33
work page 2003
- [66]
-
[67]
Kriek , M. et al. 2006, , 645, 44
work page 2006
- [68]
- [69]
-
[70]
Lada , C. J. 2006, , 640, L63
work page 2006
- [71]
- [72]
-
[73]
Larson , R. B. 1972, , 236, 7
work page 1972
- [74]
- [75]
-
[76]
K., Flynn , C., Kawata , D., & Beasley , M
Lee , H.-c., Gibson , B. K., Flynn , C., Kawata , D., & Beasley , M. A. 2004, , 353, 113
work page 2004
-
[77]
Lee , H.-c., Lee , Y.-W., & Gibson , B. K. 2002, , 124, 2664
work page 2002
-
[78]
Lee , H.-c., Worthey , G., Dotter , A., Chaboyer , B., Jevremovi \'c , D., Baron , E., Briley , M. M., Ferguson , J. W., Coelho , P., & Trager , S. C. 2009, , 694, 902
work page 2009
-
[79]
Lee , H.-c., Worthey , G., Trager , S. C., & Faber , S. M. 2007, , 664, 215
work page 2007
- [80]
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.