REVIEW
The dS/dS Correspondence
High Energy Physics - Theory · Submitted 14 Jul 2004 · 48 references
Pith's verdict: A well-motivated, honestly-hedged proposal for static-patch dS holography whose one real gap — the UV matching at the central slice — the authors name themselves.
T0 · AI review
Why Pith says this
Highlight any text to comment on it.
Referee report
The paper
The paper claims
The static patch of de Sitter space is proposed to be dual to two cutoff conformal field theories on a de Sitter slice, coupled to each other and to lower-dimensional gravity.
The reading
What carries the argument
The load-bearing object is the de Sitter slicing of (A)dS, $ds^2=e^{2A(w)}$ times the $dS_{d-1}$ metric plus $dw^2$, with $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$. In the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
The central claim is that the $dS_d(R)$ static patch is holographically dual to two conformal field theories on $dS_{d-1}(R)$, cut off at energy scale $1/R$, where they couple to each other and to $(d-1)$-dimensional gravity. The supporting structure is a parallel treatment of $dS_d$ and $AdS_d$ foliated by $dS_{d-1}$ slices, with warp factors $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$; in the paper's coordinates the warp factors are $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors given by $e^{2A(w)}=R^{-2}$ times $R^2$ factors of $1$.
Load-bearing premise
The paper assumes that the joining of the two cutoff field theories at the central slice, including all the couplings and boundary conditions there, can be treated as two conformal field theories coupled to each other and to lower-dimensional gravity; the authors state in §2.4 that they have not determined this matching, so the duality is stated as a template rather than a complete definition.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- A single observer's causal patch in de Sitter has a self-contained quantum description that does not require the full global spacetime or an entanglement interpretation across horizons.
- The $(d-1)$-dimensional Newton constant computed by dimensional reduction, $1/G_{N,d-1}\sim S\,(1/R)^{d-3}$ with $S$ the horizon entropy in Planck units, agrees with the renormalization expected from $S$ field-theoretic modes cut off at $1/R$.
- The graviton Kaluza-Klein spectrum on the sliced background has a normalizable zero mode plus a continuum above the gap $m^2>(d-2)^2/(4R^2)$, matching the spectrum expected for conformal field theory on de Sitter space.
- The fact that a probe takes forever to reach a horizon in general relativity becomes a field-theory statement: the rolling scalar suffers strong backreaction from higher-derivative couplings to the thermalized degrees of freedom, giving an approach law such as $\varphi-\varphi_0\sim c\,e^{-4\varphi_0 t/\sqrt{\lambda}}$.
- Vacuum bubbles and domain-wall shells in the bulk correspond to domain walls and vacuum transitions in the dual field theory, so nonperturbative decay of de Sitter can be described on the field-theory side.
Reading between the lines
- If the matching at the central slice can be fixed, the same construction should give a controlled count of states for any observer: the finite cutoff means a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, which is exactly the kind of bookkeeping that a de Sitter entropy bound demands.
- The proposal suggests a concrete comparison target for numerical or lattice studies of strongly coupled theories on curved backgrounds: the diffusion constant extracted from the horizon, $D=R$ in $d=5$, is a sharp number the dual field theory should reproduce.
- Iterating the reduction to higher codimension points toward a purely quantum-mechanical description of the static patch, which would let one ask whether the entropy is carried by field-theoretic degrees of freedom all the way down.
- The parallel with two-throat Randall-Sundrum geometries implies that existing warped-compactification technology — matching conditions, radion dynamics, Kaluza-Klein decomposition — can be imported directly into de Sitter holography.
Original abstract
We present a holographic duality for the de Sitter static patch which consolidates basic features of its geometry and the behavior of gravity and brane probes, valid on timescales short compared to the decay or Poincare recurrence times. Namely de Sitter spacetime $dS_d(R)$ in $d$ dimensions with curvature radius $R$ is holographically dual to two conformal field theories on $dS_{d-1}(R)$, cut off at an energy scale 1/R where they couple to each other and to $d-1$ dimensional gravity. As part of our analysis, we study brane probes in de Sitter and thermal Anti de Sitter spaces, and interpret the terms in the corresponding DBI action via strongly coupled thermal field theory. This provides a dual field theoretic interpretation of the fact that probes take forever to reach a horizon in general relativity.
The compiled record
The paper's own sentences, arranged, kept beside the review and separate from it. Each label is drawn from a closed vocabulary; the number beside it is the probability the classifier gave that label. Numbers in the tables are the authors', checked by code. No sentence in this record was written by a model.
