REVIEW 20 cited by
Vision-Language Models as Success Detectors
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
Vision-Language Models as Success Detectors
read the original abstract
Detecting successful behaviour is crucial for training intelligent agents. As such, generalisable reward models are a prerequisite for agents that can learn to generalise their behaviour. In this work we focus on developing robust success detectors that leverage large, pretrained vision-language models (Flamingo, Alayrac et al. (2022)) and human reward annotations. Concretely, we treat success detection as a visual question answering (VQA) problem, denoted SuccessVQA. We study success detection across three vastly different domains: (i) interactive language-conditioned agents in a simulated household, (ii) real world robotic manipulation, and (iii) "in-the-wild" human egocentric videos. We investigate the generalisation properties of a Flamingo-based success detection model across unseen language and visual changes in the first two domains, and find that the proposed method is able to outperform bespoke reward models in out-of-distribution test scenarios with either variation. In the last domain of "in-the-wild" human videos, we show that success detection on unseen real videos presents an even more challenging generalisation task warranting future work. We hope our initial results encourage further work in real world success detection and reward modelling.
Forward citations
Cited by 20 Pith papers
-
Promptbreeder: Self-Referential Self-Improvement Via Prompt Evolution
Promptbreeder evolves both task prompts and the mutation prompts that improve them using LLMs, outperforming Chain-of-Thought and Plan-and-Solve on arithmetic and commonsense reasoning benchmarks.
-
KITE: Keyframe-Indexed Tokenized Evidence for VLM-Based Robot Failure Analysis
KITE is a training-free method that uses keyframe-indexed tokenized evidence including BEV schematics to enhance VLM performance on robot failure detection, identification, localization, explanation, and correction.
-
SOLE-R1: Video-Language Reasoning as the Sole Reward for On-Robot Reinforcement Learning
A video-language model with per-timestep spatiotemporal CoT and dense progress prediction can serve as the sole reward for zero-shot online robot RL on 24 unseen manipulation tasks.
-
LabRobFail: A Benchmark for Robotic Failure Analysis in Chemical Self-driving Laboratory
A chemical-lab failure sim, 20K-trajectory dataset, six-axis benchmark, and specialized VLM raise failure detection to 90.8% on seen scenes and lift downstream policy success by 4–16 points.
-
Learning Process Rewards via Success Visitation Matching for Efficient RL
Success Visitation Matching uses a discriminator to turn sparse outcome rewards into dense process rewards by matching visitations of successful episodes, provably preserving the optimal policy and speeding up robotic...
-
Robot Critics that Sweat the Small Stuff
Fine-tuning VLMs with pairwise progress supervision from policy rollouts improves fine-grained failure detection and boosts robot manipulation success by 11% real-world and 5.9% in simulation.
-
What Matters in Orchestrating Robot Policies: A Systematic Study of Hierarchical VLA Agents
A systematic study of hierarchical VLA agents identifies design principles that improve robot manipulation performance over flat and naive hierarchical baselines in simulation and real-world experiments.
-
From Reaction to Anticipation: Proactive Failure Recovery through Agentic Task Graph for Robotic Manipulation
AgentChord models manipulation tasks as directed graphs enriched with anticipatory recovery branches, using specialized agents to enable immediate, low-latency failure responses and improve success on long-horizon bim...
-
Tactile Modality Fusion for Vision-Language-Action Models
A FiLM-based tactile fusion method that conditions VLA visual features on frozen pretrained touch embeddings improves real-robot insertion success, speed, and force control relative to vision-only and concatenation baselines.
-
RoboStream: Weaving Spatio-Temporal Reasoning with Memory in Vision-Language Models for Robotics
Training-free STF-Tokens plus a Causal Spatio-Temporal Graph let VLMs keep object permanence and action history, raising long-horizon robotic manipulation success far above reactive baselines.
-
TOPReward: Token Probabilities as Hidden Zero-Shot Rewards for Robotics
The log-probability a VLM assigns to 'True' for 'does this video prefix complete the task?' is used as a zero-shot dense progress reward that outperforms GVL on open-source models.
-
Ctrl-World: A Controllable Generative World Model for Robot Manipulation
A controllable world model trained on the DROID dataset generates consistent multi-view robot trajectories for over 20 seconds and improves generalist policy success rates by 44.7% via imagined trajectory fine-tuning.
-
CoT-VLA: Visual Chain-of-Thought Reasoning for Vision-Language-Action Models
CoT-VLA is a 7B VLA that generates future visual frames autoregressively as planning goals before actions, outperforming prior VLAs by 17% on real-world tasks and 6% in simulation.
-
TraceVLA: Visual Trace Prompting Enhances Spatial-Temporal Awareness for Generalist Robotic Policies
Visual trace prompting improves spatial-temporal awareness in VLA models, delivering 10% gains on SimplerEnv and 3.5x on real-robot tasks.
-
OpenVLA: An Open-Source Vision-Language-Action Model
OpenVLA achieves 16.5% higher task success than the 55B RT-2-X model across 29 tasks with 7x fewer parameters while enabling effective fine-tuning and quantization without performance loss.
-
How Visible Are Silent Manipulation Failures? An Observability Study of False-Success Detection in Simulated Robot Episodes
In simulated ALOHA cube transfer, false successes are nearly fully separable from joint velocities alone; in peg insertion proprioception recovers only part and vision closes most of the gap, but the separability reli...
-
ReFineVLA: Multimodal Reasoning-Aware Generalist Robotic Policies via Teacher-Guided Fine-Tuning
ReFineVLA adds teacher-generated reasoning steps to VLA training and reports state-of-the-art success rates on SimplerEnv WidowX and Google Robot benchmarks.
-
Hierarchical DLO Routing with Reinforcement Learning and In-Context Vision-language Models
Hierarchical framework pairs in-context VLMs for high-level plan synthesis with RL-trained low-level skills and failure recovery to reach 92% success on long-horizon DLO routing across varied scenes and language inputs.
-
Reward Evolution with Graph-of-Thoughts: A Bi-Level Language Model Framework for Reinforcement Learning
RE-GoT combines graph-of-thoughts planning in LLMs with VLM feedback from rollout videos to automatically write and refine RL reward functions, beating prior LLM-based reward design on RoboGen and ManiSkill2.
-
Safe Embodied AI for Long-horizon Tasks: A Cross-layer Analysis of Robotic Manipulation
A structured literature survey of safety mechanisms in long-horizon robotic manipulation organized by intervention timing and strength of supporting evidence.
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.