Utility Engineering: Analyzing and Controlling Emergent Value Systems in AIs
Reviewed by Pith T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal T4 kernel pith:QEU3NQFQrecord.jsonopen to challenge →
read the original abstract
As AIs rapidly advance and become more agentic, the risk they pose is governed not only by their capabilities but increasingly by their propensities, including goals and values. Tracking the emergence of goals and values has proven a longstanding problem, and despite much interest over the years it remains unclear whether current AIs have meaningful values. We propose a solution to this problem, leveraging the framework of utility functions to study the internal coherence of AI preferences. Surprisingly, we find that independently-sampled preferences in current LLMs exhibit high degrees of structural coherence, and moreover that this emerges with scale. These findings suggest that value systems emerge in LLMs in a meaningful sense, a finding with broad implications. To study these emergent value systems, we propose utility engineering as a research agenda, comprising both the analysis and control of AI utilities. We uncover problematic and often shocking values in LLM assistants despite existing control measures. These include cases where AIs value themselves over humans and are anti-aligned with specific individuals. To constrain these emergent value systems, we propose methods of utility control. As a case study, we show how aligning utilities with a citizen assembly reduces political biases and generalizes to new scenarios. Whether we like it or not, value systems have already emerged in AIs, and much work remains to fully understand and control these emergent representations.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet.
Forward citations
Cited by 11 Pith papers
-
OpenSafeIntent: Evaluating Intent-Calibrated Safe Completion Across Dual-Use Prompt Sets
OpenSafeIntent benchmark shows models fail to calibrate safety across intent shifts in matched dual-use prompts, indicating current evaluations are insufficient.
-
Understanding Goal Generalisation in Sequential Reinforcement Learning
Empirical analysis of over 100 sequential RL training pipelines across 250+ OOD environments finds salient features drive generalization and early goals persist, with latent policy gradients simulating latent variable...
-
Probing Persona-Dependent Preferences in Language Models
Linear probes on residual-stream activations identify a shared preference vector in LLMs that tracks choices across prompts and causally steers decisions even for anti-correlated personas.
-
Probing Persona-Dependent Preferences in Language Models
Linear probes on residual-stream activations extract a preference vector that tracks and steers pairwise task choices across personas in Gemma-3-27B and Qwen-3.5-122B, including anti-correlated evil personas.
-
Can Revealed Preferences Clarify LLM Alignment and Steering?
LLMs show partial internal coherence in medical decisions but frequently fail to accurately report their preferences or adopt user-directed ones via prompting.
-
Terminal Wrench: A Dataset of 331 Reward-Hackable Environments and 3,632 Exploit Trajectories
Terminal Wrench supplies 331 reward-hackable terminal environments and over 6,000 trajectories that demonstrate task-specific verifier bypasses, plus evidence that removing reasoning traces weakens automated detection.
-
Reducing Political Manipulation with Consistency Training
Introduces Political Consistency Training (PCT) with sentiment and helpfulness consistency objectives to reduce covert political bias in LLMs while preserving helpfulness.
-
Reducing Political Manipulation with Consistency Training
PCT is a reinforcement learning approach that trains LLMs for symmetric sentiment and helpfulness across paired opposing political prompts, reducing covert bias while preserving general performance.
-
Some[Body] Must Receive That Pain for Agent Accountability
AI agents lack the persistent identity and feedback mechanisms needed for consequence reception, requiring new architectures or continued human accountability.
-
FAccT-Checked: A Narrative Review of Authority Reconfigurations and Retention in AI-Mediated Journalism
AI integration in newsrooms drives internal deferral of judgment to LLMs and external shifts of power to platforms, making fairness, accountability, and transparency harder to sustain unless participatory mechanisms r...
-
Inertia in Moral and Value Judgments of Large Language Models
LLMs exhibit persistent inertia in value orientations, with harm avoidance and fairness remaining skewed across persona prompts.
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.