The abstract, sentence by sentence
We present a holographic duality for the de Sitter static patch which consolidates basic features of its geometry and the behavior of gravity and brane probes, valid on timescales short compared to the decay or Poincare recurrence times. Namely de Sitter spacetime $dS_d(R)$ in $d$ dimensions with curvature radius $R$ is holographically dual to two conformal field theories on $dS_{d-1}(R)$, cut off at an energy scale 1/R where they couple to each other and to $d-1$ dimensional gravity. As part of our analysis, we study brane probes in de Sitter and thermal Anti de Sitter spaces, and interpret the terms in the corresponding DBI action via strongly coupled thermal field theory. This provides a dual field theoretic interpretation of the fact that probes take forever to reach a horizon in general relativity.
background contribution method result interpretation main claim
| # | sentence | role | the authors' own work | states the main conclusion | strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| s0 | We present a holographic duality for the de Sitter static patch which consolidates basic features of its geometry and the behavior of gravity and brane probes, valid on timescales short compared to the decay or Poincare recurrence times. | contribution 0.96 | 0.91 | 0.71 | asserted 1.00 |
| s1 | Namely de Sitter spacetime $dS_d(R)$ in $d$ dimensions with curvature radius $R$ is holographically dual to two conformal field theories on $dS_{d-1}(R)$, cut off at an energy scale 1/R where they couple to each other and to $d-1$ dimensional gravity. | result 0.68 | 0.76 | 0.77 | asserted 1.00 |
| s2 | As part of our analysis, we study brane probes in de Sitter and thermal Anti de Sitter spaces, and interpret the terms in the corresponding DBI action via strongly coupled thermal field theory. | contribution 0.77 | 0.92 | 0.06 | asserted 0.98 |
| s3 | This provides a dual field theoretic interpretation of the fact that probes take forever to reach a horizon in general relativity. | interpretation 1.00 | 0.57 | 0.10 | asserted 0.99 |
What was examined, and what was not
- arXiv listing abstract v2
- full text
- figures and tables
- references and citing sentences
- relations to other papers
- P abstract
- S sections
- T body sentences
- C citations
- R cross-paper relations
Figures
Figures reproduced from arXiv:hep-th/0407125 by the authors.
References
How the literature uses it
103 arXiv papers cite this in 160 sentences
Papers citing it · 96 sentences without a confident label
Compares with it 3 papers
-
This matches the dS/dS formulation of the analogous entanglement entropy in [ref] .[In that framework, the UV slice playing the role of the boundary of each of the two sectors in [ref] automatically lies at the maximal surface, with no room between them to move it off-center in tracing out one of the two systems.] As just mentioned, we address the issue of off-shell contributions which naively provide stronger contributions to the path integral by incorporating UV effects, in the simplest, $U(1)$-symmetric, setting where the question arises.
The yes boundaries wavefunctions of the universe · Summary of main results and organization of the paper · 0.96
-
We note that this foliation of the static patch is similar to the one that inspires the “$dS/dS$” correspondence [ref] .
Bra-ket wormholes in gravitationally prepared states · The $π$ contour · 0.92
-
In particular, we discuss the relationship of our description of de Sitter spacetime with the DS/dS correspondence [ref] and the Shaghoulian-Susskind proposal [ref] .
Black Hole and de Sitter Microstructures from a Semiclassical Perspective · Intrinsically two-sided systems · 0.91
Cites it as background 55 papers
-
Let us set up the notation for the basic DS/dS framework [ref] .
Entropy, Entanglement and Swampland Bounds in DS/dS · Setup and notation · 0.93
-
In addition, other holographic duality models in the dS spacetime, such as the dS/dS holography [ref] and half-dS holography [ref] , have also gained attention and been studied.
Holographic $T\bar{T}$ deformation of the entanglement entropy in (A)dS$_3$/CFT$_2$ · Introduction · 0.97
-
However, we are still lacking understandings of holography in de Sitter space (dS), so-called dS/CFT correspondence [ref] (see also [ref] ), though there has been a concrete proposal in four-dimensional higher spin gravity [ref] , and interesting recent progresses in the light of the dS/dS correspondence [ref] , holographic entanglement entropy [ref] , and holography in dS static patch [ref] .
Holography in de Sitter Space via Chern-Simons Gauge Theory · Introduction · 0.99
Discussion
Disagree with the review, or know something it missed? Leave a comment, highlight any passage above to comment on it, or challenge this review formally.