REVIEW 26 cited by
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
A Minimalist Approach to LLM Reasoning: from Rejection Sampling to Reinforce
read the original abstract
Reinforcement learning (RL) has become a prevailing approach for fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) on complex reasoning tasks. Among recent methods, GRPO stands out for its empirical success in training models such as DeepSeek-R1, yet the sources of its effectiveness remain poorly understood. In this work, we revisit GRPO from a reinforce-like algorithm perspective and analyze its core components. Surprisingly, we find that a simple rejection sampling baseline, RAFT, which trains only on positively rewarded samples, yields competitive performance than GRPO and PPO. Our ablation studies reveal that GRPO's main advantage arises from discarding prompts with entirely incorrect responses, rather than from its reward normalization. Motivated by this insight, we propose Reinforce-Rej, a minimal extension of policy gradient that filters both entirely incorrect and entirely correct samples. Reinforce-Rej improves KL efficiency and stability, serving as a lightweight yet effective alternative to more complex RL algorithms. We advocate RAFT as a robust and interpretable baseline, and suggest that future advances should focus on more principled designs for incorporating negative samples, rather than relying on them indiscriminately. Our findings provide guidance for future work in reward-based LLM post-training.
Forward citations
Cited by 26 Pith papers
-
RL Post-Training Builds Compositional Reasoning Strategies
RL post-training composes primitive rewrite skills into reusable macro and parallel contraction strategies that solve problems inaccessible to the base model under large sampling budgets.
-
ARCA: Adapter-Residual Credit Assignment When Token Signals Degenerate
ARCA assigns token credit in LoRA-based LLM RL from the norm of adapter-induced hidden state changes, yielding non-degenerate distributions and competitive performance on MATH tasks with Qwen3-1.7B under GRPO.
-
Block-R1: Rethinking the Role of Block Size in Multi-domain Reinforcement Learning for Diffusion Large Language Models
Block-R1 formulates domain block size conflicts in multi-domain RL for dLLMs, releases a 41K-sample dataset with per-sample best block sizes and a conflict score, and provides a benchmark plus simple cross-domain trai...
-
Block-R1: Rethinking the Role of Block Size in Multi-domain Reinforcement Learning for Diffusion Large Language Models
Introduces Block-R1 benchmark, Block-R1-41K dataset, and a conflict score to handle domain-specific optimal block sizes in RL post-training of diffusion LLMs.
-
DiffusionNFT: Online Diffusion Reinforcement with Forward Process
DiffusionNFT performs online RL for diffusion models on the forward process via flow matching and positive-negative contrasts, delivering up to 25x efficiency gains and rapid benchmark improvements over prior reverse-...
-
Token Buncher: Shielding LLMs from Harmful Reinforcement Learning Fine-Tuning
TokenBuncher constrains response entropy via entropy-as-reward RL and a Token Noiser to stop harmful RL fine-tuning while keeping benign performance intact.
-
What are Key Factors for Updates in RL for LLM Reasoning?
Theoretical analysis of RLVR update dynamics leads to ACPO, an adaptive clipping method that outperforms DAPO and CISPO on reasoning benchmarks with 3B and 7B models.
-
From Reasoning Traces to Reusable Modules: Understanding Compositional Generalization in Language Model Reasoning
Introduces a hierarchical latent selection model showing SFT supplies raw module materials in compound traces while RL decomposes them to identify atomic modules and enable recombination for new reasoning configurations.
-
DRIFT: Refining Instruction Data via On-Policy Data Attribution
DRIFT applies on-policy influence functions with signed weighting and debiasing to attribute and refine SFT data, raising performance on 7B instruction and reasoning models over prior curation methods.
-
AsyncWebRL: Efficient Multi-Step RL for Visual Web Agents
AsyncWebRL reports up to 2.9x training speedup and new SOTA on WebGym OOD split via async overlap plus constant normalizer in GRPO, with largest gains on harder tasks.
-
Rollout-Level Advantage-Prioritized Experience Replay for GRPO
Rollout-level advantage-prioritized experience replay for GRPO recycles high-advantage individual rollouts with age eviction and fresh-anchored batches to outperform standard GRPO on math benchmarks, with gains increa...
-
Traj-Evolve: A Self-Evolving Multi-Agent System for Patient Trajectory Modeling in Lung Cancer Early Detection
Traj-Evolve combines non-parametric experience retrieval and multi-agent RL with a leave-one-out unification strategy to outperform baselines on lung cancer prediction from up to five years of multimodal EHRs, includi...
-
Multi-Step Likelihood-Ratio Correction for Reinforcement Learning with Verifiable Rewards
NFPO augments the PPO surrogate with N-step forward traces to bridge local approximations and exact policy gradients, delivering tighter policy-improvement bounds and improved results on reasoning benchmarks.
-
Selective Off-Policy Reference Tuning with Plan Guidance
SORT turns all-wrong prompts into selective learning signals by weighting tokens more predictable under plan guidance from reference solutions, improving over GRPO on reasoning benchmarks especially for weaker models.
-
Experience Sharing in Mutual Reinforcement Learning for Heterogeneous Language Models
Mutual Reinforcement Learning allows heterogeneous LLMs to exchange experience through mechanisms like Peer Rollout Pooling, Cross-Policy GRPO Advantage Sharing, and Success-Gated Transfer, with outcome-level sharing ...
-
Gradient Extrapolation-Based Policy Optimization
GXPO approximates longer local lookahead in GRPO training via gradient extrapolation from two optimizer steps using three backward passes total, improving pass@1 accuracy by 1.65-5.00 points over GRPO and delivering u...
-
Beyond Uniform Credit Assignment: Selective Eligibility Traces for RLVR
S-trace adds sparse eligibility traces to RLVR that mask low-entropy tokens, outperforming GRPO by 0.49-3.16% pass@16 on Qwen3 models while improving sample and token efficiency.
-
Odysseus: Scaling VLMs to 100+ Turn Decision-Making in Games via Reinforcement Learning
Odysseus adapts PPO with a turn-level critic and leverages pretrained VLM action priors to train agents achieving at least 3x average game progress over frontier models in long-horizon Super Mario Land.
-
Kernelized Advantage Estimation: From Nonparametric Statistics to LLM Reasoning
Kernel smoothing yields accurate value and gradient estimates for low-variance policy learning in LLM reasoning under tight per-prompt sampling budgets.
-
Kernelized Advantage Estimation: From Nonparametric Statistics to LLM Reasoning
Kernel smoothing enables accurate low-variance value and gradient estimates for policy optimization in LLM reasoning under tight sampling constraints per prompt.
-
Addressing Performance Saturation for LLM RL via Precise Entropy Curve Control
Entrocraft uses rejection sampling to enforce precise entropy schedules in LLM RL by biasing advantages, enabling longer training, better generalization, and higher performance than baselines.
-
Addressing Performance Saturation for LLM RL via Precise Entropy Curve Control
Entrocraft uses rejection sampling to enforce custom entropy curves in LLM RL, sustaining longer training, better generalization, and higher output diversity than prior regularization approaches.
-
Beyond Correctness: Harmonizing Process and Outcome Rewards through RL Training
PROF curates RL training data via PRM-ORM consistency to improve both final-answer accuracy and intermediate reasoning quality while reducing reliance on strong process reward models.
-
Selective Off-Policy Reference Tuning with Plan Guidance
SORT converts all-failed reasoning prompts into selective, structure-aware training signals by weighting tokens according to how much a reference-derived plan increases their probability.
-
Advancing Multi-Agent RAG Systems with Minimalist Reinforcement Learning
Mujica-MyGo decomposes multi-turn RAG interactions via multi-agent workflows and applies minimalist policy gradient optimization to improve performance on QA benchmarks while avoiding long-context problems.
-
Not All Rollouts are Useful: Down-Sampling Rollouts in LLM Reinforcement Learning
PODS applies max-variance down-sampling to GRPO rollouts in LLM RLVR, delivering at least 1.7x faster training to peak test accuracy on reasoning benchmarks.
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.